Do Catholics accept that more scripture can be given?
- User
Do Catholics accept that more scripture can be given?
Assistant
No, the Catholic Church teaches that public revelation, which is the revelation necessary for salvation and intended for all humanity, ceased with the death of the last Apostle (traditionally St. John).
Here's a breakdown of the Catholic understanding:
- Fullness of Revelation in Christ: Catholics believe that Jesus Christ is the definitive and complete self-revelation of God. He is the Word made flesh, and everything necessary for salvation was revealed in and through Him.
- Deposit of Faith: This complete revelation, entrusted by Christ to the Apostles, is called the "deposit of faith." It consists of Sacred Scripture (the Bible) and Sacred Tradition.
- Closed Canon: The Church teaches that the canon of Sacred Scripture (the list of books recognized as divinely inspired and belonging in the Bible) is closed. No new books can be added to the Bible.
- Role of the Church: The Church, guided by the Holy Spirit through its Magisterium (the teaching authority of the Pope and bishops in communion with him), does not receive new public revelation. Its role is to faithfully guard, interpret, and transmit the deposit of faith already received.
- Development of Doctrine: While no new public revelation is expected, the Church's understanding of the existing revelation can deepen and develop over time, guided by the Holy Spirit. This is not adding new scripture or revelation but unfolding the meaning already present.
- Private Revelation: The Church does acknowledge the possibility of private revelations (like apparitions or messages given to individuals, e.g., Lourdes, Fatima). However, these are fundamentally different:
- They are not binding on all the faithful (though the Church may approve some as "worthy of belief").
- They do not add to or change the deposit of faith.
- Their purpose is generally understood as helping people live out the existing public revelation more fully in a particular time or place.
In summary, according to Catholic teaching as articulated in documents like Vatican II's Dei Verbum (Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation) and the Catechism of the Catholic Church (especially CCC 66-67), public revelation is complete and closed. Therefore, Catholics do not expect or accept any new scripture to be given.
- User
Didn't they continue to fill the vacancy of apoatles like they did in Acts?
Assistant
That's an excellent question that points to a key distinction in Catholic understanding between the unique role of the original Twelve Apostles (and Matthias who replaced Judas) and the ongoing office of their successors, the bishops.
Here's the explanation:
-
The Unique Role of the Twelve:
- The Twelve Apostles held a unique, foundational position. They were eyewitnesses to Jesus's life, death, and resurrection.
- They were directly commissioned by Christ to be the foundations of the Church (Ephesians 2:20, Revelation 21:14).
- They were the primary recipients and transmitters of the deposit of faith – the public revelation given by Christ.
- The selection of Matthias in Acts 1 was specifically to restore the number Twelve, representing the twelve tribes of Israel, signifying the foundation of the new People of God before the descent of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost. The requirement was that he had been with Jesus from the beginning and was a witness to the Resurrection (Acts 1:21-22).
-
Cessation of Public Revelation: As mentioned before, Catholics believe public revelation ceased with the death of the last Apostle (St. John). The unique role of the Apostles as the original recipients of this revelation ended with them. There were no more eyewitnesses to the Resurrection in the same way.
-
Apostolic Succession:
- While the unique foundational role of the original Apostles ended, their office or ministry of teaching, governing, and sanctifying the Church needed to continue.
- The Apostles appointed successors (bishops) by the laying on of hands (ordination), passing on their authority and mission (e.g., Titus 1:5, 1 Timothy 4:14, 2 Timothy 1:6). This is known as Apostolic Succession.
- Bishops are the successors to the Apostles, but they do not hold the same unique role as the original Twelve. They are not eyewitnesses in the same sense, nor do they receive new public revelation.
- Their role is to guard, preserve, interpret, and faithfully transmit the deposit of faith received from the Apostles, guided by the Holy Spirit.
In summary:
- The replacement of Judas with Matthias was a specific act to complete the foundational group of Twelve eyewitnesses before Pentecost.
- Once the foundation was laid and the Apostles began their work, the need shifted from replacing eyewitnesses (which became impossible after their generation) to ensuring the continuation of their teaching and governing office.
- This continuation happens through Apostolic Succession, where bishops succeed the Apostles in their office, but not in their unique role as the original recipients of public revelation.
Therefore, the Church didn't continue filling vacancies in the original Twelve because that foundational role was unique and tied to being eyewitnesses. Instead, it established a system of succession (bishops) to carry on the ministry entrusted to the Apostles. This is why there is an ongoing line of bishops, but no expectation of new Apostles who could add to Scripture.
-
- User
How does this compare with the LDS understanding of apostasy and how a closed canon is evidence of it
Assistant
Okay, let's compare the Catholic understanding with the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) regarding apostles, revelation, and the canon, specifically addressing how the LDS view uses the concept of a closed canon as evidence for apostasy.
Catholic Perspective (Summary):
- Apostles: The original Twelve (plus Matthias) had a unique, foundational, eyewitness role. Public revelation necessary for salvation ceased with the death of the last original Apostle.
- Succession: The office and authority of the Apostles (teaching, governing, sanctifying) continue through bishops via Apostolic Succession.
- Revelation: Public revelation is closed. The Church's role is to guard, interpret, and deepen understanding of the existing deposit of faith (Scripture and Tradition).
- Canon: The biblical canon is closed, reflecting the completion of public revelation in the apostolic age.
- Continuity: The Church believes it has maintained essential continuity with the Church founded by Christ, guided by the Holy Spirit, despite historical challenges.
LDS Perspective (Summary):
- Apostles: Apostles (and Prophets) are essential for the true Church, receiving ongoing revelation from God to guide it. They hold priesthood keys (authority).
- Apostasy: The LDS Church teaches that after the death of the original Apostles, a "Great Apostasy" occurred. Priesthood authority was lost from the earth, doctrines were corrupted, and the direct line of revelation through living Apostles ceased.
- Restoration: Through the Prophet Joseph Smith, God restored the fullness of the Gospel, including priesthood authority and the offices of Apostle and Prophet. The LDS Church sees itself as this restored Church.
- Revelation: Revelation is ongoing. God continues to speak to His children through living Prophets and Apostles who lead the Church today.
- Canon: The canon of scripture is open. Because revelation continues, new scripture can be given. The Book of Mormon, Doctrine and Covenants, and Pearl of Great Price are considered scripture alongside the Bible (which they believe is God's word "as far as it is translated correctly" and acknowledge may be incomplete).
How the LDS View Uses a Closed Canon as Evidence of Apostasy:
From the LDS perspective, the very idea embraced by Catholicism (and most of traditional Christianity) that public revelation stopped and the canon of scripture is closed serves as strong evidence for the Great Apostasy:
- God is Unchanging: LDS doctrine emphasizes that God is the same yesterday, today, and forever (Hebrews 13:8; 1 Nephi 10:18). If He guided His Church through Apostles and Prophets giving revelation in the past, why would He suddenly stop?
- Need for Living Guidance: They believe humanity always needs living prophets and apostles to receive God's specific guidance for the challenges of their time, interpret scripture correctly, and administer priesthood ordinances with authority.
- Cessation Implies Loss: The belief that revelation ceased is interpreted not as a sign of completion (as in the Catholic view) but as a sign that the authorized channel for that revelation (living Apostles and Prophets recognized by God) was lost from the earth. If the true, authorized leadership structure had remained intact, revelation would have continued.
- Inconsistency with Biblical Pattern: They point to the Old Testament pattern of God continually calling prophets. To believe God would establish His ultimate Church through Christ and then leave it without direct prophetic leadership seems inconsistent with His previous dealings.
- Scriptural Interpretation: Passages like Amos 3:7 ("Surely the Lord God will do nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets") are seen as enduring principles, not limited to a specific era.
In essence: For Latter-day Saints, the Catholic (and broader traditional Christian) assertion of a closed canon and the end of apostolic revelation isn't seen as the intended design, but rather as an acknowledgment (from the LDS viewpoint) that the vital connection of ongoing, authoritative revelation through living Apostles was broken – a key characteristic of the Great Apostasy they believe necessitated the Restoration.
- User
How does the LDS interpretafion of personal revelation comlare to how Catholics understand the Holy Spirit?
Assistant
Okay, let's compare the LDS understanding of personal revelation with the Catholic understanding of the Holy Spirit's work in the life of a believer. There are both similarities and significant differences, particularly concerning authority and the relationship to established doctrine.
LDS Understanding of Personal Revelation:
- Source: The Holy Ghost (understood in LDS theology as a distinct personage of spirit, part of the Godhead alongside God the Father and Jesus Christ) communicates directly with individuals.
- Purpose: To provide personal guidance, comfort, warnings, and knowledge; to help individuals make decisions in their lives (family, work, church callings); crucially, to provide a personal witness ("testimony") of the truthfulness of the Gospel, the Book of Mormon, Joseph Smith's prophetic calling, and the living prophets and apostles.
- Recipient: Every worthy member of the Church is encouraged to seek and is believed capable of receiving personal revelation for themselves and their area of responsibility (stewardship).
- Scope/Limits: Personal revelation is primarily for the individual's own guidance and for those within their specific stewardship (e.g., a parent for their family, a bishop for his congregation). It cannot contradict established Church doctrine, scriptures, or the teachings of the living prophets and apostles. Revelation for the entire Church comes only through the President of the Church (the Prophet).
- How it's Received: Often described through feelings (peace, warmth, "burning in the bosom" - referencing D&C 9:8), thoughts, impressions, clarity of mind, and sometimes through dreams or visions. Prayer, scripture study, fasting, and righteous living are seen as ways to foster receptivity.
- Emphasis: There is a strong emphasis on actively seeking and relying upon personal revelation as a vital, ongoing part of spiritual life and decision-making. Gaining a personal testimony through revelation is foundational.
Catholic Understanding of the Holy Spirit's Work:
- Source: The Holy Spirit (understood as the Third Person of the Blessed Trinity, fully God, co-equal with the Father and the Son) dwells within the baptized believer.
- Purpose:
- Sanctification: The primary work is to make the person holy, conforming them to Christ.
- Grace: The Spirit infuses grace, particularly through the Sacraments (Baptism, Confirmation, Eucharist, etc.).
- Gifts & Fruits: The Spirit bestows the seven Gifts (Wisdom, Understanding, Counsel, Fortitude, Knowledge, Piety, Fear of the Lord) to help live a virtuous life, and produces the Fruits (Love, Joy, Peace, Patience, etc.) as evidence of His presence.
- Guidance & Discernment: The Holy Spirit does guide individuals, illuminating their minds and moving their hearts to understand God's will, make good choices, understand Scripture and Tradition, and prompting them towards good actions. This often works through reason enlightened by faith, conscience formation, prayerful reflection, and spiritual direction.
- Confirmation of Faith: The Spirit gives an inner witness that confirms the truth of the faith received through the Church.
- Charisms: Special gifts given for the building up of the Church (teaching, administration, healing, etc.).
- Recipient: All the baptized faithful receive the indwelling of the Holy Spirit and His grace.
- Scope/Limits: Personal guidance and inspiration from the Holy Spirit will always be in harmony with the objective deposit of faith (Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition) as interpreted by the Church's Magisterium (teaching authority). It does not provide new public revelation or doctrine. Personal insights are subordinate to the Church's authoritative teaching. While private revelations can occur, they are not normative and must be discerned carefully by the Church.
- How it's Received: Through prayer, the Sacraments, reading Scripture, the teachings of the Church, the formation of conscience, reflection on life circumstances, the counsel of others (spiritual direction), and inner peace or conviction that aligns with faith and reason.
- Emphasis: Emphasis is placed on cooperating with the grace already given by the Holy Spirit, particularly through the Sacraments and living according to the Church's teachings. Personal discernment is important but is always situated within the objective framework of the Church's faith.
Comparison Highlights:
- Ongoing Revelation: LDS belief strongly emphasizes ongoing new communication and guidance from God via the Holy Ghost as a normative experience. Catholics believe the Spirit guides in understanding and living the already completed public revelation.
- Authority: In LDS thought, personal revelation confirms the authority of living prophets, but operates under it. In Catholicism, the Holy Spirit guides both the individual and the Magisterium, but individual guidance is tested against the objective, Spirit-guaranteed teachings of the Church.
- Testimony vs. Faith: The LDS concept of gaining a "testimony" often relies heavily on a specific spiritual feeling confirming LDS truth claims. Catholic faith involves the Spirit's internal witness but is also understood as a rational assent to truths revealed by God and proposed by the Church, supported by signs (miracles, prophecy, the Church's life).
- Source Nature: While both speak of divine guidance, the underlying theology differs (Godhead vs. Trinity).
- Normativity: Actively seeking specific, directive personal revelations is arguably more central and emphasized in day-to-day LDS practice than the equivalent pursuit might be for the average Catholic, who might focus more on receiving grace through sacraments and living according to established moral/doctrinal teachings, trusting the Spirit works through those means.
Both traditions believe in God's personal care and guidance for individuals through His Spirit, but they understand the nature, scope, authority, and relationship of that guidance to the broader Church and its foundational revelation quite differently.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.