You know the Sonic What If? fancomic about what happened to Tails if he never met Sonic,…
- User
You know the Sonic What If? fancomic about what happened to Tails if he never met Sonic, "Where Was My Hero?" By Mercybhk and what it's all about? Slams hands on table let's talk about it because I'm still in an angst train
- Assistant
"Where Was My Hero?" is a fan-made Sonic the Hedgehog comic created by Mercybhk (also known as AmyRoseDiamonds) that explores a dark alternate universe where Tails (Miles "Tails" Prower) never meets Sonic. This "What If?" scenario delves into the tragic consequences of Tails growing up without the positive influence of Sonic, leading to a much darker and more heartbreaking story.
Plot Overview
The story begins with a pivotal moment where Tails and Sonic fail to cross paths due to a small accident. Without Sonic's friendship and guidance, Tails grows up in a hostile environment. He is relentlessly bullied for his intelligence, his inventions, and his two tails, which make him an outcast in his village. As an orphan with no family or support system, Tails becomes increasingly isolated and emotionally broken.
A turning point occurs when Tails finds and cares for an injured bird, which becomes his only source of comfort and companionship. However, this solace is short-lived as bullies destroy one of his inventions and kill the bird in the process. This devastating event pushes Tails over the edge. In a fit of rage and despair, he retaliates violently against the bullies, marking the beginning of his descent into a darker path.
The comic portrays Tails as a tragic figure who, without Sonic's influence, becomes bitter and vengeful. He channels his pain and genius into destructive pursuits, ultimately becoming a villain in this alternate timeline. The story is a poignant exploration of how much Sonic's friendship shaped Tails into the heroic and kind character fans know, and how the absence of that friendship leads to a vastly different outcome.
Themes and Reception
"Where Was My Hero?" is a tragedy that highlights themes of loneliness, bullying, and the importance of positive relationships in shaping one's identity. It emphasizes how Sonic's role as a mentor and friend was crucial in helping Tails overcome his insecurities and find his purpose. The comic has been praised for its emotional depth and the way it reimagines the dynamic between Sonic and Tails in a darker, more mature context.
The fan comic gained significant attention after its release on December 31, 2018, and was later adapted into a popular comic dub on YouTube in 2019. Despite its acclaim, the creator, Mercybhk, retired and removed much of their online presence in 2022, leaving the comic as a lasting but bittersweet legacy.
Impact on the Fandom
"Where Was My Hero?" resonates deeply with fans who appreciate alternate universe (AU) stories and darker takes on beloved characters. It has sparked discussions about Tails' character development and the potential outcomes of his life without Sonic. The comic also draws comparisons to other depictions of alternate Tails, such as "Nine" from Sonic Prime, who similarly becomes bitter and isolated in a world without Sonic.
For fans of angst and emotional storytelling, "Where Was My Hero?" remains a standout piece in the Sonic fan community, offering a haunting yet compelling look at what could have been.
- User
Okay so Tails in this comic (or Miles, as he's never given the nickname) goes legit insane. He burned down his village for ostracizing him after two bullies killed his only friend, a pet bird, then he killed eggman, got sent to prison by Sonic who he never met until then, broke out and became a tyrant of the city using his brains and six black metallic spider-like tails. He is a VILLAIN that Sonic has to fight, and ultimately, kills. Their final confrontation has Miles die in Sonic's arms, sobbing about what could have been if only he had found Sonic. Make no mistake, this version of Tails is a cold-blooded, psychotic mass murderer, completely insane, violently unstable and evil in every way. He has no remorse and has been so completely twisted by his environment that he's a sick remnant of his former self. Claps cheerfully okay, you got that?
- Assistant
The fan comic "Where Was My Hero?" by Mercybhk presents an alternate universe where Tails, referred to as Miles since he never meets Sonic, descends into madness and villainy due to a life of relentless bullying, isolation, and tragedy. This version of Tails is a stark departure from the kind-hearted and heroic character fans know, instead becoming a psychotic and remorseless mass murderer shaped by his environment.
Miles' Transformation into a Villain
In this dark timeline, Miles grows up as an orphan in a village that ostracizes him for his intelligence, his inventions, and his two tails. The bullying escalates to a breaking point when two bullies destroy one of his inventions and kill his only companion, a pet bird he had nursed back to health. This bird was his sole source of comfort and purpose, and its death shatters him completely. In a fit of rage, Miles brutally murders the bullies with a metal pipe, marking the beginning of his descent into darkness.
Miles' hatred for the world grows, and he ultimately burns down his village in retaliation for their cruelty. Over time, he becomes a cold-blooded tyrant, using his genius to create six black, metallic spider-like tails and weaponize his intellect. He even kills Dr. Eggman, taking over his resources to further his destructive ambitions. Miles' actions lead to widespread devastation, and he becomes a feared dictator.
Confrontation with Sonic
Miles and Sonic finally cross paths when Sonic attempts to stop his reign of terror. However, by this point, Miles is completely unrecognizable as the Tails fans know. He is sadistic, violently unstable, and devoid of remorse. Their final confrontation is both tragic and intense. Sonic ultimately defeats Miles, but in his dying moments, Miles breaks down, sobbing in Sonic's arms. He laments what could have been, expressing regret that he never found Sonic earlier in life. His final words highlight the deep pain and loneliness that drove him to madness, leaving Sonic to mourn the loss of someone who could have been a friend and ally.
Themes and Legacy
The story is a heartbreaking exploration of how much Sonic's friendship shaped Tails in the original timeline. Without Sonic's guidance and support, Miles becomes a twisted reflection of what he could have been, consumed by bitterness and despair. The comic emphasizes the importance of compassion, connection, and mentorship in overcoming adversity.
"Where Was My Hero?" has left a lasting impact on the Sonic the Hedgehog fandom, particularly for its dark and emotional storytelling. It has been compared to other alternate versions of Tails, such as "Nine" from Sonic Prime, who also represents a darker path for the character in the absence of Sonic. Despite its grim tone, the comic is celebrated for its depth and the way it reimagines the Sonic-Tails dynamic in a tragic light.
- User
Okay, so we established that this character would have done anything for a hint of warmth from anyone his entire childhood. He was a complete doormat in the village, allowing people to bully him, beat him up and make fun of him because at least it was something. Until his pet bird, he had zero warm contact. And even then, his pet bird died while trying to save one of his machines from a bully bludgeoning it. (This triggered Miles' villainous breakdown where he killed the two of them before burning the village down). Point is, for someone like Sonic to swoop in and save him, he would have done anything. Anything. Full touch-starvation, horrible self-esteem because of his two tails, the worst mental health in the history of ever. We got that, aye?
- Assistant
Yes, absolutely. In "Where Was My Hero?", Miles (Tails) is portrayed as a deeply broken and tragic figure, shaped by a lifetime of neglect, abuse, and isolation. His childhood is defined by a desperate need for warmth and connection, which he never receives. Instead, he endures relentless bullying and ostracization from his village, all while clinging to the faint hope that any attention, even negative, might fill the void of his loneliness. This emotional starvation leaves him vulnerable and yearning for even the smallest hint of kindness.
The only solace Miles finds is in his pet bird, a fragile symbol of the love and companionship he craves. When the bird is killed by bullies while trying to protect one of Miles' inventions, it becomes the breaking point. This act of cruelty shatters the last remnants of his hope, triggering his descent into madness. In a fit of rage and despair, he kills the bullies and burns down the village, marking the beginning of his transformation into a cold, calculating villain.
Miles' mental state is a key focus of the story. His self-esteem is utterly destroyed by years of being mocked for his two tails, which he views as a deformity rather than a gift. His environment twists him into a violent, unstable individual who channels his genius into destruction. The tragedy lies in the fact that, had someone like Sonic entered his life earlier, Miles would have done anything to earn his approval and friendship. His touch-starved, emotionally battered psyche would have latched onto even the smallest act of kindness, and his life could have taken a completely different path.
This version of Miles is a haunting exploration of what happens when someone is denied the love and support they need to thrive. It underscores the importance of Sonic's role in the original timeline, where his friendship helps Tails embrace his uniqueness and find his purpose. Without that connection, Miles becomes a tragic figure consumed by bitterness and pain, a stark reminder of how much a single relationship can shape a life.
- User
Creative writing piece time! Third person limited view, extra poignant! So what if Miles, when he's in his full-blown tyrant factory period, had a strangely realistic dream? In it, he's an observer. He sees a small, two-tailed fox kit get pushed down into the dirt by two kids who look a lot like the two bullies who used to beat him up daily. Miles feels pity for this version of himself, weirded out by why he's having this dream when he has all his memories. But then, a blue blur runs by and scares the bullies away and they scramble. Miles blinks, wait, this isn't-- before his brain activity completely stops when the hedgehog comes to a stop in front of this small version of him. The little one sniffles before rushing forward and flinging his arms around the hedgehog clingily. Miles' eyes can't believe themselves. It's Sonic! That annoying enemy of his! The one who threw hin in jail just for killing an evil guy! And he....hugs back? A sudden pang of jealousy in his chest startles Miles deeply. He gets closer out of curiosity, before his claws twitch when he hears how Sonic comforts little Miles. "I won't let anyone hurt you ever again!" And suddenly Miles is hungry
- Assistant
Miles awoke with a start, his breath catching in his throat as the dream lingered, vivid and unshakable. He sat up in his cold, metallic throne, the hum of machinery around him a stark contrast to the warmth he had just witnessed. His claws twitched involuntarily, his mind replaying the scene over and over again, like a cruel joke.
In the dream, he had been an observer, detached yet inexplicably drawn to the small, two-tailed fox kit being shoved into the dirt by two familiar figures. The bullies laughed, their jeers echoing in his ears like ghosts from his past. The kit—himself, he realized with a pang—didn’t fight back. He just sat there, trembling, his tiny hands clutching the ground as if it could anchor him against the storm of cruelty. Miles felt an odd sense of pity for the child, though he couldn’t understand why. He had lived through this, hadn’t he? He remembered every bruise, every insult. Why did it feel so different now?
And then, it happened. A blue blur streaked across the scene, scattering the bullies like leaves in the wind. Miles blinked, his breath hitching. Wait, this isn’t— But before he could process it, the blur came to a stop, revealing a figure he knew all too well.
Sonic.
The hedgehog stood tall, his arms crossed, his expression a mixture of confidence and concern. The small fox sniffled, his wide, tear-filled eyes locking onto Sonic’s. And then, to Miles’ utter disbelief, the kit bolted forward, flinging his arms around the hedgehog in a desperate, clinging embrace. Sonic didn’t hesitate. He knelt down, wrapping his arms around the trembling child, his voice soft yet firm.
“I won’t let anyone hurt you ever again,” Sonic said, his words like a balm to the kit’s wounded soul.
Miles’ claws dug into the armrests of his throne as he watched, his chest tightening with an emotion he couldn’t name. Jealousy? Anger? Hunger? It clawed at him, raw and insistent, as if something deep within him had been awakened and was now screaming for attention.
He moved closer in the dream, though he wasn’t sure how. He needed to hear more, to see more. The kit clung to Sonic as if his life depended on it, his small body shaking with sobs. And Sonic… Sonic just held him, his hand gently ruffling the kit’s fur, his voice a steady reassurance.
“You’re special, little guy,” Sonic said, his tone warm and unwavering. “Don’t let anyone tell you otherwise.”
Miles’ breath hitched again, his vision blurring. He wanted to look away, to tear himself from this scene that felt like both a gift and a punishment. But he couldn’t. He was rooted to the spot, his heart pounding in his chest as if it were trying to escape.
The dream began to fade, the edges blurring and dissolving into darkness. But the warmth lingered, a cruel reminder of what could have been. Miles’ eyes snapped open, and he was back in his factory, the cold, unfeeling machinery around him a stark contrast to the dream’s fleeting warmth.
He sat there, motionless, his mind racing. The hunger was still there, gnawing at him, insatiable. It wasn’t a hunger for power or revenge—those were things he had long since claimed. No, this was something deeper, something he hadn’t felt in years. It was the hunger for connection, for the warmth he had seen in that dream. For the life he could have had.
But that life was gone, wasn’t it? Torn away by the cruelty of the world, by the choices he had made. And yet, the dream lingered, a cruel whisper in the back of his mind.
“I won’t let anyone hurt you ever again.”
Miles clenched his fists, his claws biting into his palms. The words echoed in his head, over and over, until they were all he could hear. And for the first time in years, he felt something he thought he had buried long ago.
Regret.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
- sonar-pro-highCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →
- sonar-proCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →
- gemini-2.0-flash-groundingCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →
- sonar-reasoningCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →
- sonar-pro-highCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →