Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Mistralmistral-medium-2505· Mistral AIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I have a piece of wood that is 80 cm x 30 cm x 2 cm . I'd like to mount it on the wall,…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwen-max-2025-01-25’s answer.
  1. User

    I have a piece of wood that is 80 cm x 30 cm x 2 cm . I'd like to mount it on the wall, as a shelf. I have two supports for the shelf.

    How would you place the supports and why? I wanted to place them 10 cm from the extremities. So that one has, from left to right: left end, 10 cm nothing, then comes the support, 60 cm nothing, another support, 10 cm nothing, right end.

    But I am unsure if 10 cm from the extremities is the best for load support, hence the question.

  2. Mistral Assistant

    When mounting a shelf, the placement of the supports is crucial for ensuring stability and preventing sagging or failure under load. Your proposed placement (10 cm from each end) is a reasonable starting point, but let's analyze it further to optimize for strength and load distribution.

    Key Considerations:

    1. Load Distribution: The shelf will experience the most bending stress in the middle. Supports should be placed to minimize this stress.
    2. Material Properties: Wood is stronger in compression (top fibers) and tension (bottom fibers) but can sag if unsupported over long spans.
    3. Support Placement: The optimal placement depends on the expected load and the shelf's dimensions.

    Your Proposed Placement:

    • Supports at 10 cm from each end:
      • This leaves a 60 cm unsupported span in the middle.
      • For a 2 cm thick shelf, this is likely too long for heavy loads, as the shelf may sag noticeably over time.

    Better Placement Options:

    1. Equal Thirds (Optimal for Uniform Load):

      • Place the supports at 1/3 and 2/3 of the shelf's length.
      • For an 80 cm shelf: supports at ~26.7 cm from each end (leaving ~26.7 cm between them).
      • This minimizes deflection (sagging) because the maximum bending moment is reduced.
    2. Quarter Points (For Very Heavy Loads):

      • Place supports at 1/4 and 3/4 of the shelf's length.
      • For an 80 cm shelf: supports at 20 cm from each end (leaving 40 cm between them).
      • This provides even more support but may be overkill for light loads.
    3. Your 10 cm Placement (Modified):

      • If you prefer the 10 cm from the ends for aesthetic reasons, consider adding a third support in the middle (at 40 cm) to reduce sagging.
      • Alternatively, use thicker or stiffer wood (e.g., 3 cm instead of 2 cm) to handle the 60 cm span.

    Why Equal Thirds is Best:

    • For a uniformly distributed load (e.g., books or decor), placing supports at 1/3 and 2/3 of the length reduces the maximum deflection by ~70% compared to supports at the ends.
    • This is because the bending moment (which causes sagging) is minimized in the middle.

    Practical Recommendation:

    • For light loads (e.g., decor, small items): Your 10 cm placement is fine, but expect some sagging over time.
    • For moderate loads (e.g., books): Use equal thirds (~26.7 cm from ends).
    • For heavy loads (e.g., heavy tools): Use quarter points (~20 cm from ends) or add a middle support.

    Additional Tips:

    • Use sturdy brackets or L-shaped supports that can handle the load.
    • Ensure the supports are securely anchored to wall studs (not just drywall).
    • If the shelf is very long or heavily loaded, consider using a thicker board or adding a middle support.

    Final Answer:

    For best load support, place the two supports at ~26.7 cm from each end (equal thirds). This minimizes sagging and distributes the load evenly. If you prefer the 10 cm placement, add a third support in the middle or use thicker wood.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.