in another eden, when shigure (extra style) was released, altema.jp eventually gave him…
- User
in another eden, when shigure (extra style) was released, altema.jp eventually gave him a 98 with the highest 12 characters getting a 98, so i didn't pull. now all of a sudden, he's one of the most used allies in astral archive challenge mode top scores at 16 books. now i have to sidegrade shigure ns and use 3 starcharts on him. same with izuna: 98 score so i didn't pull, but she already was a part of 12 teams and serves a distinct purpose. however, elseal (another style) also has a 98 score but is only involved in 1 book with maybe 3 other books if anyone bothered to revisit them. i pull only for 99s and this new character for the 8th anniversary might be one. anyway, if an ally scores a 98, because future usage looks mixed, should i continue to wait for 99s?
Assistant
The dilemma you're facing highlights an important aspect of character evaluation in Another Eden: numerical ratings don't always reflect a character's practical utility across different game modes.
Rating Systems vs. Practical Utility
Shigure (Extra Style) provides an excellent case study of this disconnect. While altema.jp gave him a 98 rating (placing him among the top tier but not at the absolute peak), his practical value significantly increased with the introduction of the Astral Archive Challenge Mode. This is because:
-
Shigure ES excels as a counter-dodge-debuffer-cover tank, particularly effective against physical and slash attacks[10]
-
He wields a Katana, which is a weapon type that receives bonuses in multiple Challenge Mode books[6]
-
His personality traits likely align with many book requirements, making him valuable for maximizing Act Bonus and Party Bonus scores in numerous challenges
Similar situation occurred with Izuna - her 98 rating didn't reflect how valuable she would become for Challenge Mode teams due to her specific combination of personalities and utility.
Understanding the Challenge Mode Mechanics
The Astral Archive Challenge Mode places enormous emphasis on specific character traits:
-
Score calculations depend on Damage Score multiplied by (Act Bonus + AF Bonus + Party Bonus + Default Bonus)[6]
-
Act Bonus activates when characters with specific personalities perform actions[6]
-
Party Bonus (+1000) is awarded when each party member fulfills at least one personality bonus condition[6]
-
Challenge Mode score thresholds are extremely high - you need around 164,414,000 points for the highest rewards on some challenges[9]
Characters who can help meet these specific personality/weapon requirements while dealing substantial damage become disproportionately valuable.
Pull Strategy Considerations
Rather than rigidly adhering to the 99-only approach, consider:
-
Meta Anticipation: Elseal AS may have the same 98 rating as Shigure ES, but her specific combination of traits makes her less versatile for current endgame content.
-
Team Composition: Look beyond individual ratings to consider how a character complements your existing roster and fills specific roles.
-
Content Coverage: Characters with versatile personality traits and weapon types can cover more content requirements, even if they're not rated 99.
-
Opportunity Cost: Waiting for 99s means potentially missing characters who become meta-defining despite their slightly lower rating.
Recommendation
While focusing on 99-rated characters has merit, the evidence suggests supplementing this approach with strategic pulls for high-rated characters (98s) that have:
- Versatile personality combinations that align with multiple Astral Archive books
- Weapon types that receive bonuses in numerous challenges
- Unique utilities that aren't easily replaceable
For the upcoming 8th anniversary character, assess not just their overall rating but their specific traits and how they might perform in current endgame content like Challenge Mode. The practical utility across multiple content types may ultimately be more valuable than a single point difference in an overall rating system.
-
- User
see, those books came out after shigure ES. also, Sesta AS (rated 99) came out less than a month later and Tsubame AC (identity of Nocturne Ninja; rated 99) came out 2 weeks later. admittedly, i didn't track astral archive scores until a few months ago, so i didn't realize shigure ES's dominance until much later. are you saying i should predict future personalities for future books and future characters? it's looking like the crystal element is getting a bump and maybe the thunder element.
Assistant
You're highlighting a key insight about gacha games like Another Eden - the meta evolves based on new content releases, not just on initial character ratings. Let me address your observations:
Content-Character Timing Relationship
Yes, the Astral Archive Challenge Mode books were released after Shigure ES became available, which is precisely why his initial 98 rating didn't accurately reflect his eventual value. This happens frequently in gacha games - characters are rated based on current content, but their true value emerges when new content specifically rewards their traits.
When Shigure ES was rated, altema.jp couldn't account for future content that would make his specific combination of personalities and weapon type (Katana) particularly valuable across multiple Challenge Mode books[3]. The Book of Twin Ogres, for example, specifically rewards Katana users, and Shigure ES fulfills multiple personality conditions there (Katana, Cat lover)[3].
Personality Traits vs. Numerical Ratings
The Astral Archive Challenge Mode scoring formula puts enormous emphasis on personality traits:
Score = (Damage Score × (Act Bonus + AF Bonus + Party Bonus))/100000[3]
With Party Bonus providing +1000 points when each party member fulfills at least one required personality trait, and specific Act Bonuses when characters with matching personalities perform actions, certain character combinations become dramatically more valuable regardless of their overall rating[3].
Predicting Future Meta
Rather than strictly predicting specific personalities for future books, consider:
-
Versatility Premium: Characters with multiple personalities (like Shigure ES with Katana and Cat lover) are inherently more valuable for future content as they can fulfill multiple conditions simultaneously[3].
-
Weapon Type Consideration: Katana users like Shigure ES appear in multiple books' optimal team compositions - not just for their damage but for their contribution to the Party Bonus[3].
-
Element Diversity: You're right that Crystal and Thunder elements appear to be gaining prominence. Crystal Zone provides unique advantages, enhancing damage against enemies' weaknesses by 80%[5], while Thunder teams have received powerful new options like OA (who isn't in the current banner)[6].
Moving Beyond Rating-Only Pulls
When evaluating future characters, consider:
- How many different personalities they offer
- Whether they can fulfill multiple roles (damage, support, tank)
- Their weapon type's representation in current Challenge Mode books
- Whether they bring unique mechanics that might be valuable in future content
For example, Izuna's value came from her specific combination of personalities (including Mask and possibly other traits), making her valuable across multiple Challenge Mode books despite her 98 rating[3][4].
If you're concerned about pulling efficiency, consider targeting characters with diverse personality traits and flexible roles rather than rigidly adhering to 99-only pulls. This approach might help you build more versatile teams for both current and future content.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.