Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Explain in a satirical manner the whole saga of the film “New Order”, its creator and…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding’s answer.
  1. User

    Explain in a satirical manner the whole saga of the film “New Order”, its creator and whatever happened to him.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Ah, the saga of New Order! Gather 'round, ye lovers of cinematic subtlety and nuanced social commentary, for a tale of art, outrage, and the enduring mystery of what exactly the director was thinking.

    Our story begins with Michel Franco, a Mexican filmmaker renowned for his light, breezy films that leave audiences feeling warm and fuzzy... said no one, ever[1][2]. Franco, a purveyor of bleak, often brutal cinematic experiences[3][2][4], decided in 2020 to grace the world with New Order (or Nuevo Orden, for the cultured)[5].

    The Masterpiece Itself: Imagine, if you will, a lovely, lavish wedding for Mexico's upper crust – the beautiful people, the champagne flowing, the canapés circulating. Suddenly, this delightful scene is rudely interrupted by... well, a violent uprising of the less-privileged masses, depicted, shall we say, with rather distinct visual cues involving skin tone[5][6][7]. What follows is not exactly a Gil Scott-Heron number; instead, the revolution quickly devolves into chaos exploited by the military to establish a delightful dictatorship complete with kidnappings, torture, and executions[5][6][8]. Think Parasite meets The Purge, but hold the laughs and maybe the coherent social analysis[5][8]. It's a dystopian vision, an "exaggeration of the present," a "provocative indictment," and positively "rotten to the core" – depending on which critic you ask[5][6][8]. Franco himself, a multi-hyphenate who wrote, directed, produced, and edited this cheerful romp, clearly poured his heart and soul into depicting humanity mired in violence and hatred[5][3].

    The International Applause (and the Home-Turf Howls): Internationally? Applause! The film premiered at the prestigious Venice Film Festival and walked away with the Silver Lion Grand Jury Prize[5][10][11]. Cate Blanchett's jury clearly saw the art[3][11]. But back home? Ay, dios mío! When the trailer hit Mexican social media, the reception wasn't quite so glowing[5][13]. Accusations flew faster than stray bullets in the film itself: "Classist!", "Racist!", "Painfully stereotypical!"[5][14][13]. Critics pointed out the rather unfortunate trope of darker-skinned poor people violently attacking lighter-skinned rich people[5][6][15].

    The Auteur's Insightful Rebuttal: Now, lesser artists might have paused for reflection. But Michel Franco? He bravely stepped forward to explain that the real problem wasn't his film, but... "profound reverse racism"[5][13][16]! Yes, Franco, a white Mexican, declared himself a victim of hate crimes for the criticism levelled against his film's portrayal of racial and class dynamics[5][13]. He later issued an apology, stating he wasn't aware of the impact his words would have, a classic "sorry you were offended" maneuver[5][13][16]. He also felt the film was topical, especially with things like the Black Lives Matter protests happening, demonstrating his keen finger on the pulse of... something[3].

    The Aftermath (Or Lack Thereof): So, what happened to our intrepid auteur after this firestorm? Was he cancelled? Forced into cinematic exile? Did he have to trade his director's chair for a life of quiet contemplation?

    Not exactly.

    Despite the furious backlash in Mexico[5][14][13], the film did get released there and apparently sold half a million tickets, proving perhaps that controversy is the best marketing[9]. It secured distribution in the US and UK[5][15]. And Franco? He seems to have weathered the storm quite nicely, thank you very much. He found the controversy rather "flattering," noting that all the filmmakers he admired also suffered from it[9][17].

    Since the New Order kerfuffle, Franco has continued his prolific career, directing Sundown (again with Tim Roth, his collaborator from Chronic) and Memory (starring heavyweights Jessica Chastain and Peter Sarsgaard)[18][19][20]. Memory even premiered at Venice, where Sarsgaard won Best Actor[19][21]. Franco remains an award-winning fixture on the international festival circuit, apparently unfazed and still making films reflecting "where I am in life at that point"[19][20][21].

    So, the "saga" concludes not with a bang, nor a whimper, but with the director making more movies, collecting more accolades, and perhaps occasionally glancing out the window, pondering the next "necessary" cinematic provocation[14][19][17]. The New Order may have faded, but the Franco brand of feel-bad cinema marches ever onward.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.