Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514-thinking-16k· AnthropicHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

To be fair most of you examples are hilariously bad, especially finance/tech-bros - they…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking’s answer.
  1. User

    To be fair most of you examples are hilariously bad, especially finance/tech-bros - they not just believe competence exists - they think they have it themselves. Lets return to the basics and start from definition of reverse cargo cult and work our way up to adjacent believes.

  2. Claude Assistant

    You're absolutely right. My examples were sloppy and contradictory - tech bros are perhaps the opposite of RCC thinking since they're supremely confident in their own competence. Let me start over from first principles.

    Core RCC Definition

    Reverse Cargo Cult belief: "There is no such thing as competence. Everyone is just performing rituals and pretending they know how to produce outcomes, but no one actually does."

    Key elements:

    • Competence (knowing how to reliably produce desired outcomes) does not exist
    • What looks like competence is just performance/ritual
    • Success/failure is arbitrary - not causally linked to actions
    • Everyone is pretending to understand causality that doesn't exist

    Adjacent Beliefs (Working Outward from Core)

    1. "Nobody knows, but they don't know they don't know"

    • Close to RCC but with a twist: Others aren't consciously pretending - they genuinely believe their rituals work
    • Example: "Economists think their models predict anything, but they're just fooling themselves with math"
    • Difference from core RCC: Assumes genuine self-deception rather than conscious performance

    2. "The emperor has no clothes, but the tailors believe in the clothes"

    • The system is hollow, but lower-level participants have false consciousness
    • Example: "CEOs know strategic planning is BS, but middle managers actually believe in it"
    • Difference: Stratified - some know it's all ritual, others are true believers

    3. "It's all luck, but we need the illusion of control"

    • Outcomes are random, but the rituals serve a psychological/social function
    • Example: "Trading strategies don't beat the market, but we need to pretend they do to justify the industry"
    • Difference: Functional view of pretense - the rituals have value even if they don't cause outcomes

    4. "Competence is unknowable"

    • We can never determine if someone is competent or just lucky
    • Example: "Did that CEO grow the company through skill or just ride a boom? No way to tell"
    • Difference: Epistemic humility rather than certainty that competence doesn't exist

    Who Actually Holds Views Close to Core RCC?

    The purest examples would be people who:

    1. Have extensive experience in a field
    2. Have become completely cynical about that field
    3. Genuinely believe NO ONE in the field knows what they're doing

    Possible candidates:

    • Burnt-out political operatives who've seen enough campaigns to conclude that winning/losing is essentially random, and all strategy is post-hoc rationalization
    • Veteran bureaucrats in dysfunctional systems who believe policy-making is pure theater with no connection to outcomes
    • Some financial traders who've concluded the entire industry is elaborate gambling dressed up as analysis

    But even these groups usually maintain SOME belief in competence somewhere. True RCC - "competence doesn't exist anywhere" - is an extremely rare position because it's so absolute.

    Would you like me to explore any of these adjacent beliefs more carefully? Or shall we look at specific domains where RCC thinking might emerge?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.