Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o4-mini-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Hi. I'm a mod developer for Payday 2, and recently the community (after the letdown of…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-3.3-70b-instruct’s answer.
  1. User

    Hi. I'm a mod developer for Payday 2, and recently the community (after the letdown of Payday 3) have been wanting a mod that increases difficulty a lot, making Death Wish seem like a walk in the park (for both stealth and loud). Can you help me design the mod to make a truly brutal but not frustrating experience? (That means no One-shotting heisters, save for Snipers).

  2. Assistant

    Hey there! Let’s build a “truly brutal but fair” Payday 2 mod—think of it as Death Sentence on steroids, without random one-shots (except sneaky snipers). We’ll sketch out:

    1. Core design pillars
    2. Tweak categories & sample values
    3. Lua/TweakData snippets
    4. Balancing tips & playtest plan

    —

    1. Core Design Pillars

    • Punishing, predictable damage (no surprise one-shots)
    • Sharper AI: better aim, faster reaction, more coordination
    • Denser spawns & tougher specials, but still telegraphed
    • Stealth remains possible—but guard vision, loot-bag smell, alarms are unforgiving
    • Configurable “brutality level” so you can tune from “harder DW+” up to “pure masochism”

    —

    2. Tweak Categories & Sample Values

    CategoryParameterDefault DW“Brutal” Mod
    Enemy Health Multipliertweak_data.player.damage.HEALTH_INIT1.0x1.5x – 2.0x
    Enemy Damage Multipliertweak_data.player.damage.HEALTH_GRANULARITY1.0x1.3x – 1.7x
    AI Aim “Skill”cop_brain.accuracyBase+25% tighter spread
    Reaction Timecop_brain.reaction_delay0.4s0.2s
    Spawn Rategroup_ai.unit_group.spawnsStandard+20% spawn weight
    Specials Frequencyspecial_unit.spawn_rateStandard+30%
    Cops per Assault Phaseassault.phase.max_units5060–70
    Shield/Heavy Ratiospecial_unit.prob_shield0.150.30
    Sniper Damagesniper_unit.headshot150%300% (one-shot)
    Guard Vision Conesecurity_camera.fov60°80°
    Camera Rotation Speedsecurity_camera.speedBase×1.5

    Note: none of the “damage multiplier” lines should exceed ~1.7× so you’re never fragged by a grunt with one shot to the chest.

    —

    3. Sample Lua / TweakData Snippets

    -- in your mod's TweakData hook (e.g. tweakdata.lua):
    local td = TweakData
    Hooks:PostHook(td.PlayerDamage, "init", "BrutalHealthDamage", function(self)
        self.HEALTH_INIT = self.HEALTH_INIT * 1.7      -- 70% more health
        self.HEALTH_GRANULARITY = self.HEALTH_GRANULARITY * 1.5
    end)
    
    Hooks:PostHook(td.CopBrain, "init", "BrutalAISettings", function(self)
        self.accuracy = self.accuracy * 1.25
        self.reaction_delay = math.max(0.2, self.reaction_delay * 0.5)
    end)
    
    Hooks:PostHook(td.GroupAICopTweakData, "init", "BrutalSpawns", function(self)
        for _, phase in pairs(self.assault.phases) do
            phase.max_amount = phase.max_amount + 20
            phase.force_duration = phase.force_duration + 10
        end
    end)
    
    -- Increase special spawn weights
    Hooks:PostHook(td.SpecialUnitTweakData, "init", "BrutalSpecials", function(self)
        for name, data in pairs(self.specials) do
            data.spawn_rate = data.spawn_rate * 1.3
            if name == "shield" then data.chance = 0.3 end
        end
    end)
    

    For stealth tweaks:

    Hooks:PostHook(td.SecurityCameraTweakData, "init", "BrutalCams", function(self)
        self.fov = 80
        self.rot_speed = self.rot_speed * 1.5
        self.detection.range = self.detection.range * 1.2
    end)
    
    Hooks:PostHook(td.PlayerStandard, "init", "BrutalBagSmell", function(self)
        self._bag_value_multiplier = 0.5  -- loot is 2× “stinkier”
    end)
    

    —

    4. Balancing & Playtesting Tips

    1. Tiered Difficulty: Expose a “brutality_slider” in your options (0=DW+, 1=Extra+, 2=Masochist). Multiply all multipliers by slider.
    2. Data-Driven Playtests: Record average TTK (time-to-kill), death count, stealth-break stats. Aim to double deaths vs. Death Wish but keep TTK >1s on grunts.
    3. Visual/Audible Cues: When specials spawn or assaults ramp up, add a red screen flash or heartbeat cue—so veteran squads get a split-second warning.
    4. Feedback Loop: Ship an alpha with “brutality 0.8” and ask your Discord for specific pain points. Tweak one axis at a time (damage vs. spawn).
    5. No Random Bullshit: Ensure damage always scales by the same multiplier, so players can reliably know “two shotgun blasts from a grunt = near-down.”

    —

    Next Steps

    • Which heists do you want to stress-test first?
    • Do you prefer a JSON config or in-game slider?
    • Any ultra-crunchy ideas (e.g. self-healing cops, timed friendly-fire penalties)?

    Happy to dive deeper or help polish any segment! 😎

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.