Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Hi. I'm a mod developer for Payday 2, and recently the community (after the letdown of…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-3-mini-beta’s answer.
  1. User

    Hi. I'm a mod developer for Payday 2, and recently the community (after the letdown of Payday 3) have been wanting a mod that increases difficulty a lot, making Death Wish seem like a walk in the park (for both stealth and loud). Can you help me design the mod to make a truly brutal but not frustrating experience? (That means no One-shotting heisters, save for Snipers).

  2. Assistant

    Below is a “recipe” for a custom difficulty tier that sits above Death Sentence + One Down but remains fair. I’m calling it “Project Masochist” in the examples, but of course feel free to rename. Everything is broken up into design goals first, with concrete implementation hooks for BLT/BeardLib/HoxHud-style scripting afterwards.

    ────────────────────────────────────────

    1. Design Philosophy & Pillars ────────────────────────────────────────
    2. Brutally punishing, never random or cheap
    3. Teaches good play (positioning, ammo economy, crowd control) rather than just inflating HP/DPS
    4. Respects the “fantasy”: snipers still one-tap (as requested); everything else kills only if you let mistakes snowball
    5. Allows recovery (clutch moments), so wipes feel “our fault”, not the RNG’s

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 2. Stealth Re-imagined ──────────────────────────────────────── Problem with current higher stealth tiers: guards still follow almost deterministic routes → speedrunners exploit timing.
    Solution: make information less perfect, not merely harsher numbers.

    New mechanics • Dynamic Patrol Nodes
    Every X-Y seconds the AI digs a “possible patrol” table and randomly picks next node within a region not a path.
    ‑ Hook: GroupAIStateBesiege:assign_patrol_path_to_unit → inject random node chooser.

    • CCTV Cooperation
    Cameras now actively ping any suspicious sound to nearby guards (small radius). Essentially micro-alerts that shorten reaction time if you’re clumsy with ECM rushes.
    ‑ Hook camera callback → send a logic_stand action with state = “alert_recheck”.

    • Pager Stress
    Pager call length grows the more pagers you’ve answered ( +0.6 s per answer ). This raises the risk of overlapping radios without simply dropping the 4-pager cap.

    • Civilians Remember Faces
    If a civ was intimidated, freed, then re-spotted a maskless crew member, they insta-alert (encourages tying & moving civs).
    ‑ Re-use civ “panic” logic with a flag was_intimidated = true.

    Numbers Tune-up • Detection cones +20 % length, +12 % width
    • Cameras rotate ±10 % faster
    • ECM lasts ‑15 % duration (but keeps feedback length identical for parity)

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 3. Loud Difficulty Framework ──────────────────────────────────────── A. Wave Logic • Wave density ↑ 33 % (more bodies) but enemy health ↑ only 12 %.
    Goal: More cross-fire angles without creating sponge city.

    • Specials spawn sooner, not necessarily more: – Spawn window for first Cloaker & Taser set to wave 1.
    – Bulldozer pool unchanged until wave 3 so players have breathing room.

    B. Unit Re-Works

    1. “Command Dozer” mini-boss
      ‑ Yellow visor. Slightly less HP than Skull Dozer, but aura gives +15 % damage to cops within 10 m.
      ‑ Encourages focus-fire.
      Implementation: new entry in tweak_data.character inheriting from bulldozer.

    2. “Medic Cloaker”
      ‑ Lower melee damage, carries 2 HE med-shot grenades it can lob at downed cops to revive them (once per grenade).
      ‑ Same pager sound when jumping to stay telegraphed.

    3. Shield Behavior
      ‑ If two shields stand within 3 m they auto-activate a short “phalanx” state: move 25 % slower, resist 95 % frontal, but receive double damage from behind.
      ‑ Simple state machine in shield_logicattack.

    C. AI Tactics • Flank Probability table (Behind/Side/Front) changed from 20/30/50 to 35/35/30.
    • Surrender checks for cops disabled (they never “hesitate” in this tier).
    • Smoke grenades cooldown reduced from 30 s to 22 s → forces repositioning.

    D. Player-Side Mitigations (Fairness Tools) • Weak-point multiplier on Dozers visor ↑ from 2.0 to 2.4 (makes precision rewarding).
    • All armor kit deployables restore 10 % ammo to each mag you’re carrying when picked up (small bump to sustainability).
    • Inspire base cooldown ‑5 s – the tier is punishing enough; allow heroes to clutch.

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 4. Objective / Map Layer ──────────────────────────────────────── Instead of just throwing more cops, lightly tweak objectives to create time pressure:

    • All drill timers short roll range is removed — you always get the upper bound (e.g. 330 s on basic bank).
    • Thermite and saws jam 25 % faster unless someone is actively interacting (lets dedicated “mechanic” keep them alive).
    • Escape choppers wait 35 s less once they arrive – arrive sooner, but leave sooner too; promotes pre-clearing zone.

    (Map hooks: intercept ElementTimer values or wrap base_delay table.)

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 5. Anti-Frustration Safeties ────────────────────────────────────────

    1. No random one-shots (besides snipers). All non-sniper weapons cap to 240 raw dmg vs health.
    2. Down spiral still capped at 4 → no soft-wiping by pure attrition.
    3. Convert percent chance mechanics to deterministic cooldowns where possible. Example: Cloaker kicks every ≥ 12 s, not 7 ± random(4).

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 6. Technical Skeleton (BLT/BeardLib example) ──────────────────────────────────────── File structure: mods/ └ ProjectMasochist/ ├ mod.txt ├ hooks/ │ ├ charactertweak.lua -- HP, unit stats │ ├ gaispawns.lua -- spawn groups & wave tables │ ├ stealth.lua -- camera & pager edits │ └ objectives.lua -- drill/chopper timers ├ lua/ │ └ ai_states/ │ ├ cl_shieldphalanx.lua │ └ cl_mediccloaker.lua └ assets/ (Dozer texture, shield icons, etc)

    mod.txt (snippet) { "name" : "Project Masochist", "description" : "Difficulty tier above Death Sentence OD.", "author" : "YourName", "contact" : "", "version" : "1.0", "hooks" : [ { "hook_id" : "lib/tweak_data/charactertweakdata", "script_path" : "hooks/charactertweak.lua" }, { "hook_id" : "lib/tweak_data/groupaitweakdata", "script_path" : "hooks/gaispawns.lua" }, ... ] }

    Example tweak snippet (charactertweak.lua) local CTD = CharacterTweakData Hooks:PostHook(CTD, "init", "maso_dozer", function(self) -- Base dozer HP ×1.12 self.bulldozer_HEALTH_INIT = self.bulldozer_HEALTH_INIT * 1.12 -- Command Dozer self.commanddozer = deep_clone(self.bulldozer) local cd = self.commanddozer cd.move_speed = cd.move_speed * 0.9 cd.weapon.is_r870 = true cd.abilities = { "buff_aura" } end)

    Spawn table edit (gaispawns.lua) local GAI = GroupAITweakData Hooks:PostHook(GAI, "init", "maso_spawns", function(self, difficulty) if difficulty == "masochist" then local sg = self.unit_categories sg.EasyCloaker_PRO = sg.Cloaker_PRO sg.EasyCloaker_PRO.amount = {1,2,3,3} self.special_unit_spawn_limits = {taser = 6, shield = 20, bulldozer = 4, cloaker = 6} ... end end)

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 7. Play-Testing Checklist ──────────────────────────────────────── • Stealth solo test – Bank Heist → verify pagers feel risky but doable
    • Loud 4-man pub – Cook Off 180 s wave → confirm ammo scarcity but survival ≈20 min
    • Dozer weak-point scanning (profile hot-spot) – make sure HS TTK <1 mag with meta primaries
    • Cloaker revive grenades – look at MP synchronization; fallback to normal cloaker if desync

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 8. Optional Flair ──────────────────────────────────────── • Dynamic kill callouts: tie into Bain/Locke lines (“They’re bringing in the Command Dozer, don’t let him boost ’em!”)
    • Custom mask unlock for completing heist on the new tier – an easy motivation loop without messing with balance.

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 9. Release & Community Handling ────────────────────────────────────────

    1. Ship as separate difficulty rather than overwriting DS/OD → avoids mod mismatch lobbies.
    2. Leave config file (.json) so server hosts can toggle specific modules (e.g., want stealth suite but vanilla loud).
    3. Open beta branch on ModWorkshop; solicit logs & feedback early, especially from DSOD veterans.

    Good luck turning Payday 2 into the unforgiving (but fair) gauntlet the community’s craving. And remember: pain should feel earned, never random. 🐷🎒

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.