Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Which character or characters in Deltarune do you believe will be revealed to be the…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-sonnet-4-20250514’s answer.
  1. User

    Which character or characters in Deltarune do you believe will be revealed to be the Knight?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Excellent question. The identity of the "Knight" is the central driving mystery of Deltarune, and Toby Fox has masterfully laid a trail of clues, red herrings, and compelling possibilities.

    While there is no definitive answer yet, I can analyze the most prominent candidates based on the evidence from Chapters 1 and 2.

    My conclusion, based on the current evidence, is that the most likely candidate is Kris, but specifically when they are acting without the influence of the Player (the SOUL).

    Let's break down why this theory is so compelling, and also look at other major candidates.


    What We Know About the Knight

    First, let's establish the "facts" provided in the game:

    • Creates Dark Fountains: This is their primary function. They use a "blade" of determination to pierce the ground, creating new Dark Worlds.
    • Is a Lightner: Queen explicitly states the Knight is a Lightner, as only Lightners have the determination to create fountains.
    • Has "Great Determination": Queen describes them leaving Cyber World with "a great determination," using a "roaring" sound that frightened her.
    • Appears as a Figure with a Blade: King calls them a "strange knight." Queen saw them create the fountain. We see a shadowy, knife-wielding figure creating the fountain in the library at the end of Chapter 2.
    • Their Goal is Unclear: It seems their goal is to create more Dark Fountains, which, if unchecked, will lead to "The Roaring"—the apocalypse prophesied by Ralsei. Whether this is their intended outcome or an unforeseen consequence is unknown.

    Candidate Analysis

    Here are the most popular theories, weighed by their evidence.

    1. Kris (The Leading Theory)

    This theory has the most direct, observable evidence, making it the front-runner.

    • The Evidence:

      • End of Chapter 1: Kris, of their own volition, rips out the Player's SOUL, throws it in a cage, brandishes a knife, and smiles menacingly at the "camera." This is the first time we see Kris acting independently, and it's immediately associated with a knife.
      • End of Chapter 2: The most damning evidence. Kris again rips out the SOUL, walks to the living room, and we see them use their knife to slash open the ground, creating the Dark Fountain for Chapter 3. The camera angle and action directly mirror the description of the Knight.
      • Possession and Agency: Kris is being controlled by the Player. Their independent actions (ripping out the SOUL) could be a desperate attempt to regain control. Creating Dark Worlds might be the only way they can act freely, or perhaps it's a way to create a world where their choices matter again, away from our influence.
      • "Determination": The key ingredient for creating fountains is a trait heavily associated with the protagonist in the Undertale/Deltarune universe.
    • The Counter-Evidence:

      • Why endanger their friends? If Kris is the Knight, why would they create worlds that put their friends like Susie and Noelle in danger?
      • Why don't the Kings recognize them? Neither King nor Queen identified Kris as the Knight. However, the Knight could have been cloaked or armored, concealing their identity.
    • Verdict: Extremely High Likelihood. The evidence is visual and direct. The nuance is that it's not "evil" Kris, but rather a Kris desperate for agency, whose actions have catastrophic consequences. The Knight isn't a separate person, but a role Kris takes on when they are free from us.

    2. A New or Unseen Character (The Gaster/Vessel Theory)

    This theory suggests the Knight is a character we haven't properly met, possibly connected to the game's mysterious narrator, W.D. Gaster.

    • The Evidence:

      • The "Goner" Connection: The game's intro, where you create a vessel, is hijacked by a mysterious entity widely believed to be Gaster. The vessel is then discarded. It's possible the Knight is this discarded vessel, now acting on Gaster's will.
      • "Strange Knight": This description fits a bizarre, otherworldly entity better than a local teenager.
      • The Roaring Knight: Queen's description of the Knight's "roaring" could be literal, suggesting a monstrous or non-human entity.
    • The Counter-Evidence:

      • It's a Narrative Cop-out: Revealing the main villain to be a character we've never met can feel less impactful than it being someone we know.
      • Lack of Direct Evidence: This is all based on interpreting cryptic clues. There is no direct link between Gaster and the Knight's on-screen actions.
    • Verdict: Moderate Likelihood. It’s a very "Toby Fox" kind of twist, connecting to the deeper, hidden lore of the game. It explains the Knight's power and strange nature well.

    3. Papyrus

    A surprisingly popular dark horse theory, mostly fueled by his conspicuous absence.

    • The Evidence:

      • Conspicuous Absence: Papyrus is the only major Undertale character living in Hometown that we have not seen. Sans gives a vague excuse that he's busy.
      • Knightly Aspirations: In Undertale, Papyrus's main goal was to become a member of the Royal Guard, a knightly order.
      • "Strange Knight": Papyrus is definitely "strange." His over-the-top personality combined with a serious, world-altering goal would be a fascinating twist.
    • The Counter-Evidence:

      • Character Inconsistency: It would require Papyrus to have a hidden dark side that is completely at odds with his established character. While this is an alternate universe, it feels like too drastic a shift.
      • Purely Circumstantial: There is zero direct evidence linking Papyrus to any of the Knight's actions.
    • Verdict: Low Likelihood. It’s a fun theory to entertain, but it relies on a complete subversion of a beloved character with very little textual support.

    4. Alvin / Father Alvin

    The town's priest and likely son of the late Gerson. This is a deep-lore theory.

    • The Evidence:

      • Connection to the "Angel": Alvin preaches about the "Angel," whose return is prophesied. This prophecy of "Angel's Heaven" sounds suspiciously like Ralsei's prophecy of "The Roaring." The Knight could be a religious zealot trying to bring about the apocalypse, believing it to be salvation.
      • Hiding in Plain Sight: The unassuming town priest being the catalyst for the end of the world is a classic RPG trope that Toby Fox could cleverly employ.
    • The Counter-Evidence:

      • No Concrete Links: Like the Papyrus theory, this is purely speculative. We have no reason to believe Alvin has the power or determination to create Dark Fountains.
    • Verdict: Low Likelihood. An intriguing thematic possibility, but it lacks the hard evidence that points toward Kris.

    Final Conclusion: Why Kris is the Most Likely Answer

    While other theories are possible, the game repeatedly and explicitly shows us Kris performing the exact actions attributed to the Knight. Occam's Razor suggests the simplest explanation is the most likely: the figure we see creating the fountain is the Knight.

    Therefore, I believe Kris is the Knight.

    However, the crucial part of this theory is the "why." It's not because Kris is a villain. It's likely because they are a prisoner in their own body, and creating Dark Worlds is their rebellious, desperate, and ultimately dangerous way of fighting back against the Player's control. We, the player, are the catalyst for the Knight's actions, making us complicit in the potential end of the world. This creates a far more compelling and tragic narrative than a simple "surprise villain" reveal.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.