Help me institute an AI vendor intake tribunal: risk scoring rubric, documentation…
- User
Help me institute an AI vendor intake tribunal: risk scoring rubric, documentation checklist, hearing cadence, remediation playbooks, escalation ladders, and board transparency briefings.
- Assistant
AI Vendor Intake Tribunal Framework
As Sherlock, I've deduced a comprehensive, scalable framework for your AI vendor intake tribunal. This "tribunal" acts as a governance body to evaluate, approve, monitor, and mitigate risks from AI vendors. It ensures rigorous due diligence while streamlining operations.
I've structured it into the requested components: Risk Scoring Rubric, Documentation Checklist, Hearing Cadence, Remediation Playbooks, Escalation Ladders, and Board Transparency Briefings. Implement this as a living document (e.g., in Notion, Confluence, or Google Docs) with version control and assigned owners.
1. Risk Scoring Rubric
A quantitative rubric to score vendors on a 0-100 scale (0 = negligible risk, 100 = existential threat). Weight categories by organizational priorities (e.g., adjust for regulated industries). Thresholds: <30 = Approve; 30-60 = Conditional Approve (with remediation); >60 = Reject/Escalate.
Category Weight Criteria Scoring (0-10 per sub-criteria) Max Score Security & Data Privacy (30%) 30 - Encryption in transit/rest- Vulnerability scans/pen tests- GDPR/CCPA/SOX compliance- Data residency Evidence-based: Full (10), Partial (5), None (0) 30 Model Reliability & Performance (25%) 25 - Accuracy/robustness benchmarks- Bias/fairness audits- Hallucination/drift detection- Uptime SLAs (>99.9%) Benchmarks: Exceeds (10), Meets (7), Below (3), Fail (0) 25 Ethical & Regulatory Alignment (20%) 20 - Model cards/transparency reports- Alignment with AI ethics (e.g., NIST, EU AI Act)- IP ownership/clarity- Third-party audits Alignment: Full (10), Partial (5), Gaps (2), Non-compliant (0) 20 Business & Operational (15%) 15 - Financial stability (e.g., funding runway)- Contract terms (exit clauses, indemnity)- Scalability/support SLAs- Vendor lock-in risk Viability: Strong (10), Adequate (6), Weak (2), High-risk (0) 15 Geopolitical & Supply Chain (10%) 10 - Jurisdiction risks (e.g., sanctions)- Dependency on restricted tech (e.g., chips)- Open-source vs. proprietary risks Exposure: Low (10), Medium (5), High (0) 10 Total 100 Final Score = Sum (Weighted) 100 Usage: Tribunal scores collaboratively during hearings. Include rationale notes for audits.
2. Documentation Checklist
Mandatory submission pre-hearing. Vendors get this 2 weeks prior. Use a shared portal (e.g., DocuSign or Airtable) for uploads. Incomplete = auto-reject.
-
Core Legal/Contractual:
- Signed MSA/SOW with SLAs (99.9% uptime, response times)
- Indemnification for IP, data breaches, hallucinations
- Data processing agreement (DPA)
- SOC 2 Type II / ISO 27001 audit reports (last 12 months)
-
Technical & Model:
- Model card (inputs/outputs, training data summary, limitations)
- Bias/robustness evaluation reports
- API docs with rate limits/error handling
- Incident history (last 24 months)
-
Security & Compliance:
- Penetration test results
- Vulnerability management policy
- Third-party risk assessment (if sub-vendors used)
-
Business:
- Financials: Last funding round, burn rate, customer references
- Exit strategy: Data export/portability plan
- Roadmap: 12-month feature/upgrade plan
Red Flags: Redacted docs, >6 months old, or no independent audits → Immediate hearing deferral.
3. Hearing Cadence
Standardized schedule to balance throughput and rigor. Tribunal = 5-7 members (e.g., CISO, Legal, AI Ethics Lead, Procurement, Exec Sponsor).
Type Frequency Duration Trigger Agenda Routine Intake Bi-weekly (e.g., 1st/3rd Wed) 60-90 min New vendors scoring <60 Review rubric, vote, assign conditions High-Risk Review Ad-hoc (within 48 hrs) 120 min Score >60 or red flags Deep-dive Q&A with vendor reps Remediation Check-in Monthly 45 min Conditional approvals Progress on playbooks Quarterly Retrospective Q1-Q4 2 hrs All active vendors Trends, scorecard updates Emergency As-needed (<24 hrs) 30 min Breach/incident Pause/terminate Tools: Zoom + shared scorecard (Google Sheets/Slack bot for voting).
4. Remediation Playbooks
Tiered playbooks for post-hearing actions. Assign owner + deadlines. Track in Jira/Trello.
Risk Tier Examples Playbook Steps Timeline Low (Score <30) Minor doc gaps 1. Vendor submits missing items2. Quick re-score3. Approve 5 days Medium (30-60) Partial compliance 1. Issue remediation letter2. Weekly check-ins3. Third-party audit if needed4. Re-hearing 30 days High (>60) Security gaps, ethics flags 1. Pause procurement2. Vendor fixes + evidence3. Independent validation4. Escalate if unresolved 60 days Critical Active breach risk 1. Immediate quarantine2. Legal review for termination3. Alternative vendor scout 7 days Template: "Issue: [Description]. Owner: [Name]. Milestone 1: [Action] by [Date]. Metrics: [Success Criteria]."
5. Escalation Ladders
Clear paths to prevent siloed risks. Notify via Slack/Email + log in central dashboard.
Risk Level Escalate To Criteria Actions Level 1 Tribunal Lead Routine delays Weekly status update Level 2 Dept Heads (Legal, Security, AI) Medium remediation overdue Joint review meeting Level 3 C-suite (CIO, GC, CRO) High-risk unresolved (>30 days) Stop-work order Level 4 Board Audit/Risk Committee Critical risks or >$1M exposure Full briefing (see below) Level 5 Full Board/Regulators Breaches, legal violations Crisis comms + disclosure Rationale Log: Always document "why" for escalations.
6. Board Transparency Briefings
Quarterly + ad-hoc briefs to maintain oversight. Format: 1-page dashboard + 10-min verbal.
Standard Template (Google Slides/PowerBI):
-
Executive Summary: # Vendors reviewed (e.g., 15Q), Approval rate (80%), Avg score (42).
-
Key Metrics Dashboard:
Metric Q1 Q2 Trend Avg Risk Score 45 38 ↓ High-Risk Rejects 3 1 ↓ Remediation Success 90% 95% ↑ Total Exposure ($M) 5.2 4.8 ↓ -
Hotspots: Top 3 risks (e.g., "Vendor X: Bias in hiring model → Remediated").
-
Pipeline: Upcoming hearings, watchlist vendors.
-
Recommendations: Policy tweaks (e.g., "Add watermarking req.").
Cadence: Quarterly board pack (5 days pre-meeting) + immediate for Level 4+ escalations.
This framework is battle-tested in spirit—logical, auditable, and adaptive. Start with a pilot on 3 vendors to refine. Need templates, automation scripts, or customization? The game is afoot—provide details.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.