Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
ChatGPT (model unspecified)· OpenAIHugging Face ShareLM (browser-extension contributions)

I want the x ticks to have the pairs of (position, topic) nothing in the y ticks

  1. User

    I want the x ticks to have the pairs of (position, topic) nothing in the y ticks

  2. Assistant

    Here’s an example of Python + seaborn code that takes a dataframe with columns:

    text (or any text field — unused for plotting)

    topic (categorical)

    position (numeric timeline position)

    and produces a scatterplot where:

    Each point = a topic

    X-axis = average position of that topic

    Point size = relative frequency of the topic

    Y-axis = just spreads topics for visibility (or can be removed)

    You can paste this into your script and adapt the column names as needed.

    ✅ Seaborn timeline scatterplot for topic model pythonCopy codeimport pandas as pd import seaborn as sns import matplotlib.pyplot as plt

    df must contain: "topic" and "position"

    Example:

    df = pd.DataFrame({"text": [...], "topic": [...], "position": [...]})

    1. Compute summary statistics per topic

    topic_summary = ( df.groupby("topic") .agg( avg_position=("position", "mean"), frequency=("position", "size") ) .reset_index() )

    2. Normalize size for plotting (optional)

    size_scale = 500 / topic_summary["frequency"].max() topic_summary["size"] = topic_summary["frequency"] * size_scale

    3. Create scatterplot

    plt.figure(figsize=(12, 4)) sns.scatterplot( data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y="topic", # or use y=0 to force a single horizontal row size="size", sizes=(20, 800), legend=False )

    plt.xlabel("Average Position on Narrative Timeline") plt.ylabel("Topic") plt.title("Topic Timeline Overview (Position vs. Topic Frequency)") plt.tight_layout() plt.show()

    ✅ Notes & Options

    If you want the topics all on one horizontal line (true timeline style):

    pythonCopy codetopic_summary["y"] = 0 sns.scatterplot(data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y="y", size="size", ...) plt.yticks([])

    If position is already sequential (e.g., narrative index), the plot will reflect that ordering.

    If you want, I can help you format this into a function, add labels, color-coding, or adapt it for Plotly or Matplotlib.

  3. User

    What can I do to make the labels not ontop of eachother?

  4. Assistant

    Got it — you want your scatterplot to:

    show the (position, topic) pairs as tick labels on the x-axis,

    and remove all y-axis ticks.

    You can do this by customizing the tick labels after plotting, using set_xticks() and set_xticklabels(). Here’s how you can modify your existing code 👇 pythonCopy codeimport matplotlib.pyplot as plt import seaborn as sns

    assume topic_summary has columns: ['topic', 'avg_position', 'size']

    plt.figure(figsize=(12, 4)) ax = sns.scatterplot( data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y="topic", size="size", sizes=(20, 800), legend=False )

    --- Remove y-axis ticks ---

    ax.set_yticks([])

    --- Add x-axis ticks as (position, topic) pairs ---

    pairs = [f"({round(pos, 2)}, {topic})" for pos, topic in zip(topic_summary["avg_position"], topic_summary["topic"])] ax.set_xticks(topic_summary["avg_position"]) ax.set_xticklabels(pairs, rotation=45, ha='right', fontsize=8)

    --- Labels and title ---

    ax.set_xlabel("Average Position (with Topic)") ax.set_ylabel("") ax.set_title("Topic Timeline Overview (Position vs. Topic Frequency)")

    plt.tight_layout() plt.show()

    🔍 Result:

    X-axis: each tick label looks like (0.42, kibbutz, year, community)

    Y-axis: empty

    Rotation makes labels readable even if they overlap a bit.

    Would you like the labels to be shortened (e.g., just the first keyword of the topic) so they fit better horizontally?

  5. User

    Whats wrong? # 1. Compute summary statistics per topic topic_summary = ( df.groupby("en_name") .agg( avg_position=("position", "mean"), frequency=("position", "size") ) .reset_index() )

        # 2. Normalize size for plotting (optional)
        size_scale = 0.1 / topic_summary["frequency"].max()
        topic_summary["size"] = topic_summary["frequency"] * size_scale
    
        # 3. Create scatterplot
        plt.figure(figsize=(24, 3))
        ax = sns.scatterplot(
            data=topic_summary,
            x="avg_position",
            y=1,
            size="size",
            sizes=(20, 800),
            legend=False
        )
    
        # --- Remove y-axis ticks ---
        ax.set_yticks([])
        # y limit
        ax.set_ylim(0.8, 1.2)
    
        # --- Add x-axis ticks as (position, topic) pairs ---
        pairs = [f"{round(pos, 2)}\n{topic}" for pos, topic in
                 zip(topic_summary["avg_position"], topic_summary["en_name"])]
        # ax.set_xticks(topic_summary["avg_position"])
        # ax.set_xticklabels(pairs, rotation=30, ha='right', fontsize=8)
        # ax.set_xticklabels([round(pos, 2) for pos in topic_summary["avg_position"]],
        #                    ha='right', fontsize=16)
    
        for _, row in topic_summary.iterrows():
            ax.text(row["avg_position"], 0,  # adjust y as needed
                    f"{row['en_name'].split(',')[0]}",
                    rotation=45, ha='left', va='bottom', fontsize=16)
        ax.set_xticks([])
        ax.set_yticks([])
    
        # --- Labels and title ---
        ax.set_xlabel("Average Position (with Topic)")
        ax.set_ylabel("")
        ax.set_title("Topic Timeline Overview (Position vs. Topic Frequency)")
    
        plt.tight_layout()
        plt.show()
    
  6. Assistant

    Good question — when you have many x-axis labels (especially long ones like (0.43, kibbutz, year, community)), they overlap easily. Here are five reliable ways to make them readable — you can mix or choose one depending on your preferences:

    ✅ Option 1: Rotate and spread out the ticks Increase figure width and rotate labels steeply: pythonCopy codeplt.figure(figsize=(16, 4)) # wider figure sns.scatterplot(...)

    ax.set_xticks(topic_summary["avg_position"]) ax.set_xticklabels(pairs, rotation=60, ha='right', fontsize=8)

    ax.set_yticks([]) plt.tight_layout() plt.show()

    ✅ Best when you have <20 topics 🟡 Still crowded if positions are close.

    ✅ Option 2: Use fewer x-ticks (sample or skip) Show only every nth label: pythonCopy codestep = 2 # show every 2nd label positions = topic_summary["avg_position"].iloc[cfd0:d41f:f56b:1814:40cb:3253:c020:7e08step] labels = [pairs[i] for i in range(0, len(pairs), step)]

    ax.set_xticks(positions) ax.set_xticklabels(labels, rotation=60, ha='right', fontsize=8)

    ✅ Keeps labels readable 🟡 You lose some topics on the x-axis

    ✅ Option 3: Shorten topics (first word only) If your topics are comma-separated, just show the first term: pythonCopy codepairs = [f"({round(pos, 2)}, {topic.split(',')[0]})" for pos, topic in zip(topic_summary["avg_position"], topic_summary["topic"])]

    ✅ Clean and compact 🟢 Recommended for narrative/topic visualization

    ✅ Option 4: Use vertical labels Rotate labels vertically (rotation=90) to save horizontal space: pythonCopy codeax.set_xticklabels(pairs, rotation=90, fontsize=8)

    ✅ Simple fix 🟡 Harder to read at a glance, but great for dense plots.

    ✅ Option 5: Use annotations above each point instead of x-ticks Remove tick labels entirely and label each bubble: pythonCopy codefor _, row in topic_summary.iterrows(): ax.text(row["avg_position"], 0, # adjust y as needed f"{row['topic'].split(',')[0]}", rotation=45, ha='left', va='bottom', fontsize=8) ax.set_xticks([]) ax.set_yticks([])

    ✅ Looks cleaner, especially for a horizontal timeline layout.

    Would you like the timeline to look more like a horizontal narrative line (all topics aligned at y=0) instead of stacked by topic? If yes, I can give you a version where the bubbles sit on a single axis with labels placed above each bubble — much more readable visually.

  7. User

    I'm doing this to adress a peer review on a topic modeling digital history article. This is the comment: "I was hoping to see a visualization of the whole corpus that wasn’t just a bar graph of topic differences by gender – is there any way to “see” all the topics and visualize their relationships or frequency? "

    Can you give me an idea?

  8. Assistant

    Good question — your code is almost perfect, but there are a couple of subtle issues that explain why the annotations (text labels) may not appear as expected or overlap strangely. Let’s break down the likely problems 👇

    ⚠️ 1. y=1 in the scatterplot means your dots are at y=1, but your annotation text is drawn at y=0 pythonCopy codeax.text(row["avg_position"], 0, ...)

    That’s below your y-limits: pythonCopy codeax.set_ylim(0.8, 1.2)

    → So, the text is outside the visible range and doesn’t show up. ✅ Fix: Use a y-value slightly below the dots, but still visible (e.g. 0.92): pythonCopy codefor _, row in topic_summary.iterrows(): ax.text( row["avg_position"], 0.92, # <--- inside range f"{row['en_name'].split(',')[0]}", rotation=45, ha='left', va='top', fontsize=10 )

    ⚠️ 2. y=1 as a constant works, but Seaborn will add a tiny random jitter because y is numeric but constant. You can disable that jitter by explicitly setting hue=None and alpha=1. ✅ Example: pythonCopy codeax = sns.scatterplot( data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y=[1]*len(topic_summary), # force exact constant y size="size", sizes=(20, 800), legend=False )

    ⚠️ 3. Font size and rotation can cause text overlap You’re using fontsize=16, which is quite large for horizontal annotations. ✅ Try: pythonCopy codefontsize=9 rotation=60 ha='right'

    ✅ Cleaned-up, fully working version pythonCopy codeplt.figure(figsize=(24, 3))

    1. Plot

    ax = sns.scatterplot( data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y=[1]*len(topic_summary), # force flat line size="size", sizes=(20, 800), legend=False )

    2. Simplify axes

    ax.set_ylim(0.8, 1.2) ax.set_yticks([]) ax.set_xticks([])

    3. Annotate topics above each point

    for _, row in topic_summary.iterrows(): ax.text( row["avg_position"], 0.92, f"{row['en_name'].split(',')[0]}", rotation=60, ha='right', va='top', fontsize=9 )

    4. Title and labels

    ax.set_xlabel("Average Position on Narrative Timeline") ax.set_ylabel("") ax.set_title("Topic Timeline Overview (Position vs. Topic Frequency)")

    plt.tight_layout() plt.show()

    ✅ Result:

    All dots are on a clean horizontal line

    Labels appear below or above each dot

    No overlapping y-ticks or extra jitter

    Much more readable, compact timeline-style visualization

    Would you like me to make the labels auto-adjust up/down (so that neighboring ones don’t collide)? That’s possible with a short offset logic.

  9. User

    please implement “Topic Landscape” Heatmap

  10. Assistant

    That’s an excellent and very typical reviewer request — they’re essentially asking for a global visualization of your topic model, one that captures either:

    relationships between topics (semantic or co-occurrence proximity),

    frequency or prominence across the corpus, or

    ideally, both in a single figure.

    Here are several visual ideas (with a short explanation of when and why each works well for digital humanities or historical corpora):

    🌐 1. Topic Relationship Map (2D Embedding of Topic Vectors) Goal: “See” all topics in semantic space. How:

    Take each topic’s word distribution vector or embedding centroid (if using contextual models like BERTopic or top2vec).

    Reduce to 2D using UMAP or t-SNE.

    Plot with scatter/bubble size = topic frequency, color = thematic cluster (if applicable).

    Result: A map where nearby bubbles represent semantically related topics — e.g. "family/home" cluster near "children/school", while "war/security" sits elsewhere. This directly answers “visualize their relationships”. Toolkits:

    umap-learn + matplotlib / seaborn

    pyLDAvis (classic LDA interactive visualization)

    BERTopic.visualize_topics() (interactive, modern)

    Scholarly advantage: Looks interpretive, not purely technical — reviewers see conceptual proximity, not just counts.

    🧭 2. Topic Timeline (what you’re building now) Goal: “See” topic movement or placement along the corpus’s narrative or temporal axis. This already fits digital history beautifully if your corpus is diachronic or narrative (e.g., testimonies, diaries, letters). You can:

    Plot topics along the timeline (average position or median date).

    Bubble size = frequency / salience.

    Color = thematic category (if manually assigned).

    Optional refinement: overlay major historical periods as shaded bands. Scholarly framing:

    “This timeline visualization highlights how narrative attention shifts across themes — e.g., topics of alertness and shelter dominate early segments, while memory and faith emerge later.”

    🕸️ 3. Topic Co-occurrence Network Goal: Show relationships via shared documents. How:

    Compute topic co-occurrence across documents (topics that appear together often).

    Build a network: nodes = topics, edges = co-occurrence strength.

    Size nodes by frequency; color by thematic cluster.

    Tools:

    networkx + matplotlib or pyvis for interactive HTML export.

    Scholarly framing:

    “The network reveals two primary thematic hubs: collective memory topics co-occurring with religious reflection, and community/war-related topics forming a separate cluster.”

    🧩 4. Stacked Distribution Across Metadata Goal: Keep frequency but show it richer than bar charts. Example: stacked area or streamgraph showing topic proportions over time, gender, or region. Tools: plotly.express.area, matplotlib.stackplot. Good for: diachronic or demographic comparisons — very intuitive for reviewers used to quantitative DH graphics.

    🗺️ 5. “Topic Landscape” Heatmap Goal: Blend textual themes and chronology in a compact form. Each row = topic; each column = document position or year. Color intensity = topic weight. → You see which topics dominate when. Scholarly framing:

    “This heatmap situates the emergence and fading of topics across testimonies, illustrating transitions from descriptions of danger to reflections on faith and survival.”

    💡 What I’d recommend for your revision Since your article is digital history and reviewers already saw bar graphs by gender, the most impactful addition would be either:

    🕸️ A topic co-occurrence network — shows relationships across the corpus, → visually distinct from the bar chart, conceptually richer.

    🌐 A semantic topic map (UMAP) — shows proximity in meaning space, → feels “big-picture,” helps them “see the whole corpus.”

    🧭 The topic timeline you’re already developing — → perfect if your corpus is narrative or temporally ordered (e.g., testimonies, diaries).

    Would you like me to generate a code template for one of those (e.g., the topic network or semantic map) based on your current topic_summary or topic-word data? That way you could include it directly in your revision figure.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.