Skip to content
The Chat Archive
sonar-reasoning LMArena Search Arena 24K

I want to buy an Autopilot panel like the "miniFCU" but it's out of stock. So now i'm…

  1. User

    I want to buy an Autopilot panel like the "miniFCU" but it's out of stock. So now i'm looking at alternatives. All i need are 4 rotary encoders, something like a streamdeck could also work. But here comes the catch, i don't want something with potentiometers that get unreliable and fail after a very short time. I'm looking for something that has 4 optical rotary encoders. OPTICAL is the keyword here, this is of the utmost important, either optical encoders or hall effect encoders. Do you know of anything like that?

  2. Assistant

    For a reliable autopilot panel alternative with optical or Hall effect rotary encoders, here are the best options based on durability, resolution, and integration potential:


    1. Optical Encoder Solutions

    • C14D16N-B3 Optical Encoder (Samesky Devices[7])

      • Compact 16 PPR optical encoder with quadrature output.
      • Rugged metal construction, IP65-rated options, and 1 million-cycle lifespan.
      • Ideal for DIY panels: combine four units with a microcontroller (e.g., Arduino) for custom control.
      • Cost: ~20–20–30 per encoder.
    • DIY Optical Encoder Setup (Hackaday.io Project[5])

      • Use optical interrupters (LEDs + phototransistors) for high-resolution, detent-free sensing.
      • Example: AMS AS5047D magnetic encoder (14-bit resolution, ~10–10–15 per unit) paired with a rotating magnet[5].

    2. Hall Effect/Magnetic Encoders

    • AMT-102 Magnetic Encoder (Digi-Key)

      • Low-cost (~$25) magnetic encoder with analog or digital output.
      • Used in DIY digital setting circles (DSC) and motor control[4].
      • Compatible with Arduino for custom integration.
    • Bourns 6630 Series (Mouser)

      • High-end magnetic encoder with smooth rotation and no detents.
      • Resolution: 24 pulses/revolution, but priced at ~15–15–20 per unit[2].

    3. Pre-Built Alternatives

    • Loupedeck Live/Razer Stream Controller

      • While not optical, its tactile buttons and dials use Hall effect sensors for durability.
      • Supports custom macros and integrates with flight sim software[8].
      • Price: ~$260 (more versatile but pricier than Stream Deck).
    • AMS AS5601 Magnetic Encoder

      • 12-bit resolution, I²C/SPI output, and easy PCB integration.
      • Requires a 3D-printed knob and magnet alignment[2][5].

    Key Considerations

    • Optical vs. Hall Effect: Optical encoders (e.g., C14D16N-B3) offer higher resolution but may require dust protection. Hall effect encoders (e.g., AMT-102) are more resilient to debris.
    • DIY Integration: Pair encoders with an Arduino Nano or Raspberry Pi Pico for USB HID emulation. Use libraries like Encoder.h for quadrature decoding[1][5].
    • Cost: Building a 4-encoder panel with C14D16N-B3 units would cost ~80–80–120 + microcontroller. Pre-built solutions like Loupedeck are costlier but plug-and-play.

    For a streamlined setup, the C14D16N-B3 optical encoders or AMT-102 magnetic encoders provide the best balance of reliability and customization.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.