dsotm has a few moments that are very much skippable, and the wall, shit devolves too…
- User
dsotm has a few moments that are very much skippable, and the wall, shit devolves too much to non-music. animals and wish you were here are much more refined
- Assistant
I can see where you're coming from on Dark Side of the Moon - while it's iconic, tracks like "On the Run" and "Any Colour You Like" can feel more like sonic experiments than fully realized songs. They work as part of the album's flow, but on their own they're not as compelling as the major tracks.
The Wall definitely suffers from bloat. By the time you hit disc two, there's a lot of filler between the memorable moments. Songs like "Bring the Boys Back Home" and "Vera" feel more like Roger Waters' therapy session than essential Pink Floyd tracks. The concept is ambitious but it needed editing.
Animals and Wish You Were Here do feel tighter as complete albums. Animals especially - every track serves its purpose, and the three main suites are all killer with no real weak spots. "Dogs" might be 17 minutes but every minute earns its place. And Wish You Were Here has that perfect balance of accessibility and experimentation without losing focus.
What do you think of Meddle in this context? It's got its own pacing issues with "Seamus" but "Echoes" alone might make up for it.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.