Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-pro-high· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Ya know Secret Histories Tails by Mashed's "What if" series?? SLAMS HANDS ON TABLE I…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4o-search-preview-high-loc’s answer.
  1. User

    Ya know Secret Histories Tails by Mashed's "What if" series?? SLAMS HANDS ON TABLE I LOVE HOW ABSOLUTELY UNHINGED HE IS LET'S SCREECH AND ANALYZE HOW CRAZY HE IS

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    The "Secret History of Sonic & Tails" by Mashed reimagines Tails as a deeply unhinged and obsessive character, transforming the lovable sidekick into a chilling sociopath. This version of Tails is driven by an unhealthy fixation on Sonic, believing himself to be Sonic's one true friend and protector. His descent into madness is marked by paranoia, manipulation, and violence, making him a standout figure in Mashed's What If series.

    Tails' Unhinged Obsession

    In this alternate narrative, Tails' obsession with Sonic manifests in extreme and horrifying ways. He views anyone who gets close to Sonic as an "impostor" and systematically eliminates them. For instance:

    • Knuckles' Death: Knuckles, after becoming close friends with Sonic, dies in a freak accident involving an exploding phone battery. This is later revealed to be Tails' doing[[1]][[2]][[7]].
    • Shadow's Demise: Similarly, Shadow's hover boots malfunction and explode, another act of sabotage by Tails to remove competition for Sonic's attention[[1]][[2]][[7]].

    Tails justifies these actions by claiming that these individuals were not true friends to Sonic, but rather threats to their bond. His delusion peaks when Sonic confronts him, and Tails declares that if Sonic doesn't reciprocate his friendship, then Sonic must not be the "real" Sonic. This leads to Tails attempting to kill Sonic himself[[1]][[7]].

    Psychological Breakdown

    Tails' transformation from a loyal sidekick to a deranged antagonist is rooted in his deep-seated insecurities and need for validation. His actions are not just violent but calculated, showcasing his genius intellect and ability to manipulate situations to his advantage. For example:

    • He uses Amy as bait to lure Sonic into a confrontation, further demonstrating his cunning nature[[2]][[7]].
    • His ability to cover up his crimes initially leaves others unable to prove his guilt, adding to the tension and horror of his character[[1]][[2]].

    Symbolism and Themes

    The story explores themes of obsession, identity, and the dark side of loyalty. Tails' actions are a twisted reflection of his desire to preserve his identity as Sonic's best friend. His breakdown highlights the dangers of unchecked obsession and the fragility of relationships built on possessiveness rather than mutual respect.

    Why Fans Love This Version

    Fans are drawn to this version of Tails because of how radically it subverts expectations. The contrast between the innocent, cheerful Tails from the original Sonic games and the deranged, manipulative Tails in the Secret Histories series is both shocking and fascinating. His unhinged behavior, combined with his tragic backstory and psychological complexity, makes him a compelling and memorable character[[4]][[6]][[7]].

    In conclusion, Secret Histories Tails is a masterclass in reimagining a beloved character in a dark and twisted light. His descent into madness, driven by obsession and paranoia, creates a chilling narrative that captivates and horrifies in equal measure.

  3. User

    Creative writing piece time! How would he have acted around Sonic in the first phase? Paint me a small, bullied two-tailed fox whose hero and only friend is a free spirit constantly trying to shake him off.

  4. Perplexity Assistant

    The first phase of Tails' relationship with Sonic in this reimagined narrative would be a poignant mix of admiration, desperation, and quiet heartbreak. Here's a creative depiction of how Tails might have acted during this time:


    The little fox sat alone on the edge of the island, his two tails curled around him like a shield against the world. The other animals had long since stopped teasing him—mostly because he had stopped trying to be around them. His twin tails, the source of his ridicule, now spun idly in the air as he stared out at the horizon. He had heard the stories of a blue blur, a hero who raced through the world like the wind itself. Tails didn’t just want to meet him—he needed to. Maybe someone like that would understand him.

    When Sonic finally arrived, streaking across the island like a comet, Tails’ heart leapt. He followed the hedgehog at a distance, his small legs pumping furiously to keep up. Sonic didn’t notice him at first, too caught up in his own whirlwind of adventure. But Tails didn’t mind. He was content just to watch, to learn, to dream of being part of something bigger than himself.

    But Sonic wasn’t the hero Tails had imagined—not at first. The hedgehog was impatient, always moving, always looking for the next thrill. When Tails finally mustered the courage to approach him, Sonic barely glanced his way. “Kid, you’re slowing me down,” he said with a grin, ruffling Tails’ fur before speeding off again. Tails stood frozen, his heart sinking. But he didn’t give up. He couldn’t.

    Day after day, Tails followed Sonic, enduring the hedgehog’s teasing and indifference. He tried to prove himself, using his mechanical skills to fix Sonic’s plane and even building gadgets to help him on his adventures. But no matter what he did, Sonic always seemed to keep him at arm’s length. “You’re a good kid,” Sonic would say, “but I work alone.”

    Tails didn’t see it as rejection. To him, every word from Sonic was a treasure, every fleeting moment together a gift. He started to believe that if he just tried harder, if he just became faster, smarter, better, Sonic would finally see him as more than a tagalong. He practiced flying with his tails until they ached, pushing himself to the brink of exhaustion. He built machines late into the night, his small hands stained with oil and his eyes heavy with fatigue.

    And yet, there were moments—brief, fleeting moments—when Sonic’s carefree facade would crack. When Tails managed to keep up with him, Sonic would glance back with a look of surprise, maybe even a hint of respect. “Not bad, kid,” he’d say, and Tails would beam, his chest swelling with pride. Those moments kept him going, fueling his determination to stay by Sonic’s side no matter what.

    But deep down, a seed of doubt began to grow. What if Sonic never truly accepted him? What if he was destined to always be the little fox trailing behind, never quite fast enough, never quite good enough? Tails buried those thoughts, focusing instead on the dream that one day, Sonic would see him as an equal. One day, they would be more than hero and sidekick. They would be friends.

    For now, though, Tails was content to follow, to watch, to wait. Because even if Sonic didn’t see it, Tails knew that he was meant to be by his side. And he would do whatever it took to prove it.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.