You know the Sonic What If? fancomic about what happened to Tails if he never met Sonic,…
- User
You know the Sonic What If? fancomic about what happened to Tails if he never met Sonic, "Where Was My Hero?" By Mercybhk and what it's all about? Slams hands on table let's talk about it because I'm still in an angst train
- Assistant
"Where Was My Hero...?" is a fan-made "What If?" comic by artist MercyBhk, exploring an alternate universe where Tails (Miles Prower) never meets Sonic the Hedgehog. This divergence leads Tails down a darker path, resulting in a tragic and angst-filled narrative.
In this alternate timeline, Tails grows up isolated and bullied in his village due to his twin tails. Without Sonic's friendship and guidance, he becomes increasingly withdrawn and resentful. A pivotal moment occurs when local bullies kill his pet bird, the only companion he had. This event triggers a violent response from Tails, leading him to kill the bullies and set his village ablaze. He then embarks on a journey that ultimately transforms him into a villainous figure, seeking to destroy the world he perceives as unjust[1].
The comic delves deep into themes of isolation, the impact of bullying, and the consequences of lacking positive influences. It portrays a stark contrast to the canonical storyline, highlighting how different circumstances can drastically alter a character's trajectory. The narrative is rich with emotional depth, making it a poignant piece for fans interested in exploring darker "What If?" scenarios within the Sonic universe.
The artwork and storytelling have been praised for their ability to evoke strong emotions, effectively conveying Tails' descent into darkness. The comic has also inspired discussions about the importance of friendship and mentorship in shaping one's destiny.
For those interested in experiencing this alternate take on Tails' story, the comic was originally published as a YouTube video comprised of fan comic drawings. While the original creator has retired and taken down her accounts, the official dubbed version and some continuations have been preserved and are available for viewing[1].
It's worth noting that "Where Was My Hero...?" predates the character Nine from "Sonic Prime," another version of Tails who never met Sonic and became jaded as a result. The similarities between the two characters have sparked discussions among fans about alternate character developments[2].
Overall, "Where Was My Hero...?" offers a compelling and heart-wrenching exploration of Tails' character in a world without Sonic, providing fans with a thought-provoking narrative that lingers long after reading.
- User
Okay so Tails in this comic (or Miles, as he's never given the nickname) goes legit insane. He burned down his village for ostracizing him after two bullies killed his only friend, a pet bird, then he killed eggman, got sent to prison by Sonic who he never met until then, broke out and became a tyrant of the city using his brains and six black metallic spider-like tails. He is a VILLAIN that Sonic has to fight, and ultimately, kills. Their final confrontation has Miles die in Sonic's arms, sobbing about what could have been if only he had found Sonic. Make no mistake, this version of Tails is a cold-blooded, psychotic mass murderer, completely insane, violently unstable and evil in every way. He has no remorse and has been so completely twisted by his environment that he's a sick remnant of his former self. Claps cheerfully okay, you got that?
- Assistant
Absolutely, I understand the depth of Miles' transformation in "Where Was My Hero...?" In this alternate universe, without Sonic's friendship, Miles becomes a cold-blooded, psychotic mass murderer, completely insane, violently unstable, and evil in every way. His descent into villainy is marked by burning down his village, killing Eggman, and ultimately becoming a tyrant using his intellect and six black metallic spider-like tails. His final confrontation with Sonic ends tragically, as he dies in Sonic's arms, lamenting what could have been if only he had found Sonic earlier.
This narrative starkly contrasts with the canonical Tails, emphasizing how crucial Sonic's friendship was in shaping his character. The comic serves as a poignant exploration of how different circumstances can lead to vastly different outcomes, highlighting the importance of positive influences and support systems in one's life.
The emotional weight of Miles' story resonates deeply, offering a compelling and heart-wrenching "What If?" scenario that lingers with readers long after they've finished the comic.
- User
Okay, so we established that this character would have done anything for a hint of warmth from anyone his entire childhood. He was a complete doormat in the village, allowing people to bully him, beat him up and make fun of him because at least it was something. Until his pet bird, he had zero warm contact. And even then, his pet bird died while trying to save one of his machines from a bully bludgeoning it. (This triggered Miles' villainous breakdown where he killed the two of them before burning the village down). Point is, for someone like Sonic to swoop in and save him, he would have done anything. Anything. Full touch-starvation, horrible self-esteem because of his two tails, the worst mental health in the history of ever. We got that, aye?
- Assistant
Absolutely, I understand the depth of Miles' character in "Where Was My Hero...?" In this alternate universe, Miles experiences profound isolation and neglect throughout his childhood. His two tails make him a target for relentless bullying, and he endures this mistreatment in silence, desperate for any form of human interaction, even if it's negative. The arrival of his pet bird offers a brief respite, providing him with his first experience of warmth and companionship. However, this solace is tragically short-lived, as the bird dies while trying to protect one of Miles' machines from a bully's attack. This devastating loss triggers Miles' descent into villainy, culminating in the murder of the bullies and the destruction of his village.
Given this background, it's clear that if someone like Sonic had intervened earlier, offering friendship and support, Miles would have been profoundly receptive. His touch-starvation, abysmal self-esteem due to his unique physical trait, and severely deteriorated mental health underscore his desperate need for connection and acceptance. This narrative poignantly illustrates how the presence or absence of positive influences can dramatically alter a person's trajectory, emphasizing the critical importance of compassion and support in shaping one's destiny.
- User
Visceral written scene! So what if Miles, when he's in his full-blown tyrant factory period, had a strangely realistic dream? In it, he's an observer. He sees a small, two-tailed fox kit get pushed down into the dirt by two kids who look a lot like the two bullies who used to beat him up daily. Miles feels pity for this version of himself, weirded out by why he's having this dream when he has all his memories. But then, a blue blur runs by and scares the bullies away and they scramble. Miles blinks, wait, this isn't-- before his brain activity completely stops when the hedgehog comes to a stop in front of this small version of him. The little one sniffles before rushing forward and flinging his arms around the hedgehog clingily. Miles' eyes can't believe themselves. It's Sonic! That annoying enemy of his! The one who threw hin in jail just for killing an evil guy! And he....hugs back? A sudden pang of jealousy in his chest startles Miles deeply. He gets closer out of curiosity, before his claws twitch when he hears how Sonic comforts little Miles. "I won't let anyone hurt you ever again!" And suddenly Miles is hungry.
- Assistant
In the dim glow of his factory's control room, Miles slumped over his desk, the hum of machinery a lullaby to his exhausted mind. As sleep claimed him, a vivid dream unfolded.
He stood as an unseen observer in a familiar village scene. A small, two-tailed fox kit lay sprawled in the dirt, pushed down by two sneering children who bore an uncanny resemblance to the bullies from his past. The kit's eyes brimmed with tears, his tiny body trembling.
Miles felt an unexpected pang of pity. "Why am I dreaming this?" he wondered, knowing he had lived through this torment.
Suddenly, a blue blur streaked into the scene, sending the bullies scurrying. The figure came to a halt, revealing a blue hedgehog with a confident stance. Miles' breath hitched. "Wait, this isn't—"
The small fox sniffled, then rushed forward, flinging his arms around the hedgehog. Miles' eyes widened in disbelief. It was Sonic—the very enemy who had thwarted him, the one who had thrown him in jail for eliminating Eggman.
Sonic knelt, wrapping his arms around the kit in a protective embrace. "I won't let anyone hurt you ever again," he vowed.
A sudden pang of jealousy stabbed through Miles' chest, startling him. He stepped closer, drawn by a curiosity he couldn't suppress. His claws twitched as he listened to Sonic's comforting words. An unfamiliar hunger gnawed at him—a yearning for the warmth and protection he had never known.
The dream faded, leaving Miles awake and unsettled, the echo of Sonic's promise lingering in his mind.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
sonar-pro-highCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →
sonar-proCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →
gemini-2.0-flash-groundingCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →
sonar-reasoningCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →
sonar-pro-highCompare side by side →
- gpt-4o-search-preview-high-locCompare side by side →
sonar-pro-highCompare side by side →