Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-search-preview-high-loc· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

You know the Sonic What If? fancomic about what happened to Tails if he never met Sonic,…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-pro-high’s answer.
  1. User

    You know the Sonic What If? fancomic about what happened to Tails if he never met Sonic, "Where Was My Hero?" By Mercybhk and what it's all about? Slams hands on table let's talk about it because I'm still in an angst train

  2. Assistant

    "Where Was My Hero?" is a fan-made comic by artist MercyBhk that explores an alternate universe in the Sonic the Hedgehog series, focusing on what might have happened to Tails (Miles Prower) if he had never met Sonic. In this narrative, Tails endures relentless bullying and isolation in his village due to his two tails, leading to a tragic series of events that culminate in his transformation into a villainous figure. The story delves deep into themes of loneliness, the impact of bullying, and the profound effect that friendships can have on one's life path.

    The comic is known for its emotional depth and has been discussed extensively for its tear-jerking moments. For instance, after the death of his pet bird at the hands of bullies, Tails experiences a breaking point that sets him on a dark path. The narrative also includes a poignant ending where Sonic confronts Tails, leading to a heartfelt exchange that underscores the tragedy of missed connections and the consequences of isolation[1].

    The creator, MercyBhk, released the comic on December 31, 2018, and it later received an official dubbed version on June 27, 2019. A sequel focusing on Sonic and Amy's relationship was also released, along with a two-part interquel that began in August 2021. However, in January 2022, MercyBhk retired and took down her accounts, leaving some parts of the series unfinished[2].

    The story has been noted for its exploration of a darker, more tragic version of Tails' character, providing a stark contrast to his traditional portrayal as Sonic's cheerful sidekick. This alternate take has resonated with many fans, sparking discussions about the importance of friendship and support systems in overcoming adversity.

    For those interested in experiencing the story firsthand, the official dubbed version of "Where Was My Hero?" is available to watch[3].

    It's understandable that such a poignant and emotionally charged narrative can leave a lasting impact, leading to deep reflection and discussion. The themes explored in "Where Was My Hero?" highlight the significance of compassion and the profound effects that our relationships can have on our lives.

  3. User

    Okay so Tails in this comic (or Miles, as he's never given the nickname) goes legit insane. He burned down his village for ostracizing him after two bullies killed his only friend, a pet bird, then he killed eggman, got sent to prison by Sonic who he never met until then, broke out and became a tyrant of the city using his brains and six black metallic spider-like tails. He is a VILLAIN that Sonic has to fight, and ultimately, kills. Their final confrontation has Miles die in Sonic's arms, sobbing about what could have been if only he had found Sonic. Make no mistake, this version of Tails is a cold-blooded, psychotic mass murderer, completely insane, violently unstable and evil in every way. He has no remorse and has been so completely twisted by his environment that he's a sick remnant of his former self. Claps cheerfully okay, you got that?

  4. Assistant

    Absolutely, I understand the depth of Miles' transformation in "Where Was My Hero?" His descent into madness and villainy is a stark departure from the Tails we know, highlighting the profound impact of isolation and trauma. The narrative's exploration of these themes has resonated deeply with fans, offering a poignant 'what if' scenario that underscores the importance of friendship and support. It's a testament to the storytelling that it evokes such strong emotions and discussions.

  5. User

    Okay, so we established that this character would have done anything for a hint of warmth from anyone his entire childhood. He was a complete doormat in the village, allowing people to bully him, beat him up and make fun of him because at least it was something. Until his pet bird, he had zero warm contact. And even then, his pet bird died while trying to save one of his machines from a bully bludgeoning it. (This triggered Miles' villainous breakdown where he killed the two of them before burning the village down). Point is, for someone like Sonic to swoop in and save him, he would have done anything. Anything. Full touch-starvation, horrible self-esteem because of his two tails, the worst mental health in the history of ever. We got that, aye?

  6. Assistant

    Yes, I understand. Miles' profound isolation and desperate yearning for connection in "Where Was My Hero?" are central to his tragic transformation. His complete lack of positive interactions and the relentless bullying he faced due to his two tails left him in a state of emotional starvation. The death of his pet bird, his sole source of affection, at the hands of bullies, was the catalyst that pushed him over the edge, leading to his descent into villainy. This narrative underscores the devastating impact that prolonged isolation and lack of support can have on an individual, especially during formative years. It's a poignant exploration of how crucial empathy and companionship are in shaping one's path.

  7. User

    Creative writing piece time! Third person limited view, extra poignant! So what if Miles, when he's in his full-blown tyrant factory period, had a strangely realistic dream? In it, he's an observer. He sees a small, two-tailed fox kit get pushed down into the dirt by two kids who look a lot like the two bullies who used to beat him up daily. Miles feels pity for this version of himself, weirded out by why he's having this dream when he has all his memories. But then, a blue blur runs by and scares the bullies away and they scramble. Miles blinks, wait, this isn't-- before his brain activity completely stops when the hedgehog comes to a stop in front of this small version of him. The little one sniffles before rushing forward and flinging his arms around the hedgehog clingily. Miles' eyes can't believe themselves. It's Sonic! That annoying enemy of his! The one who threw hin in jail just for killing an evil guy! And he....hugs back? A sudden pang of jealousy in his chest startles Miles deeply. He gets closer out of curiosity, before his claws twitch when he hears how Sonic comforts little Miles. "I won't let anyone hurt you ever again!" And suddenly Miles is hungry

  8. Assistant

    In the dim glow of his command center, Miles Prower—known to the world as the tyrant of the city—sat alone, the hum of machinery his only companion. His six metallic, spider-like tails lay dormant, a stark contrast to the turmoil within his mind. Sleep was a luxury he seldom indulged in, yet tonight, exhaustion claimed him, pulling him into a dream that felt unsettlingly real.

    He found himself an observer, standing on the outskirts of a familiar village. The scene before him was painfully reminiscent of his own past. A small, two-tailed fox kit lay sprawled in the dirt, pushed down by two jeering children who bore an uncanny resemblance to the bullies of his youth. The kit's eyes brimmed with tears, his tiny frame trembling from the sting of humiliation and pain.

    Miles felt a pang of pity for this younger version of himself, a sentiment he thought long buried. He was acutely aware that this was a dream; after all, he possessed all his memories. Yet, the vividness of the scene unsettled him.

    Suddenly, a blue blur streaked across the scene, sending the bullies scrambling in fear. The figure came to a halt beside the fallen kit, revealing itself to be a blue hedgehog. Miles' breath caught in his throat. This wasn't how things had transpired.

    The small fox sniffled, then, without hesitation, flung himself into the hedgehog's arms, clinging tightly. Miles watched, his heart pounding in his chest. The hedgehog—Sonic—wrapped his arms around the kit, holding him close.

    "I won't let anyone hurt you ever again," Sonic's voice was gentle yet firm.

    Miles' claws twitched involuntarily. This was the same Sonic who had thwarted his plans, the one who had thrown him into prison for eliminating Eggman. And here he was, offering the very warmth and protection that Miles had yearned for his entire childhood.

    A surge of jealousy coursed through him, sharp and unexpected. He stepped closer, drawn by a morbid curiosity. The scene before him was a stark contrast to his own memories—a life where he had been left to fend for himself, where no blue savior had come to his rescue.

    The hunger gnawed at him, not for power or control, but for the affection and acceptance he had been denied. The realization was a bitter pill to swallow. In another life, perhaps, he could have been that small fox, embraced and protected.

    The dream began to fade, the edges blurring as consciousness beckoned. Yet, the ache in his chest remained, a haunting reminder of what could have been, if only fate had been kinder.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.