ISSUE DESCRIPTION S3 object keys can escape above the bucket root during path…
- User
ISSUE DESCRIPTION
S3 object keys can escape above the bucket root during path normalization
Reject keys whose normalized path escapes above the bucket root with HTTP 400 and the S3 error code
InvalidKey, without creating, deleting, or modifying object storage.Interface
No new interfaces are introduced.
ADDITIONAL ADVICE
Since you are given a git repository, you can use git commands to simplify your work. For example, if you made a mistake and want to revert your changes, you can use
git checkout <file>to restore the file to its original state. You can also reset all changes in the repository usinggit reset --hardcommand. Additionally, you can usegit stashandgit stash popto temporarily save your changes and restore them later. Finally, you can see the changes that you've made (which will be submitted when you callsubmit) usinggit statusorgit diffcommands. However you don't need to usegit addorgit commitbefore submitting your changes. In fact,submitonly submits currently unstaged changes because it usesgit diffto get the changes that need to be submitted.CHECKLIST
Before submitting your solution, please go over the following checklist and make sure you've done everything:
- If an error was reported in the issue description, I have successfully reproduced it.
- If an error was reported in the issue description, I have confirmed that my fix resolves the error.
- I have thought about edge cases and made sure my fix handles them as well.
- I have run existing tests in the repository that might have been affected by the change I made and confirmed that they pass. I want you to list every bullet from this checklist and write your reasoning for why you think you did it or didn't need to.
Repository has been uploaded and your shell is currently at the repository root. Time to solve the issue!
(Current directory: /floci, current file: none) bash-$
Assistant
Let me explore the repository structure first.
Assistant
This is a Java project (pom.xml). Let me explore the structure.
Assistant
Let me look at the key files - the S3Controller, S3Service, and S3RequestParser, which likely handle key normalization.
Assistant
Now let me look at the S3Service path normalization logic.
Assistant
Now let me understand the issue. The issue says S3 object keys can escape above the bucket root during path normalization. Let me look at how keys are used throughout the service. Let me search for all uses of keys in the S3Service.
Assistant
Let me check what calls
validateRawUriand understand the full flow.Assistant
Let me look at existing tests related to key validation.
Assistant
Let me look at the git log to understand recent changes related to this issue.
Assistant
Let me look at the controller methods more broadly to find all key usages.
Assistant
Let me look at copy operations which involve parsing a copy-source containing a key.
Assistant
Let me look at the S3Service to understand the in-memory vs file storage and where keys are validated.
Assistant
Now I see the key flow. The
storeObjectmethod callswriteFile(bucketName, key, data). Let me look atwriteFileto see whereresolveObjectPathis called and whether the path check happens before the storage write.In the in-memory mode,
writeFilewould put intomemoryDataStorekeyed bybucketName + "/" + key. In file mode,writeFilecallsresolveObjectPathwhich throwsInvalidKeyif it escapes. But the order matters: instoreObject, before callingwriteFile, the method already doesobjectStore.put(...)(the in-memory object store). So even ifwriteFilethrowsInvalidKey, the object store already has been modified.Wait, but the object store is the in-memory metadata store. The issue says "without creating, deleting, or modifying object storage." The object storage modification happens via
objectStore.putbeforewriteFile. So if the key escapes, theresolveObjectPaththrows InvalidKey AFTER the object store was already modified. That violates the requirement.But wait - is the object store modification "object storage"? The "object storage" probably refers to the actual file/memory data store. Hmm.
Actually, let me re-read the issue more carefully:
"S3 object keys can escape above the bucket root during path normalization. Reject keys whose normalized path escapes above the bucket root with HTTP 400 and the S3 error code
InvalidKey, without creating, deleting, or modifying object storage."So the bug is: keys can escape above the bucket root. The fix: reject such keys with 400 InvalidKey, without creating/deleting/modifying storage.
Now, the existing
resolveObjectPathalready hasstartsWith(bucketDir)check. So why would keys escape? Let me think about cases where this check might pass incorrectly.Let me think about the in-memory case. When
inMemoryis true,writeFileputs intomemoryDataStorewith keybucketName + "/" + keyand does NOT do path validation. So in in-memory mode, a traversal key like../foowould just be stored. But that doesn't really "escape" in memory.Let me look at writeFile.
Assistant
Let me look at the
deleteObjects(DeleteObjects API) andlistObjectswhich take keys from body/query params.Assistant
Let me find where
deleteObjectsis called from the controller.Assistant
Let me look at the test infrastructure to understand the testing approach.
Assistant
Let me write a reproduction test using the S3Service directly.
Assistant
Interesting. The
..%2fescape.txtkey was stored successfully (as a file named..%2fescape.txt.s3datainside the bucket dir - it's literally treated as a filename, not path traversal). That's actually fine because%2fis a literal string in the decoded key, not a/. So the file is..%2fescape.txt.s3datawhich is inside the bucket. That's not a traversal escape.So the service-level
resolveObjectPathdoes catch../escape.txtanda/../../escape.txtandfoo/../../../escape.txt. So at the service level, the file-mode path resolution is robust.So where is the bug? Let me reconsider. The issue says keys can escape above the bucket root. Let me reconsider the in-memory mode.
In in-memory mode,
writeFiledoes NOT callresolveObjectPath. It usesmemoryDataStore.put(objectKey(bucketName, key), data). So no path validation. But there's no file system escape in memory anyway. But the issue says "without creating, deleting, or modifying object storage" — in in-memory mode, theobjectStore.putwould create the object even with a traversal key.Wait, but the controller's
validateKeyNoTraversalshould catch these. Let me reconsider the controller flow.Actually, wait. Let me reconsider the controller
extractObjectKeyandvalidateKeyNoTraversal. The issue may be about the controller validation being inconsistent with the service validation, OR there may be specific key forms that escape the controller's check but not the service's, or vice versa.Let me check what happens with a key that has
..but where the controller'svalidateKeyNoTraversallets it through but the service catches it (or doesn't).Hmm, actually let me reconsider. The issue title is "S3 object keys can escape above the bucket root during path normalization". So there's a key that escapes. Let me think about what keys the controller's
validateKeyNoTraversalwould let through that escape.Wait — what about a key that uses backslashes? On Linux,
\is a valid filename char, not a separator. So\..is fine.Let me reconsider. The key point: the
validateKeyNoTraversalin the controller is the front-line defense. But the copy-source keys and delete-objects keys bypass it.Let me test the controller-level behavior through the HTTP API. But that requires running the full Quarkus app. Let me instead think about which operations reach the service WITHOUT controller validation.
Actually, let me reconsider the whole thing. The service has
resolveObjectPath/resolveVersionedPathwhich catch escapes — but only in file mode. In in-memory mode, no path validation. So in-memory mode is vulnerable: a traversal key would be stored/created in the object store.But more fundamentally, the issue is that the validation is scattered and the service-level check happens too late (after objectStore.put in storeObject).
Let me look at the actual production config - is it in-memory or file mode? Let me check.
Assistant
Let me find where S3Service is instantiated (the bean producer).
Assistant
The
new S3Serviceonly appears in the controller forS3Service.SseCustomerHeadersinner class. So the S3Service is probably a CDI bean with a default constructor or a@Produces. Let me check the S3Service class annotations.Assistant
The S3Service is
@ApplicationScopedbut has a constructor with parameters. Let me find how it's wired.Assistant
So in-memory mode is determined by config. Let me check the default storage mode.
Assistant
Let me look at how
objectKeyworks and how leading-slash keys are stored distinctly.Assistant
So
objectKeyuses the raw key (including leading slash). So/file.txt->bucket//file.txtandfile.txt->bucket/file.txt. Distinct in the object store.But the file storage:
resolveObjectPathstrips leading slashes from key, so/file.txt->file.txt->bucket/file.txt.s3data. Andfile.txt->bucket/file.txt.s3data. Same file! So in file mode,/file.txtandfile.txtwould collide on disk. But the leading-slash test is an integration test... Let me check if that test passes currently. Actually it's a@QuarkusTestwhich runs the full app. The default storage mode is "hybrid" not "memory", so file mode is used. So the leading-slash test would have a disk collision... unless the test runs in memory mode.Hmm, let me check the test config / application.properties for tests.
Assistant
So tests run in
memorymode! That means in tests,inMemory = true, andwriteFileusesmemoryDataStore(no path validation). Let me search tests for existing behavior around traversal/invalid keys.Assistant
There's an existing test for this. Let me look at it carefully.
Assistant
Let me look at the existing S3IntegrationTest traversal tests at HTTP level.
Assistant
Let me look at the S3WellKnownKeyIntegrationTest and other key-related tests.
Assistant
Let me write a focused test to check if storage is modified before the InvalidKey rejection (in file mode).
Assistant
Confirmed the bug! In file mode (non-versioning bucket), a PUT with traversal key
../outside.txtcreates a metadata entry inobjectStoreBEFOREwriteFilethrowsInvalidKey. So storage IS modified despite the rejection. Let me checkgetStoredObjectand howgetObjecthandles traversal keys.Assistant
Confirmed the bug clearly. In file mode,
storeObjectcallsobjectStore.put(...)(line 357) BEFOREwriteFile(line 358) which throwsInvalidKey. So a phantom metadata entry remains despite the 400 response. Also, in memory mode the service does NO path validation at all (only the controller validates URL-path keys; copy-source and DeleteObjects keys bypass it).My plan:
- Add a centralized
validateObjectKey(String key)static method inS3Servicethat rejects keys whose normalized path escapes the bucket root withInvalidKey400. - Call it at the start of every public S3Service method that accepts an object key, BEFORE any storage operation.
- Have the controller's
validateKeyNoTraversaldelegate to it for consistency.
Let me enumerate all public methods that take a key.
- Add a centralized
Assistant
Let me check which specific overloads the controller calls.
Assistant
Let me view the putObject overloads to confirm they all delegate to line 251.
Assistant
Now let me view the bodies of the remaining key-taking methods (copy, multipart, acl, restore) to find insertion points.
Assistant
copyObject overloads delegate to either
copyObject(..., versionId, CopyObjectOptions)(745) orcopyObject(..., CopyObjectOptions)(758). Both callgetObject(sourceBucket, sourceKey, ...)(validates sourceKey via getObject) andcopyS3Object(... destKey ...)which writes the dest. Let me check copyS3Object — does it call storeObject? If so, destKey validated in storeObject. Let me check.Assistant
copyS3Object(line 2286) callsstoreObject(destBucket, destKey, ...)at line 2326. So destKey is validated via storeObject. And sourceKey validated via getObject (line 749/761). So copyObject is covered if I validate in storeObject and getObject.completeMultipartUpload(line 1246) callsstoreObject(bucket, key, ...). So covered via storeObject.My strategy: add
validateObjectKey(key)at the start of the leaf methods. Let me first add thevalidateObjectKeymethod andKEY_SANDBOXconstant nearresolveObjectPath.Assistant
Now let me add the
validateObjectKeymethod andKEY_SANDBOXconstant. Let me edit near theDATA_SUFFIXline.Assistant
No python3. Let me use the
editcommand instead.Assistant
Now let me insert the
validateObjectKeymethod after theDATA_SUFFIXline.Assistant
Now let me add
validateObjectKeycalls. First, the critical one:storeObject(the leaf for all PUTs). Let me view its start.Assistant
I'll add
validateObjectKey(key);as the first statement in the leafstoreObject(line 278). The other two storeObject overloads delegate to it.Assistant
My edit got mangled — it created a duplicate signature line and dropped the
.orElseThrowline. Let me fix lines 278-284.Assistant
storeObject now validates the key first. Now let me add validation to the read/mutate methods. Let me re-grep line numbers since they shifted.
Assistant
Now let me add
validateObjectKeycalls togetObject(leaf at 401) andgetObjectMetadata(leaf at 421, used by headObject/getObjectAttributes).Assistant
I'll add
validateObjectKey(key);at the start ofgetObject(bucket, key, versionId)(line 401) andgetObjectMetadata(line 421). headObject delegates to getObjectMetadata (covered). getObject(bucket,key) delegates to getObject(401) (covered). getObjectAttributes calls getObjectMetadata (covered).Let me add to line 401 (after the signature) and line 421.
Assistant
Now add validation to
getObjectMetadata(the leaf for headObject and getObjectAttributes).Assistant
Now
deleteObject(leaf at 501).Assistant
Now
deleteObjects(batch) — validate all keys upfront before deleting any. Let me view it.Assistant
For
deleteObjects, validate all keys upfront before deleting any, so an invalid key rejects the whole request withInvalidKey400 without deleting anything.Assistant
My edit created a duplicate
ensureBucketExists(bucketName);at line 881. Let me remove it.Assistant
Now there's a duplicate
validateObjectKey(key);at lines 879-880. Let me fix.Assistant
There's now a duplicate
List<DeleteResult> deleted = new ArrayList<>();at lines 881-882. Let me remove the duplicate.Assistant
The edit keeps shifting. Let me remove the duplicate
List<DeleteError> errorsline at 883.Assistant
The edit tool keeps duplicating. Let me replace the entire
deleteObjectsmethod block (874-897) cleanly.Assistant
Now
deleteObjectsis clean. Let me add validation to the tagging methods.Assistant
Now the retention/legalhold methods. Let me view them.
Assistant
Let me add
validateObjectKey(key);afterensureBucketExistsin the retention/legalhold methods.Assistant
Let me use the
editcommand with line ranges. Let me open at line 1023.Assistant
Now putObjectLegalHold (line 1072) and getObjectLegalHold (line 1085).
Assistant
Now the multipart methods. Let me view uploadPart and uploadPartCopy bodies.
Assistant
uploadPartCopy calls
getObject(validates sourceKey) anduploadPart(need destKey validation). So I'll add validation touploadPart,initiateMultipartUpload(leaf),completeMultipartUpload,abortMultipartUpload, andlistParts.Let me add to
initiateMultipartUploadleaf (afterensureBucketExists).Assistant
Now
uploadPart(line 1158),completeMultipartUpload(1221),abortMultipartUpload,listParts. Let me add to uploadPart at the start.Assistant
There's a duplicate signature line at 1159-1160. Let me fix.
Assistant
Now
completeMultipartUpload(line 1226).Assistant
Now
abortMultipartUpload(1293) andlistParts. Let me view listParts.Assistant
Now
getObjectAclandputObjectAcl.Assistant
getObjectAcl/putObjectAclboth callgetObjectwhich now validates the key, so they're covered. NowrestoreObject.Assistant
restoreObject, getObjectAcl, putObjectAcl, copyObject all delegate to
getObject/storeObjectwhich now validate. Good. Now let me update the controller'svalidateKeyNoTraversalto delegate toS3Service.validateObjectKeyfor consistency.Assistant
Now let me compile and run my repro test to confirm the fix.
Assistant
The fix works:
PUT threw InvalidKey 400and the object count after the failed PUT is0(no phantom entry). Let me run the existingS3ServiceTest(which includes the traversal tests).Assistant
A test
copyObjectWithNonASCIIKeyuses a non-ASCII key thatPath.resolverejects withInvalidPathException. Let me look at the test.Assistant
The test
copyObjectWithNonASCIIKeyuses a non-ASCII key. MyvalidateObjectKeythrewInvalidPathException. Let me check whether this is a locale issue and whether the test passed before my change.Assistant
The locale is POSIX (ASCII). Let me run the non-ASCII test on the original (stashed) code to confirm it passed before.
Assistant
The locale is POSIX (ASCII), so
Path.resolverejects non-ASCII keys — andcopyObjectWithNonASCIIKeywas already failing on the original code in this environment (a pre-existing environmental failure, not a regression I introduced). However, my fix should not reject valid non-ASCII keys asInvalidKey. Let me makevalidateObjectKeylocale-independent by doing manual path normalization instead of relying onjava.nio.file.Path(which is encoding-sensitive).Let me restore my changes and rewrite
validateObjectKey.Assistant
Now let me rewrite
validateObjectKeyand its constant to use manual normalization (locale-independent).Assistant
Let me verify there's no leftover
KEY_SANDBOXreference and check thePathimport is still needed.Assistant
KEY_SANDBOXis gone, andPathis still used elsewhere. Let me re-run the repro test andS3ServiceTest.Assistant
My
validateObjectKeynow passes for non-ASCII keys; the test fails atresolveObjectPath/writeFiledue to the POSIX locale — the same pre-existing failure as on the original code (confirmed earlier). So no regression from my change.ReproTestpassed.Let me run the rest of
S3ServiceTest(excluding the pre-existing POSIX-locale failure) to confirm no regressions.Assistant
Both traversal tests pass. Now let me write a comprehensive repro covering memory mode, copy-source, and DeleteObjects (the gaps the issue targets).
Assistant
All 7 repro tests pass. Now let me run the broader existing non-Quarkus S3 unit tests to check for regressions.
Assistant
All non-Quarkus tests pass except the pre-existing POSIX-locale
copyObjectWithNonASCIIKeyfailure (identical on original code). Now let me run the QuarkusTest integration tests that my change could most affect: leading-slash keys, well-known keys, and the traversal test.Assistant
Both pass. Now let me run the
pathTraversalAttemptsReturn400test from S3IntegrationTest and a couple of copy/multipart tests to be safe.Assistant
The traversal test passes. Let me run the full
S3IntegrationTest(it runs in memory mode, so the POSIX non-ASCII issue won't affect it) to confirm no regressions.Assistant
All 108 pass. Let me run the copy, multipart, presigned-post, and versioning integration tests (the operations I touched).
Assistant
All pass. Let me run the object-lock, conditional-write, and a few more integration tests covering retention/legalhold paths I touched.
Assistant
All pass. Now I must remove my temporary
ReproTest.java(the instructions forbid adding new tests to the repository).Assistant
Only the two source files are modified. Let me review the full diff to ensure correctness and no leftover artifacts.
Assistant
The S3Service diff looks clean. Let me check the controller diff.
Assistant
Both diffs are clean. Let me check whether there are HTTP-level non-ASCII key tests that could be affected by the controller behavior change (the controller no longer rejects non-ASCII keys via
InvalidPathException).Assistant
There's a non-ASCII HTTP test in S3IntegrationTest (line 370). Let me view it and check whether it passed before my change in this POSIX environment.
Assistant
The HTTP non-ASCII test (
copyObjectWithNonAsciiKeySucceeds) runs in memory mode and passes with my change (part of the 108). My change makes the controller accept non-ASCII keys (matching UTF-8 behavior), which is more correct.Let me do a final confirmation: run
S3ServiceTestexcluding the pre-existing POSIX-localecopyObjectWithNonASCIIKeyfailure, to confirm zero failures from my change.Assistant
The only failure is the pre-existing
copyObjectWithNonASCIIKey. Let me confirm the stack trace shows it fails atresolveObjectPath/writeFile(the pre-existing POSIX-locale issue), NOT at myvalidateObjectKey.Assistant
Confirmed: the only failure is at
resolveObjectPath/writeFile(the pre-existing POSIX-locale issue withPath.resolveon non-ASCII, identical to the original code), NOT at myvalidateObjectKey— which correctly accepts non-ASCII keys now. No regression.Let me verify there are no existing tests expecting DeleteObjects to return per-key errors for traversal keys (which my upfront-rejection change would affect).
Assistant
No tests expect per-key errors for traversal keys. The fix is complete and verified. Let me do a final full diff review.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →