Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Grok 4.1 Fast· xaiHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Design a computational reproducibility rubric: environment capture, seeds, provenance,…

  1. User

    Design a computational reproducibility rubric: environment capture, seeds, provenance, and review artifacts.

  2. Assistant

    Computational Reproducibility Rubric

    Purpose

    This rubric evaluates the reproducibility of computational experiments (e.g., in machine learning, simulations, data analysis). It assesses four core pillars: Environment Capture (software/hardware setup), Seeds (stochastic reproducibility), Provenance (data and computation lineage), and Review Artifacts (verification materials).

    Scoring Scale (per criterion):

    • 4 (Excellent): Fully meets/exceeds best practices; enables bit-for-bit reproduction.
    • 3 (Good): Meets standards; reproduction likely with minor effort.
    • 2 (Fair): Partial compliance; reproduction possible but error-prone.
    • 1 (Poor): Minimal compliance; reproduction unlikely.
    • 0 (None): Absent or misleading.

    Total Score: Sum of all criteria (max 100 points).
    Thresholds: ≥90 = Excellent; 75-89 = Good; 50-74 = Fair; <50 = Poor.

    Use this rubric for self-assessment, peer review, or publication checklists. Provide evidence (e.g., links/files) for scores.

    1. Environment Capture (25 points max)

    Ensures the exact runtime environment is replicable, minimizing "it works on my machine" issues.

    CriterionDescriptionScore (0-4)Evidence
    Dependency SpecificationAll software deps (e.g., Python/R version, libraries) listed precisely (e.g., requirements.txt, environment.yml). No version ranges.
    Containerization/VirtualizationEnvironment fully containerized (Docker/Podman) or virtualized (Conda/Venv) with a shareable image/file. Includes hardware specs (CPU/GPU, RAM).
    OS & System-Level CaptureOS version, kernel, and system tools (e.g., via Dockerfile or singularity.def) specified. Reproducible on multiple platforms tested.
    Reproducibility TestInstructions + script to rebuild env and run a smoke test (e.g., docker run --rm myimage python -c "import numpy; print(numpy.__version__)").
    Subtotal/16

    Notes: Bonus +9 points if env auto-builds from a Git repo (e.g., GitHub Actions badge).

    2. Seeds (25 points max)

    Controls randomness for deterministic outputs in stochastic code (e.g., ML training, sampling).

    CriterionDescriptionScore (0-4)Evidence
    Seed DeclarationAll random sources seeded explicitly (e.g., numpy.random.seed(42), torch.manual_seed(42), random.seed(42)). Covers NumPy, PyTorch/TensorFlow, Python random, OS RNG.
    Global/Per-Module SeedsSeeds set globally at script start and per-module (e.g., CUDA, multiprocessing). Environment vars used for overrides.
    Multi-Run VerificationCode runs ≥3 times with same seed yields identical outputs (e.g., hashes match). Tested and logged.
    Seed DocumentationSeeds listed in README with rationale (e.g., "42 for universality"). Instructions to set PYTHONHASHSEED=0.
    Subtotal/16

    Notes: Bonus +9 points if seeds are configurable via CLI/args with defaults.

    3. Provenance (25 points max)

    Tracks data origins, transformations, and computation history for auditability.

    CriterionDescriptionScore (0-4)Evidence
    Data ProvenanceAll inputs (datasets, models) cited with URLs/hashes (SHA256). Raw data accessible; no "email me for data."
    Computation LineageWorkflow graph (e.g., via MLflow, DVC, or Jupyter provenance) logs steps, params, intermediates. Git commit pinned.
    Version Control IntegrationCode/data versioned in Git (or DVC). pip freeze or lockfile included. Repro instructions use exact commit.
    Output ProvenanceFinal results include metadata (e.g., JSON with hashes, params). Tamper-evident (e.g., signed artifacts).
    Subtotal/16

    Notes: Bonus +9 points if uses standards like RO-Crate or W3C PROV.

    4. Review Artifacts (25 points max)

    Provides verifiable materials for independent review/reproduction.

    CriterionDescriptionScore (0-4)Evidence
    Code & InstructionsSelf-contained repo with README.md: one-command repro (e.g., make repro). No external depedencies beyond env.
    Executable Notebooks/ScriptsInteractive artifacts (e.g., nbconvert to HTML/PDF, Binder/Colab link) showing inputs → outputs.
    Expected OutputsChecksums/hashes for all outputs (e.g., md5sum results.csv). Diffable baselines.
    Review ScriptAutomated checker (e.g., repro-test.py) that fails on mismatch. Runtime <1hr on standard hardware.
    Subtotal/16

    Notes: Bonus +9 points if hosted reproducibly (e.g., Zenodo DOI, Binder badge).

    Usage Guidelines

    • Assessor Instructions: Score based on provided materials. Require hyperlinks to artifacts.
    • Improvement Tips:
      Score RangeAction
      90-100Publish as-is.
      75-89Fix partial items.
      50-74Major env/provenance gaps; rebuild.
      <50Start over with tools like Cookiecutter or ReproZip.
    • Tools Recommendations: Docker, DVC, MLflow, Weights & Biases, Papers with Code reproducibility stamps.

    This rubric aligns with standards from ACM, NeurIPS, and ReScience. Total: /100. Comments: ________________

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.