Skip to content
The Chat Archive
claude-opus-4-20250514· Anthropic LMArena Human Preference 140K

In Japanese is it best to think of the construction “Aはさておき、B…” as “putting aside A, B…

  1. User

    In Japanese is it best to think of the construction “Aはさておき、B…” as “putting aside A, B instead”?

  2. Assistant

    Not quite - while "putting aside A" captures part of the meaning, adding "B instead" isn't accurate. The construction "AはさておきB" is better understood as:

    "Setting A aside (for now), B..." "Leaving A aside, B..." "Apart from A, B..."

    The key point is that さておき doesn't inherently create a contrast or replacement relationship between A and B. It simply shelves topic A temporarily to focus on B, without necessarily implying that B is "instead of" A.

    For example:

    • 冗談はさておき、真面目な話をしよう "Jokes aside, let's talk seriously" (Not "instead of jokes, let's talk seriously")

    • 私のことはさておき、君は大丈夫? "Setting aside (concerns about) me, are you okay?" (Not "instead of me, are you okay?")

    The construction is more about temporarily dismissing or postponing discussion of A to move on to B, rather than presenting B as a replacement or alternative to A.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.