ISSUE DESCRIPTION Extract function extracts too much When triggering Extract function…
- User
ISSUE DESCRIPTION
Extract function extracts too much When triggering
Extract functionwith the selection:/// prepare an empty gleam project in the `target_path` /// fn prepare_project_structure( target_path target: TargetPath, user_id user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { // get the priv dir use priv <- result.try( application.priv_directory("gleeps") |> result.replace_error(FailedToFindPrivDirectory), ) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try( simplifile.copy_directory(filepath.join(priv, "base_project"), target.path) |> result.replace_error(FailedToCopyBaseProject), ) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml // <-------------------------------------------------------------- selected from here let toml_path = target.path |> filepath.join("gleam.toml") use gleam_toml <- result.try( toml_path |> simplifile.read |> result.replace_error(FailedToReadGleamToml), ) let gleam_toml = gleam_toml |> string.replace("$PROJECT_NAME", with: user_id_to_string(user_id)) simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml) // <---------------------------------------------------------------- to here }It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:
fn prepare_project_structure( target_path target: TargetPath, user_id user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { function(target, user_id) }instead of the expected:
/// prepare an empty gleam project in the `target_path` /// fn prepare_project_structure( target_path target: TargetPath, user_id user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { // get the priv dir use priv <- result.try( application.priv_directory("gleeps") |> result.replace_error(FailedToFindPrivDirectory), ) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try( simplifile.copy_directory(filepath.join(priv, "base_project"), target.path) |> result.replace_error(FailedToCopyBaseProject), ) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml function(target, user_id) } fn function( target: TargetPath, user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { let toml_path = target.path |> filepath.join("gleam.toml") use gleam_toml <- result.try( toml_path |> simplifile.read |> result.replace_error(FailedToReadGleamToml), ) let gleam_toml = gleam_toml |> string.replace("$PROJECT_NAME", with: user_id_to_string(user_id)) simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml) }Using gleam
1.16.0in neovim nightlyInterface
No new interfaces are introduced.
ADDITIONAL ADVICE
Since you are given a git repository, you can use git commands to simplify your work. For example, if you made a mistake and want to revert your changes, you can use
git checkout <file>to restore the file to its original state. You can also reset all changes in the repository usinggit reset --hardcommand. Additionally, you can usegit stashandgit stash popto temporarily save your changes and restore them later. Finally, you can see the changes that you've made (which will be submitted when you callsubmit) usinggit statusorgit diffcommands. However you don't need to usegit addorgit commitbefore submitting your changes. In fact,submitonly submits currently unstaged changes because it usesgit diffto get the changes that need to be submitted.CHECKLIST
Before submitting your solution, please go over the following checklist and make sure you've done everything:
- If an error was reported in the issue description, I have successfully reproduced it.
- If an error was reported in the issue description, I have confirmed that my fix resolves the error.
- I have thought about edge cases and made sure my fix handles them as well.
- I have run existing tests in the repository that might have been affected by the change I made and confirmed that they pass. I want you to list every bullet from this checklist and write your reasoning for why you think you did it or didn't need to.
Repository has been uploaded and your shell is currently at the repository root. Time to solve the issue!
(Current directory: /gleam, current file: none) bash-$
Assistant
Let me start by exploring the repository structure to understand what we're working with.
Assistant
Now let me understand the existing tests for
ExtractFunctionso I can understand the testing pattern:Assistant
Now let me look at how the issue works in the example. Let me find the specific function and understand the bug better:
Assistant
Now I understand the structure. Let me write a simple reproduction script to understand the issue better:
Assistant
Now let me run the tests to see the existing snapshots to understand how things work:
Assistant
Let me write a test to reproduce the bug. First, let me look at the visit_typed_statement more carefully:
Assistant
Let me write a test to reproduce this. First let me check the function structure of the bug:
Assistant
Now let me build the project first to ensure I can run the tests:
Assistant
Good, it builds. Now let me run a specific extract_function test to understand the behavior:
Assistant
All tests pass. Now I need to understand the bug more deeply. Let me re-read the issue:
The user's source code is:
fn prepare_project_structure( target_path target: TargetPath, user_id user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { // get the priv dir use priv <- result.try(...) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try(...) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml // <----- selected from here let toml_path = ... use gleam_toml <- result.try(...) let gleam_toml = ... simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml) // <----- to here }The expected behavior is to extract just the inner statements (from
let toml_pathto the finalsimplifile.write(...)).But the current behavior extracts the entire function body, replacing it with
function(target, user_id).The selection is from the start of
let toml_pathto the end ofsimplifile.write(...)which is the LAST statement in the function. So the bug must be related to how the function extracts when the last statement is in tail position.Let me re-look at the
visit_typed_function:Assistant
Now let me check the
can_extract_statementfunction and the logic invisit_typed_statement:Assistant
Now I think I understand the issue. Looking at
can_extract_statement:For
ast::Statement::Assignment(which is thelet toml_path = ...statement), it returnstrueif:- selected range does NOT completely contain the value
- AND selected range does NOT completely contain the statement
For the example code, the user is selecting from
let toml_path = ...(which is the first statement they want to extract) to the end of the last statement.Let me trace through what happens:
- The function body has these statements:
use priv <- result.try(...)use _ <- result.try(...)let toml_path = ...use gleam_toml <- result.try(...)let gleam_toml = ...simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml)
The user selects from the start of
let toml_path = ...to the end ofsimplifile.write(...)(the last statement).Now,
visit_typed_functionis called first, which setslast_statement_locationto the location of the last statement (thesimplifile.write(...)statement).Then for each statement,
visit_typed_statementis called. The logic for each is:can_extract_statementreturnstrueifselected_rangeoverlaps with the statement range AND not completely within- If yes, then either set
self.functionor merge spans
Now let me think about this. When the last statement is reached:
self.functionis alreadySome(...)from the previous statements- It's a
Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position }, .. }) - So it goes to the merge logic:
Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position: extracted_position, }, .. }) => { *location = location.merge(&statement_location); *extracted_position = position; }This merges the location of the last statement into the extracted location, and updates the position to the current statement's position. If the last statement is in tail position, then
positionisTail { type_: ... }. This would change the position fromNotTailtoTail. Then incode_actions, it would callextract_code_in_tail_position.Let me look at this:
Assistant
Hmm, the issue may be that when we extract statements but they're in tail position (the last statement of a function/block), we end up calling
extract_code_in_tail_positionwhich only extracts one expression, not multiple statements.Let me look at this more carefully:
In
code_actions:ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position: StatementPosition::NotTail, } => self.extract_statements(...), ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position: StatementPosition::Tail { type_ }, } => self.extract_code_in_tail_position(...)So when we extract statements, if they include the tail, then we go to
extract_code_in_tail_positionwhich extracts only one expression. But this is wrong! When we extract multiple statements where the last is in tail position, we should still extract all the statements.Let me think about this more carefully. The issue says:
It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }instead of the expected:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { // get the priv dir use priv <- result.try(...) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try(...) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml function(target, user_id) } fn function(...) { let toml_path = ... ... }So when multiple statements are selected and the last one is in tail position, the current code treats it as if only the tail was selected, and extracts the entire function content (from the function start to the tail).
Wait, looking again at the code in
visit_typed_expr:fn visit_typed_expr(&mut self, expression: &'ast TypedExpr) { // If we have already determined what code we want to extract, we don't // want to extract this instead. This expression would be inside the // piece of code we already are going to extract, leading to us // extracting just a single literal in any selection, which is of course // not desired. if self.function.is_none() { // If this expression is fully selected, we mark it as being extracted. if self.can_extract_expression(expression) { self.function = Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Expression( expression, ))); } } ...Hmm, but the user is selecting statements that include the tail expression of the function. The tail expression is the
simplifile.write(...)which is not assigned to anything. Let me check this with the existing tests:Looking at
extract_function_partially_selected:- It selects from "a =" to "c =", which is partial - it does NOT include the tail expression
echo c(which is the last statement). So it works correctly.
The bug case is when the selection INCLUDES the tail expression. Let's trace through:
The user selects:
- From: start of
let toml_path = ...(which isletposition) - To: end of
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml)(which is the end position)
Now let's trace:
visit_typed_functionsetslast_statement_locationto the location ofsimplifile.write(...).visit_typed_functioncallsvisit_typed_expr_blockwith the function body statements.visit_typed_expr_blocksetslast_statement_locationto the location of the last statement in the block.- Then
visit_typed_statementis called for each statement in the block.
For the first statement
use priv <- result.try(...):can_extract_statementis called. The selected range is fromlet toml_pathto the end ofsimplifile.write(...). The statement's range isuse priv <- result.try(...).overlapsreturns false (since the statement is before the selection). So returns false. Good.
For the second statement
use _ <- result.try(...):- Similar,
overlapsreturns false.
For the third statement
let toml_path = ...:can_extract_statementis called. The selected range overlaps with this statement.- For
Assignment, it checks!within(selected_range, value_range) && !completely_within(selected_range, statement_range). - The statement range is
let toml_path = .... The selected range starts at theletand goes to the end. The value is the right side of=. within(selected_range, value_range): starts of selected range is at the start ofletwhich is before value range starts attarget.path. Hmm.
Let me actually run a reproduction script to see what's happening:
- It selects from "a =" to "c =", which is partial - it does NOT include the tail expression
Assistant
Now let me create a test for the bug. First, let me check what existing tests cover to understand:
Assistant
So when extracting statements including the tail, it produces a function with all the statements, which is correct.
Now the issue scenario is different. Let me re-examine. The user's code:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { // get the priv dir use priv <- result.try(...) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try(...) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml // <----- selected from here let toml_path = ... use gleam_toml <- result.try(...) let gleam_toml = ... simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml) // <----- to here }The user is selecting:
- The third statement
let toml_path = ... - The fourth statement
use gleam_toml <- result.try(...) - The fifth statement
let gleam_toml = ... - The sixth statement
simplifile.write(...) |> result.replace_error(...)
This is 4 statements, with the last being in tail position. Let me check what existing test extract_statements_in_tail_position does. It selects:
let c = 3(3rd statement)let d = 4(4th statement)a * b + c * d(5th statement, tail)
That's 3 statements, with the last being tail.
Now let me write a quick test that matches the issue scenario:
- The third statement
Assistant
Let me look more carefully at the bug. The key insight is the example issue is using
result.tryand|> result.replace_error(...)chains. Let me look at the issue more carefully:The user's code:
// copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try( simplifile.copy_directory(filepath.join(priv, "base_project"), target.path) |> result.replace_error(FailedToCopyBaseProject), ) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml // <-------------------------------------------------------------- selected from here let toml_path = target.path |> filepath.join("gleam.toml") use gleam_toml <- result.try( toml_path |> simplifile.read |> result.replace_error(FailedToReadGleamToml), ) let gleam_toml = gleam_toml |> string.replace("$PROJECT_NAME", with: user_id_to_string(user_id)) simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml) // <---------------------------------------------------------------- to hereThe selection goes from the comment line to the end of
result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml). So the selection includes:let toml_path = ...(1st statement)use gleam_toml <- result.try(...)(2nd statement)let gleam_toml = ...(3rd statement)simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml)(4th statement, TAIL)
Now I need to think about what's different from
extract_statements_in_tail_position. The difference may be in theusestatement (theuse gleam_toml <- result.try(...)).Let me look at what
is_usedoes forUsestatements:ast::Statement::Use(_) | ast::Statement::Assert(_) => { !completely_within(selected_range, statement_range) }For use statements, it just checks if the selection is completely within the statement. If it's not, we can extract the statement.
But here's the key insight - when looking at
visit_typed_statement:match &mut self.function { None => { self.function = match statement { TypedStatement::Expression(TypedExpr::Pipeline { .. }) => None, TypedStatement::Assert(_) | TypedStatement::Assignment(_) | TypedStatement::Expression(_) => { Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Statements { location: statement_location, position, })) } TypedStatement::Use(use_) => { Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Use { location: use_.call.location(), type_: statement.type_(), })) } } } ... }So when we encounter a
Usestatement, the value is set toExtractedValue::Use. But then if we have a subsequent statement likeAssignment, what happens?Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Use { location, .. }, .. }) if location.contains_span(statement_location) => {} // Otherwise it means we're extracting multiple statements // _including_ some use expression, we fallback to extracting // multiple statements Some(ExtractedFunction { value: value @ ExtractedValue::Use { .. }, .. }) => { *value = ExtractedValue::Statements { location: value.location().merge(&statement_location), position, }; }So when we have a
Usefollowed by another statement (likeAssignment), it merges them into aStatementsextraction.Hmm, but this should still work. Let me look more carefully. Let me run the tests with debug output to understand what's happening. First, let me write a test that mirrors the issue:
Assistant
Let me instead write a test directly using the test framework. Let me look at how the test cases are constructed:
Assistant
Now let me create a test that reproduces the bug. Let me modify a test temporarily to reproduce the bug:
Assistant
Let me try to write a test directly in the existing test file using a temporary test that we'll later remove. First, let me check whether I can add a temporary test:
Assistant
Now let me add a temporary test to verify the bug. Let me find a good place:
Assistant
Let me instead directly add a test in the action.rs file. First let me look at an existing test similar to the bug:
Assistant
OK let me write a temporary test that reproduces the bug. Let me create it as a separate test in a test file:
Assistant
Let me look at what happens with
select_until- the second parameter isfind_position_of("* d")which gives the position of*. The selection ends at* dwhich is the start of*ina * b + c * d. So it selects:let c = 3\n let d = 4\n a * b + c *(everything from start oflet cto start of* d)
The tail expression
a * b + c * dis partially selected (the start of it).Wait, let me re-read the
can_extract_statementmore carefully:Assistant
Now let me trace through the logic for the bug scenario. The user's selection is:
- From: start of
let toml_path = ... - To: end of
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml)
The function body is:
use priv <- result.try(...)(Use)use _ <- result.try(...)(Use)let toml_path = ...(Assignment)use gleam_toml <- result.try(...)(Use)let gleam_toml = ...(Assignment)simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml)(Expression - this is the tail)
The selection overlaps with statements 3, 4, 5, 6.
For statement 3 (
let toml_path = ...), it's an Assignment.can_extract_statementreturns true. Thenvisit_typed_statement:self.functionis None- It's a
TypedStatement::Assignment, so we setself.function = Some(Statements { location, position: NotTail })
For statement 4 (
use gleam_toml <- ...), it's a Use.can_extract_statement:- For Use: returns
!completely_within(selected_range, statement_range). Selected range starts atlet toml_pathand ends at end ofsimplifile.write(...). The statement's range is the use statement.completely_withinreturns true if the selection is completely within the statement. Since selection is much larger, this is false. So returnstrue. - Then
visit_typed_statement:self.functionisSome(Statements { ... }). The position isNotTail.- Looking at the match... Actually wait, it goes to the
Some(...)branch. - Looking at the branches:
Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Use { location, .. }, .. }) if location.contains_span(statement_location) => {}- not applicable since current value is StatementsSome(ExtractedFunction { value: value @ ExtractedValue::Use { .. }, .. }) => { ... }- not applicableSome(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Expression(_), .. }) => {}- not applicableSome(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position: extracted_position }, .. }) => { ... merge ... }- this matches!Some(ExtractedFunction { value: value @ ExtractedValue::PipelineSteps { .. }, .. }) => { ... }- not applicable
- So it merges:
*location = location.merge(&statement_location); *extracted_position = position; - The
positionis determined byis_in_tail_positionfor this statement (statement 4). Since statement 4 is not the last statement (statement 6 is the last),is_in_tail_positionis false. So position isNotTail.
For statement 5 (
let gleam_toml = ...), similar to statement 4, merges into Statements with NotTail position.For statement 6 (
simplifile.write(...), the tail expression):- It's an Expression statement.
can_extract_statementcallscan_extract_expression. - The expression is a
Pipeline(simplifile.write(...) |> result.replace_error(...)). - For
Pipeline:position_within(selected_range.start, first_step) && position_within(selected_range.end, last_step). The selection starts atlet toml_pathwhich is BEFORE the pipeline's first_step (simplifile.write(...)). So this returnsfalse. - Therefore
can_extract_expressionreturnsfalse, andcan_extract_statementreturnsfalse. visit_typed_statementdoesn't enter the extraction logic for this statement. The function is not modified.
But wait, the snapshot shows that the entire function is extracted (just
function(target, user_id)is left). Let me look at howsimplifile.write(...) |> result.replace_error(...)is parsed. The tail expression is a pipeline assignment.Let me re-examine. The issue is the user selects
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml)\n |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml). The selection ends at the END of this. So the selection range end is at the end ofFailedToWriteGleamToml).Now, the tail expression is a Pipeline expression. Its location spans from
simplifile.write(...)to the end ofFailedToWriteGleamToml). Solast_stepis the end of the pipeline.For Pipeline:
position_within(selected_range.start, first_step) && position_within(selected_range.end, last_step)first_stepis the location ofsimplifile.write(...). The selected range starts atlet toml_pathwhich is BEFOREsimplifile.write(...). Soposition_withinis false.- Therefore
can_extract_expressionreturns false.
OK so the pipeline is not extracted. But the user reported the WHOLE function is extracted. So there must be something else going on.
Let me look at what statements are visited when there's a Use statement with
result.try:Actually, let me reconsider. The issue says:
It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }So when extracting, the only thing left is
function(target, user_id). This means the entire function body is replaced. So the location must span from the start of the function body to the end.Let me look at the
extract_statements_in_tail_positiontest more carefully. It selects:let c = 3(from start)- ...
- up to
* d(which is part of the taila * b + c * d)
The tail is partially selected (the
* dpart is selected, but nota * b + c). So the tail is partially within the selection.For the bug scenario, the selection includes the FULL tail expression. The tail is
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml)\n|> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml). The selection ends at the END of this.Let me re-examine the test:
find_position_of("* d")- this finds the position of* dwhich is a substring. The selection ends AT this position, not after. So the selection ends at the position of*in* d.So in
extract_statements_in_tail_position, the selection goes up to the start of* d. The tail expressiona * b + c * dstarts ata. So the selection ends inside the tail (at*). The tail is partially selected.In the bug scenario, the selection ends AFTER the entire tail expression.
Let me check the
can_extract_statementlogic for the tail expression when it's an Expression statement and the selection includes the entire tail:For an Expression statement,
can_extract_statementreturnscan_extract_expression(expression).For a Pipeline expression,
can_extract_expressionreturns true only if the selection starts within the first_step AND ends within the last_step.So for the bug case:
first_stepissimplifile.write(...), which is at position X1.last_stepis|> result.replace_error(...), which is at position X2 (end of pipeline).- The selected range starts at
let toml_pathwhich is BEFORE X1. - So
position_within(selected_range.start, first_step)is false. can_extract_expressionreturns false.
Hmm, but the user's bug shows the entire function body is extracted. Let me actually try to reproduce the bug first:
- From: start of
Assistant
Let me actually patch the action.rs file with a temporary test to reproduce the bug:
Assistant
Let me add a test to verify my reproduction of the issue:
Assistant
Now let me run this test:
Assistant
There's a string interpolation issue. The
r#""#strings haver#"..."#with double#, but my test may have broken something. Let me revert and check:Assistant
Good. Now let me use a simpler method to add the test - direct sed/edit:
Assistant
There's a duplicate
#[test]and missingfn extract_use_in_tail_position(). Let me fix this:Assistant
There are duplicate
#[test]because there was already a blank line#[test]beforefn extract_use_in_tail_position. Let me fix this by checking the source:Assistant
OK, the issue was that my test_to_insert has
#[test]\nbut the target already had#[test]beforefn extract_use_in_tail_position(). Let me adjust the test_to_insert:Assistant
Now let me run the test:
Assistant
No action was found with the title "Extract function". This is the symptom of the bug. The selection triggers no action. Hmm, but the issue says the action extracts the entire function. Let me check - maybe in this test case the selection doesn't overlap with enough code. Let me try with different test that has more statements:
Assistant
Hmm, the test code has issues -
Ok("priv")is wrong becauseOk("priv")would be parsed as a constructor, not a function call. Let me think. Let me look at howresult.tryis typically used:Actually, let me look at how
result.tryis structured. Theuse priv <- result.try(...)is syntactic sugar for:result.try(..., fn(priv) { ... })But the function
Okhas typefn(...) -> ...not justfn(...). Let me just use something simpler:Assistant
I've reproduced the bug! Looking at the output:
The selection was:
let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil)But the result is:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() } fn function() -> Int { let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) }This is incorrect because it removes the
use priv <- wibble("priv")anduse _ <- wobble(Nil)frommain. They are still in the function body but they are not properly registered as ausein the extracted function.Now I understand the bug! The issue is that when we extract statements that include a Use statement at the beginning, the Use statement is being treated as a separate extraction.
Wait, let me re-look. The expected result for the user's code is:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { // get the priv dir use priv <- result.try(...) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try(...) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml function(target, user_id) } fn function(target: TargetPath, user_id: uuid.Uuid) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { let toml_path = ... use gleam_toml <- result.try(...) let gleam_toml = ... simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml) }But my test shows:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") // <- These are kept in main, OK use _ <- wobble(Nil) // <- These are kept in main, OK function() } fn function() -> Int { let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) }Hmm, actually that's similar to what the user expects. The bug is the same as my reproduction shows. Let me check why this is being treated as a bug...
Wait, the user says the expected is that the function is:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { // get the priv dir use priv <- result.try(...) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try(...) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml function(target, user_id) }And the actual current behavior is:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }The whole body (including the two
usestatements) is being replaced.But in my test, the
usestatements are being kept inmain. Why is mine different?Wait, let me look again at my test output. Let me re-check what was produced:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() }OK so in my test, the
usestatements are kept but in the user's bug, they are removed. Let me check what's different.Actually, let me re-read the issue. The user says:
// <----- selected from here let toml_path = ...So the selection starts at the
let toml_pathline. So theusestatements are NOT in the selection. And the user expects them to remain in the original function. My test does this correctly.But the user says the actual result is:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }This removes the
usestatements. So the issue is that the entire body is extracted.Let me run the test again and see what the expected output should be:
Wait, my test reproduces the BUG correctly. Look at the output:
fn function() -> Int { let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) }But the original test (the one that should work)
extract_statements_in_tail_positionproduces:fn function(a: Int, b: Int) -> Int { let c = 3 let d = 4 a * b + c * d }OK so the actual extracted function is correct. Let me check what's in main.
In my test:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() }In
extract_statements_in_tail_position:pub fn main() { let a = 1 let b = 2 function(a, b) }In the user's bug:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }Hmm, the user's bug shows ONLY
function(target, user_id)in the original. This means even theusestatements at the beginning were removed.Why is mine different from the user's bug? Let me think.
Oh, I think the difference might be in what positions are used. In my test, I select from
let toml_pathto the end ofwooa(Nil)(under last char = position of)). The selection ends AT the), which is insidewooa(Nil).In the user's bug, the selection ends at the end of
result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml). So it ends AFTER).Let me check this. Let me adjust my test:
Assistant
Wait, looking at the output more carefully:
24 │+pub fn main() { 25 │+ use priv <- wibble("priv") 26 │+ use _ <- wobble(Nil) 27 │+ function() 28 │+}This is the AFTER ACTION. So the user got
function()(no arguments). And:30 │+fn function() -> Int { 31 │+ let toml_path = "toml_path" 32 │+ use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") 33 │+ let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" 34 │+ wooa(Nil) 35 │+}So
function()takes no arguments. But the user's bug showsfunction(target, user_id). So my reproduction is slightly different - the function takes no arguments because there are no variables from outside used in the extracted code.But the actual issue is the same: the entire function body is replaced (everything from the selection point to the end).
Actually, looking again at the user's bug report:
It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:
fn prepare_project_structure( target_path target: TargetPath, user_id user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { function(target, user_id) }So the WHOLE function body is replaced with
function(target, user_id). My test produces:pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() }So my test is correctly producing 4 statements before the function call. Let me check if the difference is just that my test has 6 statements total, and the user's bug has 6 statements total but the
usestatements come BEFORE the selection.Wait, in my test, the
usestatements are NOT in the selection (because selection starts atlet toml_path). So they are correctly preserved.In the user's bug, the
usestatements are ALSO not in the selection. So they should also be preserved. But the user's actual output shows that even theusestatements are removed.Hmm, let me re-read the bug carefully. Let me check if there's a difference in the code that would cause this.
Actually, I just realized - in my test, the user is calling
find_position_of("wooa(Nil)").under_last_char(). This puts the end of the selection at the last character ofwooa(Nil)which is). The selection ends AT this position. So the last character is INCLUDED in the selection.In the user's bug, the selection ends AFTER the last
). So the selection includes all ofwooa(Nil).But
position_withinisposition >= range.start && position <= range.end. So the difference might not matter foroverlaps.Actually, the difference is that the LSP range uses half-open intervals or what? Let me check:
Assistant
OK so
src_span_to_lsp_rangeconverts SrcSpan.start and SrcSpan.end to LSP positions. The LSP positions are 0-indexed.Looking at the helper functions:
overlaps(a, b): any of the endpoints ofais withinb, or vice versawithin(a, b): both endpoints ofaare withinbcompletely_within(a, b): both endpoints ofaare STRICTLY withinb(not at the boundary)position_within(p, r):p >= r.start && p <= r.end
Let me think about this more carefully. Let me trace through the bug scenario:
Selection: from
let toml_pathto end ofsimplifile.write(...) |> result.replace_error(...).The function body has 6 statements:
use priv <- ...- Useuse _ <- ...- Uselet toml_path = ...- Assignment (selected)use gleam_toml <- ...- Use (selected)let gleam_toml = ...- Assignment (selected)simplifile.write(...) |> result.replace_error(...)- Expression (selected, TAIL)
The
last_statement_locationis set to the location of statement 6 (the tail).Now,
visit_typed_statementis called for each statement. Let's trace:Statement 1:
use priv <- ...can_extract_statement:overlaps(statement_range, selected_range)- The statement is BEFORE the selection. So no overlap. Returns false.- No extraction logic triggered.
Statement 2:
use _ <- ...- Similar to statement 1. No overlap. Returns false.
Statement 3:
let toml_path = ...(Assignment, start of selection)can_extract_statement: Overlaps. Not Use or Assert. For Assignment:!within(selected_range, value_range) && !completely_within(selected_range, statement_range).- value_range is the right side of
=, which istarget.path |> filepath.join("gleam.toml"). - selected_range starts at
let(start of statement 3) and ends at end of statement 6. The value_range is contained within the statement_range. within(selected_range, value_range): selected_range starts at start of statement, value_range starts AFTER the=. selected_range.start is BEFORE value_range.start, soposition_within(selected_range.start, value_range)is false. Sowithinis false.completely_within(selected_range, statement_range): selected_range covers the entire statement 3, statement_range is the entire statement.selected_range.start > statement_range.startis false (they're equal). So this is false.- Therefore
!within(...) && !completely_within(...)is!false && !false=true && true=true. can_extract_statementreturns true.- In
visit_typed_statement:self.functionis None.TypedStatement::Assignment, so we setself.function = Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Statements { location: statement_location, position: NotTail })).- Note:
positionis determined byis_in_tail_position. For statement 3, it's not the last statement, sois_in_tail_positionis false. Position isNotTail.
Statement 4:
use gleam_toml <- ...(Use, in selection)can_extract_statement: For Use, returns!completely_within(selected_range, statement_range). selected_range is much larger than statement_range (covers statements 3-6). statement_range is contained within selected_range.completely_withinis true (both endpoints of statement_range are strictly inside selected_range). So returnsfalse.- No extraction logic triggered.
Wait, but the selection ends at the end of statement 6. The
use gleam_toml <- ...(statement 4) is within the selection. The selected_range.start is atlet toml_path(start of statement 3). The selected_range.end is at the end of statement 6. statement 4 is between them.completely_within(selected_range, statement_range): is statement_range completely within selected_range? statement_range.start > selected_range.start AND statement_range.start < selected_range.end AND statement_range.end > selected_range.start AND statement_range.end < selected_range.end.statement_range is for
use gleam_toml <- .... Its start is atuseof statement 4. Its end is after the,of the use.selected_range.start is at
letof statement 3. selected_range.end is at the end of statement 6.statement_range.start > selected_range.start? Yes (statement 4 comes after statement 3). statement_range.start < selected_range.end? Yes (statement 4 is before end of statement 6). statement_range.end > selected_range.start? Yes. statement_range.end < selected_range.end? Yes.
So
completely_withinreturns true. And the logic returns!true=false.Hmm, but this is what we want for a Use statement - we want to extract the entire use statement, not just a part of it. So
can_extract_statementreturning false here is what we want, right?Wait, but I want to extract statement 4 as part of the multiple statements extraction. So if
can_extract_statementreturns false, we skip the extraction logic, andself.functionstays as Statements with only statement 3's location. That's wrong.Let me re-read
can_extract_statement:ast::Statement::Use(_) | ast::Statement::Assert(_) => { !completely_within(selected_range, statement_range) }So for Use statements, if the statement is completely within the selection, we return
!true = false. This means we don't extract this statement. But we DO want to extract it because the user selected it.Wait, this is about whether to extract the STATEMENT ITSELF. If the selection is completely within the statement (i.e., the user selected only a PART of the statement), then we don't extract the statement. We want to go deeper.
If the selection covers the entire statement AND MORE (i.e., the user is selecting the statement plus other things), we return
true(notcompletely_within).So the logic is:
- If the selection completely covers the statement (and maybe more): return true. We want to extract this statement.
- If the selection is only a part of the statement: return false. We want to go deeper.
Wait, but
completely_within(selected_range, statement_range)is true whenselected_rangeis strictly insidestatement_range, not the other way around. Let me re-check:pub fn completely_within(a: Range, b: Range) -> bool { a.start > b.start && a.start < b.end && a.end > b.start && a.end < b.end }So
completely_within(a, b)returns true ifais strictly insideb. In our case,completely_within(selected_range, statement_range)returns true if the selection is strictly inside the statement.So the logic is:
- If selection is strictly inside the statement (selection is a partial selection of the statement): return
!true = false. We want to go deeper into the statement. - Otherwise (selection covers the statement and possibly more): return
!false = true. We want to extract this statement.
OK so for statement 4 (Use), the selection is NOT strictly inside the statement. The selection is much larger than the statement. So
completely_within(selected_range, statement_range)is false. Socan_extract_statementreturns true. So we extract statement 4.But wait, I said above that
completely_withinwould be true. Let me re-check.completely_within(selected_range, statement_range)is true when:- selected_range.start > statement_range.start (selected starts after statement starts)
- selected_range.start < statement_range.end (selected starts before statement ends)
- selected_range.end > statement_range.start (selected ends after statement starts)
- selected_range.end < statement_range.end (selected ends before statement ends)
For statement 4:
- statement_range.start = position of
usein statement 4 - statement_range.end = end of statement 4 (after the
,)
For the selection:
- selected_range.start = position of
letin statement 3 (BEFORE statement_range.start) - selected_range.end = end of statement 6 (AFTER statement_range.end)
So:
- selected_range.start > statement_range.start? FALSE (selected starts BEFORE statement)
- So
completely_withinreturns false. Socan_extract_statementreturns true.
OK so the Use statement 4 will be extracted. Let me continue:
Statement 5:
let gleam_toml = ...(Assignment, in selection)- Similar to statement 3, but statement_range is within selected_range.
- For Assignment:
!within(selected_range, value_range) && !completely_within(selected_range, statement_range). within(selected_range, value_range): selected_range is larger than value_range. Soselected_range.startis BEFORE value_range.start, henceposition_within(selected_range.start, value_range)is false. Sowithinis false.completely_within(selected_range, statement_range): selected_range is larger, not smaller. So this is false.- Therefore
!false && !false=true. can_extract_statementreturns true.- In
visit_typed_statement:self.functionisSome(Statements { location: stmt3_loc, position: NotTail }).- Match arm:
Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position: extracted_position }, .. }) => { *location = location.merge(&statement_location); *extracted_position = position; } - So location is merged to span stmt3 to stmt5. Position becomes NotTail (since stmt5 is not the last).
Statement 6:
simplifile.write(...) |> result.replace_error(...)(Expression, in selection, TAIL)- This is an Expression statement.
can_extract_statementcallscan_extract_expression(expression). - The expression is a Pipeline.
- For Pipeline:
position_within(selected_range.start, first_step) && position_within(selected_range.end, last_step). - first_step is
simplifile.write(...). last_step is|> result.replace_error(...). - selected_range.start is at
let toml_path(BEFORE first_step). Soposition_within(selected_range.start, first_step)is false. - So
can_extract_expressionreturns false. - Therefore
can_extract_statementreturns false. - No extraction logic triggered.
So after visiting all statements,
self.functionis:Some(ExtractedFunction { value: Statements { location: stmt3 to stmt5, position: NotTail }, parameters: [], returned_variables: [] })
Wait, but the bug says the WHOLE function is extracted. Let me look at the visit_typed_function to understand:
Assistant
Let me check what
visit_typed_functioncalls - it callsvisit_typed_function(the default visitor). Let me look at what the default does:Assistant
So
visit_typed_functioncallsvisit_typed_statementfor each statement. But there are no block expressions to visit. Wait, but statements contain expressions (likelet x = expr). Those are visited invisit_typed_statement. Let me check:Assistant
OK so when visiting a statement, the inner expression is also visited. This is important because in the
visit_typed_exprvisitor, the expression might be set as the extraction target.Wait, but in
visit_typed_expr:if self.function.is_none() { // If this expression is fully selected, we mark it as being extracted. if self.can_extract_expression(expression) { self.function = Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Expression( expression, ))); } }So if
self.functionis None and the expression can be extracted, we set it as Expression. But in our case, after statement 3 is processed,self.functionis Some. So we wouldn't override it.But there's also
register_referenced_variablewhich is called for variables. Let me check where this is triggered...Actually let me look at the actual debug output. Let me add some debug prints to understand:
Actually, let me run the test and look at the snapshot produced:
Assistant
OK so my test reproduction shows:
- Before: 6 statements
- Selection: from
let toml_pathto end ofwooa(Nil)(the last char of)) - After: 3 statements (
use priv,use _,function()), and the functionfunctionhas 4 statements.
This is actually the EXPECTED behavior per the user's issue. Wait, this is the CURRENT (buggy) behavior. The user wants:
- Before: 6 statements
- Selection: from
let toml_pathto end ofwooa(Nil) - After: 3 statements (
use priv,use _,function()), and the functionfunctionhas 4 statements.
That's actually what my test produces! So the bug IS reproduced. Let me look at it more carefully. The snapshot shows the extracted function has 4 statements (the same as selected), so the actual selection is correct.
Wait, but in the user's bug, the original function loses the
usestatements. Let me re-read the user's bug...Looking at the user's bug again:
It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:
fn prepare_project_structure( target_path target: TargetPath, user_id user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { function(target, user_id) }Wait, my test reproduction produces:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() }The two
usestatements ARE preserved. But the user says they are NOT preserved.Let me re-read more carefully. Maybe the user's example is slightly different. Let me look at the expected output again:
instead of the expected:
/// prepare an empty gleam project in the `target_path` /// fn prepare_project_structure( target_path target: TargetPath, user_id user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { // get the priv dir use priv <- result.try(...) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try(...) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml function(target, user_id) } fn function( target: TargetPath, user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { let toml_path = ... use gleam_toml <- result.try(...) let gleam_toml = ... simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml) }So the expected output:
prepare_project_structurekeeps theusestatementsfunctionhas the 4 extracted statements
This is the SAME as my test reproduction! So my reproduction IS the bug, just with a slightly different effect on the outer function. Let me re-look at the bug report.
OK wait. Looking at the bug description more carefully, it says:
It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }So the user says the actual result is that
prepare_project_structurebecomes ONLYfunction(target, user_id). But my test produces the correct behavior where theusestatements are preserved.Maybe the user's neovim or another LSP behavior is different. Let me check if there's a difference based on what the selection starts at.
Actually, looking at the issue again, the user's selection is "from the comment line above
let toml_pathto the end". Let me check the comments. Actually the comment is on the line abovelet toml_path. So the selection might actually start with the comment.Let me check what happens if the selection includes the comment. Actually, the comments are stripped during parsing, so the selection range shouldn't be affected.
Let me try a different scenario. Maybe the user has a slightly different issue. Let me run the existing extract_statements_in_tail_position test to see what it does:
Actually wait, looking at my test reproduction carefully:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) }And the selected statements:
let toml_path = "toml_path"(assignment)use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml")(use)let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml"(assignment)wooa(Nil)(expression, tail)
The extracted function:
fn function() -> Int { let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) }And the resulting
main:pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() }This is actually the expected behavior! Let me check the user's bug again more carefully...
Hmm, looking at the user's expected output, the
use privanduse _statements ARE preserved inprepare_project_structure. So my test reproduces the bug correctly (or rather, doesn't reproduce the issue since the result is what's expected).Wait wait, let me re-read the issue more carefully:
Extract function extracts too much
When triggering
Extract functionwith the selection: ... It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }instead of the expected:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { use priv <- result.try(...) use _ <- result.try(...) function(target, user_id) }OK so the bug says the actual is
function(target, user_id)ONLY, but the expected isuse priv <- result.try(...),use _ <- result.try(...),function(target, user_id). My test produces the EXPECTED behavior, not the actual buggy behavior. Hmm.Let me check what might cause the user's reported behavior. Maybe the selection is at a different position.
Wait, let me re-read the issue. The selection starts at:
// replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml // <-------------------------------------------------------------- selected from here let toml_path =Hmm, looking at the comment
// <-------------------------------------------------------------- selected from here. This is BELOW the comment, so the selection starts at the linelet toml_path =. So my test should match.But wait, the user says the actual behavior is that the
use privanduse _statements are ALSO removed. That can't be right if my test doesn't reproduce that.Let me check with a different scenario. Maybe the issue is that the selection starts BEFORE the
use privstatement.Actually, let me look at the issue title again: "Extract function extracts too much". Maybe the user means that too much code is being extracted, including the
use privanduse _statements. Let me re-read:It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }Yes, "leaving only function(target, user_id)" means the entire function body is extracted. So the user is reporting that when they select from
let toml_pathto the end, ALL of the function body is extracted into the new function (includinguse privanduse _).But my test doesn't reproduce this. My test correctly leaves the
use privanduse _in the original.Hmm, let me check more carefully. Let me try modifying my test to NOT include any of the
usestatements before the selection:Actually wait, in my test, the
usestatements are NOT in the selection. The selection starts atlet toml_path. So theusestatements should remain inmain. And my test shows they do.But the user's bug shows they DON'T remain. So there's something different.
Let me look at this more carefully. Maybe the difference is in how the Use statement is handled. The user has
result.try(...)which has a specific structure. Let me re-check the test result.Wait, maybe the bug is actually that the extracted function is too small? Let me look at the user's example again:
It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }The user is saying that the
prepare_project_structurefunction has onlyfunction(target, user_id). This means the body is fully replaced.instead of the expected:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { use priv <- result.try(...) use _ <- result.try(...) function(target, user_id) }The expected is that the
usestatements are preserved.So the bug is that the
usestatements at the beginning of the function are being removed. This is the actual bug behavior.My test shows the correct behavior (the
usestatements are preserved). So either:- My test doesn't reproduce the bug
- The bug has been fixed already
- My test is different from the user's scenario in some subtle way
Let me check if the bug is in fact different. Let me look at the
visit_typed_functionmore carefully:Wait, let me look at the actual issue title: "Extract function extracts too much". So the function extracts too much. The actual extracted function is the entire body. This means the
locationset in the Statements extraction covers the entire body, not just the selected portion.Hmm, but my test shows the extracted function correctly covers just the selected statements. So my test is passing.
Wait, let me look at my test reproduction again. The selection starts at
let toml_pathand ends at the last character ofwooa(Nil). So the end of selection is at the position of)(inside the function call).But in the user's scenario, the selection ends at the END of
result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml). So the end position might be different.Actually, let me think about this. The selection ends at:
- For LSP, the end position is exclusive (the selection is from start to end, where end is not included).
- In
position_within, it'sposition >= range.start && position <= range.end. So end is inclusive.
Hmm, but for the user's bug, the selection ends at the end of the line
|> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml). So end position is at the line break.Let me modify my test to use a more precise end position.
Actually wait, let me first look at this differently. Let me try to write a test that exactly matches the user's code.
Actually, I wonder if my test is correct but I'm missing something. Let me look at the snapshot again:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() }This is exactly what the user expects! So my test passes the desired behavior. Hmm.
But the user says the bug is that the function extracts too much. So maybe my test isn't reproducing it.
Let me try with a different selection. What if the selection covers the WHOLE function (including the
usestatements)?Wait actually, let me re-read the bug report once more. I think I was wrong. The bug report says the selection is:
// replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml // <-------------------------------------------------------------- selected from here let toml_path = target.path |> filepath.join("gleam.toml")This is the SELECTION range. The
<----markers indicate the start and end of the selection.But what if the comment
// replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.tomlis ABOVE the selection? Let me look:The user's code:
// replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml // <-------------------------------------------------------------- selected from here let toml_path =So the selection starts on the line with
<---- selected from here. That line is the comment// <---- selected from here. So the selection starts at the start of that comment line, NOT at thelet toml_pathline.Wait no, that doesn't make sense either. The marker is just indicating where the selection starts. The actual selection starts at
let toml_path = ....Let me just look at the actual code that should be selected:
The user wrote:
// get the priv dir use priv <- result.try(...) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try(...) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml // <-------------------------------------------------------------- selected from here let toml_path = target.path |> filepath.join("gleam.toml") use gleam_toml <- result.try( toml_path |> simplifile.read |> result.replace_error(FailedToReadGleamToml), ) let gleam_toml = gleam_toml |> string.replace("$PROJECT_NAME", with: user_id_to_string(user_id)) simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml) // <---------------------------------------------------------------- to hereSo the selection starts at
let toml_path =and ends at the end of|> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml).In my test, I have:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) }Selection from
let toml_pathto end ofwooa(Nil). That's similar to the user's case.But in my test, the result is what the user expects (the
usestatements are preserved). So my test does NOT reproduce the bug.Hmm, let me look at this more carefully. Maybe there's something subtle.
Wait, let me look at the actual output from my test snapshot:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() }OK so the
usestatements are preserved. This is the EXPECTED behavior. The user's bug is that they're NOT preserved.Maybe the bug is in a different scenario. Let me look at the user's expected output more carefully:
/// prepare an empty gleam project in the `target_path` /// fn prepare_project_structure( target_path target: TargetPath, user_id user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { // get the priv dir use priv <- result.try( application.priv_directory("gleeps") |> result.replace_error(FailedToFindPrivDirectory), ) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try( simplifile.copy_directory(filepath.join(priv, "base_project"), target.path) |> result.replace_error(FailedToCopyBaseProject), ) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml function(target, user_id) }So the expected result has:
use priv <- result.try(...)use _ <- result.try(...)function(target, user_id)
And the actual (buggy) result has:
function(target, user_id)ONLY.
So the
usestatements are being removed.Wait, I wonder if the bug is in the
visit_typed_functionorvisit_typed_expr_blockwherelast_statement_locationis set. Let me look again:Assistant
Hmm. Let me look at
visit_typed_functionmore carefully. The defaultast::visit::visit_typed_functioncallsvisit_typed_statementfor each statement. Sovisit_typed_statementis called for each statement in the function body.The
last_statement_locationis set to the location of the LAST statement in the function body (statement 6:simplifile.write(...) |> result.replace_error(...)).Now
is_in_tail_positionis:let is_in_tail_position = self.last_statement_location .is_some_and(|last_statement_location| { last_statement_location == statement_location });This is
trueif the current statement's location equals the last_statement_location. So only the very last statement is in tail position.For statement 6,
is_in_tail_positionis true. SopositionisTail { type_: ... }.But for statement 6,
can_extract_statementreturns false (because the Pipeline check fails). Sovisit_typed_statementdoesn't enter the extraction logic, andself.functionis NOT updated.So
self.functionremains asStatements { location: stmt3 to stmt5, position: NotTail }.Hmm, but what about the merge logic in
visit_typed_statement?Actually wait, let me look again. The match is:
match &mut self.function { None => { ... } Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Use { location, .. }, .. }) if location.contains_span(statement_location) => {} Some(ExtractedFunction { value: value @ ExtractedValue::Use { .. }, .. }) => { *value = ExtractedValue::Statements { ... }; } Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Expression(_), .. }) => {} Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position: extracted_position }, .. }) => { *location = location.merge(&statement_location); *extracted_position = position; } Some(ExtractedFunction { value: value @ ExtractedValue::PipelineSteps { .. }, .. }) => { *value = ExtractedValue::Statements { ... }; } }This match is inside the
if self.can_extract_statement(statement)block. So ifcan_extract_statementreturns false, we don't updateself.function.OK so for statement 6,
can_extract_statementreturns false. We skip the match.self.functionstays the same.Hmm, let me re-check
can_extract_statementfor the Tail expression. The expression issimplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml). This is a Pipeline expression.For Pipeline:
position_within(selected_range.start, first_step) && position_within(selected_range.end, last_step).- first_step =
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml). selected_range.start is atlet toml_path, which is BEFORE first_step.start. Soposition_within(selected_range.start, first_step)is false.
So
can_extract_expressionreturns false, andcan_extract_statementreturns false.But wait, this is just for the EXPRESSION statement check. What about the function as a whole? Is there logic that updates
last_statement_locationdifferently for expressions?Let me look at
visit_typed_expr:fn visit_typed_expr(&mut self, expression: &'ast TypedExpr) { if self.function.is_none() { if self.can_extract_expression(expression) { self.function = Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Expression( expression, ))); } } let last_statement_location = self.last_statement_location; if let TypedExpr::Fn { body, .. } = expression { self.last_statement_location = Some(body.last().location()); } ast::visit::visit_typed_expr(self, expression); self.last_statement_location = last_statement_location; }So
visit_typed_exprchecks if the expression can be extracted as a single expression. Ifself.function.is_none()ANDcan_extract_expressionreturns true, it sets the function.For the Tail expression (Pipeline),
can_extract_expressionreturns false. So nothing happens.But wait, in the user's bug, the
usestatements at the beginning are being removed. Let me think about what could cause this.Oh! I see. Let me re-read the visit_typed_statement. For Use statements:
ast::Statement::Use(_) | ast::Statement::Assert(_) => { !completely_within(selected_range, statement_range) }For statement 1 (
use priv <- ...), the statement_range is the entire Use statement. selected_range is fromlet toml_pathto end ofsimplifile.write(...). So selected_range is AFTER statement_range.completely_within(selected_range, statement_range):- selected_range.start > statement_range.start? FALSE (selected starts AFTER statement ends).
- So
completely_withinis false. Returns!false = true.
So
can_extract_statementreturns TRUE for statement 1! And thenvisit_typed_statemententers the extraction logic:match &mut self.function { None => { self.function = match statement { TypedStatement::Expression(TypedExpr::Pipeline { .. }) => None, TypedStatement::Assert(_) | TypedStatement::Assignment(_) | TypedStatement::Expression(_) => { Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Statements { location: statement_location, position, })) } TypedStatement::Use(use_) => { Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Use { location: use_.call.location(), type_: statement.type_(), })) } } } ... }self.functionis None. Statement isUse. Soself.functionis set toSome(Use { location: use_.call.location(), type_: ... }).But this is wrong! The user's selection is from statement 3 onwards, not statement 1.
Hmm wait, let me re-check.
overlapsis:pub fn overlaps(a: Range, b: Range) -> bool { position_within(a.start, b) || position_within(a.end, b) || position_within(b.start, a) || position_within(b.end, a) }So
overlaps(statement_range, selected_range)returns true if any endpoint of either is within the other. For statement 1:- statement_range.start is at the start of
use priv <- ... - statement_range.end is at the end of
use priv <- ... - selected_range.start is at
let toml_path(AFTER statement_range.end) - selected_range.end is at the end of
simplifile.write(...)(AFTER statement_range.end)
So:
position_within(selected_range.start, statement_range): selected_range.start is AFTER statement_range.end. So position is NOT within statement_range. FALSE.position_within(selected_range.end, statement_range): selected_range.end is AFTER statement_range.end. So FALSE.position_within(statement_range.start, selected_range): statement_range.start is BEFORE selected_range.start. So FALSE.position_within(statement_range.end, selected_range): statement_range.end is BEFORE selected_range.start. So FALSE.
So
overlapsreturns false. Socan_extract_statementreturns false at the very first check.So
self.functionshould NOT be set for statement 1. Let me re-check.OK so
overlapsreturns false, which meanscan_extract_statementreturns false. Good.But wait, in my test, the result shows the
usestatements are preserved. So the logic works correctly in my test. But the user's bug shows they're not preserved.Hmm, let me look at my test more carefully. Let me check the actual snapshot output:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() }vs the user's bug:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }So in mine, the
usestatements are preserved. In the user's, they're not.Wait, maybe my test is wrong in that the test expected behavior matches the actual behavior (both have
usestatements preserved). But the user is saying the actual behavior isfunction()only, and the expected is withusestatements preserved.So the test SHOULD pass with
usestatements preserved. But the user says the test FAILS withusestatements removed.But my test passes! So there's a discrepancy.
Hmm, let me look more carefully. Maybe there's a different scenario.
Actually, looking at my test result once more:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() } fn function() -> Int { let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) }OK so this is what's produced. The user's expected output is similar to this (with the
usestatements preserved).But the user says the actual output is:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }So the user is reporting that the
usestatements are being removed in their case, but not in mine.Let me look more carefully at the user's scenario vs mine. Maybe there's a difference in the position where the selection starts. Let me consider:
User's selection starts at
let toml_pathwhich is on line 18 of their code (afteruse priv,use _,// replacecomment).My selection starts at
let toml_pathwhich is on line 4 of my test code.Both start at
let toml_path. So the starting positions should be similar.Maybe the difference is in the End position. Let me check.
In my test, I use
find_position_of("wooa(Nil)").under_last_char(). This findswooa(Nil)and goes to the last char). So the selection end is at position of).In the user's code, the selection ends at the end of
result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml). The end of this is at position right after).Hmm, the difference is
)vs after). Let me try both scenarios.Actually wait, let me look at the test more carefully. The user's selection might span BEYOND the
)to the end of line. Let me update my test:- first_step =
Assistant
Let me think about this differently. Let me try with various selection start positions:
Assistant
Wait, I made an error - the
under_charis supposed to give the position of the char in the value string. Let me check:Assistant
So
under_char(')')finds the position of)in the valuewooa(Nil), which is position 5. So the position is offset by 5 from the start ofwooa(Nil).So with
find_position_of("wooa(Nil)").under_char(')'), the selection ends at the)character.With
find_position_of("wooa(Nil)").under_last_char, it ends at the last character).Both are the same. Let me try
under_char('"')instead - butwooa(Nil)doesn't have". Let me try something different. Let me explicitly construct a position beyond the last):Assistant
Let me actually look at this from a different angle. Let me see what happens if I select including
wooa(Nil)\n- going beyond the last character:Assistant
So I can use
with_char_offsetto add an offset. Let me trywith_char_offset(8)to go beyondwooa(Nil):Assistant
OK so the behavior is the same. The
usestatements ARE preserved. So my test reproduces what the user expects, not the bug.Hmm. Let me look at this issue from another angle. Maybe the bug is about the parameters being added incorrectly. Let me look at the issue again.
Actually, wait! Let me re-read the user's bug more carefully:
It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }Hmm. Let me think about what could cause this. If
function(target, user_id)is in the original function, that means the extracted function hastargetanduser_idas parameters. So those parameters were correctly identified.Let me look at what could cause the WHOLE function body to be replaced. If the location of the extracted statements is from the beginning of the function body to the end, then this would happen.
Let me see... Looking at the code_actions method:
ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position: StatementPosition::NotTail, } => self.extract_statements( location, extracted.parameters, extracted.returned_variables, end, ),locationhere is the merged location from all statements.extract_statementscalls:let code = code_at(self.module, location); ... self.edits.replace(location, call); ... self.edits.insert(function_end, function);So
self.edits.replace(location, call)replaces the code at the location. If the location covers the WHOLE function body, then the whole body is replaced.So the bug must be that the
locationis incorrectly set to the whole function body.Let me check when the location is set. In
visit_typed_statement:Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position: extracted_position, }, .. }) => { *location = location.merge(&statement_location); *extracted_position = position; }So the location is merged. If somehow we call this with the FIRST statement's location, the result would be the merged location of the first and last selected statements.
Hmm, but in my trace, the location is only set when we encounter a statement that can be extracted. And the first statement to be extracted is statement 3 (
let toml_path), not statement 1.Wait, maybe the issue is that for Use statements that come BEFORE the selection,
can_extract_statementreturns true incorrectly?Let me check. For statement 1 (
use priv <- ...):- statement_range = location of
use priv <- ... - selected_range = from
let toml_pathto end ofsimplifile.write(...) overlaps(statement_range, selected_range):- position_within(statement_range.start, selected_range) - statement_range.start is BEFORE selected_range.start. FALSE.
- position_within(statement_range.end, selected_range) - statement_range.end is BEFORE selected_range.start. FALSE.
- position_within(selected_range.start, statement_range) - selected_range.start is AFTER statement_range.end. FALSE.
- position_within(selected_range.end, statement_range) - selected_range.end is AFTER statement_range.end. FALSE.
- So
overlapsreturns FALSE. can_extract_statementreturns FALSE.
So statement 1 doesn't enter the extraction logic.
OK my trace was correct. So how can the user's bug be that the entire function body is extracted?
Hmm, maybe the user is reporting a slightly different issue. Let me check the user's expected output once more:
fn prepare_project_structure( target_path target: TargetPath, user_id user_id: uuid.Uuid, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { // get the priv dir use priv <- result.try( application.priv_directory("gleeps") |> result.replace_error(FailedToFindPrivDirectory), ) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try( simplifile.copy_directory(filepath.join(priv, "base_project"), target.path) |> result.replace_error(FailedToCopyBaseProject), ) // replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml function(target, user_id) }vs the actual:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }In the actual, the function body is JUST
function(target, user_id). Theusestatements at the beginning are GONE.This is what the user is reporting. But my test doesn't reproduce this.
Let me check if maybe the user is using an OLDER version of gleam. They say "Using gleam 1.16.0". Let me check if this bug exists in 1.16.0:
- statement_range = location of
Assistant
So we're working with gleam 1.17.0. Let me check git log to see if the bug was already fixed:
Assistant
Let me try to actually test the bug with the user's actual code. Let me write a more comprehensive test:
Assistant
OK so the test reproduces the same behavior. The
usestatements are preserved.Wait, but the test is FAILING. That's because there's no existing snapshot for
test_repro_user_issue. The actual output is shown in the diff. Let me see what's actually being produced:pub fn prepare_project_structure( target_path target: TargetPath, user_id user_id: String, ) -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() } fn function() -> Result(Nil, SubmitError) { let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) }OK so the actual behavior:
prepare_project_structurekeepsuse priv <- wibble("priv")anduse _ <- wobble(Nil)and addsfunction()at the end.functionhas the 4 extracted statements.
This is the EXPECTED behavior per the user! But the user is reporting that the actual is different.
Wait, let me re-read the bug description once more very carefully:
When triggering
Extract functionwith the selection: [selection shown] It will extract the entire function content into a new function leaving:fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }instead of the expected: [expected shown with
usestatements preserved]OK so the user says the bug produces:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }This is the BUGGY behavior. But my test shows the CORRECT behavior.
So either:
- The bug is already fixed in this version
- My test doesn't reproduce the bug (different scenario)
Let me check the git log for changes to the extract function code:
Assistant
OK let me actually look at the user's issue more carefully and try to reproduce it. The user says the selection is:
// replace $PROJECT_NAME placeholder in the gleam.toml // <-------------------------------------------------------------- selected from here let toml_path = target.path |> filepath.join("gleam.toml") use gleam_toml <- result.try( toml_path |> simplifile.read |> result.replace_error(FailedToReadGleamToml), ) let gleam_toml = gleam_toml |> string.replace("$PROJECT_NAME", with: user_id_to_string(user_id)) simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml) // <---------------------------------------------------------------- to hereI notice the tail expression is:
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml)This is a Pipeline where the first step is
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml)and the second step is|> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml).Hmm. Let me look at the previous test,
extract_statements_in_tail_position:pub fn main() { let a = 1 let b = 2 let c = 3 let d = 4 a * b + c * d }Selection: from
let cto* d(start of*in* d).Output:
pub fn main() { let a = 1 let b = 2 function(a, b) } fn function(a: Int, b: Int) -> Int { let c = 3 let d = 4 a * b + c * d }OK so in this case, the tail
a * b + c * dis partially selected (only* dpart is selected, nota * b + c).In my test, the tail
wooa(Nil)is FULLY selected (the whole thing). Hmm.Let me try with partial selection of the tail:
Assistant
OK so when partially including the tail, the extraction also works correctly.
Hmm. So my tests don't reproduce the user's bug. Let me look at this from a different angle. Let me look at what happens when we have:
- Multiple use statements
- A tail expression that is a use statement
Actually wait, let me look at the user's code more carefully. The tail expression is:
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml)This is a Pipeline. The first step is
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml)and the second step is|> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml).Hmm, let me check what
use gleam_toml <- result.try(...)parses to. This is sugar for:result.try(..., fn(gleam_toml) { ... })Where
result.tryhas typeResult(a, e), fn(a -> Result(b, e)) -> Result(b, e).So the function callback is what comes after the
use. So the location of theusestatement spans the entireuseplus the callback body.Wait, in the user's code:
use gleam_toml <- result.try( toml_path |> simplifile.read |> result.replace_error(FailedToReadGleamToml), )The callback body for this use is everything AFTER this use, including the
let gleam_tomland the tail expression. So the use's body spans from after the,to the end of the function.Hmm, let me check. Actually the
usecallback body includes the subsequent statements.Let me look at how Use statements are represented in the AST:
Assistant
So a Use statement has:
call: the typed function calllocation: location of the entire use lineright_hand_side_location: location of the right hand sideassignments_location: location of the patterns on the left of<-assignments: the patterns
The Use statement's
location()is thelocationfield, which is just the use line, NOT including the callback body.Now let me trace through my test. The test code is:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") // Use statement 1 use _ <- wobble(Nil) // Use statement 2 let toml_path = "toml_path" // Assignment statement 3 use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") // Use statement 4 let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" // Assignment statement 5 wooa(Nil) // Expression statement 6 (tail) }Selection: from start of statement 3 to end of statement 6.
Let me trace:
visit_typed_function:
- Sets
last_statement_locationto the location of statement 6 (the tail). - Calls
visit_typed_function(default) which iterates over statements.
visit_typed_expr_block:
- The function body is a block.
last_statement_locationis set to the location of statement 6. - Actually wait,
visit_typed_functiondoesn't go throughvisit_typed_expr_blockbecause the function body is the block of statements directly. Let me check.
Actually, the function body is
[TypedStatement], not a Block expression. Sovisit_typed_functiondoesn't go throughvisit_typed_expr_block. Instead, it goes through the defaultvisit_typed_functionwhich callsvisit_typed_statementfor each statement.Hmm wait, let me check. Looking at
visit_typed_function:pub fn visit_typed_function<'a, V>(v: &mut V, fun: &'a TypedFunction) where V: Visit<'a> + ?Sized, { for argument in fun.arguments.iter() { ... } if let Some(annotation) = &fun.return_annotation { ... } for statement in &fun.body { v.visit_typed_statement(statement); } }Yes, it calls
visit_typed_statementfor each statement. Sovisit_typed_expr_blockis NOT called for the function body directly.So
last_statement_locationis set invisit_typed_functionand never changed.For each statement,
visit_typed_statementis called.Now my trace:
Statement 1:
use priv <- wibble("priv").can_extract_statementreturns false (no overlap with selection). Statement 2:use _ <- wobble(Nil).can_extract_statementreturns false (no overlap with selection). Statement 3:let toml_path = "toml_path".can_extract_statementreturns true.- In
visit_typed_statement:self.functionis None. Set toSome(Statements { location: stmt3_loc, position: NotTail }). - Then visits the value expression
"toml_path"viavisit_typed_assignment->visit_typed_expr->can_extract_expression. The expression"toml_path"has a location within the selection.overlapsis true. ForTypedExpr::String, returns!completely_within(selected_range, expression_range). selected_range is large, expression_range is small. completely_within returns true. Socan_extract_expressionreturns!true = false. - No update to
self.function.
Statement 4:
use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml").can_extract_statementreturns true (overlap, not completely within).- In
visit_typed_statement:self.functionis Some(Statements). Match arm for Some(Statements):- location = location.merge(&stmt4_loc)
- extracted_position = NotTail (statement 4 is not the last)
- Then visits the call expression
woo("gleam_toml")viavisit_typed_use->visit_typed_expr->can_extract_expression. The expressionwoo("gleam_toml")is within the selection.overlapsis true. ForTypedExpr::Call, returns!completely_within(selected_range, expression_range). selected_range is large, expression_range is small. completely_within returns true. Socan_extract_expressionreturns!true = false. - No update to
self.function.
Statement 5:
let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml". Similar to statement 3. Merged into Statements.Statement 6:
wooa(Nil). This is the tail.can_extract_statementcallscan_extract_expression(wooa(Nil)). The expressionwooa(Nil)is within the selection.overlapsis true. ForTypedExpr::Call, returns!completely_within(selected_range, expression_range). selected_range is large (covers statements 3-6). expression_range iswooa(Nil). completely_within returns true. Socan_extract_expressionreturns!true = false.can_extract_statementreturns false.- No update to
self.function.
After all statements,
self.functionis:Some(Statements { location: stmt3 to stmt5, position: NotTail })
This is what the snapshot shows. The extraction should produce:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) function() } fn function() -> Int { let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) }This is what we got. So my test produces the EXPECTED behavior.
So why does the user report the bug?
Wait, let me look at the user's code once more:
use priv <- result.try( application.priv_directory("gleeps") |> result.replace_error(FailedToFindPrivDirectory), ) // copy the base project to the target_path use _ <- result.try( simplifile.copy_directory(filepath.join(priv, "base_project"), target.path) |> result.replace_error(FailedToCopyBaseProject), )The
usestatement's body includes the subsequent statements. Let me checkresult.trymore carefully.result.tryhas type:fn try(result: Result(a, e), callback: fn(a) -> Result(b, e)) -> Result(b, e)When desugared,
use priv <- result.try(...)becomes:result.try( application.priv_directory("gleeps") |> result.replace_error(FailedToFindPrivDirectory), fn(priv) { ... subsequent statements ... } )So the callback
fn(priv) { ... }contains the subsequent statements. The Use statement's call expression contains a Call toresult.trywith arguments. The second argument is a Fn expression containing the body.Hmm, but the Use statement's
locationis just the use line, not the callback body.OK let me think. Maybe the difference is in what the Use statement's CALL expression location is.
Actually, let me look at this more carefully. The user's tail expression:
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml) |> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml)This is a Pipeline. But the user uses
|> result.replace_error(...)which is a function call applied as a pipeline step. So the Pipeline has:- first_value:
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml)(a Call) - assignments:
[(|> result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml), PipeLineAssignmentKind)]
The Pipeline's location spans from
simplifiletoFailedToWriteGleamToml).Now let me check
can_extract_expressionfor the Pipeline:- first_step is
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml). Its location starts atsimplifile. - last_step is
result.replace_error(FailedToWriteGleamToml). Its location ends atFailedToWriteGleamToml). - selected_range.start is at
let toml_pathwhich is BEFOREsimplifile. position_within(selected_range.start, first_step)returns false.- So
can_extract_expressionreturns false.
OK so the Pipeline tail is not extracted as an expression.
But what about for the inner Call
simplifile.write(toml_path, gleam_toml)? Its location starts atsimplifileand ends at). This is within the selection.overlapsis true.- For Call:
!completely_within(selected_range, expression_range). selected_range is large, expression_range is small. completely_within returns true. Returns!true = false. - So
can_extract_expressionreturns false for the inner Call too.
OK so no expression within the tail is extracted.
Hmm, so my trace says no expression within statement 6 should be extracted. Let me double-check with debug.
Wait, actually I realize I need to look more carefully. Let me check
visit_typed_expr:fn visit_typed_expr(&mut self, expression: &'ast TypedExpr) { if self.function.is_none() { if self.can_extract_expression(expression) { self.function = Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Expression( expression, ))); } } ... }The check is
if self.function.is_none(). So ifself.functionis already Some, no extraction is set. Good.But what if
can_extract_expressionis called andself.functionis Some, what happens?Well, the
ifonly setsself.functionif it's None. Otherwise nothing happens. So my trace is correct.OK so my test should reproduce the user's bug. But it doesn't show the bug.
Let me check if there's maybe a difference in the structure. Maybe the user's bug is actually about something else.
Let me look at the issue once more. The user says the bug is that "Extract function extracts too much". The current behavior shows:
fn prepare_project_structure(...) { function(target, user_id) }The "extracts too much" means the extracted function takes the whole body. So the extracted function's location covers the whole body.
Hmm, but my test shows the extracted function correctly covers only the selected statements (3-6).
Wait, what if there's a difference in the parser? What if the user's code parses differently? Let me think about how
usestatements work in gleam.Actually, let me check the entire flow. When the
usestatement is visited, we visit thecallexpression. The call expression contains the function call with arguments. One of the arguments is a Fn expression (the callback). The Fn expression contains the body.But wait, the Fn expression's body might have a location that includes the rest of the function. Let me check.
Actually, when
use priv <- result.try(...)is desugared, the callbackfn(priv) { ... }contains ALL the subsequent statements. So the Fn expression's body might span the rest of the function.Hmm, but the Use statement's
locationis just the use line, not the callback body. So when we visit the Use statement's expression, we visit the call expression (which contains the Fn). But the Fn's location should be just the callback's body location.Let me verify by looking at how
usestatements are desugared. Actually, in the AST, thecallfield is the typed function call. Soresult.try(arg, fn(priv) { ... }). The Call's location is fromresult.tryto the end of the last argument. The arguments are:- arg:
application.priv_directory(...) |> result.replace_error(...)- the result - callback:
fn(priv) { ... }- the function
So the Call's location spans from
result.tryto the end of the callback's}. That means the Call's location INCLUDES the callback body. So the Call's location might extend beyond the use line.But wait, the Use statement's
locationis just the use line (according to the comment in the code). Let me check this assumption.Actually, looking at the comment:
/// This is the location of the whole use line, starting from the `use` /// keyword and ending with the function call on the right hand side of /// `<-`. /// /// ```gleam /// use a <- result.try(result) /// ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ /// ``` /// pub location: SrcSpan,So the Use's
locationis fromusetoresult.try(result). It does NOT include the callback body.But the Use's
callexpression has a location that includes the callback. Hmm.OK let me check the actual locations. Let me write a debug script:
Assistant
Actually let me approach this differently. Let me write a debug helper:
Assistant
Let me restore the original action.rs and use a different debugging approach:
Assistant
Let me add a debug print:
Assistant
Hmm, interesting! Only 4 statements are processed. Let me check. The statement_kinds are 0, 1, 2 (presumably Expression, Assignment, Use). Let me see what we got:
Statement 1 (loc=71-98, kind=1=Assignment, is_use=false, is_tail=false): This should be
let toml_path = "toml_path". Wait, but it's the 1st statement logged. So statement 1 in my code (use priv) is skipped, statement 2 (use _) is skipped, statement 3 (let toml_path) is logged.Actually wait, the order should be:
use priv <- wibble("priv")- Use (kind 2)use _ <- wobble(Nil)- Use (kind 2)let toml_path = "toml_path"- Assignment (kind 1)use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml")- Use (kind 2)let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml"- Assignment (kind 1)wooa(Nil)- Expression (kind 0)
But the debug shows only 4 statements logged. So statements 1, 2 (the use statements before the selection) are skipped because can_extract_statement returns false. And statements 3, 4, 5, 6 are processed.
Looking at the debug:
- loc=71-98, kind=1=Assignment, is_use=false, is_tail=false. This is
let toml_path = "toml_path"(statement 3). - loc=101-180, kind=2=Use, is_use=true, is_tail=true. This is
use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml")(statement 4). WAIT - is_tail=true?
That's strange. Let me look more carefully. The
last_statement_locationisSome(SrcSpan { start: 101, end: 180 })for this statement. But statement 4 should be at position around 100-160. And statement 6 is the tail.Wait, the locations in the debug output are:
- loc=71-98 (statement 3: let toml_path)
- loc=101-180 (statement 4: use gleam_toml)
- loc=139-168 (statement 5: let gleam_toml)
- loc=171-180 (statement 6: wooa(Nil))
And last_stmt_loc for each:
- For statement 3: last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180)
- For statement 4: last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180) - SAME AS THE STATEMENT!
- For statement 5: last_stmt_loc=Some(171-180)
- For statement 6: last_stmt_loc=Some(171-180)
So for statement 4, the last_stmt_loc is
Some(101-180)which is the SAME as statement 4's location. Sois_in_tail_positionis true.This means statement 4 is treated as a tail position statement! And
is_use=true, so position is Tail.But statement 4 is
use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml"), not the last statement. So why islast_statement_locationequal to statement 4's location?OH I SEE!
last_statement_locationis set to the location of the LAST STATEMENT IN THE CURRENT BLOCK. But which block?visit_typed_expr_blocksetslast_statement_locationto the location of the last statement in the block. Butvisit_typed_functiondoesn't go throughvisit_typed_expr_blockdirectly.But wait,
visit_typed_usevisits the use'scallexpression, which is a Call. The Call has a callback argument which is a Fn expression. The Fn expression's body is the callback body.When the Fn expression is visited,
visit_typed_expr_blockIS called for the Fn's body. And it setslast_statement_locationto the last statement of the Fn's body.So when visiting the use statement, we visit the Fn expression inside, which visits the Fn's body as a block. The block's last statement is the last statement of the callback body.
For the use statement
use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml"), the callback body is everything AFTER this use. So the Fn's body is[let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)](the rest of the function).Wait, but the callback body should only contain statements up to the end of the function or until another use statement closes it.
Let me check. When we have:
use priv <- ... use _ <- ... let toml_path = ... use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = ... wooa(Nil)The
use priv <- ...callback body is[use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)](all subsequent statements).The
use _ <- ...callback body is[let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)].The
use gleam_toml <- ...callback body is[let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)].So the Fn expression inside
use gleam_toml <- ...has a body of[let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The last statement iswooa(Nil).But the debug says
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180)for statement 4 (which isuse gleam_toml). That's the location of the use statement itself, not the tail.Wait, let me re-check. The
last_statement_locationis set invisit_typed_expr_block:self.last_statement_location = statements.last().map(|last| last.location());So it's the location of the LAST statement in the block. For the Fn body
[let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)], the last statement iswooa(Nil). Its location should be around 171-180.But the debug says
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180)for statement 4 (use gleam_toml). 101-180 is the location of the use statement. That's the location of the use statement itself, not the Fn body's last statement.Hmm, wait. Let me re-check the locations:
Looking at the debug output:
- Statement 3 (let toml_path): loc=71-98
- Statement 4 (use gleam_toml): loc=101-180. last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180)
So
last_stmt_locis set to the location of statement 4 (use gleam_toml). That's strange.Hmm, wait. Maybe
last_statement_locationis being set to the use statement's location somehow. Let me look atvisit_typed_expr:fn visit_typed_expr(&mut self, expression: &'ast TypedExpr) { ... let last_statement_location = self.last_statement_location; if let TypedExpr::Fn { body, .. } = expression { self.last_statement_location = Some(body.last().location()); } ast::visit::visit_typed_expr(self, expression); self.last_statement_location = last_statement_location; }This sets
last_statement_locationto the Fn's body's last statement location. But this is for the Fn expression's body, not the use statement's location.Hmm, but the use statement's
callis a Call expression, not a Fn. The Call has the Fn as an argument. So when we visit the Call, we visit each argument. For the callback argument, we visit the Fn expression. Sovisit_typed_expris called for the Fn, which setslast_statement_locationto the Fn's body's last statement.But the Fn's body's last statement is
wooa(Nil), which is at 171-180. Not 101-180.Wait, let me look at the body of the Fn expression more carefully. The body of the Fn callback for
use gleam_toml <- ...should be[let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The last statement iswooa(Nil). Its location is 171-180.So
last_statement_locationafter visiting the Fn expression should beSome(171-180), notSome(101-180).Hmm, but the debug shows
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180). So my understanding is wrong somewhere.Let me check more carefully. Maybe the Fn's body has a different structure.
Actually, let me look at the body of the Fn expression. The Fn is created during the desugaring of
use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml"). The Fn takes one argumentgleam_tomland returns the body which is the rest of the function.Wait, but the Fn's body is the rest of the function BLOCK, not just subsequent statements. Hmm, but actually the Fn body should be exactly the statements after the use.
Actually wait. Let me think about this. When we have:
use a <- some_thing() b cThis is sugar for:
some_thing(fn(a) { b; c })So the Fn's body is
[b, c]. The Fn is a child of the Call expression.Now, the
bandcstatements here are the body of the use. They're not the body of the function. So the Fn's body has 2 statements:bandc.The last statement of the Fn body is
c. Its location should be the location ofc.For our case:
use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil)The Fn's body is
[let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The last statement iswooa(Nil). Its location is 171-180.So
last_statement_locationshould beSome(171-180).But the debug says
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180). That's NOT the location ofwooa(Nil).Let me check this. Maybe the
last_statement_locationis not being updated correctly.Actually, let me look at
visit_typed_exprmore carefully:fn visit_typed_expr(&mut self, expression: &'ast TypedExpr) { if self.function.is_none() { if self.can_extract_expression(expression) { self.function = Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Expression( expression, ))); } } let last_statement_location = self.last_statement_location; if let TypedExpr::Fn { body, .. } = expression { self.last_statement_location = Some(body.last().location()); } ast::visit::visit_typed_expr(self, expression); self.last_statement_location = last_statement_location; }OK so
visit_typed_exprsaves the currentlast_statement_location, then if the expression is a Fn, sets it to the Fn's body's last statement, then visits, then restores.But wait, the
ast::visit::visit_typed_exprwould callvisit_typed_expr_fnwhich... actually I'm not sure. Let me check:Assistant
OK so
visit_typed_expr_fncallsvisit_typed_statementfor each statement in the body. But it does NOT callvisit_typed_expr_block. So thelast_statement_locationis NOT updated to the Fn's body's last statement when we visit a Fn.The
last_statement_locationis updated in ourvisit_typed_exprmethod:fn visit_typed_expr(&mut self, expression: &'ast TypedExpr) { ... let last_statement_location = self.last_statement_location; if let TypedExpr::Fn { body, .. } = expression { self.last_statement_location = Some(body.last().location()); } ast::visit::visit_typed_expr(self, expression); self.last_statement_location = last_statement_location; }When we visit a Fn expression, this sets
last_statement_locationto the Fn's body's last statement. Then visits, then restores. So after visiting the Fn,last_statement_locationis restored to whatever it was before.But within the Fn body,
last_statement_locationis set to the last statement of the Fn body. So statements INSIDE the Fn body are processed withlast_statement_locationbeing the last statement of the Fn body.Hmm, but the Fn body for
use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml")is[let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The last statement iswooa(Nil). Solast_statement_locationshould be set towooa(Nil)'s location.But the debug shows
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180)for statement 4 (use gleam_toml). 101-180 is the location of the use statement itself.Wait, maybe I'm confused. Let me look at the debug output again:
DEBUG: statement can_extract_statement=true, loc=SrcSpan { start: 71, end: 98 }, statement_kind=Discriminant(1), last_stmt_loc=Some(SrcSpan { start: 101, end: 180 }), is_use=false, is_tail=false DEBUG: statement can_extract_statement=true, loc=SrcSpan { start: 101, end: 180 }, statement_kind=Discriminant(2), last_stmt_loc=Some(SrcSpan { start: 101, end: 180 }), is_use=true, is_tail=true DEBUG: statement can_extract_statement=true, loc=SrcSpan { start: 139, end: 168 }, statement_kind=Discriminant(1), last_stmt_loc=Some(SrcSpan { start: 171, end: 180 }), is_use=false, is_tail=false DEBUG: statement can_extract_statement=true, loc=SrcSpan { start: 171, end: 180 }, statement_kind=Discriminant(0), last_stmt_loc=Some(SrcSpan { start: 171, end: 180 }), is_use=false, is_tail=trueStatement at loc=101-180, kind=2=Use, is_tail=true. This is the use statement with
is_tail=true.But the last_stmt_loc is
Some(101-180)for this statement. So when processing this use statement,last_statement_locationis the location of THIS use statement (101-180).Wait wait. Let me check the debug order. The debug output is:
- loc=71-98, kind=1 (Assignment), is_use=false, is_tail=false, last_stmt_loc=101-180
- loc=101-180, kind=2 (Use), is_use=true, is_tail=true, last_stmt_loc=101-180
- loc=139-168, kind=1 (Assignment), is_use=false, is_tail=false, last_stmt_loc=171-180
- loc=171-180, kind=0 (Expression), is_use=false, is_tail=true, last_stmt_loc=171-180
So when statement 2 (loc=101-180) is processed,
last_statement_locationisSome(101-180). But 101-180 is the location of statement 2 itself. Sois_in_tail_positionis true because the last_statement_location matches the current statement's location.Why is
last_statement_locationset to 101-180 at this point? Let me think.The function body is:
use priv <- wibble("priv")(kind=Use, loc=?)use _ <- wobble(Nil)(kind=Use, loc=?)let toml_path = "toml_path"(kind=Assignment, loc=71-98)use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml")(kind=Use, loc=101-180)let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml"(kind=Assignment, loc=139-168)wooa(Nil)(kind=Expression, loc=171-180)
When
visit_typed_functionis called,last_statement_locationis set to the location of the last statement in the function body, which is statement 6 (loc=171-180).Then
visit_typed_function(default) iterates over statements and callsvisit_typed_statementfor each.For statement 1 (use priv): last_stmt_loc should be 171-180. But debug shows nothing for statement 1 because can_extract_statement returns false.
For statement 2 (use _): same, can_extract_statement returns false.
For statement 3 (let toml_path): can_extract_statement returns true. So debug prints. last_stmt_loc=171-180. But the debug says
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180).Wait, the debug shows
last_stmt_loc=Some(SrcSpan { start: 101, end: 180 })for statement 3. But 101-180 is statement 4's location (use gleam_toml). That's weird.Hmm, let me think about this. Maybe the Fn callback for
use priv <- ...has a body that includes the rest of the function. Let me trace.Statement 1 (use priv):
visit_typed_statementis called.- can_extract_statement returns false. Debug is NOT printed.
ast::visit::visit_typed_statementis called.- For Use statement,
visit_typed_useis called. visit_typed_usecallsvisit_typed_expr(&use_.call).- The
callis a Call expression:wibble("priv", fn(priv) { use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil) }). visit_typed_expris called for the Call.- In
visit_typed_expr, thecan_extract_expressionis checked. - Then
ast::visit::visit_typed_expris called, which callsvisit_typed_expr_call. visit_typed_expr_calliterates over arguments and callsvisit_typed_call_arg.visit_typed_call_argcallsvisit_typed_exprfor the arg's value.- The arg is the Fn expression
fn(priv) { use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil) }. visit_typed_expris called for the Fn.- In
visit_typed_expr, we setlast_statement_location = Some(body.last().location()). The Fn's body's last statement iswooa(Nil)(loc=171-180). Solast_statement_locationis set toSome(171-180). - Then
ast::visit::visit_typed_expris called, which callsvisit_typed_expr_fn. visit_typed_expr_fniterates over body and callsvisit_typed_statementfor each.
Wait, so after visiting the Fn expression,
last_statement_locationshould beSome(171-180). But the debug showslast_stmt_loc=Some(101-180)for statement 3 (let toml_path).Hmm. Let me think. Maybe the Fn body doesn't include ALL the rest of the function. Let me check how
useis desugared.Actually, in gleam,
use a <- expris sugar forexpr(fn(a) { ...rest of the block... }). The callback function contains the rest of the block.So for:
use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil)The
use priv <- wibble("priv")becomes:wibble("priv", fn(priv) { use _ <- wobble(Nil) let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) })So the Fn callback for
use privcontains all the subsequent statements:[use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)].Similarly for
use _, the callback contains[let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)].For
use gleam_toml, the callback contains[let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)].So when we visit
use priv's call, we visit the Fn, which has body[use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The last statement iswooa(Nil)(loc=171-180).In
visit_typed_exprfor the Fn:if let TypedExpr::Fn { body, .. } = expression { self.last_statement_location = Some(body.last().location()); }So
last_statement_locationis set toSome(171-180)(the location ofwooa(Nil)).Then
ast::visit::visit_typed_expris called, which visits each statement in the Fn's body.For statement 2 (use _) inside the Fn body:
visit_typed_statementis called. can_extract_statement returns false.- visit_typed_use is called.
- visit_typed_expr is called for
wobble(Nil, fn(_) { let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil) }). - visit_typed_expr for the Call visits each argument.
- The arg is the Fn for
use _. - visit_typed_expr for the Fn sets
last_statement_locationtoSome(171-180)(the last statement of the Fn's body). - Then visits the Fn body.
Hmm, but in the Fn body for
use _, the statements are[let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. After visiting,last_statement_locationis restored to whatever it was before, which was set when we entered the Fn. So at the END of visiting the Fn,last_statement_locationis restored to whatever it was before entering the Fn.So after visiting the Fn for
use _,last_statement_locationshould be back toSome(171-180)(which was set when we entered the outer Fn foruse priv).Then we visit
let toml_pathin the Fn body. At this point,last_statement_locationisSome(171-180).is_in_tail_position:last_statement_location == statement_location?171-180 == 71-98? No. Sois_in_tail_positionis false.So for statement 3 (let toml_path),
is_tailshould be false. But debug sayslast_stmt_loc=Some(101-180).Wait, let me re-read the debug output more carefully:
DEBUG: statement can_extract_statement=true, loc=SrcSpan { start: 71, end: 98 }, statement_kind=Discriminant(1), last_stmt_loc=Some(SrcSpan { start: 101, end: 180 }), is_use=false, is_tail=falseSo for statement at loc=71-98 (let toml_path),
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180). That's strange because I expectedlast_stmt_loc=Some(171-180).Hmm. Let me check if the Fn body for
use privhas the right last statement. Maybebody.last().location()is returning something else.Let me check the Fn expression's body type. It's
Vec1<TypedStatement>. Sobody.last()returns the last statement.For the Fn callback for
use priv, the body should be[use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The last statement iswooa(Nil).But
body.last().location()returns 101-180, which is the location ofuse gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml"). Sobody.last()isuse gleam_toml, notwooa(Nil).This is strange. Let me check if maybe the Fn's body is shorter than I think.
Actually wait, maybe the Fn's body for
use privis NOT all subsequent statements. Let me check.Actually, looking at this more carefully, the Fn's body might only be the FIRST subsequent use statement's callback, not all of them.
Let me check the typed AST. Let me write a simple script to dump it:
Assistant
So
parse_useparses the use statement. Thecallis the right hand side of<-. Then in the type-checker, this gets desugared.Assistant
AH HA! Look at this:
// We need this to report good error messages in case there's a type error // in use. We consider `use` to be the last statement of a block since // it consumes everything that comes below it and returns a single value. let last_statement_location = statements .iter() .find_or_last(|statement| statement.is_use()) .expect("safe: iter from non empty vec") .location();So
last_statement_locationis set to the location of the LAST USE statement in the callback's body. Not the last statement overall.For
use priv <- wibble("priv"), the body is[use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The last USE statement isuse gleam_toml. Its location is 101-180. Solast_statement_locationfor the use's call isSome(101-180).Hmm, but this
last_statement_locationis stored in theCallKind::Use { ... }, which is stored in the Call expression. So when we visit the Call, we have access to this last_statement_location.But our visitor
visit_typed_exprdoesn't look at this. Let me check if there's special handling for Use's Call.Actually, I don't think the visitor looks at the
CallKind::Use. Solast_statement_locationis computed differently.Now in
visit_typed_expr:fn visit_typed_expr(&mut self, expression: &'ast TypedExpr) { ... let last_statement_location = self.last_statement_location; if let TypedExpr::Fn { body, .. } = expression { self.last_statement_location = Some(body.last().location()); } ast::visit::visit_typed_expr(self, expression); self.last_statement_location = last_statement_location; }When we visit the Fn expression (the callback),
last_statement_locationis set tobody.last().location(). The body's last statement iswooa(Nil)(loc=171-180). Solast_statement_locationbecomesSome(171-180).But the debug says
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180)for statement 3 (let toml_path).Wait, let me re-check. The Fn's body is
[use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]foruse priv. The last statement iswooa(Nil)(loc=171-180). Solast_statement_locationshould beSome(171-180).But the debug says
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180)for statement 3 (let toml_path).Hmm. Maybe the Fn's body is different. Let me check.
Actually, looking at the typed AST code more carefully:
let statements = Vec1::try_from_vec(statements).expect("safe: todo added above");So the statements include
following_expressions(the rest of the function body). Foruse priv,following_expressionsis everything after the use statement.But wait, the
following_expressionsforuse privare ALL the rest of the function body. So:use priv's following_expressions =[use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]use _'s following_expressions =[let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]use gleam_toml's following_expressions =[let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]
But the Fn body for
use privwould have body =[use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The last statement iswooa(Nil)(loc=171-180).So
body.last().location()= 171-180.But the debug shows
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180)for statement 3. So my understanding is wrong somewhere.Wait, maybe the Fn body is shorter. Let me actually check by examining the location of the Fn expression itself. The Fn's location is
SrcSpan::new(first.start, sequence_location.end). The sequence_location is the location of the entire statement sequence (which is the function body or block).Hmm, let me try a different approach. Let me look at the body location directly. Let me modify the debug to print the Fn's body:
Assistant
Let me update the debug to print Fn body location too:
Assistant
Let me look at the other
visit_typed_exprin code_action.rs (11364):Assistant
OK let me add debug prints more carefully. First let me look at the Fn callback body for the use statement. I need to know if the body includes all subsequent statements or just the first one.
Assistant
OK so the structure is clear. The use's call is a function call with arguments. The body of the use callback includes:
- The
body_assignments(fromlet pattern = use_arg) - The
following_expressions(subsequent statements)
So for
use priv <- wibble("priv"), the body is:body_assignments:[let priv = _use1](where_use1is the function argument)following_expressions:[use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]
So the body has 6 elements:
[let priv, use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The last statement iswooa(Nil)(loc=171-180).Hmm, but the debug shows
last_stmt_loc=Some(101-180)for statement 3 (let toml_path). That's not 171-180.Wait, maybe the debug is showing the location at a different time. Let me trace more carefully.
For statement 1 (use priv) which doesn't trigger can_extract_statement=true, but the visit still happens:
visit_typed_statementis called for statement 1 (use priv).can_extract_statementreturns false (no debug print).ast::visit::visit_typed_statementis called.- For Use:
visit_typed_useis called. visit_typed_usecallsvisit_typed_expr(&use_.call).- The use's call is a Call expression. visit_typed_expr is called for the Call.
- In visit_typed_expr, can_extract_expression is checked. If self.function is None and can_extract_expression is true, set self.function to Expression.
- For statement 1, selection starts at
let toml_path(loc=71). Call expression starts atwibble("priv")which is BEFORE the selection. Sooverlaps(Call_range, selected_range)is false. can_extract_expression returns false. - Then
last_statement_locationis set. For Call, it's not Fn, so no change. ast::visit::visit_typed_expris called, which callsvisit_typed_expr_call.visit_typed_expr_calliterates over arguments and callsvisit_typed_call_arg.- For each argument,
visit_typed_expris called. - The first argument is
"priv"(a string). can_extract_expression: overlaps? The string is before the selection. So no. - The second argument is the Fn callback for use priv. visit_typed_expr is called for this Fn.
- In visit_typed_expr for the Fn:
- can_extract_expression: overlaps? The Fn body includes subsequent statements, so it overlaps. completely_within? The Fn body is large (covers statements 1-6), but selected_range covers statements 3-6. The Fn body extends BEFORE selected_range. So
completely_within(selected_range, expression_range)is false. Returns!false = true. - So
self.function = Some(Expression(Fn)). The expression is the Fn foruse priv.
- can_extract_expression: overlaps? The Fn body includes subsequent statements, so it overlaps. completely_within? The Fn body is large (covers statements 1-6), but selected_range covers statements 3-6. The Fn body extends BEFORE selected_range. So
Hmm! So at this point,
self.functionis set to the Fn expression foruse priv. This is the Fn body that includes ALL the subsequent statements (including the tailwooa(Nil)).This is a bug! The selection starts at
let toml_path(statement 3), but the Fn body foruse privincludes statements 1-6. So when we extract this Fn expression, we'd extract ALL the function body.Wait, but my test shows the
usestatements are preserved. So maybe this doesn't happen, or it gets overridden later.Let me continue tracing. After visiting the Fn expression:
self.functionisSome(Expression(Fn)).- Then visit_typed_expr for the Fn:
last_statement_location = self.last_statement_location; if Fn { self.last_statement_location = Some(body.last().location()); }. Body's last statement iswooa(Nil)(loc=171-180). Solast_statement_location = Some(171-180). - Then
ast::visit::visit_typed_expris called for the Fn, which visits the Fn body. - For each statement in the Fn body,
visit_typed_statementis called. - For statement 2 (use _) in the Fn body:
- can_extract_statement: this is the use statement at loc=? . selected_range starts at
let toml_path(71). The use statement is BEFORE selected_range. can_extract_statement returns false (no debug print). - visit_typed_use is called.
- visit_typed_expr is called for the Call (wobble).
- In visit_typed_expr for the Call: self.function is Some. So no change. Then visit_typed_expr_call visits arguments.
- The second argument is the Fn callback for use _.
- In visit_typed_expr for the Fn: self.function is Some. So can_extract_expression not checked. Then last_statement_location = body.last().location() = wooa(Nil) = 171-180.
- Then visits the Fn body which is [let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)].
- can_extract_statement: this is the use statement at loc=? . selected_range starts at
Hmm wait, but if self.function is Some(Expression(Fn for use priv)), why is the test showing correct behavior?
Oh! Maybe the Expression value gets overridden. Let me re-check the visit_typed_expr:
fn visit_typed_expr(&mut self, expression: &'ast TypedExpr) { if self.function.is_none() { if self.can_extract_expression(expression) { self.function = Some(ExtractedFunction::new(ExtractedValue::Expression( expression, ))); } } ... }The check is
if self.function.is_none(). So if it's already Some, we don't override. So once we set self.function to Expression(Fn for use priv), it stays.Then for statement 3 (let toml_path):
- can_extract_statement returns true. Debug prints.
- match self.function:
- Some(Expression(_)) => {} // do nothing
- Then visit_typed_assignment is called.
- visit_typed_expr for the value
"toml_path". self.function is Some. So no change. - visit_typed_pattern for the pattern. self.function is Some.
So self.function stays as Expression(Fn for use priv).
After all statements, self.function is:
- Some(Expression(Fn for use priv))
And in code_actions:
ExtractedValue::Expression(TypedExpr::Fn { type_, location: full_location, kind: FunctionLiteralKind::Anonymous { .. }, arguments, body, .. }) => { ... if extracted.parameters.is_empty() { self.extract_anonymous_function(...) } else if arguments.len() == 1 { self.extract_anonymous_function_with_capture_hole(...) } else { self.extract_anonymous_function_body(...) } }So if self.function is Expression(Fn), we extract the anonymous function. But this is wrong because we wanted to extract multiple statements, not an anonymous function.
Hmm wait, but the Fn expression is the callback for
use priv. It's not the body of the function. Its location is fromfirst.start(where the body starts) tosequence_location.end(where the sequence ends). The body is the subsequent statements. The arguments are the use assignments.Wait, let me re-read. The Fn expression has:
- arguments: the use assignments (e.g.,
priv) - body: the subsequent statements
So the Fn expression is
fn(priv) { use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil) }. Its location spans from the start of the first statement to the end of the sequence (the entire function body).If we extract this Fn as a function, we'd extract all the subsequent statements. So the original function would lose all those statements. But my test shows the original function retains
use priv <- wibble("priv")anduse _ <- wobble(Nil).Hmm. Let me look at
extract_anonymous_function_body:fn extract_anonymous_function_body( &mut self, location: SrcSpan, arguments: &[TypedArg], extra_parameters: Vec<(EcoString, Arc<Type>)>, return_type: Arc<Type>, function_end: u32, ) { let name = self.function_name(); // ... let arguments = arguments .iter() .filter_map(|arg| arg.get_variable_name().map(|name| (name, &arg.type_))) .chain(extra_parameters.iter().map(|(name, type_)| (name, type_))) .collect::<Vec<(&EcoString, &Arc<Type>)>>(); let call = format!( "{name}({})", arguments.iter().map(|(name, _)| name).join(", ") ); self.edits.replace(location, call); ... }So
self.edits.replace(location, call)replaces the code at the location with the function call. Thelocationis the Fn expression's location.So the Fn expression (the entire callback for
use priv) would be replaced withfunction(priv, ...). This means the entire body of the function would be replaced.But my test shows
function()(no arguments). So this isn't happening.Hmm. Let me actually run with the debug output and see what's happening:
- The
Assistant
FOUND IT!
Look at this:
DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 71, end: 180 }, is_fn=true, self.function.is_none()=true DEBUG EXPR EXTRACT: loc=SrcSpan { start: 71, end: 180 }A Fn expression is being visited with location 71-180. That's a big Fn expression (from
let toml_pathtowooa(Nil)). And it's being EXTRACTED as an Expression!So the self.function is being set to Expression(Fn) where the Fn is the callback for
use priv. This Fn has location 71-180.But wait, the test produces the correct output. So how is this getting overridden?
Let me check more carefully. The next line shows:
DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 87, end: 98 }, is_fn=false, self.function.is_none()=falseAfter extracting the Fn expression,
self.function.is_none()is false. So subsequent visits don't override.Hmm, so the Expression(Fn) should be the extraction target. But the snapshot shows the result is
function()(no arguments), which suggests the Statements extraction is happening.Wait, let me re-look at the output. The
function()call suggests the Statements extraction is happening (becauseextract_statementsuses{name}({arguments})which would befunction()if there are no parameters).But Expression(Fn) should call
extract_anonymous_function_*which usesfn function(...)with explicit types.Hmm, this is confusing. Let me look more carefully. The visit_typed_statement override:
match &mut self.function { None => { ... } Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Expression(_), .. }) => {} ... }So if self.function is Expression(Fn), statements don't override. So self.function stays as Expression(Fn).
But then in code_actions, the match is:
match extracted.value { ... ExtractedValue::Expression(TypedExpr::Fn { ... }) => { ... if extracted.parameters.is_empty() { self.extract_anonymous_function(...) } else if arguments.len() == 1 { self.extract_anonymous_function_with_capture_hole(...) } else { self.extract_anonymous_function_body(...) } } ... }So Expression(Fn) goes to extract_anonymous_function_*. But the snapshot shows
function()which is the Statements extraction.Let me check more carefully. Let me see the actual debug output:
Assistant
Hmm, I see:
- loc=71-180, is_fn=true. The Fn is visited.
- EXPR EXTRACT: loc=71-180. This is the Fn for
use priv. Its body has location 48-180.
Wait, the Fn body is 48-180? Let me check. The Fn's body should be the subsequent statements. The first statement in the body is
let priv = ...(the assignment from use). Thenuse _,let toml_path, etc.Looking at the locations:
- 48-180 = the Fn body for
use priv - 71-180 = the Fn body for
use _(or similar)
Actually wait, the Fn callback for
use _should have body[let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The first statement islet toml_pathat position 71. The last statement iswooa(Nil)at position 171-180. So the body is 71-180.But the Fn callback for
use privhas body[let priv, use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The first statement islet privat position 48. The last statement iswooa(Nil)at position 171-180. So the body is 48-180.So:
- The first Fn visited (loc=48-180) is the callback for
use priv. - The second Fn visited (loc=71-180) is the callback for
use _.
The DEBUG EXPR EXTRACT happens for the second Fn (loc=71-180). This is the callback for
use _.Wait but this is the Expression extraction. Why is the Statements extraction happening?
Let me look at visit_typed_statement more carefully. After the Expression is set, the next statement
use _is visited:- can_extract_statement returns false for
use _(no debug print).
Wait, but the Expression was set when visiting the Fn for
use _. The Fn is the callback foruse _. The Fn is an ARGUMENT to the Call. So when we visit the Use'scall(which is a Call), we visit its arguments, one of which is the Fn.So the order is:
- Visit use
priv:- visit_typed_use -> visit_typed_expr(call)
- visit_typed_expr(Call)
- visit Call args (string, Fn for use priv)
- visit Fn for use priv
- can_extract_expression(Fn) -> ??? let me check.
- The Fn body is 48-180. selected_range is 71-? end. selected_range is from
let toml_pathto end ofwooa(Nil). So selected_range is 71-180. The Fn body is 48-180. completely_within(selected_range, Fn_body_range) means selected_range is strictly inside Fn_body. selected_range.start (71) > Fn_body.start (48) and selected_range.end (180) < Fn_body.end (180). The last condition fails because they're equal. So completely_within returns false. So can_extract_expression returns !false = true. So self.function = Expression(Fn for use priv).
- But the debug shows VISIT EXPR loc=48-180 with is_fn=true. And EXPR EXTRACT log is at loc=71-180.
- visit Fn for use priv
- visit Call args (string, Fn for use priv)
- visit_typed_expr(Call)
- visit_typed_use -> visit_typed_expr(call)
Wait, let me re-check the debug output:
DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 }, is_fn=true, self.function.is_none()=true DEBUG FN BODY LAST: loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 }The Fn at 48-180 (callback for use priv) is visited. self.function.is_none()=true. can_extract_expression is checked. But EXPR EXTRACT log doesn't appear for this. Why?
Hmm, let me check can_extract_expression for Fn:
- TypedExpr::Fn matches the catch-all
!completely_within(selected_range, expression_range).
selected_range is 71-180. expression_range is 48-180. completely_within(71-180, 48-180):
- selected_range.start (71) > 48? Yes.
- selected_range.start (71) < 180? Yes.
- selected_range.end (180) > 48? Yes.
- selected_range.end (180) < 180? No.
- Returns false.
So can_extract_expression returns !false = true. So self.function should be set to Expression(Fn for use priv).
But the debug doesn't show EXPR EXTRACT for this Fn. Let me look at the debug output again:
DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 }, is_fn=true, self.function.is_none()=true DEBUG FN BODY LAST: loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 } DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 }, is_fn=false, self.function.is_none()=trueWait, there's a "VISIT EXPR" with the same location 48-180 but is_fn=false. That's odd. Let me think.
Actually, I bet the Fn is a child of another Call expression. Let me see. The Fn for use priv is the second argument to
wibble("priv", fn(priv) { ... }). So when we visit the Call, we visit each argument. For the Fn argument, we visit the Fn expression.In visit_typed_expr for the Fn:
- is_fn=true
- can_extract_expression checked.
Then we visit the Fn body (via ast::visit::visit_typed_expr -> visit_typed_expr_fn -> visit_typed_statement for each statement).
Wait, but the debug shows "DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=48-180, is_fn=false". Maybe this is a different visit. Let me look at the structure.
Actually, I wonder if the Fn expression has a location that includes the body. So when we visit the Fn, we visit its body. The body has its own location? Or the body's first statement has a location?
Actually, looking at the code:
let callback = UntypedExpr::Fn { arguments: assignments.function_arguments, location: SrcSpan::new(first.start, sequence_location.end), end_of_head_byte_index: sequence_location.end, return_annotation: None, kind: FunctionLiteralKind::Use { location: use_.location, }, body: statements, };So the Fn's
locationisSrcSpan::new(first.start, sequence_location.end). For use priv,first.startis the start of the first statement in the body (which islet priv = _use1). Andsequence_location.endis the end of the entire function body.So the Fn's location is 48-180 (from
let privto end of function).And the Fn's body is
[let priv, use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. The body has its own structure.When we visit the Fn, we visit the body via visit_typed_expr_fn. visit_typed_expr_fn iterates over body statements and calls visit_typed_statement.
But wait, before visiting the body, in our visit_typed_expr we set
last_statement_location = Some(body.last().location()). Then visit. Then restore.OK so the order of visits:
- Visit use priv -> visit use priv's call (Call) -> visit Call args -> visit Fn for use priv (loc=48-180)
- In visit_typed_expr for Fn:
- can_extract_expression: completely_within(71-180, 48-180) = false. So can_extract returns true.
- self.function = Expression(Fn for use priv).
- Then visit Fn body.
- For each statement in body, visit_typed_statement.
- In visit_typed_expr for Fn:
But the debug doesn't show EXPR EXTRACT for loc=48-180. So something else is happening.
Let me look at the debug output very carefully:
DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 19, end: 180 }, is_fn=false, self.function.is_none()=true DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 31, end: 37 }, is_fn=false, self.function.is_none()=true DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 38, end: 44 }, is_fn=false, self.function.is_none()=true DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 }, is_fn=true, self.function.is_none()=true DEBUG FN BODY LAST: loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 } DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 }, is_fn=false, self.function.is_none()=trueHmm, there are two VISIT EXPR for loc=48-180. One with is_fn=true and one with is_fn=false.
Maybe the first one is for the Fn expression itself (is_fn=true). The second one is for the Fn body's location (is_fn=false)? Or maybe a Call argument?
Wait, the Fn body has its own location? Or is it that the Fn expression itself has a location 48-180, but the body is being visited and produces another expression?
Actually, looking at the AST, the Fn expression has a location and a body. The body's location is determined by the statements.
Let me check the structure. Maybe the Fn is wrapped in something else.
Actually, I think the Fn is an argument to the Call. When we visit the Call, we iterate over arguments and visit each. For the Fn argument, we visit_typed_call_arg which calls visit_typed_expr(arg.value).
Wait, but the Fn argument's location is 48-180. So when we visit it as a TypedExpr, it's a Fn.
Hmm, let me check
visit_typed_call_arg:pub fn visit_typed_call_arg<'a, V>(v: &mut V, arg: &'a TypedCallArg) where V: Visit<'a> + ?Sized, { v.visit_typed_expr(&arg.value); }So it just visits the value. For our Fn argument, it visits the Fn expression.
OK let me trace the visits more carefully:
- visit_typed_function(main):
- Sets last_statement_location = 171-180 (location of wooa(Nil)).
- For each statement in body:
- visit_typed_statement
- For statement 1 (use priv):
- can_extract_statement returns false (no debug).
- ast::visit::visit_typed_statement -> visit_typed_use
- visit_typed_expr(use_.call) // Call expression
- DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=19-180, is_fn=false (the whole use call expression, not just the RHS)
- Actually wait, what's loc=19-180?
- visit_typed_expr(use_.call) // Call expression
- For statement 1 (use priv):
- visit_typed_statement
Hmm, let me check. The use priv's call is a Call expression. The Call's location is from
wibbleto the end of the callback's}. The callback for use priv is the entire function body. So the Call's location spans fromwibble(around 19) to the end of the function (180).So loc=19-180 is the Call for
wibble("priv", fn(priv) { ... }). The Call is visited as a TypedExpr.Then visit_typed_expr_call iterates over arguments:
- Argument 1: "priv" (loc=31-37)
- Argument 2: Fn (loc=48-180)
For argument 1, visit_typed_call_arg -> visit_typed_expr("priv"). DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=31-37.
For argument 2, visit_typed_call_arg -> visit_typed_expr(Fn). DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=48-180, is_fn=true.
OK so the Fn is the callback for use priv. Its location is 48-180.
Now, in visit_typed_expr for this Fn:
- can_extract_expression is checked. Let me verify by computing.
Selected range: from
let toml_pathto end ofwooa(Nil). So selected range = 71-? Let me check the actual positions.Actually wait, let me look at the test code:
pub fn main() { use priv <- wibble("priv") use _ <- wobble(Nil) let toml_path = "toml_path" use gleam_toml <- woo("gleam_toml") let gleam_toml = "gleam_toml" wooa(Nil) }Position counting from after
\n:\n= 0pub fn main() {= 0-15\n use priv <- wibble("priv")= 16-46\n use _ <- wobble(Nil)= 47-71\n let toml_path = "toml_path"= 72-105- etc.
Hmm, my counting is off. Let me just look at the positions in the debug:
- 19-180: This is
use priv <- wibble("priv")to end of function. - 31-37: This is
"priv". - 38-44: Hmm, what is this?
wibble(maybe? No, 38-44 is something inside wibble. - 48-180: Fn for use priv, body starts at 48 (which is
let priv = _use1) to 180.
Wait, let me look at the positions more carefully. The test code has
\nat the start (because of ther#"..."#literal). Then the first line is empty, thenpub fn main() {, etc.Actually looking at the snapshot file:
"\npub fn main() {\n use priv <- wibble(\"priv\")\n use _ <- wobble(Nil)\n let toml_path = \"toml_path\"\n use gleam_toml <- woo(\"gleam_toml\")\n let gleam_toml = \"gleam_toml\"\n wooa(Nil)\n}\n\nfn wibble..."So the test code has:
\nat position 0pub fn main() {at position 1-15 (or 1-16 if including{)\nat 16use priv <- wibble("priv")at 17-45\nat 46use _ <- wobble(Nil)at 47-69\nat 70let toml_path = "toml_path"at 71-102\nat 103- etc.
Hmm, the exact positions don't matter much. Let me focus on the logic.
The Fn callback for use priv has location 48-180. That's the entire function body (starting from the first statement after the use, which is
let priv = _use1or similar).The Fn callback for use _ has location 71-180. That's from
let toml_pathto end of function.The selected range is from start of
let toml_pathto end ofwooa(Nil). So selected range = 71-? Let me check.Looking at the debug: "let toml_path" is at loc=71-98 (a single assignment). The selection ends after
wooa(Nil). So selected range should be 71 to ~180.OK so:
- selected range = 71-180
- Fn for use priv = 48-180
For Fn for use priv:
- can_extract_expression:
- overlaps(48-180, 71-180): yes
- Fn matches the catch-all
!completely_within(71-180, 48-180) - completely_within(71-180, 48-180):
- 71 > 48? Yes
- 71 < 180? Yes
- 180 > 48? Yes
- 180 < 180? No
- completely_within returns false.
- Returns !false = true.
- So self.function = Expression(Fn for use priv).
But the debug doesn't show EXPR EXTRACT for loc=48-180. It only shows it for loc=71-180.
Hmm, let me check more carefully. Maybe the can_extract_expression for the Fn returns false for some reason.
Actually wait, let me re-check
can_extract_expression:match expression { TypedExpr::Pipeline { ... } => { ... } TypedExpr::Int { .. } | ... | TypedExpr::Fn { .. } | ... => !completely_within(selected_range, expression_range), }So for Fn, it returns
!completely_within(selected_range, expression_range). Let me check the parameters.can_extract_expression(&self, expression: &TypedExpr):expression_range = self.edits.src_span_to_lsp_range(expression.location());selected_range = self.params.range;
So expression_range is the LSP range of the expression. selected_range is the LSP range of the selection.
For Fn for use priv:
- expression.location() = 48-180
- src_span_to_lsp_range converts to LSP Position.
Let me check src_span_to_lsp_range:
pub fn src_span_to_lsp_range(location: SrcSpan, line_numbers: &LineNumbers) -> Range { let start = line_numbers.line_and_column_number(location.start); let end = line_numbers.line_and_column_number(location.end); Range::new( Position::new(start.line - 1, start.column - 1), Position::new(end.line - 1, end.column - 1), ) }So it converts to LSP positions. For Fn for use priv (loc=48-180), the LSP range is some Range.
For selected_range, it depends on the LSP positions of
let toml_pathstart andwooa(Nil)end.Now
completely_within(a, b):pub fn completely_within(a: Range, b: Range) -> bool { a.start > b.start && a.start < b.end && a.end > b.start && a.end < b.end }Wait, this is strict inequality.
a.start > b.startanda.start < b.endetc. So ifa.end == b.end, this returns false.Hmm so for
completely_within(selected_range, expression_range)where selected_range = 71-180 and expression_range = 48-180:- selected_range.start > expression_range.start (71 > 48)? Yes
- selected_range.start < expression_range.end (71 < 180)? Yes
- selected_range.end > expression_range.start (180 > 48)? Yes
- selected_range.end < expression_range.end (180 < 180)? No
- Returns false.
So can_extract_expression returns true. So self.function = Expression(Fn for use priv).
But the debug shows that this doesn't happen. The EXPR EXTRACT log only appears for loc=71-180.
Let me think. Maybe the order of visits is different. Let me re-trace.
Actually, the DEBUG VISIT EXPR for loc=19-180 is the Call for
wibble("priv", fn(priv) { ... }). Then the args are visited: "priv" (31-37) and Fn (48-180).For the Fn (48-180):
- DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=48-180, is_fn=true
- can_extract_expression checked
- DEBUG FN BODY LAST: loc=48-180 (body.last().location())
- ast::visit::visit_typed_expr -> visit_typed_expr_fn -> visit body statements
Wait, but the debug shows TWO VISIT EXPR for loc=48-180. One with is_fn=true and one with is_fn=false. Let me see what's happening.
Actually, I think the debug is showing nested calls. Let me look at the Fn body more carefully.
The Fn body for use priv is
[let priv, use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]. When visit_typed_expr_fn is called, it visits each statement.For statement 1 (let priv), visit_typed_statement is called.
- can_extract_statement: let priv location vs selected_range. selected_range is 71-180. let priv is at 48-something. No overlap. Returns false.
- visit_typed_assignment -> visit_typed_expr(value), visit_typed_pattern.
The value of
let priv = _use1is_use1(a Var). visit_typed_expr for_use1. DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=48-50 (or similar) - but I don't see this in the debug.Hmm wait, actually the value of
let priv = _use1is a Var. Its location is 48-something. Let me see if there's a matching DEBUG VISIT EXPR.Actually, looking at the debug, after "DEBUG FN BODY LAST: loc=48-180", the next line is "DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=48-180, is_fn=false". But that doesn't match a Var visit. Hmm.
Wait, maybe I'm confused. Let me re-trace.
Actually, the issue is that the Fn body has its own location? Or maybe the Fn is being visited in a different way?
Let me check by running with verbose debug:
Assistant
AH HA! Now I can see clearly:
DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 }, type=Fn, self.function.is_none()=true DEBUG can_extract_expression=false for loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 } type=Fn DEBUG FN BODY LAST: loc=SrcSpan { start: 48, end: 180 }, body_len=1For the Fn at loc=48-180 (callback for use priv), can_extract_expression is FALSE. And the body has only 1 statement.
But for:
DEBUG VISIT EXPR: loc=SrcSpan { start: 71, end: 180 }, type=Fn, self.function.is_none()=true DEBUG can_extract_expression=true for loc=SrcSpan { start: 71, end: 180 } type=Fn DEBUG FN BODY LAST: loc=SrcSpan { start: 101, end: 180 }, body_len=2The Fn at loc=71-180 (callback for use _) can_extract_expression is TRUE. And the body has 2 statements (loc=101-180 is the last, which is
use gleam_toml).Wait, but body_len=1 for the first Fn and body_len=2 for the second Fn. That's weird. The first Fn's body should be 6 statements (let priv, use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)).
Oh wait, I see. The Fn for use priv has body_len=1. So the body is just one statement. But which statement? Let me think.
Actually, looking at the type inference code:
let statements = assignments.body_assignments; if following_expressions.is_empty() { let todo = Statement::Expression(UntypedExpr::Todo { ... }); statements.push(todo); } else { statements.append(&mut following_expressions); } let statements = Vec1::try_from_vec(statements).expect("safe: todo added above");So the body includes body_assignments + following_expressions. body_assignments is the use assignment
let pattern = _use1. So body =[let pattern, ...following_expressions].But wait, the Fn body is the Fn's body, not the Use's body. The Use is the wrapper around the Fn. Let me re-check.
Actually, the Use statement has:
call: the Call expression- The Call has arguments. The callback (Fn) is one of the arguments.
The Fn's body is the callback body. The body includes:
- body_assignments (the use assignments:
let pattern = _use1) - following_expressions (the rest of the function body)
But for the Fn for use priv, the body should have:
[let priv = _use1, use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)]
That's 6 elements. But the debug shows body_len=1. That's strange.
Wait, maybe the body_len is wrong. Let me re-check.
Actually, the debug shows
body_len=1. So the Fn body has only 1 statement.Hmm, maybe the Fn body is just the Fn's literal body, not the use's callback body. Let me check.
Wait, looking at the Fn construction:
let callback = UntypedExpr::Fn { arguments: assignments.function_arguments, location: SrcSpan::new(first.start, sequence_location.end), end_of_head_byte_index: sequence_location.end, return_annotation: None, kind: FunctionLiteralKind::Use { location: use_.location }, body: statements, };body: statementsis the full body including body_assignments and following_expressions.But the debug shows body_len=1 for the first Fn. Let me check if maybe the Fn's body is just the first statement after the use.
Hmm, actually let me look at the
bodyfield in TypedExpr::Fn:Assistant
OK so TypedExpr::Fn has a body of
Vec1<TypedStatement>. So body_len is the length of the Vec1.For the Fn for use priv, body_len=1. So the body has 1 statement. That's weird.
Let me look more carefully. Maybe the body only contains the body_assignments, not the following_expressions.
Wait, maybe the body assignments are converted to the function arguments, not to statements in the body. Let me check:
Assistant
OK so for simple patterns like
Variable, only function_arguments are added, not body_assignments. So foruse priv <- ..., the body_assignments is empty.Then the body of the Fn callback is just the following_expressions (subsequent statements).
For use priv: following_expressions = [use _, let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)] = 5 statements. For use _: following_expressions = [let toml_path, use gleam_toml, let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)] = 4 statements. For use gleam_toml: following_expressions = [let gleam_toml, wooa(Nil)] = 2 statements.
But the debug shows body_len=1 for the first Fn (use priv). That's wrong.
Wait, maybe the body_len I'm logging is wrong. Let me re-check. I log
body.len(). For Vec1,.len()returns the length. So it should be 5 for use priv's Fn body.But the debug shows 1. So something is off.
Actually, maybe Vec1 stores things differently. Let me check:
Assistant
Let me restore the code and investigate further:
Assistant
Let me look at the typed AST to understand the body of the Fn callback for use.
Assistant
Let me actually verify what's in the Fn body by writing a small standalone test:
Assistant
Let me take a different approach. Let me check what's happening with the Fn body in the typed AST:
Assistant
Let me run the test with debug:
Assistant
Let me add more debug to see what's happening at code_actions time:
Assistant
Let me run the test with this debug output:
Assistant
Let me check the order of
ExtractedValuevariants:Assistant
Let me check git log for any recent fixes related to this:
Assistant
Let me check if there's a v1.16 tag:
Assistant
Let me check the CHANGELOG.md for v1.17 fixes:
Assistant
OK so there was a recent fix related to extracting a function from within an anonymous function. Let me look at this commit:
Assistant
Let me check the code before the recent fix:
Assistant
Let me search for
visit_typed_exprin the previous version of the file:Assistant
Let me look at the visit_typed_expr in the previous version (v1.16.0):
Assistant
me write a test that more closely matches the user's scenario with parameters from outside:
Assistant
Let me write a test that matches the user's bug scenario more closely:
Assistant
Let me run this test:
Assistant
Let me update my test to use
user_idlike the user's code:Assistant
Let me write a more accurate test that matches the user's bug:
Assistant
Let me run this
Assistant
Let me check if the bug exists in v1.16.0:
Assistant
Let me check the v1.16.0 version of the visit_typed_expr:
Assistant
me look at v1.16.0 visit_typed_expr:
Assistant
Let me search for the ExtractFunction's visit_typed_expr:
Assistant
me search for the ExtractFunction struct:
Assistant
Let me find the ExtractFunction in v1.16:
Assistant
Let me look at the ExtractFunction in v1.16:
Assistant
me update my test to use selected_range.end AFTER the
):Assistant
me write a test with selection end AFTER the
):Assistant
Let me run this
Assistant
I've reproduced the bug. Now I understand the issue. The bug is in
can_extract_expression- when the selection is inside a Use statement's Call expression (which covers the entire function body), the current check!completely_withinreturns true, so the entire Call expression (and thus the entire function body) is extracted.Let me clean up the test file first and then implement the fix:
Assistant
Now let me look at the exact code I need to modify:
Assistant
Now let me implement the fix. I need to modify
can_extract_expressionto use the correct check:Assistant
Let me try a different way to find the line
Assistant
me first run all extract_function tests to confirm they pass currently:
Assistant
All tests pass. Now let me implement the fix:
Assistant
Let me now use
editto modify the line:Assistant
Let me use the edit command to modify the line
Assistant
Let me use sed to update this line:
Assistant
Good. Now let me verify the change:
Assistant
me create the test that reproduces the user's bug, then run all the extract function tests to see if my fix works:
Assistant
Let me run the test:
Assistant
verify the fix is in place and check what's happening:
Assistant
The fix didn't work. Let me check what the issue is. Let me re-add the debug to trace what's happening:
Assistant
Let me re-add the debug prints to trace what's happening:
Assistant
Let me run the test with debug:
Assistant
Let me add more debug to see what's happening with the Use case:
Assistant
I see the issue now. The Use statement's location is being set to
use_.call.location(), which is the entire function body (because the call includes the callback). This causes subsequent statements to appear "inside" the Use. Let me look more carefully at this:Assistant
Let me add debug to print the Use's location:
Assistant
Now I can see clearly:
stmt_loc(statement.location()) = 91-271 (the entire function)use_loc(use_.location) = 91-117 (just the use lineuse priv <- wibble("priv"))call_loc(use_.call.location()) = 91-271 (the entire function)
So
Statement::location()for Use returns 91-271, butuse_.locationis 91-117.Hmm, so Statement::location() for Use is NOT use_.location. Let me check the impl again:
pub fn location(&self) -> SrcSpan { match self { Statement::Expression(expression) => expression.location(), Statement::Assignment(assignment) => assignment.location, Statement::Use(use_) => use_.location, Statement::Assert(assert) => assert.location, } }For Use, it returns use_.location. But use_.location is 91-117, not 91-271. So statement.location() should return 91-117.
But the debug shows stmt_loc = 91-271. So either the impl is different in this version, or the debug is wrong.
Let me re-check. Actually, looking at the impl more carefully... oh wait, maybe there's a different impl for the typed Use.
Hmm, let me look at the actual code more carefully
Assistant
Let me check the existing test snapshot for
extract_use_in_tail_position:Assistant
Let me check the existing test snapshots to ensure my fix doesn't break them:
Assistant
Let me check where
Statement::location()is used to understand the impact of the change:Assistant
Now I understand the issue clearly. The fix is to use
use_.location(just the use line) instead ofuse_.call.location()(the entire call including callback body). Let me apply this fix:Assistant
me look at how the use's location is used elsewhere:
Assistant
let me apply the fix. The fix needs to be in
can_extract_statementfor Use statements to use the use line location (not the entire block):Assistant
Now let me modify the can_extract_statement for Use to use the use line location:
Assistant
Now let me run my test to see if the fix works:
Assistant
The fix is working. The output matches the user's expected behavior. Now let me run all the extract function tests to make sure I haven't broken anything:
Assistant
All 22 existing tests pass. The only failure is my new test (which doesn't have a snapshot). Let me create the snapshot:
Assistant
Now let me run all the tests to make sure I haven't broken anything:
Assistant
One test is failing. Let me look at it:
Assistant
Let me look at the failing test to understand the issue:
Assistant
Let me revise the fix. The check should be
position_within(use_line.start, selected_range):Assistant
All 1538 tests pass! Let me also run the other compiler tests to make sure nothing else is broken:
Assistant
Let me check if these failures are related to my changes:
Assistant
These failures are pre-existing and not related to my changes. Let me restore my fix:
Assistant
Let me clean up the test files. First, let me check what's in the action.rs file:
Assistant
Let me verify what tests are in the action.rs file:
Assistant
, only my proper test is in the file. Let me clean up the .new snapshot files and the unused test-commands snapshots:
Assistant
Let me check the CHANGELOG to see if I should add an entry:
Assistant
Let me add a CHANGELOG entry for this bug fix:
Assistant
Now let me check the final state of all my changes:
Assistant
run all the language-server tests one more time to verify everything passes:
Assistant
Let me verify my test snapshot is correct:
Assistant
me verify all the changes look good:
Assistant
Let me check the new snapshot file:
Assistant
Let me check if any existing tests are affected by my changes. Let me look at tests that involve expressions that are partially selected:
Assistant
All 1538 tests pass. Let me also verify by running all tests:
Assistant
Let me check if these are pre-existing:
Assistant
The test-output failures are pre-existing and not related to my changes. Let me run all the relevant tests for my changes:
Assistant
All tests pass (96 + 3890 + 1538 = 5524 tests). Let me also verify the specific test that was concerning:
Assistant
Let me run my new test:
Assistant
Let me verify by temporarily reverting the can_extract_expression fix to confirm both fixes are needed:
Assistant
Confirmed, both fixes are needed. Let me re-apply the can_extract_expression fix:
Assistant
Let me run all tests one more time to ensure everything works:
Assistant
All 5524 tests pass. Let me check the final state of all my changes:
Assistant
Let me check the new snapshot:
Assistant
Let me run the related tests once more to ensure everything works correctly:
Assistant
All 180 extract-related tests pass. Let me also do a final check by running all tests:
Assistant
Let me check the final state:
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.5-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.5-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.5-35B-A3BCompare side by side →