Hi. I'm a mod developer for Payday 2, and recently the community (after the letdown of…
- User
Hi. I'm a mod developer for Payday 2, and recently the community (after the letdown of Payday 3) have been wanting a mod that increases difficulty a lot, making Death Wish seem like a walk in the park (for both stealth and loud). Can you help me design the mod to make a truly brutal but not frustrating experience? (That means no One-shotting heisters, save for Snipers).
- Assistant
Absolutely, I'd be thrilled to help you design a brutal yet fair difficulty mod for Payday 2! Striking that perfect balance between hardcore challenge and fun is key, especially when you want to avoid frustrating mechanics like one-shot downs. Since Death Sentence is already tough, you’ll be looking to go beyond it in thoughtful ways — both in stealth and loud gameplay — without feeling cheap or unfair.
Below is a high-level breakdown of ideas you can use to develop your "Nightmare"-tier difficulty mod (name suggestion?), tailored to both stealth and loud, while also incorporating some smart AI behavior redesigns, strategic pacing changes, and risk-reward incentives.
🔥 Difficulty Mod Concept — "Overkill Protocol" or "Hell's Reign"
🎯 Core Design Philosophy
Make it punishing to mistakes and require planning, skill, and team coordination — but not impossible or random.
- No one-shot kills except snipers.
- Encourage optimal synergy between heisters.
- Expand on enemy AI to make them smarter, not just tankier.
- Stealth: Mistakes snowball fast.
- Loud: Sustain pressure without unfair spikes.
🚨 Global Mechanics Changes
- Mission Timer/Heat Level Scaling: Introduce a heat-level mechanic. The longer you stay, the tougher the enemies that spawn (like police adapting).
- No Teleporting Spawns: Enemies spawn realistically, from logical map locations and entry points.
- Revamped Damage Model:
- Enemies do more damage, but it's consistent and avoidable.
- Balanced armor penetration: Armor slowing down but not negating all damage.
- "Warning" Knockdown: 1st down = longer bleedout and slightly less penalty, rewarding preparation and revives.
📦 Stealth Difficulty Enhancements
🕵️ Stealth AI & Systems Tweaks:
-
Guard AI Overhaul:
- Smarter patrols (non-strict patterns or more dynamic paths).
- Suspicion distances extended and customized per guard type.
- Guards investigate camera blackouts or frequent operator idling.
- Guards can radio for backup ONCE per heist as a soft alarm mechanic.
-
Civilians Behavior:
- Civs may try to run for panic buttons if nearby.
- Higher chance civilians don’t comply instantly, especially guards in disguise.
-
Hardcore Pager Tweaks:
- Introduce pager interception mechanic: You need to jam a signal tool on cooldown (adds challenge but NOT randomness).
- Limit to 3 pagers maximum, but allow a Hack-skill based workaround (e.g., short-term comms freeze or fake confirmation).
-
Cameras Are Smarter:
- Can track where ECMs are placed if enemies pass by and spot them.
- Are monitored — if too many are shut down, guards may go into "Suspicion Mode".
😬 Punishment Curve for Mistakes
- Minor mistakes (like bumping civs, camera hit) generate escalating suspicion.
- Get 1–2 warning events (e.g., minor radio traffic escalation), on the 3rd, all nearby guards switch to alert stance.
🔫 Loud Difficulty Enhancements
🚔 Enemy AI Behavior Tweaks:
-
Tactics, not just stats:
- Enemies flank better with coordination.
- Cloakers no longer YOLO—pair with other units or drop from unexpected angles (ceiling vents, darkness).
- Shields coordinate with push teams.
-
Unit Role Synergies:
- Bulldozers + Medics = a death squad. You need focus fire coordination.
- Mini-boss squads: Captain Winters-style lieutenants that act like mobile command units making enemies tougher.
-
Sniper Zones:
- Create longer sightlines on maps (or move snipers closer but high up).
- Use IR lasers before snipers shoot (gives counterplay window).
- Tracer rounds — risky, but you can find and remove them.
-
Special Enemy Rework:
- Tasers can disable gadgets (sentries/ECMs).
- Flashbangs are more likely to hit exposed players (more use of cover needed).
- Add a new unit? Like a “Saboteur” who disables your deployables or drops smoke bombs to obscure vision.
💽 Heister Side Mechanics:
💪 Reward Better Play:
- Better XP/$$ per clean wave — incentivizes mastering levels.
- Skill Synergy Boosts:
- Team bonuses if 4 different skill trees are active across the crew.
- Bonuses for using loudouts with synergy (e.g., one crowd control, one armor tank, one stealth tech).
🛑 Punish Mistakes Intelligently:
- Armor/Health has slower regen if you're constantly taking damage.
- Each down increases AI aggression toward that player for a time — zip around weaker players.
💣 Deployables Matter More:
- Sentries are smarter, scan for specials, and mark priority targets (can be upgraded via support skill).
- Ammo bags grant temporary buffs (e.g., bonus reload speed for 30s after use).
- Medic bags over haste kits—choose wisely. Limited per section.
🎮 Proposed Mod Features / Toggles
Let players tune some options:
- Enable/Disable pager hacking.
- Enable “No Mercy” mode — enemies don’t de-escalate.
- Hardcore Stealth Mode: No pagers.
- Ironman Mode: No downs at all.
🌐 Backend / Technical (If you're using BLT / BeardLib):
AI Rework via CharacterTweakData
- Edit
"brain"for cops to rewrite behavior trees — more flanking, prioritizing low-health heisters. - Modify movement speed, visual acuity.
WeaponTweakData
- Refine damage curves per enemy class.
- Reduce heister base weapon damage scaling to keep time-to-kill fair but unforgiving.
DelayedEnemySpawnElement / SpawnGroupLogic
- Customize when, what, and how enemies spawn.
- Use heat stages to modularly increase difficulty.
🧠 Testing and Progression
Difficulty Curves:
- Make sure early stages aren’t too brutal – give players time to gear up.
- Ramp from manageable → overwhelming only if they linger.
Beta Test Suggestions:
- Offer wave-based progression (like PD: Survive).
- Community playtesting via Discord / mod platform to balance AI tweaking.
🎁 Bonus: Give Heisters Some Toys?
- Add custom weapons or gadgets that are only usable in this mode (heat-vision drone? ECM that hacks radios?).
- Skill tree extension or minor perks exclusive for beating missions on this Nightmare mode.
Let me know:
- What kind of difficulty multiplier or system you're already using?
- Are you using vanilla codebases or extensive Lua scripting?
- Do you want this to be compatible with existing mods like OVERKILL+, Restoration Mod, etc.?
I'd love to help you write actual Lua script logic or tweak specific map files depending on what you want to work on first.
Which part of the mod would you like to dive into first — enemy behavior, stealth AI, or deployment/pager logic?
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
- o3-2025-04-16Compare side by side →
- grok-3-mini-betaCompare side by side →
gemma-3-27b-itCompare side by side →
- grok-3-mini-betaCompare side by side →
- gpt-4.1-2025-04-14Compare side by side →
gemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17Compare side by side →
- o4-mini-2025-04-16Compare side by side →
llama-3.3-70b-instructCompare side by side →
qwen-max-2025-01-25Compare side by side →