Skip to content
The Chat Archive

Side-by-side comparison

Both conversations start with the same prompt. Responses were generated in different, uncontrolled contexts. This is not a benchmark.
First prompt

Provide a design for a disk topology for a NAS built on TrueNAS Scale, as well as a dataset layout. The available disks are as follows:

  • 2x 18TB disks
  • 5x 14TB disks
  • 3x 12TB disk
  • 4x 8TB disks
  • 2x 120GB disks
  • 2x SLOW 8TB drives

There are 17 drive bays available. The two smallest disks are to be used for a mirrored pool that servers as a boot device. The two slow drives are SMR disks that will be used in their own pool to provide a Time Machine target for some Macs. The two 18TB disks will be in their own pool and will serve as a backup target for the main pool (or some subset of it.)

You are asked to design the topology. The data being stored includes video files, music files, disk images, archived software, photos, and some text files. While much of the data could be recreated or downloaded, some of it is impossible to replace. You may leave bays available for a hot spare or to allow for future expansion. I prefer not to use RAIDZ, as mirrored arrays rebuild faster.

My main priorities are redundancy to reduce the risk of data loss, cost efficiency, and space efficiency. Raw performance is not a significant concern.

If you need more information before creating your design, please provide me with a short questionnaire.

gpt-4-0314· OpenAI WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Based on your requirements and available disks, below is the proposed design for the disk topology and dataset layout.

Disk Topology:

  1. Boot Pool: 2x 120GB disks in a mirrored pool (120GB usable)
  2. Main Pool:
    • 2x 8TB disks in a mirrored vdev (8TB usable)
    • 5x 14TB disks, configured as 2 mirrored vdevs: 2x14TB vdev (14TB usable) and 3x14TB vdev (28TB usable)
    • 3x 12TB disks in a mirrored vdev (12TB usable)
  3. Backup Pool: 2x 18TB disks in a mirrored pool (18TB usable)
  4. Time Machine Pool: 2x SLOW 8TB disks in a mirrored pool (8TB usable)

Total usable space: 70TB

Dataset Layout:

  1. Main Pool:
    • /music for music files
    • /video for video files
    • /photos for photos
    • /disk_images for disk images
    • /archived_software for archived software
    • /text_files for text files
  2. Backup Pool:
    • /backup as a backup target for the main pool or selected datasets
  3. Time Machine Pool:
    • /time_machine for the Time Machine target for your Macs

This design achieves redundancy with multiple mirrored configurations for the main pool, as well as dedicated backup and Time Machine pools. The dataset layout allows for easier organization and management of your files.

If you have any concerns or further questions, feel free to ask.

gpt-4-0314· OpenAI WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Design for Disk Topology:

  1. Boot Pool:

    • 2x 120GB disks (mirrored)
  2. Main Pool:

    • 5x 14TB disks (mirrored pairs + one hot spare)
    • 3x 12TB disks (mirrored pair + one hot spare)
    • 4x 8TB disks (two mirrored pairs)
  3. Backup Pool:

    • 2x 18TB disks (mirrored)
  4. Time Machine Pool:

    • 2x SLOW 8TB drives (mirrored)

Dataset Layout:

  1. Main Pool:

    • Dataset 1: Videos
    • Dataset 2: Music
    • Dataset 3: Disk Images
    • Dataset 4: Archived Software
    • Dataset 5: Photos
    • Dataset 6: Text Files
  2. Backup Pool:

    • Backup Datasets (subset or full duplication of Main Pool Datasets, based on priority)
  3. Time Machine Pool:

    • Time Machine target for Macs

Questionnaire:

  1. How much data storage capacity do you currently require for each type of data (videos, music, disk images, archived software, photos, text files)?
  2. What is the expected growth rate of your data storage requirements?
  3. Are there any specific data types that require more frequent backups or high-speed access?
  4. What is your budget for this NAS setup?
  5. Are there any other specific requirements or constraints to consider when designing the NAS topology?

Sign in to record which response you prefer.