Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
grok-3-mini-beta· xAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

can we prioritize more by price? I moreso want to find the cheapest tires that are past…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o3-mini’s answer.
  1. User

    can we prioritize more by price? I moreso want to find the cheapest tires that are past a sound threshold for winter safety and similar factors. I cant remember really noticing anything else with other tires I have owned, so I don't care as much for gimmicks (unless they cause serious negative side affects that are likely to be noticeable). rerank based on this. That said, you are free to use your discretion if there are solid reasons for why a given tire should not be recommended. Additionally, I don't have a Costco membership but give me your rankings on the best places to look at for tire prices and installs.

  2. Assistant

    Below, I'll re-rank the top 15 tires from my previous recommendations based on your updated priorities. Specifically:

    • Prioritizing Price: I'll sort primarily by the estimated set price (lowest first), then by cost per mile (¢/mile) as a tiebreaker. This focuses on the cheapest options that still meet a "sound threshold" for winter safety in northern Utah. By "sound threshold," I mean tires that provide:

      • Adequate snow and ice traction (preferably with the 3PMSF symbol for severe snow capability, but I'll include M+S tires with strong owner reviews in real-world Intermountain West conditions if they don't have obvious safety drawbacks).
      • No major noticeable negatives (e.g., excessive noise, poor handling, or high risk of flats/blowouts that could lead to real issues like vibrations or reduced control).
    • Discretion Applied: I'm excluding or de-prioritizing tires that might not meet your threshold based on potential risks:

      • For example, I won't recommend tires with poor winter traction reports (e.g., if they're only "adequate" and could lead to noticeable skidding in fresh snow, which is common in northern Utah).
      • From the original list, I removed or lowered tires like the Continental PureContact LS (decent but not standout in snow) and Falken Sincera SN250 A/S (cheap but with reports of mushy handling in winter, which could be a noticeable negative).
      • This leaves us with 12 solid options that balance cheapness and safety. I didn't force it to 15 if they don't qualify—better to be conservative.

    The result is a list focused on value-driven, no-frills tires that are safe enough for year-round use without unnecessary gimmicks. Prices are still estimates for a set of four (e.g., size 205/55R16), installed at a typical shop (more on that below).

    Re-Ranked Top 12 Tires (Prioritizing Cheapest First, with Safety Threshold)

    Here's the re-ranked list. I focused on tires that are reliable, have good basic performance, and won't cause noticeable issues like harsh rides or frequent flats. All selected tires have at least adequate winter grip based on reviews, but I prioritized those with 3PMSF for your location.

    #Tire & Winter BadgeMileage WarrantyMy “Real-World” Life*Est. Set Price¢ / mile†Why It Made The List
    1Kumho Solus TA31 (M+S)‡60 k48 k$4000.83Cheapest option that still handles UT winters well enough—good traction on plowed roads, no major complaints about noise or wear. Basic and reliable without extras.
    2General Altimax RT43 (M+S)‡65 k52 k$4500.87Solid value pick with strong owner reports in snowy areas; quiet and durable. Lacks 3PMSF but passes your threshold for safety—won’t notice any gimmick downsides.
    3Hankook Kinergy 4S2 (H750) (3PMSF)60 k48 k$5001.04Affordable with excellent all-around grip; low rolling resistance means better fuel economy without any noticeable negatives. A step up in safety for the price.
    4Cooper CS5 Ultra Touring (M+S)‡70 k56 k$5000.89Very quiet and long-lasting for the cost; adequate snow performance on cleared roads. No frills, just dependable—ideal if you want cheap without surprises.
    5Vredestein Quatrac Pro (3PMSF)50 k40 k$5301.33Balances price and 3PMSF safety; good snow bite without overcomplicating things. Real-world life matches your car’s timeline, so no wasted longevity.
    6Pirelli Cinturato All-Season Plus II (M+S)‡70 k56 k$5400.96Fuel-efficient and grippy enough for winter; no noticeable road noise or handling issues. It’s basic but safe—a good mid-cheap option with occasional rebates.
    7Toyo Celsius (3PMSF)60 k48 k$5501.15Aggressive winter pattern for better snow evacuation; still comfortable on dry roads. Cheaper than pricier 3PMSF tires and won’t introduce negatives like vibration.
    8BFGoodrich Advantage T/A Sport (Weather-Rated) (3PMSF)60 k48 k$5501.14Sporty feel without gimmicks; strong in snow and ice. If you value a slight edge in handling for the price, this is a safe bet—rebates often make it even cheaper.
    9Nokian WR G4 (3PMSF)60 k48 k$5601.17From winter experts; excellent hydroplaning resistance. It’s straightforward and safe, though a bit numb—worth it for the price if snow is frequent.
    10Firestone WeatherGrip (3PMSF)65 k52 k$5601.08Tough casing resists potholes, with solid ice performance. No major downsides reported—just reliable winter safety at a reasonable cost.
    11Bridgestone WeatherPeak (3PMSF)70 k56 k$6001.07A bit more expensive but justifies with strong traction; quiet and predictable. Only here because it’s a safe upgrade without noticeable negatives.
    12Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady (3PMSF)60 k48 k$6001.25Good slush/ice control; often has rebates that drop it closer to $500. It’s basic safety-focused without extras that could backfire.

    * “Real-World Life” = Assumes ~80% of the warranty, based on typical driver experiences.
    \† ¢/mile = Price ÷ Real-World Life × 100. Rounded to nearest 0.01¢.
    \‡ Lacks 3PMSF but has strong winter reviews in areas like northern Utah; included because they meet your "sound threshold" without risks.

    Why Only 12? I dropped the rest (e.g., Michelin CrossClimate2, Falken Sincera) because they either exceed your price focus or have potential negatives (e.g., Falken's softer handling in snow could lead to noticeable instability). If you want more options, we can revisit, but this keeps it to truly budget-friendly yet safe choices.

    Key Shopping Tips for Finding the Best Deals

    Since you don't have a Costco membership, I'll rank the best places to search for tire prices and installations based on affordability, availability, and reliability. These are tailored for someone prioritizing cheap, no-frills service. Focus on comparing "out-the-door" prices (including installation, mounting, balancing, and any TPMS fees—expect $15–25 per tire for basics).

    Ranked Best Places to Look:

    1. Discount Tire (Top Recommendation):

      • Why: Hands down the best for budget shoppers—low prices, frequent rebates (e.g., $50–100 off sets), and free services like lifetime rotations and road hazard warranties. They have a huge inventory and excellent install quality. Search their site or app for local deals; they often beat online competitors.
      • Pros: Transparent pricing, easy online quotes, and nationwide locations. Great for your sedan—quick installs with alignment options (~80–80–100 extra, which I still recommend).
      • Cons: Might not always have the absolute cheapest off-brand tires, but their perks make up for it.
      • How to Use: Start here for Kumho or General Altimax; check for current promos on their website.
    2. Walmart:

      • Why: Super affordable prices on tires like Kumho or Hankook, plus in-store installations starting at $15–20 per tire. They partner with TireRack for variety, and you can often find clearance deals.
      • Pros: Walk-in convenience, low overhead costs mean cheaper installs, and they handle alignments affordably. Good for quick, no-fuss service.
      • Cons: Limited selection of premium brands; installations might not be as thorough as specialized shops.
      • How to Use: Use Walmart's online tire finder to compare prices, then visit a store for install. Look for seasonal sales (e.g., fall/winter).
    3. TireRack (Online-First):

      • Why: Excellent for finding the cheapest online prices and shipping tires to a local installer. They have detailed reviews to confirm safety thresholds, and you can filter by price.
      • Pros: Often $20–50 cheaper per set than in-store, with free shipping to installers. Use their "buy and ship" option for tires like Pirelli or Toyo.
      • Cons: You'll need to arrange installation separately (e.g., at a local shop), which adds a step.
      • How to Use: Search for your tire size and the models above; they show real-time pricing and rebates. Pair with a local installer for ~$75 total install cost.
    4. SimpleTire (Online):

      • Why: Another solid online option for budget tires, with prices often matching or beating Walmart. They focus on value brands and ship quickly.
      • Pros: Easy rebate tracking and a wide range of cheap options (e.g., Kumho at 350–350–380). Good for comparing against Discount Tire.
      • Cons: Like TireRack, installation isn't included—you'll need a local shop.
      • How to Use: Use their site to get quotes, then have tires delivered to a nearby mechanic for install.
    5. Local Auto Shops (e.g., Pep Boys, Midas, or Independent Mechanics):

      • Why: These are good for installs if you find tires elsewhere (e.g., online). They often match prices and handle basics cheaply.
      • Pros: Flexible scheduling, and they might offer bundle deals (e.g., tires + alignment for $100 off). Useful for off-brand tires.
      • Cons: Prices can vary widely; avoid if they add hidden fees.
      • How to Use: Buy tires from TireRack or SimpleTire, then bring them here for install. Call ahead for quotes on your top tires.

    General Advice for Hunting Deals:

    • When to Shop: Target October/November (pre-winter) or April/May for the best rebates. Use sites like Discount Tire's rebate page or Google for "current tire deals" on your top models.
    • How to Compare: Always add in installation/alignment costs (~80–80–100 total) when calculating true price. For example, if Kumho is $400 at Discount Tire with free install, that's your winner.
    • Budget Tip: Aim for tires in the top 5–8 here—they're the cheapest while staying above your safety threshold. If a deal drops a tire's price (e.g., Kumho to $350), jump on it.
    • Final Reminder: Don't skimp on alignment during install; it's cheap insurance for even wear and safety, especially with your car's mileage.

    This re-ranked list should make it easy to search for deals. Let me know if you need more details on any tire or place!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt