I want the x ticks to have the pairs of (position, topic) nothing in the y ticks
- User
I want the x ticks to have the pairs of (position, topic) nothing in the y ticks
- Assistant
Here’s an example of Python + seaborn code that takes a dataframe with columns:
text (or any text field — unused for plotting)
topic (categorical)
position (numeric timeline position)
and produces a scatterplot where:
Each point = a topic
X-axis = average position of that topic
Point size = relative frequency of the topic
Y-axis = just spreads topics for visibility (or can be removed)
You can paste this into your script and adapt the column names as needed.
✅ Seaborn timeline scatterplot for topic model pythonCopy codeimport pandas as pd import seaborn as sns import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
df must contain: "topic" and "position"
Example:
df = pd.DataFrame({"text": [...], "topic": [...], "position": [...]})
1. Compute summary statistics per topic
topic_summary = ( df.groupby("topic") .agg( avg_position=("position", "mean"), frequency=("position", "size") ) .reset_index() )
2. Normalize size for plotting (optional)
size_scale = 500 / topic_summary["frequency"].max() topic_summary["size"] = topic_summary["frequency"] * size_scale
3. Create scatterplot
plt.figure(figsize=(12, 4)) sns.scatterplot( data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y="topic", # or use y=0 to force a single horizontal row size="size", sizes=(20, 800), legend=False )
plt.xlabel("Average Position on Narrative Timeline") plt.ylabel("Topic") plt.title("Topic Timeline Overview (Position vs. Topic Frequency)") plt.tight_layout() plt.show()
✅ Notes & Options
If you want the topics all on one horizontal line (true timeline style):
pythonCopy codetopic_summary["y"] = 0 sns.scatterplot(data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y="y", size="size", ...) plt.yticks([])
If position is already sequential (e.g., narrative index), the plot will reflect that ordering.
If you want, I can help you format this into a function, add labels, color-coding, or adapt it for Plotly or Matplotlib.
- User
What can I do to make the labels not ontop of eachother?
- Assistant
Got it — you want your scatterplot to:
show the (position, topic) pairs as tick labels on the x-axis,
and remove all y-axis ticks.
You can do this by customizing the tick labels after plotting, using set_xticks() and set_xticklabels(). Here’s how you can modify your existing code 👇 pythonCopy codeimport matplotlib.pyplot as plt import seaborn as sns
assume topic_summary has columns: ['topic', 'avg_position', 'size']
plt.figure(figsize=(12, 4)) ax = sns.scatterplot( data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y="topic", size="size", sizes=(20, 800), legend=False )
--- Remove y-axis ticks ---
ax.set_yticks([])
--- Add x-axis ticks as (position, topic) pairs ---
pairs = [f"({round(pos, 2)}, {topic})" for pos, topic in zip(topic_summary["avg_position"], topic_summary["topic"])] ax.set_xticks(topic_summary["avg_position"]) ax.set_xticklabels(pairs, rotation=45, ha='right', fontsize=8)
--- Labels and title ---
ax.set_xlabel("Average Position (with Topic)") ax.set_ylabel("") ax.set_title("Topic Timeline Overview (Position vs. Topic Frequency)")
plt.tight_layout() plt.show()
🔍 Result:
X-axis: each tick label looks like (0.42, kibbutz, year, community)
Y-axis: empty
Rotation makes labels readable even if they overlap a bit.
Would you like the labels to be shortened (e.g., just the first keyword of the topic) so they fit better horizontally?
- User
Whats wrong? # 1. Compute summary statistics per topic topic_summary = ( df.groupby("en_name") .agg( avg_position=("position", "mean"), frequency=("position", "size") ) .reset_index() )
# 2. Normalize size for plotting (optional) size_scale = 0.1 / topic_summary["frequency"].max() topic_summary["size"] = topic_summary["frequency"] * size_scale # 3. Create scatterplot plt.figure(figsize=(24, 3)) ax = sns.scatterplot( data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y=1, size="size", sizes=(20, 800), legend=False ) # --- Remove y-axis ticks --- ax.set_yticks([]) # y limit ax.set_ylim(0.8, 1.2) # --- Add x-axis ticks as (position, topic) pairs --- pairs = [f"{round(pos, 2)}\n{topic}" for pos, topic in zip(topic_summary["avg_position"], topic_summary["en_name"])] # ax.set_xticks(topic_summary["avg_position"]) # ax.set_xticklabels(pairs, rotation=30, ha='right', fontsize=8) # ax.set_xticklabels([round(pos, 2) for pos in topic_summary["avg_position"]], # ha='right', fontsize=16) for _, row in topic_summary.iterrows(): ax.text(row["avg_position"], 0, # adjust y as needed f"{row['en_name'].split(',')[0]}", rotation=45, ha='left', va='bottom', fontsize=16) ax.set_xticks([]) ax.set_yticks([]) # --- Labels and title --- ax.set_xlabel("Average Position (with Topic)") ax.set_ylabel("") ax.set_title("Topic Timeline Overview (Position vs. Topic Frequency)") plt.tight_layout() plt.show() - Assistant
Good question — when you have many x-axis labels (especially long ones like (0.43, kibbutz, year, community)), they overlap easily. Here are five reliable ways to make them readable — you can mix or choose one depending on your preferences:
✅ Option 1: Rotate and spread out the ticks Increase figure width and rotate labels steeply: pythonCopy codeplt.figure(figsize=(16, 4)) # wider figure sns.scatterplot(...)
ax.set_xticks(topic_summary["avg_position"]) ax.set_xticklabels(pairs, rotation=60, ha='right', fontsize=8)
ax.set_yticks([]) plt.tight_layout() plt.show()
✅ Best when you have <20 topics 🟡 Still crowded if positions are close.
✅ Option 2: Use fewer x-ticks (sample or skip) Show only every nth label: pythonCopy codestep = 2 # show every 2nd label positions = topic_summary["avg_position"].iloc[c949:a31b:6358:c8dd:f7af:c2be:7cd:8d0dstep] labels = [pairs[i] for i in range(0, len(pairs), step)]
ax.set_xticks(positions) ax.set_xticklabels(labels, rotation=60, ha='right', fontsize=8)
✅ Keeps labels readable 🟡 You lose some topics on the x-axis
✅ Option 3: Shorten topics (first word only) If your topics are comma-separated, just show the first term: pythonCopy codepairs = [f"({round(pos, 2)}, {topic.split(',')[0]})" for pos, topic in zip(topic_summary["avg_position"], topic_summary["topic"])]
✅ Clean and compact 🟢 Recommended for narrative/topic visualization
✅ Option 4: Use vertical labels Rotate labels vertically (rotation=90) to save horizontal space: pythonCopy codeax.set_xticklabels(pairs, rotation=90, fontsize=8)
✅ Simple fix 🟡 Harder to read at a glance, but great for dense plots.
✅ Option 5: Use annotations above each point instead of x-ticks Remove tick labels entirely and label each bubble: pythonCopy codefor _, row in topic_summary.iterrows(): ax.text(row["avg_position"], 0, # adjust y as needed f"{row['topic'].split(',')[0]}", rotation=45, ha='left', va='bottom', fontsize=8) ax.set_xticks([]) ax.set_yticks([])
✅ Looks cleaner, especially for a horizontal timeline layout.
Would you like the timeline to look more like a horizontal narrative line (all topics aligned at y=0) instead of stacked by topic? If yes, I can give you a version where the bubbles sit on a single axis with labels placed above each bubble — much more readable visually.
- User
I'm doing this to adress a peer review on a topic modeling digital history article. This is the comment: "I was hoping to see a visualization of the whole corpus that wasn’t just a bar graph of topic differences by gender – is there any way to “see” all the topics and visualize their relationships or frequency? "
Can you give me an idea?
- Assistant
Good question — your code is almost perfect, but there are a couple of subtle issues that explain why the annotations (text labels) may not appear as expected or overlap strangely. Let’s break down the likely problems 👇
⚠️ 1. y=1 in the scatterplot means your dots are at y=1, but your annotation text is drawn at y=0 pythonCopy codeax.text(row["avg_position"], 0, ...)
That’s below your y-limits: pythonCopy codeax.set_ylim(0.8, 1.2)
→ So, the text is outside the visible range and doesn’t show up. ✅ Fix: Use a y-value slightly below the dots, but still visible (e.g. 0.92): pythonCopy codefor _, row in topic_summary.iterrows(): ax.text( row["avg_position"], 0.92, # <--- inside range f"{row['en_name'].split(',')[0]}", rotation=45, ha='left', va='top', fontsize=10 )
⚠️ 2. y=1 as a constant works, but Seaborn will add a tiny random jitter because y is numeric but constant. You can disable that jitter by explicitly setting hue=None and alpha=1. ✅ Example: pythonCopy codeax = sns.scatterplot( data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y=[1]*len(topic_summary), # force exact constant y size="size", sizes=(20, 800), legend=False )
⚠️ 3. Font size and rotation can cause text overlap You’re using fontsize=16, which is quite large for horizontal annotations. ✅ Try: pythonCopy codefontsize=9 rotation=60 ha='right'
✅ Cleaned-up, fully working version pythonCopy codeplt.figure(figsize=(24, 3))
1. Plot
ax = sns.scatterplot( data=topic_summary, x="avg_position", y=[1]*len(topic_summary), # force flat line size="size", sizes=(20, 800), legend=False )
2. Simplify axes
ax.set_ylim(0.8, 1.2) ax.set_yticks([]) ax.set_xticks([])
3. Annotate topics above each point
for _, row in topic_summary.iterrows(): ax.text( row["avg_position"], 0.92, f"{row['en_name'].split(',')[0]}", rotation=60, ha='right', va='top', fontsize=9 )
4. Title and labels
ax.set_xlabel("Average Position on Narrative Timeline") ax.set_ylabel("") ax.set_title("Topic Timeline Overview (Position vs. Topic Frequency)")
plt.tight_layout() plt.show()
✅ Result:
All dots are on a clean horizontal line
Labels appear below or above each dot
No overlapping y-ticks or extra jitter
Much more readable, compact timeline-style visualization
Would you like me to make the labels auto-adjust up/down (so that neighboring ones don’t collide)? That’s possible with a short offset logic.
- User
please implement “Topic Landscape” Heatmap
- Assistant
That’s an excellent and very typical reviewer request — they’re essentially asking for a global visualization of your topic model, one that captures either:
relationships between topics (semantic or co-occurrence proximity),
frequency or prominence across the corpus, or
ideally, both in a single figure.
Here are several visual ideas (with a short explanation of when and why each works well for digital humanities or historical corpora):
🌐 1. Topic Relationship Map (2D Embedding of Topic Vectors) Goal: “See” all topics in semantic space. How:
Take each topic’s word distribution vector or embedding centroid (if using contextual models like BERTopic or top2vec).
Reduce to 2D using UMAP or t-SNE.
Plot with scatter/bubble size = topic frequency, color = thematic cluster (if applicable).
Result: A map where nearby bubbles represent semantically related topics — e.g. "family/home" cluster near "children/school", while "war/security" sits elsewhere. This directly answers “visualize their relationships”. Toolkits:
umap-learn + matplotlib / seaborn
pyLDAvis (classic LDA interactive visualization)
BERTopic.visualize_topics() (interactive, modern)
Scholarly advantage: Looks interpretive, not purely technical — reviewers see conceptual proximity, not just counts.
🧭 2. Topic Timeline (what you’re building now) Goal: “See” topic movement or placement along the corpus’s narrative or temporal axis. This already fits digital history beautifully if your corpus is diachronic or narrative (e.g., testimonies, diaries, letters). You can:
Plot topics along the timeline (average position or median date).
Bubble size = frequency / salience.
Color = thematic category (if manually assigned).
Optional refinement: overlay major historical periods as shaded bands. Scholarly framing:
“This timeline visualization highlights how narrative attention shifts across themes — e.g., topics of alertness and shelter dominate early segments, while memory and faith emerge later.”
🕸️ 3. Topic Co-occurrence Network Goal: Show relationships via shared documents. How:
Compute topic co-occurrence across documents (topics that appear together often).
Build a network: nodes = topics, edges = co-occurrence strength.
Size nodes by frequency; color by thematic cluster.
Tools:
networkx + matplotlib or pyvis for interactive HTML export.
Scholarly framing:
“The network reveals two primary thematic hubs: collective memory topics co-occurring with religious reflection, and community/war-related topics forming a separate cluster.”
🧩 4. Stacked Distribution Across Metadata Goal: Keep frequency but show it richer than bar charts. Example: stacked area or streamgraph showing topic proportions over time, gender, or region. Tools: plotly.express.area, matplotlib.stackplot. Good for: diachronic or demographic comparisons — very intuitive for reviewers used to quantitative DH graphics.
🗺️ 5. “Topic Landscape” Heatmap Goal: Blend textual themes and chronology in a compact form. Each row = topic; each column = document position or year. Color intensity = topic weight. → You see which topics dominate when. Scholarly framing:
“This heatmap situates the emergence and fading of topics across testimonies, illustrating transitions from descriptions of danger to reflections on faith and survival.”
💡 What I’d recommend for your revision Since your article is digital history and reviewers already saw bar graphs by gender, the most impactful addition would be either:
🕸️ A topic co-occurrence network — shows relationships across the corpus, → visually distinct from the bar chart, conceptually richer.
🌐 A semantic topic map (UMAP) — shows proximity in meaning space, → feels “big-picture,” helps them “see the whole corpus.”
🧭 The topic timeline you’re already developing — → perfect if your corpus is narrative or temporally ordered (e.g., testimonies, diaries).
Would you like me to generate a code template for one of those (e.g., the topic network or semantic map) based on your current topic_summary or topic-word data? That way you could include it directly in your revision figure.
- User
If num_bins=20 we get a square matrix?
- Assistant
Perfect — the “Topic Landscape” Heatmap is one of the most elegant ways to “see” the entire topic model across your corpus. It’s interpretive (historians love it), compact, and looks great in an article. Let’s walk through exactly how to implement it.
🧭 Goal Visualize:
Rows = topics
Columns = document positions or chronological segments
Color = topic prominence (average weight)
This works whether your “position” column is:
a numeric timeline index (e.g., 0–1 normalized), or
an actual date/year (which can be binned).
✅ Example Implementation in Python (Seaborn) pythonCopy codeimport pandas as pd import seaborn as sns import matplotlib.pyplot as plt import numpy as np
---------------------------------------------------------
df must have at least:
- 'topic' (categorical)
- 'position' (numeric or chronological order)
- optionally 'weight' (topic intensity per segment or doc)
---------------------------------------------------------
Example structure:
df = pd.DataFrame({
'topic': [...],
'position': [...], # e.g., narrative index or year
'weight': [...] # optional, else counts are used
})
1. Bin positions into discrete segments
num_bins = 30 df["pos_bin"] = pd.cut(df["position"], bins=num_bins, labels=False)
2. Compute average topic presence per bin
heatmap_data = ( df.groupby(["topic", "pos_bin"]) .agg(weight=("weight", "mean") if "weight" in df.columns else ("position", "size")) .reset_index() .pivot(index="topic", columns="pos_bin", values="weight") .fillna(0) )
3. Normalize per-topic (optional, for visual contrast)
heatmap_data = heatmap_data.div(heatmap_data.max(axis=1), axis=0)
4. Plot heatmap
plt.figure(figsize=(14, len(heatmap_data) * 0.4)) sns.heatmap( heatmap_data, cmap="YlGnBu", cbar_kws={'label': 'Relative Topic Intensity'}, linewidths=0.3 )
plt.xlabel("Narrative / Chronological Position") plt.ylabel("Topic") plt.title("Topic Landscape: Distribution of Topics Across the Corpus")
plt.tight_layout() plt.show()
🧩 Result:
Each row shows a topic (e.g., "alertness, soldier, section")
Each column = a slice of your corpus timeline (e.g., first → last segment)
Color intensity = relative strength of the topic in that segment.
You can visually trace topic arcs — e.g., a “war” topic that dominates early, then fades as “memory” rises.
💬 Optional Refinements 🔹 Add chronological x-axis If position is a year or date, replace bin labels: pythonCopy codebin_edges = pd.cut(df["position"], bins=num_bins, retbins=True)[1] plt.xticks( ticks=np.arange(num_bins), labels=[f"{int(b)}" for b in bin_edges[:-1]], rotation=45 )
🔹 Sort topics by temporal center of mass To make the plot narrative-like (early-to-late themes): pythonCopy codetopic_order = heatmap_data.apply(lambda x: np.argmax(x.values), axis=1).sort_values().index sns.heatmap(heatmap_data.loc[topic_order], ...)
🪶 Scholarly framing for your revision: You could caption it like:
Figure X. Topic Landscape Heatmap showing how each topic’s prominence varies along the corpus timeline. Early sections focus on war and shelter, while later portions emphasize memory, reflection, and identity.
Would you like me to adapt the code directly to your variable names (e.g. en_name, position, weight or frequency)? That way it’ll run immediately on your dataset._
- User
This gave me 0 for all bin edges:
bin_edges = pd.cut(df["position"], bins=num_bins, retbins=True)[1] plt.xticks( ticks=np.arange(num_bins), labels=[f"{int(b)}" for b in bin_edges[:-1]], rotation=45 )
- Assistant
Excellent question — and that’s a subtle one 👏 👉 No, setting num_bins = 20 does not make the matrix square. Let’s unpack what’s going on.
🧮 What determines the matrix shape When we create: pythonCopy codeheatmap_data = df.groupby(["topic", "pos_bin"]).agg(...).pivot(index="topic", columns="pos_bin")
The rows come from unique values of topic
The columns come from the number of position bins (num_bins, if all are used)
So:
#rows = number of topics
#columns = up to num_bins (some bins might be empty)
✅ Example: topicsbins15 topics20 bins → 15 × 20 matrix ✅35 topics20 bins → 35 × 20 matrix ✅ Only if you happen to have 20 topics and 20 bins will it be square — but that’s just coincidence.
🧩 Interpreting the axes
X-axis (columns) = timeline / position segments (bins)
Y-axis (rows) = topics
Each cell = topic intensity in that timeline segment
So, num_bins simply controls horizontal resolution of your timeline:
small (e.g., 10) → broad chronological phases
large (e.g., 50) → fine-grained progression
💡 TL;DR SettingEffectnum_binsnumber of timeline slices (x-axis width)#topicsnumber of rows (y-axis height)Not squareNormal — that’s how the landscape should look!
Would you like me to show how to automatically choose num_bins based on corpus length (e.g., one bin per 50 documents or per 2% of corpus)? That gives a visually balanced heatmap without guessing._
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →
- ChatGPT (model unspecified)Compare side by side →