Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
MiniMaxminimax-m1· MiniMaxHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Let α-equivalence, written =α, be the smallest relation on Λ−, such that P =α P for all…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Amazon Novaamazon-nova-experimental-chat-05-14’s answer.
  1. User

    Let α-equivalence, written =α, be the smallest relation on Λ−, such that P =α P for all P ; λx.P =α λy.P [x := y] if y 6 ∈ FV(P ), prove the rules: P =α P ′ ⇒ ∀x ∈ V : λx.P =α λx.P ′; P =α P ′ ⇒ ∀Z ∈ Λ− : P Z =α P ′ Z; P =α P ′ ⇒ ∀Z ∈ Λ− : Z P =α Z P ′; P =α P ′ ⇒ P ′ =α P ; P =α P ′ & P ′ =α P ′′ ⇒ P =α P ′′.

  2. MiniMax Assistant

    To prove the rules of α-equivalence given its definition as the smallest relation satisfying reflexivity and the renaming condition, we proceed as follows:


    1. Symmetry (Rule 4): ( P =\alpha Q \implies Q =\alpha P )

    Proof by contradiction:

    • Assume ( =\alpha ) is not symmetric. Then there exist terms ( P, Q ) such that ( P =\alpha Q ) but ( Q \neq_\alpha P ).
    • Define the symmetric closure ( S = =\alpha \cup =\alpha^{-1} ).
    • ( S ) satisfies the base conditions:
      • Reflexivity: ( S ) contains all ( (P, P) ), inherited from ( =_\alpha ).
      • Renaming: If ( \lambda x.P =\alpha \lambda y.P[x := y] ), then ( (\lambda x.P, \lambda y.P[x := y]) \in S ). Similarly, if ( \lambda y.P[x := y] =\alpha \lambda x.P ), then ( (\lambda y.P[x := y], \lambda x.P) \in S ). Thus, ( S ) satisfies renaming.
    • Since ( S ) satisfies the base conditions and ( =\alpha ) is the smallest such relation, ( S \subseteq =\alpha ). But ( S \supseteq =\alpha ), so ( S = =\alpha ). Hence, ( =_\alpha ) is symmetric.

    2. Transitivity (Rule 5): ( P =\alpha Q \land Q =\alpha R \implies P =_\alpha R )

    Proof by contradiction:

    • Assume ( =\alpha ) is not transitive. Then there exist ( P, Q, R ) such that ( P =\alpha Q ), ( Q =\alpha R ), but ( P \neq\alpha R ).
    • Define the transitive closure ( T = =\alpha \cup {(P, R) \mid \exists Q: P =\alpha Q \land Q =_\alpha R} ).
    • ( T ) satisfies the base conditions:
      • Reflexivity: Inherited from ( =_\alpha ).
      • Renaming: If ( \lambda x.P =_\alpha \lambda y.P[x := y] ), then ( (\lambda x.P, \lambda y.P[x := y]) \in T ). Transitivity does not interfere with renaming.
    • Since ( T \supseteq =\alpha ) and satisfies the base conditions, ( =\alpha \subseteq T ). But ( T ) adds ( (P, R) ), contradicting minimality. Hence, ( =_\alpha ) is transitive.

    3. Congruence under Abstraction (Rule 1): ( P =\alpha Q \implies \lambda x.P =\alpha \lambda x.Q )

    Proof:

    • Assume ( P =\alpha Q ). Define the relation ( R = =\alpha \cup {(\lambda x.P, \lambda x.Q)} ).
    • Check if ( R ) satisfies the base conditions:
      • Reflexivity: Inherited from ( =_\alpha ).
      • Renaming: For any term ( S ) and variables ( y, z ) with ( z \notin \text{FV}(S) ), ( (\lambda y.S, \lambda z.S[y := z]) \in R ) (already in ( =_\alpha )).
    • Since ( R ) satisfies the base conditions and ( =\alpha ) is the smallest, ( (\lambda x.P, \lambda x.Q) \in =\alpha ). Thus, congruence holds.

    4. Congruence under Left Application (Rule 2): ( P =\alpha Q \implies \forall Z \in \Lambda^- : PZ =\alpha QZ )

    Proof:

    • Assume ( P =\alpha Q ). Define ( R = =\alpha \cup {(PZ, QZ) \mid Z \in \Lambda^-} ).
    • Check if ( R ) satisfies the base conditions:
      • Reflexivity: Inherited from ( =_\alpha ).
      • Renaming: Unaffected by added application pairs.
    • Since ( R ) satisfies the base conditions and ( =\alpha ) is minimal, ( (PZ, QZ) \in =\alpha ). Hence, congruence holds.

    5. Congruence under Right Application (Rule 3): ( P =\alpha Q \implies \forall Z \in \Lambda^- : ZP =\alpha ZQ )

    Proof:

    • Similar to Rule 2. Define ( R = =_\alpha \cup {(ZP, ZQ) \mid Z \in \Lambda^-} ).
    • Check base conditions (reflexivity and renaming are preserved).
    • By minimality, ( (ZP, ZQ) \in =_\alpha ). Hence, congruence holds.

    Conclusion

    All five rules are consequences of defining ( =_\alpha ) as the smallest relation satisfying reflexivity and renaming. Assuming any rule fails allows constructing a smaller relation satisfying the base conditions, contradicting minimality. Thus, the rules must hold.

    [ \boxed{\text{All rules are proven by minimality and closure under base conditions.}} ]

  3. User

    Let α-equivalence, written =α, be the smallest relation on Λ−, such that P =α P for all P ; λx.P =α λy.P [x := y] if y 6 ∈ FV(P ), prove the rules: P =α P ′ ⇒ ∀x ∈ V : λx.P =α λx.P ′; P =α P ′ ⇒ ∀Z ∈ Λ− : P Z =α P ′ Z; P =α P ′ ⇒ ∀Z ∈ Λ− : Z P =α Z P ′; P =α P ′ ⇒ P ′ =α P ; P =α P ′ & P ′ =α P ′′ ⇒ P =α P ′′.

  4. MiniMax Assistant

    To prove the stated rules for α-equivalence, we leverage the fact that =α is defined as the smallest relation satisfying the given base conditions. This minimality ensures that any valid rule must hold in =α; otherwise, we could construct a smaller relation that still satisfies the base conditions, contradicting minimality.


    1. Rule: If ( P =\alpha P' ), then ( \forall x \in V: \lambda x.P =\alpha \lambda x.P' )

    Proof:
    Assume for contradiction that there exist terms ( P, P' ) and variable ( x ) such that ( P =\alpha P' ) but ( \lambda x.P \neq\alpha \lambda x.P' ).

    Define a new relation ( R ) as ( =_\alpha \cup {(\lambda x.P, \lambda x.P')} ).

    • ( R ) satisfies reflexivity and the renaming rule (since ( =_\alpha ) does, and we added no new pairs violating with them).
    • ( R ) is strictly smaller than ( =\alpha ) (since it excludes ( (\lambda x.P, \lambda x.P') )), contradicting the minimality of ( =\alpha ).

    Thus, ( \lambda x.P =_\alpha \lambda x.P' ) must hold.


    2. Rule: If ( P =\alpha P' ), then ( \forall Z \in \Lambda^-: PZ =\alpha P'Z )

    Proof:
    Assume for contradiction that there exist ( P, P', Z ) such that ( P =\alpha P' ) but ( PZ \neq\alpha P'Z ).

    Define ( R = =_\alpha \cup {(PZ, P'Z)} ).

    • ( R ) satisfies reflexivity and renaming (no new conflicting added).
    • ( R ) is smaller than ( =_\alpha ), contradicting minimality.

    Thus, ( PZ =_\alpha P'Z ) must hold.


    3. Rule: If ( P =\alpha P' ), then ( \forall Z \in \Lambda^-: ZP =\alpha ZP' )

    Proof:
    Similar to Rule 2, by considering right application instead of left. Define ( R = =_\alpha \cup {(ZP, ZP')} ).

    • ( R ) satisfies base conditions.
    • Contradicts minimality if ( ZP \neq_\alpha ZP' ).

    Thus, ( ZP =_\alpha ZP' ).


    4. Rule: If ( P =\alpha P' ), then ( P' =\alpha P ) (Symmetry)

    Proof:
    Assume ( =\alpha ) is not symmetric. Then there exist ( P, P' ) with ( P =\alpha P' ) but ( P' \neq_\alpha P ).

    Define the symmetric closure ( R = =\alpha \cup {(P', P) \mid (P, P') \in =\alpha} ).

    • ( R ) satisfies reflexivity and renaming (symmetric pairs don’t violate renaming).
    • ( R ) is smaller than ( =_\alpha ), contradicting minimality.

    Thus, ( =_\alpha ) is symmetric.


    5. Rule: If ( P =\alpha P' ) and ( P' =\alpha P'' ), then ( P =_\alpha P'' ) (Transitivity)

    Proof:
    Assume ( =\alpha ) is not transitive. Then there exist ( P, P', P'' ) with ( P =\alpha P' ), ( P' =\alpha P'' ), but ( P \neq\alpha P'' ).

    Define the transitive closure ( R = =\alpha \cup {(P, P'') \mid \exists Q: (P, Q), (Q, P'') \in =\alpha} ).

    • ( R ) satisfies reflexivity and renaming (transitive pairs don’t conflict).
    • ( R ) is smaller than ( =_\alpha ), contradicting minimality.

    Thus, ( =_\alpha ) is transitive.


    Conclusion

    All five rules hold because their failure would allow constructing a smaller relation satisfying the base conditions, contradicting the minimality of ( =\alpha ). Hence, the rules are inherent properties of ( =\alpha ).

    \boxed{\text{All rules are proven by minimality of } =_\alpha.}

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.