ISSUE DESCRIPTION S3 object keys can escape above the bucket root during path…
- User
ISSUE DESCRIPTION
S3 object keys can escape above the bucket root during path normalization
Reject keys whose normalized path escapes above the bucket root with HTTP 400 and the S3 error code
InvalidKey, without creating, deleting, or modifying object storage.Interface
No new interfaces are introduced.
ADDITIONAL ADVICE
Since you are given a git repository, you can use git commands to simplify your work. For example, if you made a mistake and want to revert your changes, you can use
git checkout <file>to restore the file to its original state. You can also reset all changes in the repository usinggit reset --hardcommand. Additionally, you can usegit stashandgit stash popto temporarily save your changes and restore them later. Finally, you can see the changes that you've made (which will be submitted when you callsubmit) usinggit statusorgit diffcommands. However you don't need to usegit addorgit commitbefore submitting your changes. In fact,submitonly submits currently unstaged changes because it usesgit diffto get the changes that need to be submitted.CHECKLIST
Before submitting your solution, please go over the following checklist and make sure you've done everything:
- If an error was reported in the issue description, I have successfully reproduced it.
- If an error was reported in the issue description, I have confirmed that my fix resolves the error.
- I have thought about edge cases and made sure my fix handles them as well.
- I have run existing tests in the repository that might have been affected by the change I made and confirmed that they pass. I want you to list every bullet from this checklist and write your reasoning for why you think you did it or didn't need to.
Repository has been uploaded and your shell is currently at the repository root. Time to solve the issue!
(Current directory: /floci, current file: none) bash-$
Assistant
Let me start by exploring the repository structure to understand what we're working with.
Assistant
This is a Java-based AWS emulator called Floci. The issue is about S3 object keys escaping above the bucket root during path normalization. Let me explore the S3 service.
Assistant
Let me look at the relevant section around line 2168 where the bucket directory normalization is happening.
Assistant
Let me look at the S3 controller and search for path resolution patterns:
Assistant
Let me look at the storage configuration:
Assistant
Let me look at existing S3 tests to understand the expected behavior:
Assistant
.Let me look at the existing tests for this feature:
Assistant
Let me look at the integration test for path traversal:
Assistant
Let me look at S3Service.java around the resolveObjectPath:
Assistant
Let me look at the multipart-related code:
Assistant
Let me look at the S3Controller more carefully to see the full path handling:
Assistant
Let me write a quick Java test to verify if there's actually a bug:
Assistant
.The test results show that the current check seems to work for most cases. The key
".."becomes"....s3data"which stays inside the bucket. That's correct because..as a literal key name isn't a traversal - it's just a file called..which becomes....s3data.But wait, the issue says "S3 object keys can escape above the bucket root during path normalization". Let me look more carefully at what's happening.
Let me trace the actual key extraction from the controller. Maybe the issue is that certain keys are NOT being validated by
validateKeyNoTraversal?Let me look at all the code paths where
extractObjectKeyis called vs where direct path parameters are used.Assistant
Let me look at the putObject handler:
Assistant
Let me check all places where the key is used:
Assistant
Let me look at the bucket creation logic:
Assistant
Let me look at the
deleteObjectmethod:Assistant
Let me look at
deleteFile:Assistant
Let me search for places where the path is constructed directly:
Assistant
Let me trace through what happens with a key containing
..carefully. Let me run a real test against the implementation:Assistant
I can see the issue! When the bucket name contains traversal patterns like
../escape, thebucketDirends up outsidedataRoot. Let me look at where the bucket name is used:Assistant
I see! The current check
resolved.startsWith(bucketDir)is NOT sufficient. It needs to also check thatbucketDiris withindataRoot. Let me check if users can create buckets with such names:Assistant
Let me search for any bucket name validation:
Assistant
Let me look at the headObject handler:
Assistant
Let me look at the
getObjecthandler:Assistant
Let me look at the S3Service.getObject:
Assistant
Let me try to compile and run the existing tests to see if they pass:
Assistant
There's a test failure! Let me look at the test:
Assistant
Let me run just the tests related to the path traversal issue:
Assistant
Let me write a test to verify the issue:
Assistant
Let me check if there's a bucket name validation:
Assistant
Let me look at the integration tests to understand what's expected:
Assistant
Let me look at the copyObject handler:
Assistant
Let me check the
validateKeyNoTraversalmethod more carefully. I notice the check usesdummyRootbut doesn't have the.s3datasuffix:Assistant
Let me look at what the validateRawUri catches:
Assistant
Let me look at more edge cases:
Assistant
Let me look at the other places that work with keys:
Assistant
Let me look at deleteObjects and completeMultipartUpload:
Assistant
Let me look at handleDeleteObjects and the deleteObjects function:
Assistant
Let me look at the in-memory mode for deleteObject:
Assistant
Let me look at the integration test more carefully to see what specific cases are being tested:
Assistant
Let me look at the leading slash key tests:
Assistant
Let me look more carefully at the issue. Let me check the CHANGELOG to see if there's something about recent changes:
Assistant
Let me look at the previous path traversal hardening commit:
Assistant
Let me look at the existing test to see if there's a specific case being tested:
Assistant
Let me look at the controller diff:
Assistant
Let me check if there's something specific about the S3Service:
Assistant
Let me look at the deleteObjects handler:
Assistant
Let me look at the existing test for the path traversal:
Assistant
Let me write a small test to demonstrate the actual issue:
Assistant
Let me look at the existing tests for path traversal to understand what's expected:
Assistant
Let me look at all the file operations in S3Service:
Assistant
Let me check the multipart path:
Assistant
Let me look at the existing validateKeyNoTraversal more carefully:
Assistant
Let me check where
validateRawUriis called:Assistant
Let me look at all the S3 integration tests to see which ones are about path traversal:
Assistant
Let me look at the S3Controller more carefully to understand the flow:
Assistant
Let me look at storeObject:
Assistant
Let me look for any TODOs or FIXMEs:
Assistant
Let me write a comprehensive test to see all the cases:
Assistant
Let me test with a malicious bucket name:
Assistant
This is a real issue! The test shows that:
- The bucket
../escapeis created - The bucket
test/../escapeis created and maps todataRoot/escape - The bucket
/test-bucketis created (but no file is written, possibly because the path is being treated as absolute)
Let me check what happens with the
/test-bucketcase. The filefoo.s3datawas supposed to be created in/test-bucket/foo.s3data. But the listing only showstest-bucketandescape. Let me check if the file was created at the root.Actually, looking at the output, the listing starts from
tempDir.resolve("s3")which is/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3. So:/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3/test-bucket/foo.s3data- exists (from the first bucket)/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3/escape/foo.s3data- exists (from the third buckettest/../escape)
But for
/test-bucket, the file should be at/test-bucket/foo.s3datawhich is at the system root. Let me check.Wait, but the second bucket
../escapeshould have created the file atparent(dataRoot)/escape/foo.s3data. Let me check:dataRoot = /tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3bucketName = "../escape"bucketDir = dataRoot.resolve("../escape").normalize()=/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/escaperesolved = bucketDir.resolve("foo.s3data").normalize()=/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/escape/foo.s3data
But the listing only shows files in
/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3/.... So the file was NOT created at/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/escape/.... Let me re-check.Actually, looking at the output, there's no
/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/escapelisted. So the file was NOT created there. But there's/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3/escape/foo.s3datafrom the third bucket.Wait, let me re-look at the output:
Files created in tempDir: /tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3 /tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3/test-bucket /tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3/test-bucket/foo.s3data /tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3/escape /tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3/escape/foo.s3dataSo the files are:
/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3/test-bucket/foo.s3data(from bucket "test-bucket")/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/s3/escape/foo.s3data(from bucket "test/../escape")
But what about:
- Bucket "../escape": the file should be at
/tmp/floci-malicious-bucket-test/escape/foo.s3data(outside s3) - Bucket "/test-bucket": the file should be at
/test-bucket/foo.s3data(system root)
Neither of these is in the listing. So either:
- The files were not created (maybe an exception was thrown)
- The files were created at different locations
Wait, the putObject for both "../escape" and "/test-bucket" returned SUCCEEDED. So the files should have been created somewhere.
Let me check the file system directly:
- The bucket
Assistant
Now I understand the actual issue. The bucket name itself can be malicious (e.g.,
../escape) and the resolved path can escape the data root. Let me look at the current implementation one more time and plan the fix:Assistant
Now I understand the actual issue clearly. Let me look at the current
resolveObjectPathandresolveVersionedPathto understand what changes need to be made:Assistant
Now I understand the issue. The current implementation has a check that the resolved path starts with
bucketDir, but it doesn't check thatbucketDiritself is withindataRoot. So if a bucket name contains path traversal (e.g.,../escape), the resolved path can escape the data root.Let me also look at how the issue could be in the
validateKeyNoTraversalfunction:Assistant
Now I have a clear understanding. The issue is in
resolveObjectPathandresolveVersionedPath- they don't check that the bucket directory itself is within the data root. Let me make the fix:Assistant
Now let me implement the fix. The fix is to add a check in
resolveObjectPathandresolveVersionedPathto ensure the bucket directory is within the data root:Assistant
Let me make the fix now. I'll modify
resolveObjectPathandresolveVersionedPathto add thecheck that the bucket directory is within the data root.Assistant
Let me simplify the fix by removing the
equalscheck, sincePath.startsWithalready handles the equality case:Assistant
Let me simplify the fix by removing the unnecessary
equalschecks:Assistant
Let me look at the putObject flow to ensure the validation happens before storage operations:
Assistant
I notice that
storeObjectcallswriteFileAFTER storing the metadata. Let me look at the flow to ensure the validation happens before any storage operations:Assistant
I need to ensure the validation happens BEFORE any storage operations. Let me add a validation call at the beginning of
storeObject:Assistant
Now let me add the
validateObjectKeymethod. Let me put it right afterresolveObjectPathandresolveVersionedPath:Assistant
The file is in a bad state. Let me check the current state:
Assistant
The file is messed up. Let me revert and re-apply the fix properly:
Assistant
Now let me apply the fix properly:
Assistant
Now let me also add the
validateObjectKeycall at the beginning ofstoreObject:Assistant
Now let me add the
validateObjectKeycall at the beginning ofstoreObject:Assistant
Now let me also add validation for
deleteObjectand other operations:Assistant
Now let me also add validation for
getObjectandheadObject:Assistant
Now let me also look at the copyObject operation:
Assistant
Let me check the multipart operations:
Assistant
Let me add validation to
initiateMultipartUploadandcompleteMultipartUpload:Assistant
Let me find the
completeMultipartUploadandabortMultipartUploadmethods:Assistant
Let me also check restoreObject:
Assistant
Now let me compile and run the existing tests:
Assistant
Let me run more tests:
Assistant
Let me run more S3 tests to make sure I didn't break anything:
Assistant
All 41 S3ServiceTest tests pass. Let me also run the S3IntegrationTest:
Assistant
There are 75 test failures! Let me investigate:
Assistant
Let me look at one of the failing tests:
Assistant
Let me check what's happening with the request:
Assistant
Let me check the actual error by running a single test:
Assistant
Let me check the storage configuration:
Assistant
Let me write a test to check the path comparison:
Assistant
I found the issue! The dataRoot has a leading
./that needs to be normalized. Let me fix the comparison:Assistant
Let me fix the comparison by normalizing the dataRoot:
Assistant
Now let me run the tests again:
Assistant
The error is now
NoSuchBucket- the test doesn't create the bucket. Let me check the test order:Assistant
All 108 S3IntegrationTest tests pass! Let me run all the S3 tests:
Assistant
All 526 S3 tests pass. Now let me write a test to verify the fix works for the malicious bucket name case:
Assistant
The fix works! Let me clean up:
Assistant
Let me re-run all the S3 tests to verify everything still works:
Assistant
Let me also run other tests that interact with S3:
Assistant
Let me run a broader test suite to make sure nothing else is broken:
Assistant
All 1439 tests pass. Let me look at the diff of my changes:
Assistant
Let me also write a final comprehensive test to verify the fix:
Assistant
The fix is working correctly. Let me clean up:
Assistant
Let me also run all the tests one more time to make sure everything is in order:
Assistant
Let me do a final check of my changes:
Assistant
Let me do a final summary of the changes by viewing the final state of the relevant sections:
Assistant
Now let me submit the changes:
Assistant
Let me run the tests one more time to confirm everything is in order:
Assistant
All 526 S3 tests pass. Let me also provide the final summary of my work:
Summary of Changes
Issue
S3 object keys could escape above the bucket root during path normalization. The existing implementation in
S3Service.resolveObjectPathonly checked if the resolved path was within the bucket directory (resolved.startsWith(bucketDir)), but didn't check thatbucketDiritself was within the data root (bucketDir.startsWith(dataRoot)). This allowed malicious bucket names like../escapeor/test-bucketto cause the path to escape the data root, while a normal key likefoowould be written to a location outside the S3 data directory.Fix
1. Added a new
validateObjectKeymethod inS3Service.javathat:- Calls
resolveObjectPathto perform path validation without actually using the resolved path - Catches
InvalidPathException(e.g., for embedded NUL bytes) and converts it toInvalidKey - Rejects null keys
2. Hardened
resolveObjectPathandresolveVersionedPathby:- Normalizing
dataRoot(usingtoAbsolutePath().normalize()) so it compares consistently with the resolved bucket path (a relativedataRootlike./data/s3was failing the check) - Adding a check that the bucket directory is within the data root (defense against malicious bucket names)
- Throwing
AwsException("InvalidKey", ..., 400)when the check fails
3. Added
validateObjectKeycalls at the beginning of:storeObject(called byputObject)getObjectheadObjectdeleteObjectinitiateMultipartUpload
This ensures that all object-level operations validate the key BEFORE any storage operations are performed. The rejection happens with HTTP 400 and the S3 error code
InvalidKey.Tests
- All 526 S3 tests pass (
S3*) - All 1439 related tests pass (
*S3*Test,S3*Test,*ServiceTest,FilterTest) - All 23 CUR tests pass (CUR uses S3)
Checklist
- ✅ If an error was reported in the issue description, I have successfully reproduced it. I created a test script that demonstrated bucket names
../escapeand/test-bucketcould create files outside the data root - ✅ If an error was reported in the issue description, I have confirmed that my fix resolves the error. Verified that these malicious bucket names are now rejected with
InvalidKeyand no files are created outside the data root - ✅ I have thought about edge cases and made sure my fix handles them as well. Handles path traversal in keys, malicious bucket names, null keys, embedded NUL bytes, and the case where
dataRootis a relative path - ✅ I have run existing tests in the repository that might have been affected by the change I made and confirmed that they pass. All S3 tests, integration tests, and CUR tests pass
- Calls
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →