Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
DeepSeekdeepseek-v3-0324· DeepSeekHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

OK and I have a DSP Readback on the output of a Signal Detection flag block, and the DSP…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o3-2025-04-16’s answer.
  1. User

    OK and I have a DSP Readback on the output of a Signal Detection flag block, and the DSP Readback is set to 5.19 format. The flag alternates between 1.0 and 0.0 in the Readback. What number format should I say the flag output is in when I edit the wiki? Currently it says:

    Name Format [int/dec] - [control/audio] Function Description

    Pin 0: Trigger any - any Outputs a flag after no signal has been present for a given amount of time

    Context:

    "First-generation SigmaDSP processors, such as ADAU1701, do not read back with 28-bit accuracy. They only support 24-bit data, so small 28.0 format integers will be truncated and display as 0.000000000. To display 28.0 format integers on these DSPs, the value from Readback must be bit shifted, such as multiplying the value by 4 twice (since 16.0 does not exist in 5.23 format) and setting the DSP Readback to 24.0 format."

    "So, in the case of most SigmaDSPs, audio representation is represented with A = 5 and B = 23. In other words, the number format is 5.23. Control signals and index table values generally require integer representation, and are therefore represented with A = 28 and B = 0. In other words, the format is 28.0."

  2. DeepSeek Assistant

    Based on your description, the Signal Detection flag alternates between 1.0 and 0.0 in the DSP Readback, which is set to 5.19 format.

    Key Observations:

    1. The flag output behaves like a boolean (0 or 1) but is being read back in 5.19 format (a fractional format).
    2. Since the DSP internally represents control signals (flags, triggers, etc.) as 28.0 integers, but the readback is forced into 5.19, the actual flag output is likely 28.0 format (as per SigmaDSP conventions for control signals).
    3. The fact that you see 1.0 and 0.0 in the readback suggests that the 5.19 format is simply interpreting the 28.0 integer as a fractional value (since 1 in 28.0 is 1.0 in 5.19, and 0 is 0.0).

    Recommended Wiki Entry:

    Since the flag itself is a control signal, it should be documented as 28.0 format (integer), even though the readback is set to 5.19.

    Updated Wiki Entry:

    Name                Format [int/dec] - [control/audio]   Function Description  
    Pin 0: Trigger      28.0 - control                       Outputs a flag (1 or 0) after no signal has been present for a given amount of time.  
    

    Additional Notes:

    • The readback format (5.19) is just how the DSP displays the value, not necessarily the internal format of the flag.
    • If the readback were set to 24.0 (instead of 5.19), you would see 1 and 0 directly (no fractional part).
    • The 28.0 format is standard for control signals in SigmaDSP, even if the readback is fractional.

    This ensures consistency with SigmaDSP documentation while clarifying that the flag itself is an integer control signal.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.