Skip to content
The Chat Archive
sonar-pro LMArena Search Arena 24K

You know the Sonic What If? fancomic about what happened to Tails if he never met Sonic,…

  1. User

    You know the Sonic What If? fancomic about what happened to Tails if he never met Sonic, "Where Was My Hero?" By Mercybhk and what it's all about? Slams hands on table let's talk about it because I'm still in an angst train

  2. Assistant

    "Where Was My Hero?" by Mercybhk is a fan-made Sonic the Hedgehog alternate universe (AU) story that explores a dark and tragic "What If?" scenario: what would have happened if Tails (Miles "Tails" Prower) had never met Sonic. Originally published as a fan comic on DeviantArt and later adapted into a YouTube comic dub, the story is a dramatic and emotional exploration of Tails' life without Sonic's positive influence[[1]][[3]][[7]].

    Plot Summary

    In this AU, a small twist of fate prevents Tails from meeting Sonic. Without Sonic's friendship and support, Tails grows up in a harsh and unforgiving environment. He is relentlessly bullied for his intelligence, his inventions, and his two tails, while his village does nothing to protect him. As an orphan with no family or friends, Tails becomes increasingly isolated and bitter. His only solace comes from his inventions and a small bird he rescues and cares for, which becomes his sole companion and source of hope.

    However, tragedy strikes when the bullies destroy one of Tails' inventions and kill the bird in the process. This event pushes Tails over the edge. In a fit of rage and despair, he retaliates violently against his tormentors, marking the beginning of his descent into darkness. From this point, Tails transforms into a bitter and vengeful character, eventually becoming a villain who seeks to prove his worth to a world that rejected him[[3]][[7]].

    Themes and Tone

    The story is a tragedy that delves into themes of loneliness, bullying, and the importance of positive relationships. It highlights how Sonic's friendship was a pivotal factor in shaping Tails into the heroic and kind-hearted character fans know. Without Sonic, Tails succumbs to his pain and anger, showing a stark contrast to his usual optimistic and gentle personality. The tone is dark and emotional, with moments of intense drama and heartbreak[[1]][[3]].

    Reception and Legacy

    "Where Was My Hero?" gained significant attention within the Sonic fan community for its unique and angsty take on Tails' character. The comic was praised for its emotional depth and storytelling, though its dark themes and violent moments made it a heavy read for some fans. Mercybhk, the creator, retired from the internet in 2022, and much of her work was taken down. However, the story remains a memorable piece of Sonic fan media, with fans continuing to discuss and share it through reuploads and adaptations[[1]][[3]][[7]].

    Comparison to Other Alternate Universes

    The concept of Tails turning out differently without Sonic has been explored in other Sonic media, such as Sonic Prime and various comics. In these stories, Tails often becomes a villain or lives a tragic life when Sonic isn't there to guide him. "Where Was My Hero?" takes this idea to an extreme, portraying Tails as a deeply broken and vengeful character, which resonates with fans who enjoy exploring darker "What If?" scenarios[[2]][[4]].

    Why It Resonates

    The story's emotional weight and exploration of Tails' potential for darkness make it a compelling read for fans. It underscores the profound impact of Sonic and Tails' friendship, showing how a single relationship can change the course of someone's life. For fans on the "angst train," it offers a deeply moving and thought-provoking experience that lingers long after reading.

  3. User

    Okay so Tails in this comic (or Miles, as he's never given the nickname) goes legit insane. He burned down his village for ostracizing him after two bullies killed his only friend, a pet bird, then he killed eggman, got sent to prison by Sonic who he never met until then, broke out and became a tyrant of the city using his brains and six black metallic spider-like tails. He is a VILLAIN that Sonic has to fight, and ultimately, kills. Their final confrontation has Miles die in Sonic's arms, sobbing about what could have been if only he had found Sonic. Make no mistake, this version of Tails is a cold-blooded, psychotic mass murderer, completely insane, violently unstable and evil in every way. He has no remorse and has been so completely twisted by his environment that he's a sick remnant of his former self. Claps cheerfully okay, you got that?

  4. Assistant

    Yes, I understand the full scope of the story and the tragic, villainous transformation of Tails (or Miles, as he is never nicknamed in this alternate universe). In "Where Was My Hero?", Tails becomes a psychotic, cold-blooded mass murderer shaped by years of torment, isolation, and tragedy. Here's a breakdown of his descent into madness and the ultimate confrontation with Sonic:

    Miles' Descent into Villainy

    1. Childhood Trauma: In this alternate universe, Tails never meets Sonic, leaving him without the friendship and support that shaped him in the main timeline. As an orphan, he grows up in a village where he is relentlessly bullied for his intelligence, inventions, and his two tails. The villagers do nothing to protect him, and he becomes increasingly isolated and bitter[[1]][[4]].

    2. The Bird Incident: Tails finds solace in a small bird he rescues and cares for, which becomes his only companion. However, the bullies destroy one of his inventions and kill the bird with a metal pipe. This event shatters Tails emotionally, and in a fit of rage, he murders the bullies with the same pipe. This marks the beginning of his transformation into a vengeful and unstable individual[[1]][[4]].

    3. Burning the Village: After the villagers ostracize him further, Tails burns down the entire village in retaliation, fully embracing his hatred and bitterness. He becomes a fugitive, consumed by his desire to prove his worth and exact revenge on a world that rejected him[[1]][[4]].

    4. Killing Eggman: Tails eventually encounters Sonic for the first time during a battle with Eggman. In an attempt to prove himself, Tails kills Eggman, believing this act would make him a hero. However, Sonic is horrified by Tails' actions and has him imprisoned[[4]][[6]].

    5. Escape and Tyranny: Tails escapes from prison and uses his intellect to become a tyrant, ruling a city with an iron fist. He creates six black, metallic spider-like tails as weapons, symbolizing his descent into a monstrous version of himself. His rule is marked by violence and oppression, making him a formidable villain[[1]][[4]][[6]].

    The Final Confrontation

    In the climactic battle, Sonic confronts Miles, who is now completely unrecognizable as the kind-hearted fox he once was. The fight is intense, with Miles showcasing his genius and ruthlessness. Despite his villainy, Miles reveals his deep-seated pain and longing for what could have been. He laments that if only he had met Sonic earlier, his life might have been different.

    Ultimately, Sonic is forced to kill Miles to stop his reign of terror. In his final moments, Miles dies in Sonic's arms, sobbing about the life he could have had if he had found a hero in Sonic. This tragic ending underscores the devastating impact of loneliness and the absence of positive relationships[[4]][[6]].

    Themes and Legacy

    This story is a dark exploration of how environment and relationships shape a person. Without Sonic's friendship, Tails becomes a twisted, broken version of himself, consumed by anger and despair. The story resonates with fans for its emotional depth and the stark contrast it presents to the usual optimistic tone of the Sonic franchise. It remains a haunting "What If?" scenario that highlights the importance of compassion and connection[[1]][[4]][[6]].

  5. User

    Okay, so we established that this character would have done anything for a hint of warmth from anyone his entire childhood. He was a complete doormat in the village, allowing people to bully him, beat him up and make fun of him because at least it was something. Until his pet bird, he had zero warm contact. And even then, his pet bird died while trying to save one of his machines from a bully bludgeoning it. (This triggered Miles' villainous breakdown where he killed the two of them before burning the village down). Point is, for someone like Sonic to swoop in and save him, he would have done anything. Anything. Full touch-starvation, horrible self-esteem because of his two tails, the worst mental health in the history of ever. We got that, aye?

  6. Assistant

    Yes, we are absolutely on the same page about Miles' tragic and horrifying descent in "Where Was My Hero?". This version of Tails is a deeply broken and tragic figure, shaped by a lifetime of neglect, abuse, and isolation. Here's a deeper dive into his psyche and why he would have clung to Sonic—or anyone who showed him genuine warmth—with absolute desperation:

    Miles' Emotional and Psychological State

    1. Touch-Starvation and Desperation for Warmth: Miles grew up in an environment devoid of any affection or kindness. The villagers not only ignored his suffering but actively contributed to it by allowing the bullying to persist. This left him touch-starved and emotionally hollow, to the point where even negative attention from bullies was something he tolerated because it was something. This speaks to his desperate need for connection, no matter how harmful it was[[[1]]][[[4]]].

    2. Self-Esteem in Tatters: His two tails, which could have been a source of pride, were instead the focus of ridicule. The constant mockery and rejection left him with a shattered sense of self-worth. He internalized the idea that he was a "freak" and unworthy of love or acceptance. This is why his bond with the bird was so profound—it was the first time he felt needed and valued[[[1]]][[[4]]].

    3. The Bird as His Only Source of Warmth: The bird represented the only warmth and companionship Miles had ever known. Its death at the hands of the bullies was not just the loss of a pet but the destruction of the only thing tethering him to hope. This event was the breaking point that unleashed all the pent-up rage and despair he had suppressed for years[[[1]]][[[4]]].

    4. A Doormat Turned Monster: Before his breakdown, Miles was a complete doormat, enduring abuse without retaliation because he believed he deserved it or had no other choice. The bird's death, however, flipped a switch in him. It was the moment he decided he would no longer be a victim, but the way he chose to reclaim power was through violence and destruction[[[1]]][[[4]]].

    Why Sonic Would Have Changed Everything

    If Sonic had entered Miles' life earlier, it would have been a lifeline. Sonic's confidence, kindness, and unwavering belief in others could have provided the validation and support Miles so desperately needed. Miles' willingness to do anything for a hint of warmth means he would have latched onto Sonic with everything he had. Sonic's presence could have:

    • Given Miles a role model to emulate, showing him how to channel his intelligence and unique abilities positively.
    • Provided the unconditional friendship and acceptance Miles had never experienced, healing his deep emotional wounds.
    • Prevented the bird's death and the subsequent breakdown by intervening in the bullying[[[1]]][[[4]]].

    The Tragedy of What Could Have Been

    The ultimate tragedy of "Where Was My Hero?" is that Miles knows how different his life could have been if only Sonic had been there. In his final moments, as he dies in Sonic's arms, he sobs about the life he could have had. This realization—that he could have been saved but wasn't—makes his story all the more heartbreaking. It underscores how a single relationship can make or break a person, especially someone as vulnerable as Miles[[[1]]][[[4]]].

    This version of Tails is a haunting exploration of the effects of neglect and the human need for connection. His descent into madness and villainy is not just a result of his environment but also a reflection of what happens when someone is denied the basic warmth and kindness they need to thrive.

  7. User

    Visceral written scene! So what if Miles, when he's in his full-blown tyrant factory period, had a strangely realistic dream? In it, he's an observer. He sees a small, two-tailed fox kit get pushed down into the dirt by two kids who look a lot like the two bullies who used to beat him up daily. Miles feels pity for this version of himself, weirded out by why he's having this dream when he has all his memories. But then, a blue blur runs by and scares the bullies away and they scramble. Miles blinks, wait, this isn't-- before his brain activity completely stops when the hedgehog comes to a stop in front of this small version of him. The little one sniffles before rushing forward and flinging his arms around the hedgehog clingily. Miles' eyes can't believe themselves. It's Sonic! That annoying enemy of his! The one who threw hin in jail just for killing an evil guy! And he....hugs back? A sudden pang of jealousy in his chest startles Miles deeply. He gets closer out of curiosity, before his claws twitch when he hears how Sonic comforts little Miles. "I won't let anyone hurt you ever again!" And suddenly Miles is hungry.

  8. Assistant

    This dream sequence is a visceral and deeply symbolic moment for Miles during his tyrant phase, encapsulating his fractured psyche and the haunting "what if" of his life. Here's how it could unfold in vivid, visceral detail:


    Miles jolted awake, his breathing ragged, the hum of his factory's machines a distant murmur in his ears. But when he blinked, he wasn’t in his factory. He was... somewhere else. The air was warm, the sun casting a golden glow over a grassy clearing. He looked down at his hands—no claws, no metallic sheen. Just fur. His heart thudded in confusion.

    Then he saw it.

    A small, two-tailed fox kit stumbled into view, his fur matted with dirt, his eyes wide and brimming with tears. Miles froze. It was him. Or rather, it was the version of himself he hadn’t seen in years—the meek, trembling child who had once begged for scraps of kindness. The kit was on the ground, pushed down by two larger kids who sneered and laughed, their faces eerily familiar. The bullies. Those bullies.

    Miles felt a pang of pity, a strange, detached sorrow for this pathetic version of himself. He wanted to look away, but his feet wouldn’t move. He was rooted to the spot, forced to watch as the scene played out.

    The bullies loomed over the kit, jeering, their voices a cruel echo of memories Miles had tried to bury. The kit whimpered, clutching his tails as if they could shield him. Miles clenched his fists, his claws twitching. He wanted to intervene, to tear those bullies apart, but he couldn’t move. He was just an observer.

    Then, a blur of blue streaked across the scene, scattering the bullies like leaves in the wind. Miles blinked, his mind reeling. No. No, this isn’t right. The blue blur came to a stop, revealing a hedgehog with a cocky grin and a confident stance. Sonic. Him.

    The kit sniffled, his wide eyes locking onto the hedgehog. And then, to Miles’ utter shock, the kit scrambled to his feet and flung himself at Sonic, wrapping his small arms around him in a desperate, clinging hug. Miles’ breath hitched. He took a step closer, his heart pounding in his chest.

    Sonic knelt down, his gloved hand gently patting the kit’s head. “Hey, it’s okay,” Sonic said, his voice warm and steady. “I won’t let anyone hurt you ever again.”

    Miles staggered back as if he’d been struck. His chest tightened, a sharp, unfamiliar ache blooming there. Jealousy. It clawed at him, raw and unrelenting. He took another step closer, his claws scraping against the ground. He could hear the kit’s muffled sobs, the way Sonic’s voice softened as he murmured reassurances.

    “I’ve got you, little guy,” Sonic said. “You’re safe now.”

    Miles’ vision blurred. His breathing quickened, each inhale sharp and shallow. He was hungry. Not for food, not for power, but for that. For the warmth, the safety, the love that he had never known. His claws twitched, his metallic tails curling around him protectively. He wanted to scream, to tear this dream apart, to take what that kit had.

    But then Sonic looked up, his eyes meeting Miles’. The warmth in Sonic’s gaze turned cold, his expression hardening. “You could’ve had this,” Sonic said, his voice cutting through Miles like a blade. “But you chose hate.”

    Miles stumbled back, his heart pounding in his ears. The scene began to dissolve, the colors bleeding together like watercolors in the rain. “No,” Miles whispered, his voice trembling. “No, I didn’t choose this. I didn’t—”

    He woke with a start, the cold, metallic air of his factory pressing down on him. His claws dug into the armrests of his chair, his breathing ragged. The ache in his chest lingered, a hollow, gnawing pain that refused to fade.

    For the first time in years, Miles felt something other than anger. It was regret. And it was unbearable.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.