Skip to content
The Chat Archive
o3-mini· OpenAI LMArena Human Preference 140K

can we prioritize more by price? I moreso want to find the cheapest tires that are past…

  1. User

    can we prioritize more by price? I moreso want to find the cheapest tires that are past a sound threshold for winter safety and similar factors. I cant remember really noticing anything else with other tires I have owned, so I don't care as much for gimmicks (unless they cause serious negative side affects that are likely to be noticeable). rerank based on this. That said, you are free to use your discretion if there are solid reasons for why a given tire should not be recommended. Additionally, I don't have a Costco membership but give me your rankings on the best places to look at for tire prices and installs.

  2. Assistant

    Below is a ranked list of 15 tire options—from the lowest‐priced to the higher‐priced—provided they meet a “sound” minimum for winter safety. In other words, these tires are either all‑season models with proven winter performance (many even have the Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake “3PMSF” certification) or have solid owner‐reports in northern Utah winters. (Do note that a few of the very cheapest options are “M+S” only; many drivers in your region find them perfectly acceptable, but if you want the added confidence of a true winter–rated tire, check the ones marked with “3PMSF.”)

    Below is an estimated “set of four” price (including mounting and balancing at a discount shop—not a Costco sale, since you mentioned you don’t have a membership) along with notes on each. (Prices will vary by promotions, region, and installer—but these serve as useful targets when comparing deals online.)


    Top 15 Budget-Conscious, Winter-Safe Tires

    RankTireWinter RatingEst. Set PriceNotes
    1Kumho Solus TA31M+S (no 3PMSF badge)~$400The absolute cheapest option from a major OE supplier. Owners in northern Utah report acceptable winter traction on mostly plowed roads.
    2General Altimax RT43M+S (excellent owner reports in UT/CO)~$450A perennial value champion. Although not marked 3PMSF, it’s popular where winters are moderate to severe and stands up well to the cold.
    3Falken Sincera SN250 A/SM+S~$480Excellent “cost per mile” and refinement. It trades a bit of aggressive snow bite for saving money—but reviews suggest it stays safe and predictable.
    4Hankook Kinergy 4S23PMSF~$500The lowest–priced tire on this list with the recognized 3PMSF certification. Provides extra assurance for icy or unplowed conditions.
    5Cooper CS5 Ultra TouringM+S~$500A U.S.–made option noted for quiet, reliable performance in winter conditions on plowed roads.
    6Vredestein Quatrac Pro3PMSF~$530A European performance–oriented all-weather tire. Offers genuine winter capability with the 3PMSF badge, while its tread life aligns with a lower–mile horizon.
    7Pirelli Cinturato All-Season Plus IIM+S~$540Good wet braking and low rolling resistance. It’s a tad more expensive than some budget picks but balances performance with fuel economy.
    8Toyo Celsius3PMSF~$550An aggressive winter–pattern tire that acts as a “mild” snow tire. It’s a solid choice if you can grab a deal.
    9BFGoodrich Advantage T/A Sport (Weather-Rated)3PMSF~$550Offers sporty handling along with 3PMSF certification. Rebates are sometimes available, so watch for extra savings.
    10Firestone WeatherGrip3PMSF~$560A sleeper hit with excellent ice traction per tests. Its robust casing also helps reduce the risk of pothole damage.
    11Nokian WR G43PMSF~$560Coming from a brand famed for winter expertise, it offers superb hydro and snow evacuation. Slight tradeoffs on steering feel may be noticed.
    12Bridgestone WeatherPeak3PMSF~$600A newer all-weather design with long tread–warranty and excellent snow‐and–ice performance—ideal if you find a bargain.
    13Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady3PMSF~$600A tire that performs predictably in winter conditions and often carries rebates. It’s a solid mid–pack pick when safety is paramount.
    14Continental PureContact LSM+S~$620Outstanding on wet and dry roads, though its snow traction is only “good.” Better suited if you’re in more urban or well–cleared areas.
    15Michelin CrossClimate23PMSF~$650The premium option from Michelin. Best for those who want top–notch winter performance and are willing to pay extra; however, it is more than most budgets require given your usage horizon.

    * A Note on “M+S” vs. “3PMSF”:
    While M+S (Mud and Snow) ratings are acceptable in regions with routine plowing and moderate winter conditions, the 3PMSF symbol is the gold standard if you face extended periods of severe winter weather or wish for added peace of mind. For northern Utah winters, many drivers have used the M+S models (like the Altimax RT43 or Kumho TA31) without incident, but if you expect frequent icy patches or unplowed roads, opt for one of the 3PMSF–rated options (e.g., Hankook Kinergy 4S2 or Vredestein Quatrac Pro).


    Where to Look for Tire Prices and Installs When You Don’t Have Costco

    Since you don’t have a Costco membership, here are some alternative retailers known for competitive pricing and professional installations:

    1. Discount Tire (also known as America's Tire):

      • Frequently has promotions and free services (like rotations and balancing). Their prices are very competitive; you can often negotiate or use coupons.
    2. Walmart Auto Tire Centers:

      • Offer low prices with straightforward installation fees (typically around $15 per tire). They sometimes run seasonal promotions and rebates.
    3. Tire Rack or SimpleTire:

      • These online retailers offer excellent deals and user reviews. They’ll ship tires to a local installer, and you can compare multiple local shop installation fees online.
    4. Local Tire Shops / Independent Workshops:

      • Many local establishments have competitive pricing and may offer free alignment checks or giveaways with a tire purchase. It may be worth calling a few to get quotes.
    5. National Chains (e.g., Firestone, Goodyear):

      • While often a bit pricier, they frequently have online promotions, rebates, or financing deals that can narrow the price gap.

    Tip: When comparing deals, always factor in the “out-the-door” price—including mounting, balancing, TPMS sensor service (if needed), and any alignment (if required). Given your mileage and winter concerns, it’s wise to budget around an extra 80–80–100 for a four-wheel alignment if you haven’t had one recently.


    Final Thoughts

    If your primary goal is to spend as little as possible while ensuring that winter safety is not compromised:

    • For Maximum Budget Savings:
      • Kumho Solus TA31 (<400)or∗∗GeneralAltimaxRT43∗∗( 400) or **General Altimax RT43** (~450) — Both have proven safe in many northern Utah winters, though they lack the 3PMSF badge.
    • For 3PMSF Certification on a Budget:
      • Hankook Kinergy 4S2 (~$500) is your best bet.

    Use the list above to scout current deals online and call local installers to compare “total installed” prices. Happy hunting—and safe driving this winter!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.