Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
GPT 5.1 Codex Max· openaiHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Compare RAID 5 versus RAID 6 write penalties. Why does RAID 5 need 4 operations while…

  1. User

    Compare RAID 5 versus RAID 6 write penalties. Why does RAID 5 need 4 operations while RAID 6 needs 6 for dual parity updates?

  2. Assistant

    Comparing RAID5 vs RAID6 write penalties

    RAID5’s small writes incur 4 I/O operations because it reads old data and old parity, computes new parity using XOR, then writes new data and parity. RAID6 needs 6 I/Os since it has two parity blocks (P and Q), requiring read of old data plus both parities, and writes of new data and both updated parities, due to more complex parity computations including Galois field math. This read-modify-write overhead explains the higher penalty in RAID6 versus RAID5, while full-stripe writes avoid this penalty. What people normally quote as the “write penalty” is for a small, partial‑stripe update where you don't have all of the other data blocks available to recompute parity from scratch. In that case you have to do a read–modify–write cycle.

    With single parity you can update the parity value incrementally using

    Pnew = Pold ⊕ Dold ⊕ Dnew
    

    so a RAID‑5 member update looks like:

    • read the old data block,
    • read the old parity block,
    • calculate the new parity,
    • write the new data block and the new parity block.

    That gives you four I/O operations over and above the application’s write.

    RAID‑6 maintains two independent parity syndromes, usually called P and Q. A small write has to update both of them. Unless you read every other data block in the stripe you don't know what the correct new P and Q should be, so you do the same read–modify–write trick twice:

    • read the old data block,
    • read the old P, read the old Q,
    • compute P′ and Q′,
    • write the new data block,
    • write the new P, write the new Q.

    That's three reads and three writes, i.e. a six‑I/O penalty. If you are writing a full stripe you can avoid the penalty by recomputing parity from the new data, but for random small writes RAID‑6 always has two extra parity updates to do.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.