I want to buy an Autopilot panel like the "miniFCU" but it's out of stock. So now i'm…
- User
I want to buy an Autopilot panel like the "miniFCU" but it's out of stock. So now i'm looking at alternatives. All i need are 4 rotary encoders, something like a streamdeck could also work. But here comes the catch, i don't want something with potentiometers that get unreliable and fail after a very short time. I'm looking for something that has 4 optical rotary encoders. OPTICAL is the keyword here, this is of the utmost important, either optical encoders or hall effect encoders. Do you know of anything like that?
- Assistant
For a reliable autopilot panel alternative with optical or Hall effect rotary encoders, here are the best options based on durability, resolution, and integration potential:
1. Optical Encoder Solutions
-
C14D16N-B3 Optical Encoder (Samesky Devices[7])
- Compact 16 PPR optical encoder with quadrature output.
- Rugged metal construction, IP65-rated options, and 1 million-cycle lifespan.
- Ideal for DIY panels: combine four units with a microcontroller (e.g., Arduino) for custom control.
- Cost: ~30 per encoder.
-
DIY Optical Encoder Setup (Hackaday.io Project[5])
- Use optical interrupters (LEDs + phototransistors) for high-resolution, detent-free sensing.
- Example: AMS AS5047D magnetic encoder (14-bit resolution, ~15 per unit) paired with a rotating magnet[5].
2. Hall Effect/Magnetic Encoders
-
AMT-102 Magnetic Encoder (Digi-Key)
- Low-cost (~$25) magnetic encoder with analog or digital output.
- Used in DIY digital setting circles (DSC) and motor control[4].
- Compatible with Arduino for custom integration.
-
Bourns 6630 Series (Mouser)
- High-end magnetic encoder with smooth rotation and no detents.
- Resolution: 24 pulses/revolution, but priced at ~20 per unit[2].
3. Pre-Built Alternatives
-
Loupedeck Live/Razer Stream Controller
- While not optical, its tactile buttons and dials use Hall effect sensors for durability.
- Supports custom macros and integrates with flight sim software[8].
- Price: ~$260 (more versatile but pricier than Stream Deck).
-
AMS AS5601 Magnetic Encoder
- 12-bit resolution, I²C/SPI output, and easy PCB integration.
- Requires a 3D-printed knob and magnet alignment[2][5].
Key Considerations
- Optical vs. Hall Effect: Optical encoders (e.g., C14D16N-B3) offer higher resolution but may require dust protection. Hall effect encoders (e.g., AMT-102) are more resilient to debris.
- DIY Integration: Pair encoders with an Arduino Nano or Raspberry Pi Pico for USB HID emulation. Use libraries like
Encoder.hfor quadrature decoding[1][5]. - Cost: Building a 4-encoder panel with C14D16N-B3 units would cost ~120 + microcontroller. Pre-built solutions like Loupedeck are costlier but plug-and-play.
For a streamlined setup, the C14D16N-B3 optical encoders or AMT-102 magnetic encoders provide the best balance of reliability and customization.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.