Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Hi. I'm a mod developer for Payday 2, and recently the community (after the letdown of…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4.1-2025-04-14’s answer.
  1. User

    Hi. I'm a mod developer for Payday 2, and recently the community (after the letdown of Payday 3) have been wanting a mod that increases difficulty a lot, making Death Wish seem like a walk in the park (for both stealth and loud). Can you help me design the mod to make a truly brutal but not frustrating experience? (That means no One-shotting heisters, save for Snipers).

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, fellow heister! Payday 2's Death Wish and even Death Sentence (DS) on current patches can feel a bit too manageable for veterans. Let's design a truly brutal difficulty that pushes the boundaries of what's possible, forces meta shifts, and demands mastery, without falling into frustrating one-shot territory (except for Snipers, as requested).

    Let's call this new difficulty "Inferno" or "Abaddon".

    Here's a breakdown of elements we can tweak for both Loud and Stealth, focusing on increasing challenge through enemy behavior, numbers, player limitations, and objective complexity, rather than just raw damage sponges or instant kills.

    Core Design Philosophy:

    • Punish Mistakes Severely: Small errors snowball into catastrophe.
    • Force Adaptation: The old meta might not cut it. Players need to rethink builds and tactics.
    • Emphasize Teamwork: Solo play should be significantly harder, if not impossible on many maps. Coordination is key.
    • Relentless Pressure: Keep players on their toes constantly.
    • Brutal, Not Unfair: Avoid unavoidable damage loops or instant non-sniper deaths.

    Difficulty Name: Inferno / Abaddon (Choose one or let players choose)

    Key Difficulty Modifiers (Applied over Death Sentence / One Down):

    I. Loud Gameplay - Turning the Heat Up

    1. Enemy Numbers & Density:

      • Increased Spawn Caps: Significantly higher maximum number of enemies active simultaneously.
      • Faster Spawn Rates: Reinforcements arrive much quicker, reducing effective "lull" periods between waves.
      • Higher Density: Enemies cluster more effectively and push into objectives/player positions more aggressively.
      • More Flankers: AI is more inclined to use alternative routes and flanking maneuvers.
    2. Enemy AI Enhancements:

      • Improved Coordination: Enemies prioritize targets better, focus fire on downed teammates, and react more cohesively.
      • Smarter Cover Usage: AI uses cover more effectively and is less prone to standing in the open.
      • Suppression Fire: Enemies use suppression tactics more intelligently to pin players down.
      • Grenade Usage: Enemies use grenades more often and more accurately to flush players out of cover.
    3. Special Unit Modifications:

      • Increased Spawn Rates & Caps: More specials overall, especially during assaults.
      • "Elite" Specials (Optional, but cool):
        • Elite Shield: More health/armor, shield has slightly more coverage, moves faster.
        • Elite Taser: Higher chance to instantly disable player, taser beam lasts longer, moves faster.
        • Elite Cloaker: Faster movement, more aggressive charge range, shorter warning sound, higher damage kick.
        • Elite Dozer: More health (but still killable with focus fire), slightly faster movement, higher damage minigun/shotgun, armored head (requires precise headshots or armor break).
        • Elite Sniper: Higher damage (confirm one-shot capability), faster target acquisition, maybe shoots through thin cover.
        • Elite Medic: Heals faster, heals more health, prioritizes Dozers and groups of specials. Increased health.
        • Elite Capt. Winters (if applicable): More shields, higher health, shields regenerate faster, accompanying phalanx units are stronger.
      • Increased Special Unit Health/Armor: Base health/armor buffs for all specials (on top of Elite versions if used).
      • Smarter Special Pathing: Specials are better at finding paths to the players.
    4. Assault Wave Intensity:

      • Longer Assaults: Assault waves last significantly longer.
      • Shorter Assault Breaks: The time between assaults is greatly reduced, offering less time to regroup and resupply.
      • Higher Peak Intensity: Assaults peak with even more enemies and specials than DS.
    5. Player Limitations (Resource Management is Key):

      • Reduced Ammo Pickups: Ammo dropped by enemies is reduced (e.g., 30-50% less).
      • Fewer Deployable Uses: Players have fewer uses for Ammo Bags, Med Kits, and Doctor Bags (e.g., 1 or 2 uses per bag). FAKs might also have fewer charges.
      • Slower Interaction Speeds: Interacting with objectives (drilling, hacking, opening safes, etc.) takes longer.
      • Stamina Drain: Stamina drains faster, forcing players to manage movement more carefully.
      • Inspire Cooldown: Inspire has a significantly longer cooldown.
    6. Objective & Map Modifications:

      • Objectives take longer: Drills jam more often, hacks take longer.
      • More Guards/Patrols during Loud sections: Reinforcements include patrol units that actively search areas.
      • Environmental Hazards: Small environmental hazards could appear (e.g., temporary smoke, increased likelihood of alarms triggering nearby cameras even during loud).

    II. Stealth Gameplay - Walking on Eggshells

    1. Guard & Camera Density:

      • Significantly More Guards: Maps have many more patrol guards.
      • Increased Static Guards: More guards standing still in key areas.
      • More Cameras: More cameras overall, covering more angles.
      • Fewer Camera Blind Spots: Existing camera blind spots are reduced or eliminated.
    2. Guard & Civilian AI Enhancements:

      • Faster Detection: Guards and civilians detect players, opened doors, broken objects, and bodies much faster.
      • Increased Suspicion Range: Suspicion range for noise and visibility is increased.
      • More Thorough Searches: Guards investigate suspicious signs (open doors, dropped items) for longer and search nearby areas more thoroughly.
      • Improved Communication: Guards communicate suspicious activity or findings to other guards more effectively and quickly.
      • Civilian Panic: Civilians panic faster and are harder to control (tying/dominating takes longer, higher chance of resisting). More civilians on maps.
      • React to Broken Objects: Breaking glass, knocking over objects, etc., instantly draws guard attention from a wider range.
    3. Detection Mechanics:

      • Noise Matters: Actions like crouching, opening certain doors, or even walking near thin walls generate noise that can alert guards.
      • Lighting: Poorly lit areas offer less concealment benefit. Good lighting makes you more visible.
    4. Pager & Body Bag Limitations:

      • Fewer Pagers: Significantly reduced number of pagers available (e.g., 1 or 2 per player total).
      • Shorter Pager Timer: Pagers have a very short time limit.
      • Failed Pager Penalty: Failing a pager check immediately triggers the alarm without a short grace period.
      • Fewer Body Bags: Significantly fewer body bags available. Body bags are bulkier or take longer to deploy.
    5. Objective & Map Modifications:

      • More Key Items: Objectives require finding and securing more key items spread across the map.
      • Complex Routes: Accessing objectives requires navigating more complex paths with multiple security layers (more locked doors, keycard readers, hacks).
      • Longer Objective Timers: Safes take longer to drill silently or require more complex hacks.
      • Less Forgiving Placement: Key objectives might be placed in high-traffic areas or areas with limited cover/escape routes.
    6. Stealth Failure Penalty:

      • Instant Heavy Assault: Failing stealth immediately triggers a severe assault wave, often starting with multiple specials.
      • Loud Start at High Intensity: If the map has a loud section, it starts at max or near-max assault intensity.

    III. UI & Feedback

    • Unique Difficulty Icon: A distinct icon on the level select and in-game UI.
    • Clear Difficulty Name: "Inferno" or "Abaddon" prominently displayed.
    • Optional: Unique Enemy Skins/Effects: Give elite specials or standard enemies a subtle visual cue (e.g., red glow, different armor pattern) to signify the higher difficulty.

    Balancing & Implementation Considerations:

    • Iterative Testing: This will require extensive playtesting. Start with moderate buffs and gradually increase them based on community feedback.
    • Avoid Instakills (Non-Sniper): This is crucial. While enemy damage should be high, players should still have a brief moment to react or get to cover before dying from a single common enemy shot or special ability (Cloaker kick is an exception as it's melee and meant to down). Snipers are explicitly allowed to one-shot.
    • Weapon/Perk Deck Meta Shift: Be prepared for certain builds to become mandatory or completely unviable. This is part of the challenge and forces players to experiment. For example, ammo-hungry weapons might struggle significantly. Deployable-heavy builds might be essential.
    • Mod Settings: Consider making aspects of the difficulty configurable for users (e.g., toggle Elite Specials, adjust ammo pickup rate multiplier, adjust pager count). This adds complexity but allows players to fine-tune their challenge.
    • Community Feedback Loop: Establish a clear channel for players to report what feels frustrating vs. challenging, what enemies are overtuned, etc.

    Example Numerical Adjustments (These are just starting points!):

    • Common Enemy Health/Armor: +50-100% over DS
    • Common Enemy Damage: +30-50% over DS (careful here to avoid instakills)
    • Special Health/Armor: +100-200% over DS (for Elite versions even more)
    • Special Damage: +50-100% over DS (again, avoid instakills)
    • Ammo Pickup: 50% of DS rate
    • Deployable Uses: Reduced to 1-2 per bag
    • Pager Count: Reduced to 1-2 total per player
    • Stealth Detection Speed: 50% faster than DS
    • Guard/Camera Count: +50-100% over DS
    • Assault Break Duration: Reduced by 50%
    • Assault Duration: Increased by 50%

    This is a comprehensive framework. Building and balancing it will be a significant undertaking, but it has the potential to create the ultimate challenge for Payday 2 veterans looking for a reason to return and truly test their skills. Good luck!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.