dsotm has a few moments that are very much skippable, and the wall, shit devolves too…
- User
dsotm has a few moments that are very much skippable, and the wall, shit devolves too much to non-music. animals and wish you were here are much more refined
- Assistant
I totally get where you're coming from with your thoughts on Pink Floyd's discography—it's always interesting to hear different takes on these classics! Pink Floyd's albums can be polarizing because of their experimental nature, and it's fair to say that not every moment hits the mark for everyone. Let me break this down a bit based on what you said and share some context, while keeping it spoiler-free for anyone who hasn't dived deep.
On Dark Side of the Moon (DSOTM):
You're right that it has some skippable moments for certain listeners. The album is a masterpiece for many, but its ambient and atmospheric sections (like parts of "On the Run" or the spoken-word bits in "Brain Damage") can feel drawn out if you're not in the mood for that kind of prog-rock introspection. It's designed as a cohesive experience, almost like a sonic journey, but I can see how that might not land for everyone on repeat listens.
On The Wall:
Oof, yeah, "shit devolves too much to non-music" is a strong way to put it, and I won't argue against your experience. The album is essentially a rock opera with a lot of narrative elements, including dialogue, sound effects, and minimalistic passages that prioritize storytelling over traditional song structures. Tracks like "Another Brick in the Wall" are iconic, but the overall concept can feel overly theatrical or experimental to the point where it strays from what people expect as "music." It's one of those albums that's more of an event than a straight listen, which might explain why it doesn't click for you.
On Animals and Wish You Were Here:
I'm with you on these being more refined. Animals (1977) is a tighter, more focused album with a clear concept inspired by George Orwell's Animal Farm, and its rock-heavy sound (think gritty guitar work on tracks like "Dogs") makes it feel less meandering. Similarly, Wish You Were Here (1975) is often praised for its emotional depth and polished production—it's got those epic, guitar-driven suites like "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" that balance experimentation with accessibility. They both have a sense of refinement that makes them stand out as more straightforward yet profound entries in Pink Floyd's catalog.
If you're looking for more albums in that vein, I'd recommend checking out Meddle (1971) for its blend of experimentation and solid rock vibes, or even The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967) for Syd Barrett's psychedelic influence, though it's a bit more chaotic. What specifically do you think makes Animals and Wish You Were Here stand out for you? Or have you explored any other Pink Floyd albums that you love or hate? I'd love to hear more! 😊
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.