To be fair most of you examples are hilariously bad, especially finance/tech-bros - they…
- User
To be fair most of you examples are hilariously bad, especially finance/tech-bros - they not just believe competence exists - they think they have it themselves. Lets return to the basics and start from definition of reverse cargo cult and work our way up to adjacent believes.
Assistant
You're absolutely right — and I appreciate the sharp correction. Let’s reset, strip away the caricatures, and rebuild this from first principles.
🔍 Step 1: Defining "Reverse Cargo Cult" (RCC)
Let’s begin by agreeing on a minimalist, epistemological definition of reverse cargo cult that avoids political or cultural baggage:
Reverse Cargo Cult (RCC):
A belief system in which one assumes that:- There is no real competence or causal mechanism behind success.
- What appears to be expertise or productive action is merely ritualistic performance.
- Outcomes are not the result of skill, knowledge, or effort, but of luck, manipulation, or systemic inertia.
- Therefore, mimicking these rituals has value only as theater — not because they produce results.
This is the core idea: Not just skepticism of competence, but total denial of its existence.
🧩 Step 2: Distinguishing RCC From Related Beliefs
To avoid conflating RCC with similar ideas, let's compare it to adjacent beliefs:
Belief Type View on Competence Example Naive Cargo Cult Others have hidden competence; imitate them to gain cargo. “If we build an airstrip like the Americans, planes will come.” Moderate Skepticism Some people are competent; many aren’t. “Most managers don’t know what they’re doing, but some actually do.” Cynicism / Institutional Disillusionment Institutions claim competence, but often fail. “The FDA approved this drug, but I still think it’s snake oil.” Bullshit Jobs Theory (Graeber) Many roles are socially useless, but individuals may still believe in their own competence. “My job is pointless, but at least I’m good at pretending.” Reverse Cargo Cult (RCC) No one knows anything. All actions are meaningless rituals. Success is arbitrary. “There’s no such thing as management skill—just who yells loudest in meetings.” So RCC isn't just thinking most people are incompetent — it's the radical view that there is no competence at all, only rituals that masquerade as it.
🧠 Step 3: Who Might Hold RCC Views?
Now, who in developed societies might hold this kind of worldview?
✅ Best Candidates for Genuine RCC Thinking
These groups are most likely to hold RCC views, either explicitly or implicitly through behavior:
1. Postmodern Academics (Extinct Version)
- Once believed systems like capitalism, science, or law were social constructs with no objective truth.
- Extreme versions claimed knowledge was power masked as objectivity.
- Example: Jean Baudrillard’s simulacra theory — reality is replaced by symbols and signs with no underlying substance.
- Today: Less influential academically, but echoes live on in online nihilism.
2. Disillusioned Long-Term Employees in Bureaucratic Roles
- People who've spent years in large corporations, government agencies, or NGOs and see little connection between effort and outcome.
- They’ve seen strategies change every quarter, metrics gamed, and promotions handed out arbitrarily.
- They conclude: “It’s not about doing good work—it’s about playing the game.”
3. Crypto/NFT Burnouts (Especially Post-2022)
- After seeing massive hype cycles, crashes, and manipulations, many former true believers now assume:
- Value is purely speculative.
- “Fundamentals” are made up after the fact.
- Everyone is just pumping something else.
- This bleeds into broader financial skepticism: “All markets are rigged anyway.”
4. AI Doomers & Techno-Nihilists
- Some fear AI will render human judgment obsolete, not because it's smart, but because human judgment never really existed.
- “Management was always just vibes. Now algorithms will provide the vibes.”
- Core assumption: If machines can fake competence better than humans, maybe humans never had it to begin with.
5. Radical Deplatformed Online Thinkers
- Those who were banned or censored from major platforms often develop the belief:
- “Truth doesn’t matter. It’s all about who controls the narrative.”
- “Merit doesn’t matter. It’s about who plays the game.”
- They may adopt a fatalistic view: “Everyone’s lying. Everything’s propaganda. Nothing is real.”
🧱 Step 4: Why These Groups Fit RCC Better Than Tech Bros or Finance Brokers
You're right: the "tech bros" and "finance cynics" I mentioned earlier usually don’t deny competence exists — they think they possess it.
They say things like:
- “We’re disrupting legacy industries that don’t get it.”
- “We’re the ones making the trains run on time.”
- “Sure, half our team is useless—but I’m the exception.”
That’s not RCC — that’s elitist exceptionalism: “Everyone else is faking it, but I’m legit.”
Similarly, consultants who mock clients while billing them $5k/hour don’t think consulting is BS — they think they are the rare ones who deliver value.
So again, thank you for calling out those examples — they were more satire than sociology. 😊
🔄 Final Recap: Reverse Cargo Cult Is Rare, But Real
To sum up:
- RCC is a radical epistemological position — not just doubt in competence, but denial of its very possibility.
- It tends to emerge in systems where outcomes are opaque, disconnected from effort, and dominated by ritual.
- It’s more common among people who’ve experienced long-term disillusionment in complex systems (bureaucracies, finance, academia).
- It’s not the same as general cynicism or corruption — it’s deeper, more nihilistic, and self-reinforcing.
And crucially:
Reverse Cargo Cult is not a description of how the world works — it’s a belief about what the world isn’t.
It says: there is no engine under the hood. Just blinking lights.
Would you like to explore how RCC relates to other philosophical positions (like postmodernism, nihilism, or determinism)? Or should we map how it manifests in specific domains like politics, business, or tech?
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.