Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

in another eden, when shigure (extra style) was released, altema.jp eventually gave him…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high’s answer.
  1. User

    in another eden, when shigure (extra style) was released, altema.jp eventually gave him a 98 with the highest 12 characters getting a 98, so i didn't pull. now all of a sudden, he's one of the most used allies in astral archive challenge mode top scores at 16 books. now i have to sidegrade shigure ns and use 3 starcharts on him. same with izuna: 98 score so i didn't pull, but she already was a part of 12 teams and serves a distinct purpose. however, elseal (another style) also has a 98 score but is only involved in 1 book with maybe 3 other books if anyone bothered to revisit them. i pull only for 99s and this new character for the 8th anniversary might be one. anyway, if an ally scores a 98, because future usage looks mixed, should i continue to wait for 99s?

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    The strategy of only pulling for characters rated 99 on Altema has some significant drawbacks, especially considering how the Astral Archive Challenge Mode has reshaped character value in Another Eden.

    Rating Systems vs. Actual Utility

    Altema's rating system (with scores like 98 or 99) primarily evaluates characters based on their raw power, damage output, and general utility. However, these ratings don't perfectly predict a character's value in specific content like Astral Archive Challenges[6]. The Challenge Mode uniquely values:

    1. Characters with multiple relevant personality traits that match book requirements
    2. Units that can function effectively within the 5-turn limit
    3. Characters that complement specific scoring mechanics (Act Bonus, Party Bonus)[6]

    Shigure ES is a perfect example of this disconnect. While his 98 rating suggested he was "almost top tier" but not essential, his actual utility skyrocketed because of his versatile personality traits and wind-focused kit that works exceptionally well in many Challenge books[6][7].

    The Personality Factor

    The Challenge Mode scoring system heavily rewards having characters with specific personality traits. Looking at the comprehensive list from search result #6, characters who appear in multiple personality categories (like Katana+Eastern or Wind+Fists) become disproportionately valuable[6].

    Shigure shows up in several key personality lists:

    • Katana personality
    • Eastern personality
    • And likely others that make him useful across 16 different books[6][7]

    Similarly, Izuna's multiple personality traits make her valuable across many books despite "only" having a 98 rating.

    Stellar Awakening Considerations

    The Stellar Awakening system has further complicated character evaluation. Getting a character to level 100 requires:

    • Three star charts specific to that character
    • 80 light/shadow points for full potential (though 30-35 is workable)[5]

    Since you mention needing to "sidegrade Shigure NS and use 3 starcharts," this is a significant investment. For gacha characters, getting these resources typically requires:

    1. Pulling the character's 5-star version from their featured banner
    2. Or combining All Cosmo Star Charts with character-specific charts[5]

    Strategic Recommendations

    Based on this analysis, I recommend:

    1. Look beyond the number rating: A character with a 98 but with valuable personality traits for Challenge Mode might be more useful than a 99 with limited personalities.

    2. Consider versatility: Characters like Shigure ES who fit into many team compositions (16 books!) provide more long-term value than niche 99-rated units.

    3. Review personality traits: Before skipping a banner, check if the character has valuable personality combinations for Challenge Mode content[6].

    4. Consider future content: The 8th anniversary character you mentioned might be rated 99, but evaluate their personality traits and how they'll fit into existing content.

    5. Pull strategically: For F2P or light spenders, focus on characters that serve multiple roles rather than chasing every 99.

    Conclusion

    The altema.jp rating system alone is an incomplete guide for pulling decisions. Shigure ES and Izuna demonstrate that a versatile 98 can often provide more practical value than a specialized 99, especially for Challenge Mode. Consider expanding your criteria beyond just the numerical rating to include personality traits, content compatibility, and team synergy.

    For the upcoming 8th anniversary character, evaluate not just their potential 99 rating, but also their personalities and how they'll complement your existing roster for various content types.

  3. User

    see, those books came out after shigure ES. also, Sesta AS (rated 99) came out less than a month later and Tsubame AC (identity of Nocturne Ninja; rated 99) came out 2 weeks later. admittedly, i didn't track astral archive scores until a few months ago, so i didn't realize shigure ES's dominance until much later. are you saying i should predict future personalities for future books and future characters? it's looking like the crystal element is getting a bump and maybe the thunder element.

  4. Perplexity Assistant

    You're right to notice the timing discrepancy - Shigure ES's true value didn't become apparent until more Astral Archive Challenge books were released after his banner. This pattern reveals a significant limitation in relying solely on Altema's 98/99 rating system for pull decisions.

    The Challenge Mode Personality Factor

    Astral Archive Challenge Mode has fundamentally changed how character value is assessed in Another Eden. The mode rewards having characters with specific personality traits that match book requirements, and characters who appear in multiple personality categories (like Katana+Eastern or Wind+Fists) become exponentially more valuable[1][6].

    Shigure ES is particularly valuable because he possesses multiple key personality traits:

    • Katana personality
    • Eastern personality
    • Wind personality
    • And likely others[1]

    This combination makes him useful across 16 different Challenge books, far more than many characters with higher raw power ratings[1][6].

    Prediction Challenges

    Predicting future book requirements is challenging but not impossible:

    1. Element pattern recognition: Your observation about Crystal and Thunder elements getting increased attention is astute. Looking at search result #1, several newer books include these element personalities, suggesting WFS is creating content to make these elements more relevant[1][8].

    2. Personality trait combinations: Characters with versatile personality combinations tend to maintain long-term value. For example, Izuna with both Thunder and Mask personalities appears in multiple books[1][8][9].

    3. Act Bonus generators: Characters who can generate high Act Bonus scores due to matching multiple required personalities (like Shanie Alter being both Wind and Cursed, generating 150 points in one book) will always be valuable[8].

    Strategic Recommendations

    Rather than strictly waiting for 99-rated characters, consider:

    1. Analyze personality versatility: Before skipping a 98-rated character, check their personality traits against existing books and consider how versatile they might be for future content[1][6].

    2. Balance current and future value: Characters like Sesta AS (99) offer immediate power, but characters with versatile personality combinations like Shigure ES may provide more long-term value across multiple content types[6][8][9].

    3. Consider element coverage: With Crystal and Thunder getting more attention, having strong characters in these elements will likely pay off. This may include:

      • Thunder: Izuna, Orleya, Skull, Victor[1][9]
      • Crystal: Melody, Miyu ES[1]
    4. Watch for multi-personality characters: When new characters are announced, pay special attention to those who fulfill multiple personality categories, as they're more likely to fit into future books[1][8].

    Looking Forward

    For the upcoming 8th anniversary character, beyond just looking at their potential 99 rating, analyze:

    • What personality traits they possess
    • How those traits complement existing book requirements
    • Whether they fill gaps in your roster's personality coverage

    While perfect prediction is impossible, expanding your evaluation criteria beyond Altema ratings to include personality versatility will lead to more strategic pulling decisions that better prepare you for future Astral Archive challenges.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.