Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-pro· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Ya know Secret Histories Tails by Mashed's "What if" series?? SLAMS HANDS ON TABLE I…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4o-search-preview-high-loc’s answer.
  1. User

    Ya know Secret Histories Tails by Mashed's "What if" series?? SLAMS HANDS ON TABLE I LOVE HOW ABSOLUTELY UNHINGED HE IS LET'S SCREECH AND ANALYZE HOW CRAZY HE IS

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    The "Secret Histories" version of Tails, created by Mashed, is a dark and twisted reimagining of Sonic's lovable sidekick, Miles "Tails" Prower. This version of Tails is a far cry from the cheerful, loyal, and mechanically gifted fox fans know from the Sonic franchise. Instead, he is portrayed as a delusional, obsessive, and violent character whose love for Sonic spirals into a deadly fixation.

    Unhinged Obsession

    In this alternate narrative, Tails' obsession with Sonic drives him to eliminate anyone who threatens their "best friend" dynamic. He views Sonic's other friends, such as Knuckles and Shadow, as impostors who don't truly care for Sonic. Tails orchestrates their deaths in gruesome ways, such as sabotaging Knuckles' phone battery to cause an explosion and tampering with Shadow's hover boots to make them malfunction fatally[[1]][[2]][[6]]. His justification is chilling: he believes only he truly loves Sonic and that others are merely pretenders.

    Psychological Breakdown

    Tails' descent into madness is marked by his inability to accept Sonic's rejection. When Sonic confronts him, stating that they are not and never will be best friends, Tails' delusion reaches its peak. He concludes that if Sonic doesn't consider him his best friend, then Sonic must be an impostor. This warped logic leads Tails to attempt to kill Sonic himself, cementing his role as a tragic and terrifying antagonist[[1]][[2]][[6]].

    Mastermind and Manipulator

    Beyond his violent tendencies, Secret Histories Tails is depicted as a cunning and manipulative figure. He covers his tracks meticulously, making it difficult for others to prove his involvement in the deaths of Sonic's friends. In some versions of the story, he even ventures into the multiverse, recruiting alternate versions of Sonic's allies who meet his standards while eliminating those who don't[[2]]. This portrayal elevates him from a mere obsessive sidekick to a dangerous mastermind capable of wreaking havoc across dimensions.

    Symbolism and Themes

    This version of Tails serves as a dark commentary on obsession, jealousy, and the dangers of unchecked devotion. His transformation from a loyal friend to a deranged antagonist highlights how love, when twisted by insecurity and possessiveness, can lead to destruction. The story also explores themes of identity and belonging, as Tails' entire sense of self-worth is tied to his relationship with Sonic.

    Fan Reactions

    Fans of the "Secret Histories" series have been captivated by this unhinged portrayal of Tails. Many appreciate the depth and complexity added to his character, as well as the horror elements that make the story both unsettling and compelling. The animation's dark humor and dramatic storytelling have made it a standout entry in Mashed's "What If" series[[4]][[6]][[7]].

    In summary, Secret Histories Tails is a fascinating and horrifying reimagining of a beloved character, turning him into a symbol of obsessive love gone wrong. His unhinged behavior, tragic backstory, and chilling logic make him one of the most memorable and disturbing figures in the "Secret Histories" universe.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.