Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Which character or characters in Deltarune do you believe will be revealed to be the…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Mistralmistral-medium-2505’s answer.
  1. User

    Which character or characters in Deltarune do you believe will be revealed to be the Knight?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Of course! The identity of the Knight is arguably the central mystery of Deltarune, and there are many compelling theories floating around. As an AI, I don't have personal beliefs, but I can analyze the evidence and arguments for the most popular and plausible candidates.

    Here's a breakdown of the most likely suspects, weighing the evidence for and against each one.


    The Primary Suspects

    1. Kris

    Kris is, by far, the most directly implicated character. The evidence is so strong that the real question isn't if they are involved, but why and in what capacity.

    Evidence For:

    • Chapter 1 Cliffhanger: At the end of Chapter 1, Kris rips out their own SOUL (which represents the player), throws it in a cage, and brandishes a knife with a menacing red glint in their eye. This is the first indication that Kris has a will of their own, separate from the player's control.
    • Chapter 2 Cliffhanger: This is the smoking gun. We watch, without control, as Kris gets up in the middle of the night, slashes Toriel's tires to prevent her from stopping them, and then uses their "determination" to open a Dark Fountain in the living room, creating the world of Chapter 3. They are shown, unequivocally, creating a Dark Fountain.
    • The Knight's "Blade": The King in Chapter 1 refers to the Knight's "strange blade." Kris is consistently associated with a knife.
    • Motive? Kris seems to resent the player's control. Opening Dark Fountains might be their way of creating worlds where they can act freely with their friends, away from the player's influence. Or, it could be a more malicious act of rebellion.

    Evidence Against (or Complicating Factors):

    • Conflicting Goals: Why would Kris spend all day sealing the very fountains they create at night? It suggests a split personality, possession, or a goal more complex than simply "open fountains."
    • Rouxls Kaard's Testimony: Rouxls saw the Knight create the Cyber World fountain. He describes them as a figure of "shadowy import," but his description is vague. He doesn't recognize Kris, but then again, he's Rouxls.
    • The Player's Role: The theory's biggest complication is us, the player. Kris only seems to perform these "Knighly" actions when our SOUL is removed. This has led to the idea that it's not truly Kris who is the Knight, but rather a third entity that possesses Kris's body when the player is not in control.

    Conclusion: Kris is almost certainly a Knight, as they physically create a fountain. The real mystery is whether they are the original Knight who created the first two fountains, and what their true motivation is.


    2. Dess Holiday

    Dess is Noelle's older sister who has been missing for some time. Her absence is a source of great sorrow and mystery in Hometown.

    Evidence For:

    • Narrative Weight: Connecting the town's greatest mystery (Dess's disappearance) with the game's central plot mystery (the Knight's identity) is narratively satisfying.
    • The "Holiday" Connection: The family name "Holiday" is thematically significant. Some fans theorize a connection to "knight" (as in "holy day"). Her full name might be December Holiday, connecting her to a wintery theme.
    • Motive: Perhaps she is trapped in a Dark World, or something happened to her related to them. Her actions as the Knight could be an attempt to get back, get revenge, or reshape the world.
    • The "Roaring" Knight: If something terrible happened to her, it could explain why she is described as a "roaring" Knight, filled with rage or grief.

    Evidence Against:

    • Lack of Direct Evidence: This theory is built almost entirely on circumstantial evidence and her status as a "mystery box" character. There is no direct, in-game text linking Dess to the Knight or the creation of fountains.
    • Physicality: We have no idea what happened to her. Is she even physically capable of being the Knight?

    Conclusion: A compelling dark horse theory that ties character backstory and plot together, but it lacks the hard evidence that points to Kris.


    3. A Third Entity (Possibly Gaster or a Follower)

    This theory suggests that the Knight is not a character we know in the traditional sense, but an external force that may be possessing someone—most likely Kris.

    Evidence For:

    • Explains Kris's Behavior: This cleanly explains why Kris acts against their "daytime" goal of sealing fountains. The entity takes over when the player's SOUL is removed, using Kris's body as a vessel to create Dark Fountains.
    • Gaster's Presence: W.D. Gaster's influence is felt everywhere in Deltarune: the vessel creation sequence, the strange sounds from the cell phone, the man behind the tree, the recurring number 666. As a being shattered across time and space, he is a prime candidate for an entity acting through others.
    • The "Roaring": A "roaring" could describe the sound of something otherworldly or reality-bending, fitting Gaster's theme.

    Evidence Against:

    • Physical Description: Queen and Rouxls both saw a physical person. While this person could have been a possessed Kris, they describe a distinct being. Queen even calls them a "peon," which doesn't sound like a god-like entity.
    • Too Abstract? Making the villain a mysterious, unseen puppet master can sometimes feel less personal or impactful than having it be a character we know and interact with.

    Conclusion: This theory elegantly resolves the contradictions in Kris's behavior. The Knight might not be a person, but an actor using people as pawns.


    Other, Less Likely Possibilities

    • Papyrus: Conspicuously absent from town, despite his house being there. In Undertale, he desperately wanted to be in the Royal Guard, a knightly order. This would be a shocking subversion of his character, but it feels unlikely given his established personality.
    • Father Alvin: The town priest, mentioned by Asgore and on a gravestone. A religious figure bringing about an apocalypse is a classic trope. However, he has very little presence in the story so far, making it a twist with little foundation.
    • The "Multiple Knights" Theory: This theory proposes that there isn't just one Knight. The original Knight (who opened the first two fountains) could be one person, while Kris has now become a second Knight at the end of Chapter 2. This would explain the differing descriptions—the King's fearsome Knight might be different from the one Queen saw, who might be different from Kris.

    Final Verdict

    Based on the direct, on-screen evidence, Kris is the most likely candidate to be revealed as the Knight, or at least a Knight. The act of them creating a fountain in the living room is undeniable.

    However, the story is clearly not that simple. The most probable scenario is a combination of theories: Kris is the physical body of the Knight, but they are either being influenced, possessed, or are acting out of a desperate rebellion against the player's control. Their identity as the Knight is likely intertwined with the game's core themes of choice, determinism, and freedom.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.