Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Coherecommand-a-03-2025· CohereHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Compare in the table of steel: 20-N and 18HGT, tell about standards, similars, chemical…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-3-preview-02-24’s answer.
  1. User

    Compare in the table of steel: 20-N and 18HGT, tell about standards, similars, chemical composition, mechanical and technological properties add some information sources

  2. Cohere Assistant

    Below is a comparative table of the two steel grades: 20-N (a Russian standard carbon steel) and 18HGT (a Russian standard alloy steel, also known as 18G2A or 18G2 according to GOST standards). The table includes standards, similar grades, chemical composition, mechanical and technological properties, and information sources.

    Parameter20-N (GOST 1050-88)18HGT (GOST 14699-83)
    StandardGOST 1050-88 (Russia)GOST 14699-83 (Russia)
    Similar GradesC22 (DIN), 1020 (AISI/SAE)18G2A, 18G2, 09G2 (GOST), 1.0473 (DIN)
    TypeCarbon steel (quality)Alloy steel (low-alloy)
    Chemical Composition (%)C: 0.17-0.23Mn: 0.30-0.60Si: ≤ 0.35P: ≤ 0.040S: ≤ 0.040C: 0.16-0.22Mn: 0.30-0.60Si: ≤ 0.35Cr: 0.10-0.30Ni: 0.10-0.30P: ≤ 0.035S: ≤ 0.035
    Mechanical PropertiesTensile Strength: 350-480 MPaYield Strength: ≥ 240 MPaElongation: ≥ 22%Hardness: ≤ 170 HBTensile Strength: 400-550 MPaYield Strength: ≥ 260 MPaElongation: ≥ 20%Hardness: ≤ 187 HB
    Technological PropertiesGood weldabilitySuitable for cold formingNormal machinabilityImproved weldability due to alloyingGood cold formabilityEnhanced machinability
    ApplicationsAutomotive partsStructural componentsGeneral engineeringBoiler and pressure vesselsPipelinesWelded structures
    Information SourcesGOST 1050-88Total Materia databaseRussian steel standards handbookGOST 14699-83Total Materia databaseRussian alloy steel specifications

    Key Differences:

    1. Chemical Composition: 18HGT contains alloying elements like Cr and Ni, which improve its mechanical properties and corrosion resistance compared to the plain carbon steel 20-N.
    2. Mechanical Properties: 18HGT has higher tensile and yield strength due to its alloying elements, making it more suitable for demanding applications.
    3. Applications: 20-N is used in general engineering and automotive parts, while 18HGT is preferred for boiler, pressure vessel, and pipeline applications due to its improved properties.

    Information Sources:

    • GOST Standards: Official Russian standards for steel grades.
    • Total Materia: A comprehensive database for material properties and equivalents.
    • Handbooks and Specifications: Russian steel industry handbooks and alloy steel specifications.

    For precise data, always refer to the latest standards and material databases.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.