Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Explain in a satirical manner the whole saga of the film “New Order”, its creator and…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding’s answer.
  1. User

    Explain in a satirical manner the whole saga of the film “New Order”, its creator and whatever happened to him.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, buckle up, buttercup, because the saga of Michel Franco's "New Order" (or Nuevo Orden if you're feeling spicy) is a masterclass in how not to win friends and influence people, particularly in your own country.

    Imagine, if you will, a visionary filmmaker, Señor Franco, fresh off critical acclaim, deciding Mexico needed a cinematic wake-up call. What kind of call? Oh, just a gentle nudge depicting a high-society wedding descending into a hellscape of class warfare, brutal military crackdowns, summary executions, and vibrant green paint used for rather unfortunate purposes. Think "Parasite" meets "The Purge," but with less coherent social commentary and significantly more bleakness. Subtlety, clearly, was not invited to this particular artistic fiesta.

    The film premiered at the prestigious Venice Film Festival in 2020 and – surprise! – snagged the Silver Lion Grand Jury Prize. International critics were divided but intrigued; it was provocative, daring, visually arresting! Surely, this was the work of a bold auteur holding up a mirror to society's darkest potential, a necessary, if unpleasant, medicine.

    Then, the film prepared for its Mexican debut. And that's when the metaphorical piñata, stuffed not with candy but with accusations of classism, racism, and colorism, was violently whacked open. Critics and audiences back home pointed out that the film seemed to portray the impoverished masses largely as a violent, undifferentiated mob, while the victims – the wealthy, predominantly lighter-skinned elite – were given slightly more, shall we say, characterisation before meeting gruesome ends. The optics, as they say, were less than ideal. It was accused of reinforcing harmful stereotypes and presenting a scenario where the marginalized uprising was depicted with such crude brutality that it almost seemed to justify the ensuing authoritarian nightmare. Nuance checked out early.

    Now, enter our auteur, Michel Franco, stage left, armed with a foot to insert firmly into his mouth. When confronted with the criticisms, particularly the term "whitexican" (a pejorative for privileged, often lighter-skinned Mexicans perceived as out of touch), Franco lamented that calling out "whitexicans" was, in itself, deeply racist. This, to put it mildly, did not calm the waters. It was akin to dousing a grease fire with a bucket of premium gasoline. The backlash intensified, accusing him of profound tone-deafness and dismissing legitimate concerns about representation and social dynamics in his film. He defended his film as a dystopia, a warning, not a literal depiction, but the damage was done. The film became a symbol of artistic privilege clashing with social reality.

    So, "whatever happened to him?" Was he tarred, feathered, and forced to direct telenovelas for eternity? Not quite. Despite the furore in Mexico, Franco's international career, cushioned by festival laurels and a certain arthouse cachet, trundled onwards. He didn't vanish into the ether of the "cancelled." In fact, he followed up "New Order" relatively quickly with films like "Sundown" (2021) starring Tim Roth and Charlotte Gainsbourg, and "Memory" (2023) starring Jessica Chastain and Peter Sarsgaard. These films, while perhaps less overtly incendiary, continued his exploration of bleak themes and uncomfortable character studies.

    Essentially, the "New Order" saga became a fascinating, if cringeworthy, case study: a critically lauded (abroad) film sparks outrage (at home) for its perceived problematic depictions, the director fumbles the response spectacularly, yet ultimately continues his career making challenging, often grim, cinema. He remains a respected, if controversial, figure in international film circles, proving that sometimes, even a cinematic Molotov cocktail, clumsily thrown, can still get you invited to the next festival. The "warning" landed, just maybe not in the way he intended.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.