I want to buy an Autopilot panel like the "miniFCU" but it's out of stock. So now i'm…
- User
I want to buy an Autopilot panel like the "miniFCU" but it's out of stock. So now i'm looking at alternatives. All i need are 4 rotary encoders, something like a streamdeck could also work. But here comes the catch, i don't want something with potentiometers that get unreliable and fail after a very short time. I'm looking for something that has 4 optical rotary encoders. OPTICAL is the keyword here, this is of the utmost important, either optical encoders or hall effect encoders. Do you know of anything like that?
Assistant
Okay, I understand. You're looking for an alternative to the miniFCU or similar autopilot panels, specifically one that uses optical or Hall effect rotary encoders (not potentiometers) for increased reliability. You need at least 4 rotary encoders, and a Stream Deck-like device could also be a possibility. Let me search for options that meet these criteria.
Okay, after searching, here's what I've found regarding autopilot panels or similar devices with optical or Hall effect rotary encoders:
1. DIY Options & Components:
- Arduino-based Projects: Many flight sim enthusiasts create their own autopilot panels using Arduino boards and rotary encoders[1]. You'll need some electronics knowledge, but it allows for full customization. Search results mention using Arduino Pro Micro, MCP23017 I2C Port expander, and rotary encoders. Mobiflight is a software often used in these DIY projects.
- Rotary Encoders from Reputable Suppliers:
- Megatron offers optical and Hall effect rotary encoders. They highlight the benefits of optical encoders (high resolution, speed, long lifetime, resistance to magnetic fields)[1]. They also offer Hall effect encoders.
- Leo Bodnar Electronics: A known supplier for sim racing and flight sim components. They offer rotary encoders, some pre-wired for easy connection to their interface boards[2][3]. Note: Their website doesn't explicitly state optical or Hall effect, so you'd need to confirm the encoder type.
- CUI Devices: Offers optical rotary encoders designed for panel mounting[4]. Check out the RE25 series.
- P3 America: Specializes in Hall effect rotary encoders with analog output[5]. These are used in various industrial applications[5][6].
2. Complete or Semi-Complete Solutions:
- BBJ SimRacing Button Box: While primarily for sim racing, these button boxes often include rotary encoders. You'd need to confirm the type of encoder they use (likely standard mechanical encoders, but it's worth checking)[1].
- Flight Velocity and Siminnovations Knobster: These are dual-encoder devices designed for flight simulation. User reviews suggest these work well, but again, verify the encoder type to ensure it meets your "optical or Hall effect" requirement.
- Open-AutopilotPanel (GitHub): This is a 3D-printable autopilot panel design for Microsoft Flight Simulator that uses rotary encoders.
3[7][8]. Stream Deck Alternatives:
- While the Stream Deck itself doesn't use rotary encoders with optical or Hall effect sensors, the Stream Deck + does have four rotary encoders. It is important to verify what type of encoder they use, as they might use potentiometers.
- Some users combine a standard Stream Deck XL with a Stream Deck + to get the button grid of the XL and the rotary encoders of the +.
- DIY Stream Deck: There are DIY Stream Deck projects using Arduino and custom PCBs[1]. These could potentially be adapted to use optical/Hall effect encoders.
Key Considerations & Recommendations:
- Encoder Type is Crucial: Carefully check the specifications of any rotary encoder before purchasing to confirm it uses optical or Hall effect sensing. Many readily available encoders use potentiometers or mechanical contacts.
- DIY vs. Pre-built: A DIY approach offers the most flexibility in choosing specific components (like the exact encoder type), but requires more technical skill. Pre-built solutions are easier to integrate but may have limited customization options.
- Software Compatibility: Ensure that any panel or device you choose is compatible with your flight simulation software (e.g., Microsoft Flight Simulator, X-Plane) and, if necessary, supports customization software like SPAD.next or Air Manager.
- "Dual Rotary Controllers": A few search results mention dual rotary controllers (inner and outer knobs). These are found in some aircraft and can be useful for certain cockpit functions[8][9]. The Octavi is one example, but availability and encoder type should be checked[1].
I recommend starting by researching the specific rotary encoders offered by Megatron, CUI Devices and P3 America. Then, if you're comfortable with a DIY project, explore the Arduino-based autopilot panel designs. If you prefer a pre-built solution, contact the manufacturers of the BBJ SimRacing button box, Flight Velocity Dual Encoder, and Siminnovations Knobster to confirm the encoder types they use. Good luck!
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.