Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Step 3.5 Flash· unknownHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

You are given a 2D grid of integers. Write a function to find the size of the largest…

  1. User

    You are given a 2D grid of integers. Write a function to find the size of the largest "plus sign" of 1s. A plus sign is made of a central 1 and four arms of equal length of 1s. Please write a function that solves this problem, explain your algorithm. A dynamic programming approach is common, where you pre-compute the lengths of consecutive 1s in each of the four directions for every cell, and what is the time and space complexity of your solution.

  2. Assistant

    We need to solve the problem: Given a 2D grid (matrix) of integers (presumably containing 0s and 1s), find the size of the largest plus sign of 1s. A plus sign is defined as a central 1 and four arms of equal length of 1s. The "size" of the plus sign is the length of each arm (including the center? Usually the size is the number of 1s in one arm? Let's clarify. In standard problems (LeetCode 764: Largest Plus Sign), the size is defined as the order of the plus sign, which is the length of each arm (including the center). So the total number of 1s in the plus is (order * 4 - 1). But the problem says: "largest 'plus sign' of 1s. A plus sign is made of a central 1 and four arms of equal length of 1s." It doesn't explicitly say whether the arm length includes the center. Typically, the central point is counted as part of each arm? Actually, the arms emanate from the center, so if you have an arm length k, that means there are k consecutive 1s in that direction from the center, not counting the center? But often the definition: the plus sign of order k consists of a central point and four arms each of length k-1 (if you count the center in each arm? Wait). Let's recall LeetCode 764: "In a 2D grid of 0s and 1s, we can define a plus sign as a subgrid with at least one 1 such that all entries in the plus sign are 1. The plus sign is defined by the center cell and four arms of length k (each arm goes from the center to one of the four directions: up, down, left, right). The order of the plus is k+1? Actually they define: "The order of the largest plus sign is the maximum length of the arm such that the plus sign of that order exists." They say: "The arm length is the number of cells in the arm, including the center." So if you have order 3, each arm has length 3, meaning center + 2 cells outward? That would be total cells = 1 + 42 = 9? Actually if each arm length includes the center, then the arms overlap at the center; total unique cells = 1 + 4(arm_length-1). For arm_length = 3, total = 1+4*2=9. That's typical. But many solutions define dp[i][j][direction] as the number of consecutive 1s in that direction, including cell (i,j). Then the plus size at (i,j) is min of the four directions. That yields the order (arm length) including the center. So we can use that.

    Thus we need to compute for each cell, the number of consecutive 1s in up, down, left, right directions. Then the largest plus size = max over cells of min(up, down, left, right). That's the answer (if arm length includes the center). If the problem expects the total number of 1s, we can multiply accordingly. But we can present as order.

    Now algorithm: We can do DP in two passes: first compute left and right in one pass? Actually we need four directions. Common approach:

    Initialize dp[i][j] to large number, but we can store four arrays: up[i][j], down[i][j], left[i][j], right[i][j]. Or we can combine into one dp[i][j] that holds min of four, but need to compute each direction separately.

    Approach:

    • For each cell (i,j):
      • if grid[i][j] == 1: up[i][j] = (i==0) ? 1 : up[i-1][j] + 1 left[i][j] = (j==0) ? 1 : left[i][j-1] + 1 else: up[i][j] = 0; left[i][j] = 0.

    But note: up direction: consecutive 1s above including current. For up, we traverse from top to bottom; for down, from bottom to top; for left from left to right; for right from right to left.

    So:

    • First pass: top-left to bottom-right to compute left and up.
    • Second pass: bottom-right to top-left to compute right and down. Or we can compute down by reversed order.

    Pseudo: n = number of rows, m = number of columns. Create dp[n][m] initialized to large maybe?

    Actually we want to store the minimum of the four for each cell eventually. So we can compute all four separately and take min.

    Implementation: Initialize arrays up, down, left, right with same dimensions, fill with 0.

    1. For i from 0 to n-1: For j from 0 to m-1: if grid[i][j] == 1: up[i][j] = (i > 0) ? up[i-1][j] + 1 : 1; left[i][j] = (j > 0) ? left[i][j-1] + 1 : 1; else: up[i][j] = left[i][j] = 0;

    2. For i from n-1 downto 0: For j from m-1 downto 0: if grid[i][j] == 1: down[i][j] = (i < n-1) ? down[i+1][j] + 1 : 1; right[i][j] = (j < m-1) ? right[i][j+1] + 1 : 1; else: down[i][j] = right[i][j] = 0;

    Then for each cell (i,j), compute order = min(up[i][j], down[i][j], left[i][j], right[i][j]). Keep maxOrder = max(maxOrder, order). Return maxOrder. (If we want the total number of 1s in the plus, we return maxOrder4 - 3? Actually if order is arm length including center, total cells = 4(order-1) + 1 = 4*order - 3. But typical answer is order.)

    Complexities: Time: O(nm) because we traverse each cell constant times (four passes actually O(2nm) essentially). Space: O(nm) for the four arrays. Could be O(nm) total. Or we can compress to O(m) or O(n) if we reuse arrays but need to store at least two directions at a time? Actually we need all four to compute min at each cell. We can compute min on the fly after computing down and right? We could store up and left from first pass, and then compute down and right in second pass and directly update the result by taking min of up[i][j], left[i][j], and current down/right. So we need up and left stored (size nm). Or we can store only up and left arrays. Then second pass computes down and right locally and takes min. That reduces space to 2 arrays + grid? Actually we need up and left stored; we can also reuse one array for down? We can compute down on the fly and then take min? But we need up[i][j] and left[i][j] for each cell. So we need those stored. So space O(n*m). That is acceptable.

    Alternatively, we can use a single dp array for each direction but overall O(n*m).

    So answer: time O(nm), space O(nm). If we only need max, we can also compute in second pass without storing down and right arrays fully, but we need to reference down[i+1][j] and right[i][j+1] as we go reversed; we could compute down and right using temporary variables? Actually we can compute down[i][j] based on down[i+1][j]; we need down[i+1][j] which is from next row, so we need to store the down values for the row i+1. Similarly right[i][j] depends on right[i][j+1] which is from next column in same row, so we need the right values for columns to the right in the same row. So we could compute right from rightmost column to leftmost, we can compute on the fly without storing whole array if we only need to compare with up and left at the same cell. But we need down[i+1][j] from the next row; if we process rows from bottom to top, we can keep an array for down for the current row? Actually down[i][j] = (if grid[i][j]==1) then down[i+1][j] + 1 else 0. When processing row i, we need down for row i+1. So we need to store down for the row below. That can be a single array of length m (for the row below). Similarly for right? right[i][j] = (if grid[i][j]==1) then right[i][j+1] + 1 else 0. While processing a row from right to left, we need the value for the next column (j+1). That we can keep in a variable for the current row as we traverse right-to-left: we can compute right on the fly and store in an array or just use a variable? Because for each cell we need to combine with up[i][j] and left[i][j] (which are stored from first pass) and down[i][j] and right[i][j] (computed on the fly). But down[i][j] we need from row i+1, which we could store in an array for the row below as we process rows upward. So we can do:

    First pass: compute up and left, store them in two 2D arrays (or we could also compute min with later? we need both up and left for each cell). Could store up and left in two 2D arrays.

    Second pass: traverse from bottom to top, for each row i: For j from m-1 down to 0: compute down = (if grid[i][j]==1) then (if i < n-1) down_next_row[j] + 1 else 1 else 0. compute right = (if grid[i][j]==1) then (if j < m-1) right_current_row[j+1] + 1 else 1 else 0. But careful: right_current_row we compute as we go from rightmost to leftmost; we can store in an array for the row, but we could also use a variable to hold the right length for the next cell? Actually we need right for the current cell to compute the min. As we traverse from j=m-1 down to 0, we can keep a variable 'prev_right' for the cell to the right (i.e., j+1). For j=m-1, right = 1 if grid[i][j]==1 else 0. For j=m-2, right = (grid[i][j]==1)? (prev_right+1) else 0. So we can use a single variable for right for the current row as we iterate leftwards. That will give right[i][j] for that cell. So we don't need to store entire right array; we can compute right on the fly and then discard after we use it for that cell. Similarly, down we need to store per column for the next row. We can have an array down_next of length m, which initially for row n (out of bounds) is zeros. Then for row i from n-1 down to 0, we compute down for each column using down_next[j] (the down value from row i+1). After processing row i, we set down_next[j] = down for that cell for the next iteration (row i-1). Actually careful: we need down[i][j] for the current cell. Then for next row (i-1) we need down[i][j] as down_next? Actually down[i][j] depends on down[i+1][j]. So when processing row i, we have down_next which holds down[i+1][j] for all j. Then we compute down_ij. Then after finishing row i, we need to update down_next for the next row (i-1) with the computed down_ij. So we can do: For each row i (starting from n-1 down to 0): For each j from m-1 down to 0: if grid[i][j]==1: down_ij = down_next[j] + 1; right = (j==m-1) ? 1 : (prev_right + 1) where prev_right is right for j+1. else: down_ij=0, right=0. Then compute order = min(up[i][j], left[i][j], down_ij, right). Update max. We need to keep the computed down_ij values to update down_next for the next row. So we can store them in a temporary array down_current[j] = down_ij. After finishing row, set down_next = down_current. That requires O(m) extra space per row. But overall we have O(nm) for up and left, plus O(m) for down_next, and O(1) for right per row. So space O(nm) still due to up and left. Could we reduce up and left also to O(m) if we process row by row? For left: left[i][j] depends on left[i][j-1] from same row, so we could compute left on the fly in first pass and store maybe in up-left combined? But we need both up and left for each cell when computing min later. If we want to minimize space, we could compute all four directions in one pass? Possibly with dynamic programming that updates from all directions? There's known approach using DP with O(1) extra space? Not typical. We'll stick to O(n*m) space.

    But the problem says: "A dynamic programming approach is common, where you pre-compute the lengths of consecutive 1s in each of the four directions for every cell, and what is the time and space complexity of your solution." So they expect the straightforward solution using four DP arrays, leading to O(nm) time and O(nm) space. That's fine.

    Now implement function in Python (or any language). We'll provide a clear solution.

    Let's also consider grid may not be square; our algorithm works for n x m.

    Edge cases: all zeros => answer 0. Actually a plus sign requires at least center 1, so if there is any 1, order at least 1 (since arm length = 1, arms of length 1 means only center? Actually if arm length = 1, that means each arm has length 1 including the center, so the plus sign is just the single cell. So min(up,down,left,right) >= 1 if cell is 1. So answer >= 1 if there's at least one 1. So we return maxOrder.

    If the problem asks for size meaning total cells, we could adapt.

    I'll assume they want the order (arm length including center). In LeetCode 764, they ask: "Return the order of the largest plus sign ... If there is none, return 0." So answer is an integer.

    Thus solution: compute dp arrays and return max.

    Now for explanation:

    Algorithm:

    1. Let n = rows, m = cols.
    2. Create four 2D arrays: left, right, up, down (or maybe we can combine). Initialize all with 0.
    3. First pass (top-left to bottom-right): for i in range(n): for j in range(m): if grid[i][j] == 1: up[i][j] = (up[i-1][j] if i>0 else 0) + 1 left[i][j] = (left[i][j-1] if j>0 else 0) + 1 else: up[i][j] = left[i][j] = 0
    4. Second pass (bottom-right to top-left): for i in reversed(range(n)): for j in reversed(range(m)): if grid[i][j] == 1: down[i][j] = (down[i+1][j] if i < n-1 else 0) + 1 right[i][j] = (right[i][j+1] if j < m-1 else 0) + 1 else: down[i][j] = right[i][j] = 0
    5. Then answer = max( min(up[i][j], down[i][j], left[i][j], right[i][j]) ) over all i,j. Or we can compute during second pass to avoid another loop.
    6. Return answer.

    Complexities:

    • Time: O(n*m) because we traverse grid a constant number of times (2 passes).
    • Space: O(nm) for storing the four arrays (each of size nm). If we use only two arrays by reusing, we could reduce to O(nm) anyway. But typical is O(nm).

    We can also improve space to O(m) or O(n) with some tricks but not necessary.

    Now produce code in Python:

    def orderOfLargestPlusSign(n, mines): Actually LeetCode input has n as size of grid and mines list. But here we are given grid of integers. So we can accept grid as parameter: largest_plus_sign(grid). We'll assume grid is list of list of ints (0 or 1). We'll compute.

    Let's write:

    def largest_plus_sign(grid): if not grid or not grid[0]: return 0 n = len(grid) m = len(grid[0]) up = [[0]*m for _ in range(n)] down = [[0]*m for _ in range(n)] left = [[0]*m for _ in range(n)] right = [[0]*m for _ in range(n)]

    # compute up and left
    for i in range(n):
        for j in range(m):
            if grid[i][j] == 1:
                up[i][j] = (up[i-1][j] if i > 0 else 0) + 1
                left[i][j] = (left[i][j-1] if j > 0 else 0) + 1
            else:
                up[i][j] = 0
                left[i][j] = 0
    
    # compute down and right
    for i in range(n-1, -1, -1):
        for j in range(m-1, -1, -1):
            if grid[i][j] == 1:
                down[i][j] = (down[i+1][j] if i < n-1 else 0) + 1
                right[i][j] = (right[i][j+1] if j < m-1 else 0) + 1
            else:
                down[i][j] = 0
                right[i][j] = 0
    
    max_order = 0
    for i in range(n):
        for j in range(m):
            order = min(up[i][j], down[i][j], left[i][j], right[i][j])
            if order > max_order:
                max_order = order
    
    return max_order
    

    If they want total number of 1s: return max_order * 4 - 3 (if max_order>0). But we can leave as order.

    Now write explanation: We'll use DP to precompute lengths of consecutive 1s in each direction. The central idea: for a cell (i,j), the maximum plus sign centered at that cell has arm length limited by the shortest arm among the four directions. So we compute for each cell the length of 1s in up, down, left, right (including the cell). Then the order at that cell = min of these four. The global maximum is answer.

    Explain the DP recurrences:

    • up[i][j] = 0 if grid[i][j] == 0 else 1 + up[i-1][j] (if i>0)
    • left[i][j] = 0 if grid[i][j] == 0 else 1 + left[i][j-1] (if j>0)
    • down[i][j] = 0 if grid[i][j] == 0 else 1 + down[i+1][j] (if i < n-1)
    • right[i][j] = 0 if grid[i][j] == 0 else 1 + right[i][j+1] (if j < m-1)

    These are computed in appropriate order to ensure dependencies are already computed: up and left in forward pass; down and right in backward pass.

    Time: each cell is processed a constant number of times => O(nm). Space: four arrays each nm => O(nm). Can be optimized to O(nm) or even O(m) but we stick to O(n*m).

    Now we must write a function that solves this problem and explain algorithm and complexity. We'll produce final answer accordingly.

    Also note that the input grid might contain integers other than 0/1? They said integers, but likely 0/1. We'll treat any non-zero? Actually typical: plus sign of 1s, so we treat exactly 1. But we could treat any positive? We'll stick to 1.

    Also note: The grid can be large; but O(n*m) is optimal because we need to examine each cell at least once.

    Now for final answer: Provide Python function, plus explanation.

    We'll also mention that we can compute max on the fly in second pass to avoid third loop, but not necessary.

    Let's produce answer in a structured way.

    We'll include:

    • Problem restatement.
    • Approach: DP.
    • Detailed steps.
    • Pseudocode/Code.
    • Complexity analysis.
    • Edge cases.

    Now produce final output. Solution Explanation

    We are given a 2‑dimensional grid grid containing only 0s and 1s.
    A plus sign consists of a central cell with value 1 and four arms that extend upwards, downwards, leftwards and rightwards. All cells belonging to the plus must be 1. The four arms have the same length. The order of the plus sign is the number of cells along one arm including the centre.
    (For order k the total number of 1s in the plus is 4·k - 3.)

    The task is to find the largest possible order of a plus sign that occurs anywhere in the grid. If no 1 exists the answer is 0.


    1. Key Insight

    For a fixed cell (i, j) to be the centre of a plus sign of order k, the four arms must contain at least k consecutive 1s:

    up[i][j]   ≥ k
    down[i][j] ≥ k
    left[i][j] ≥ k
    right[i][j] ≥ k
    

    where up[i][j] denotes the length of the vertical segment of consecutive 1s starting at (i, j) and going upwards (including (i, j) itself), and similarly for the other three directions.

    Consequently, the maximal order achievable at (i, j) is

    order(i, j) = min( up[i][j], down[i][j], left[i][j], right[i][j] )
    

    The final answer is the maximum of order(i, j) over all cells.


    2. Computing the four directional lengths – DP

    All four directional values can be computed in linear time using dynamic programming because each value depends only on the neighbour in that direction.

    • Up & Left – scan from top‑left to bottom‑right
    if grid[i][j] == 1:
        up[i][j]   = 1 + (up[i-1][j]   if i > 0 else 0)
        left[i][j] = 1 + (left[i][j-1] if j > 0 else 0)
    else:
        up[i][j] = left[i][j] = 0
    
    • Down & Right – scan from bottom‑right to top‑left
    if grid[i][j] == 1:
        down[i][j]  = 1 + (down[i+1][j]  if i < n-1 else 0)
        right[i][j] = 1 + (right[i][j+1] if j < m-1 else 0)
    else:
        down[i][j] = right[i][j] = 0
    

    Both scans visit each cell a constant number of times → O(n·m) time.


    3. Algorithm

    largest_plus_sign(grid):
        n = number of rows, m = number of columns
        allocate four n×m matrices: up, down, left, right, all filled with 0
    
        # 1st pass: up and left
        for i = 0 … n-1:
            for j = 0 … m-1:
                if grid[i][j] == 1:
                    up[i][j]   = 1 + (up[i-1][j]   if i > 0 else 0)
                    left[i][j] = 1 + (left[i][j-1] if j > 0 else 0)
                else:
                    up[i][j] = left[i][j] = 0
    
        # 2nd pass: down and right
        for i = n-1 … 0:
            for j = m-1 … 0:
                if grid[i][j] == 1:
                    down[i][j]  = 1 + (down[i+1][j]  if i < n-1 else 0)
                    right[i][j] = 1 + (right[i][j+1] if j < m-1 else 0)
                else:
                    down[i][j] = right[i][j] = 0
    
        max_order = 0
        for every cell (i, j):
            order = min(up[i][j], down[i][j], left[i][j], right[i][j])
            max_order = max(max_order, order)
    
        return max_order        # if max_order==0 → no plus sign exists
    

    If the problem asks for the total number of 1s in the plus, return
    max_order * 4 - 3 (only for max_order > 0).


    4. Complexity Analysis

    Time – Each of the three nested loops touches every cell a constant number of times. → O(n·m).

    Space – Four auxiliary matrices of size n·m. → O(n·m).

    (One could reduce the extra space to O(n·m) → O(min(n,m)) by clever re‑use, but the typical DP solution uses O(n·m) and remains optimal in time.)


    5. Reference Implementation (Python)

    from typing import List
    
    def largest_plus_sign(grid: List[List[int]]) -> int:
        """
        Returns the order (arm length including centre) of the largest plus sign
        composed of 1's in the given binary grid. If no 1 exists, returns 0.
        """
        if not grid or not grid[0]:
            return 0
    
        n, m = len(grid), len(grid[0])
        # allocate DP tables
        up    = [[0] * m for _ in range(n)]
        down  = [[0] * m for _ in range(n)]
        left  = [[0] * m for _ in range(n)]
        right = [[0] * m for _ in range(n)]
    
        # 1st pass: up and left
        for i in range(n):
            for j in range(m):
                if grid[i][j] == 1:
                    up[i][j]   = 1 + (up[i-1][j]   if i > 0 else 0)
                    left[i][j] = 1 + (left[i][j-1] if j > 0 else 0)
                else:
                    up[i][j] = left[i][j] = 0
    
        # 2nd pass: down and right
        for i in range(n-1, -1, -1):
            for j in range(m-1, -1, -1):
                if grid[i][j] == 1:
                    down[i][j]  = 1 + (down[i+1][j]  if i < n-1 else 0)
                    right[i][j] = 1 + (right[i][j+1] if j < m-1 else 0)
                else:
                    down[i][j] = right[i][j] = 0
    
        max_order = 0
        for i in range(n):
            for j in range(m):
                order = min(up[i][j], down[i][j], left[i][j], right[i][j])
                if order > max_order:
                    max_order = order
    
        return max_order
    

    The function follows exactly the algorithm described above and meets the required time and space bounds.