Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gpt-4o-search-preview-high-loc· OpenAI LMArena Search Arena 24K

Do Catholics accept that more scripture can be given?

  1. User

    Do Catholics accept that more scripture can be given?

  2. Assistant

    The Catholic Church teaches that public revelation concluded with the death of the last apostle, marking the completion of the divine revelation necessary for salvation. This belief is articulated in the document Dei Verbum from the Second Vatican Council, which states:

    > "The Christian economy, therefore, since it is the new and definitive Covenant, will never pass away; and no new public revelation is to be expected before the glorious manifestation of our Lord Jesus Christ."[1]

    Consequently, the Church holds that the canon of Scripture is closed, meaning no additional books are to be added to the Bible. The Church's magisterium, or teaching authority, is responsible for authentically interpreting the Word of God as contained in Sacred Scripture and Tradition. This role does not include adding to or altering the established canon of Scripture[2].

    While the Church recognizes that private revelations may occur, these do not belong to the deposit of faith and are not considered part of the canonical Scriptures. Therefore, Catholics do not accept the possibility of new Scripture being given beyond what has already been revealed and canonized.

  3. User

    Didn't they continue to fill the vacancy of apoatles like they did in Acts?

  4. Assistant

    Yes, the Catholic Church maintains the practice of apostolic succession, which involves the continuous appointment of successors to the apostles. This tradition began with the replacement of Judas Iscariot by Matthias, as described in Acts 1:15–26. The apostles recognized the necessity of preserving their mission and authority, leading them to appoint successors to continue their work.

    This practice is rooted in the understanding that the apostles' mission was to be perpetuated beyond their lifetimes. The early Church Fathers, such as Pope St. Clement I, affirmed this belief. In his letter to the Corinthians, written around AD 80, he stated that the apostles appointed their earliest converts as bishops and deacons, and provided that upon their death, other approved men should succeed them in their ministry[1].

    Through apostolic succession, the Catholic Church ensures the continuity of its teaching authority and the preservation of the apostolic mission. This unbroken line of succession is seen as essential for maintaining the integrity and unity of the Church's doctrine and practice.

  5. User

    How does this compare with the LDS understanding of apostasy and how a closed canon is evidence of it

  6. Assistant

    The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church) and the Catholic Church have fundamentally different perspectives on apostasy and the nature of the scriptural canon.

    LDS Perspective on Apostasy and Open Canon:

    The LDS Church teaches that a "Great Apostasy" occurred shortly after the ascension of Jesus Christ. This period was characterized by the corruption of Christian doctrine through the integration of Greek and other philosophies, divisions among followers, and the martyrdom of the apostles, which led to a loss of priesthood authority to administer the church and its ordinances. As a result, the original church established by Jesus Christ was no longer present on the earth. Latter-day Saints believe that this apostasy necessitated a restoration of the original doctrines and rites of Christianity. They hold that this restoration began with Joseph Smith's First Vision in 1820, where God the Father and Jesus Christ appeared to him, calling him to be a prophet. Through subsequent revelations, the LDS Church was established, and priesthood authority was restored. This belief in continuous revelation supports the LDS Church's open scriptural canon, which includes the Bible, the Book of Mormon, the Doctrine and Covenants, and the Pearl of Great Price. The open canon allows for the addition of new scriptures as revealed to the church's prophets. (en.wikipedia.org, en.wikipedia.org)

    Catholic Perspective on Apostasy and Closed Canon:

    In contrast, the Catholic Church teaches that public revelation concluded with the death of the last apostle, marking the completion of the divine revelation necessary for salvation. This belief is articulated in the document Dei Verbum from the Second Vatican Council, which states:

    > "The Christian economy, therefore, since it is the new and definitive Covenant, will never pass away; and no new public revelation is to be expected before the glorious manifestation of our Lord Jesus Christ."

    Consequently, the Catholic Church holds that the canon of Scripture is closed, meaning no additional books are to be added to the Bible. The Church's magisterium, or teaching authority, is responsible for authentically interpreting the Word of God as contained in Sacred Scripture and Tradition. This role does not include adding to or altering the established canon of Scripture. While the Church recognizes that private revelations may occur, these do not belong to the deposit of faith and are not considered part of the canonical Scriptures.

    Comparison:

    The LDS Church views the closed canon of traditional Christianity as evidence of the Great Apostasy, suggesting that the cessation of new revelation indicates a departure from the original, dynamic relationship between God and His church. In contrast, the Catholic Church sees the closed canon as a testament to the completeness and sufficiency of the revelation given through Jesus Christ and the apostles, with the magisterium serving to interpret and preserve this deposit of faith without adding to it.

    These differing views underscore the distinct theological foundations of each tradition regarding the continuity of revelation and the authority to define and interpret sacred scripture.

  7. User

    How does the LDS interpretafion of personal revelation comlare to how Catholics understand the Holy Spirit?

  8. Assistant

    The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church) and the Catholic Church both emphasize the importance of divine guidance in the lives of believers, but they conceptualize and experience this guidance differently.

    LDS Understanding of Personal Revelation:

    In LDS theology, personal revelation is a fundamental principle, allowing individuals to receive direct communication from God through the Holy Ghost. This personal revelation is considered essential for making decisions, understanding divine will, and strengthening one's faith. Members are encouraged to seek personal revelation through prayer, scripture study, and righteous living. Elder Dale G. Renlund of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles emphasized that receiving revelation requires effort, including prayer, fasting, and patience. He noted that "waiting on the Lord and trusting that He will answer when He knows it is best is a very important work"[1].

    The LDS Church teaches that personal revelation can manifest in various ways, such as feelings of peace, enlightenment, or specific promptings to act. These revelations are believed to be in harmony with the teachings of the Church and are sought to guide personal decisions and spiritual growth.

    Catholic Understanding of the Holy Spirit:

    In Catholic theology, the Holy Spirit is the third person of the Holy Trinity and plays a vital role in guiding the Church and its members. The Holy Spirit is believed to impart seven gifts—wisdom, understanding, counsel, fortitude, knowledge, piety, and fear of the Lord—which aid believers in living a Christian life[2].

    Catholics believe that the Holy Spirit works through the Church's sacraments, sacred scripture, and the magisterium (teaching authority) to guide the faithful. While personal inspiration and guidance by the Holy Spirit are acknowledged, they are generally understood to occur within the context of the Church's teachings and traditions. Private revelations may be recognized but are not considered part of the deposit of faith and are not obligatory for all believers.

    Comparison:

    The LDS Church places a strong emphasis on the individual's ability to receive direct, personal revelation from God, viewing it as a continuous and essential aspect of spiritual life. This belief underscores the idea that God continues to reveal His will to individuals beyond the canonized scriptures.

    In contrast, the Catholic Church emphasizes the role of the Holy Spirit in guiding the Church collectively through established teachings, traditions, and the magisterium. Personal experiences of the Holy Spirit are valued but are typically understood within the framework of the Church's doctrines and are not seen as adding to the public revelation that concluded with the apostles.

    In summary, while both traditions recognize the importance of divine guidance through the Holy Spirit, the LDS Church encourages and expects ongoing personal revelation for individuals, whereas the Catholic Church emphasizes the Holy Spirit's role in guiding the Church as a whole, with personal inspirations understood within the context of established Church teachings.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.