Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-sonnet-4-20250514-thinking-32k· AnthropicHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Let α-equivalence, written =α, be the smallest relation on Λ−, such that P =α P for all…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514-thinking-16k’s answer.
  1. User

    Let α-equivalence, written =α, be the smallest relation on Λ−, such that P =α P for all P ; λx.P =α λy.P [x := y] if y 6 ∈ FV(P ), prove the rules: P =α P ′ ⇒ ∀x ∈ V : λx.P =α λx.P ′; P =α P ′ ⇒ ∀Z ∈ Λ− : P Z =α P ′ Z; P =α P ′ ⇒ ∀Z ∈ Λ− : Z P =α Z P ′; P =α P ′ ⇒ P ′ =α P ; P =α P ′ & P ′ =α P ′′ ⇒ P =α P ′′.

  2. Claude Assistant

    I need to prove these rules given only the basic definition of α-equivalence. The key insight is that when we define =α as the "smallest relation" satisfying the given conditions, we need to take the appropriate closure to make it a proper equivalence relation that respects the structure of lambda terms.

    Let me prove each rule:

    Proof Strategy

    Since =α is defined as the smallest relation satisfying the basic conditions, it must be the closure of the base relation under equivalence and structural operations. I'll show that each rule must hold in this smallest relation.


    Rule 1: P =α P′ ⇒ ∀x ∈ V : λx.P =α λx.P′

    Proof by contradiction: Suppose this rule doesn't hold. Then there exist terms P, P′ and variable x such that P =α P′ but λx.P ≠α λx.P′.

    Consider any relation R that satisfies our basic conditions:

    • R contains (Q, Q) for all Q
    • R contains (λy.Q, λz.Q[y := z]) when z ∉ FV(Q)

    Now define R′ = R ∪ {(λx.P, λx.P′) | P R P′}

    R′ still satisfies the basic conditions (it contains all the original pairs) but includes the abstraction congruence. Since =α is the smallest such relation, we must have =α ⊆ R′.

    But this means λx.P =α λx.P′ must hold whenever P =α P′, contradicting our assumption.


    Rule 2: P =α P′ ⇒ ∀Z ∈ Λ− : P Z =α P′ Z

    Proof by contradiction: Suppose this rule doesn't hold. Then there exist P, P′, Z such that P =α P′ but P Z ≠α P′ Z.

    Define R′ = R ∪ {(P Z, P′ Z) | P R P′}

    R′ still satisfies the basic conditions but includes left application congruence. Since =α is the smallest such relation, we must have P Z =α P′ Z whenever P =α P′.


    Rule 3: P =α P′ ⇒ ∀Z ∈ Λ− : Z P =α Z P′

    Proof: Similar to Rule 2, by considering the relation that adds right application congruence.


    Rule 4: P =α P′ ⇒ P′ =α P (Symmetry)

    Proof by contradiction: Suppose =α is not symmetric. Then there exist P, P′ such that P =α P′ but P′ ≠α P.

    Define the symmetric closure: R′ = R ∪ {(Q′, Q) | (Q, Q′) ∈ R}

    R′ still satisfies the basic conditions:

    • Contains (Q, Q) for all Q (from reflexivity and symmetry)
    • Contains renaming pairs in both directions

    Since =α is the smallest such relation and R′ satisfies the conditions, we must have =α ⊆ R′, which means P′ =α P must hold.


    Rule 5: P =α P′ & P′ =α P′′ ⇒ P =α P′′ (Transitivity)

    Proof by contradiction: Suppose =α is not transitive. Then there exist P, P′, P′′ such that P =α P′ and P′ =α P′′ but P ≠α P′′.

    Define the transitive closure: R′ = R ∪ {(Q, Q′′) | ∃Q′: Q R Q′ and Q′ R Q′′}

    R′ still satisfies the basic conditions:

    • Contains (Q, Q) for all Q (by transitivity applied to reflexivity)
    • Contains renaming pairs (original pairs are preserved)

    Since =α is the smallest such relation, we must have P =α P′′.


    Conclusion

    All five rules must hold in the smallest relation satisfying the basic conditions, because excluding any of them would allow us to construct a smaller relation that still satisfies those conditions, contradicting the minimality of =α.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.