Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
ClaudeClaude Haiku 4.5· anthropicHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Derive the Heisenberg uncertainty principle from the general uncertainty relation.…

  1. User

    Derive the Heisenberg uncertainty principle from the general uncertainty relation. Compute the position-momentum commutator and show non-commutativity implies measurement limits.

  2. Claude Assistant

    This is a comprehensive question about the Heisenberg uncertainty principle in quantum mechanics. I'll break this down into several parts:

    1. Start with the general uncertainty relation
    2. Compute the position-momentum commutator
    3. Show how non-commutativity implies measurement limits
    4. Derive the explicit Heisenberg uncertainty principle

    Let me work through this carefully.

    Part 1: General Uncertainty Relation

    The general uncertainty relation (Robertson uncertainty relation) states that for any two observables A and B:

    ΔA · ΔB ≥ (1/2)|⟨[A,B]⟩|

    where:

    • ΔA = √(⟨A²⟩ - ⟨A⟩²) is the standard deviation of A
    • ΔB = √(⟨B²⟩ - ⟨B⟩²) is the standard deviation of B
    • [A,B] = AB - BA is the commutator
    • ⟨...⟩ denotes expectation value

    Part 2: Position-Momentum Commutator

    The canonical commutation relation (CCR) is: [x̂, p̂] = x̂p̂ - p̂x̂ = iℏ

    Let me derive this from first principles using position representation.

    In position representation:

    • x̂ψ(x) = xψ(x)
    • p̂ = -iℏ(d/dx)

    [x̂, p̂]ψ = x̂p̂ψ - p̂x̂ψ

    Let's compute each term: x̂p̂ψ = x̂(-iℏ dψ/dx) = -iℏx(dψ/dx)

    p̂x̂ψ = p̂(xψ) = -iℏ d(xψ)/dx = -iℏ(ψ + x dψ/dx) = -iℏψ - iℏx(dψ/dx)

    Therefore: [x̂, p̂]ψ = -iℏx(dψ/dx) + iℏψ + iℏx(dψ/dx) = iℏψ

    So [x̂, p̂] = iℏ

    Part 3: Applying the General Uncertainty Relation

    Now we apply the general uncertainty relation with A = x̂ and B = p̂:

    Δx · Δp ≥ (1/2)|⟨[x̂, p̂]⟩| = (1/2)|⟨iℏ⟩| = (1/2)ℏ

    Therefore: Δx · Δp ≥ ℏ/2

    This is the Heisenberg uncertainty principle in its most fundamental form.

    Part 4: Understanding What This Means

    The physical interpretation reveals why simultaneous measurement of position and momentum cannot both be arbitrarily precise. Let me work through the detailed proof of the Robertson uncertainty relation to show why this constraint emerges from the commutation relation.

    For any observables A and B in state |ψ⟩, I define the deviation operators ΔA = A - ⟨A⟩ and ΔB = B - ⟨B⟩, where ⟨A⟩ and ⟨B⟩ are their expectation values.

    The key is proving (ΔA)²(ΔB)² ≥ (1/4)|⟨[A,B]⟩|². Starting with the state |φ⟩ = ΔB|ψ⟩, the norm constraint ⟨φ|φ⟩ ≥ 0 gives us ⟨ψ|(ΔB)²|ψ⟩ ≥ 0, confirming (ΔB)² ≥ 0. From here, I can construct a similar state involving both operators to establish the full inequality through the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality applied to the commutator. d anti-Hermitian parts. The commutator [A,B] is anti-Hermitian since [A,B]† = -[A,B], which means ⟨[A,B]⟩ is purely imaginary. I can express this as ⟨[A,B]⟩ = i·c where c is real, allowing me to rewrite the inequality as (ΔA)² - λc + λ²(ΔB)² ≥ 0. For this quadratic in λ to hold for all real λ, the discriminant must be non-positive: c² - 4(ΔA)²(ΔB)² ≤ 0, which gives (ΔA)(ΔB) ≥ |c|/2 = |⟨[A,B]⟩|/2. For this quadratic in λ to hold for all values, the discriminant must be non-positive: C² - 4(ΔA)²(ΔB)² ≤ 0, which gives (ΔA)²(ΔB)² ≥ C²/4.

    Since C = -i⟨[A,B]⟩, we have |C| = |⟨[A,B]⟩|, and therefore (ΔA)·(ΔB) ≥ |⟨[A,B]⟩|/2.

    I cannot complete this thought as the next thinking section is empty.

    Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle: Derivation from General Uncertainty Relation

    1. General Uncertainty Relation (Robertson, 1929)

    For any two observables  and B̂ in quantum state |ψ⟩:

    ΔA⋅ΔB≥12∣⟨[A^,B^]⟩∣\Delta A \cdot \Delta B \geq \frac{1}{2}|\langle[\hat{A}, \hat{B}]\rangle|

    where:

    • ΔA=⟨A2⟩−⟨A⟩2\Delta A = \sqrt{\langle A^2 \rangle - \langle A \rangle^2} (standard deviation)
    • [A^,B^]=A^B^−B^A^[\hat{A}, \hat{B}] = \hat{A}\hat{B} - \hat{B}\hat{A} (commutator)

    2. Proof of Robertson Uncertainty Relation

    Construction: Consider the positive semi-definite norm ⟨ϕ∣ϕ⟩≥0\langle \phi | \phi \rangle \geq 0 where ∣ϕ⟩=(ΔA^+iλΔB^)∣ψ⟩|\phi\rangle = (\Delta\hat{A} + i\lambda\Delta\hat{B})|\psi\rangle, with λ ∈ ℝ

    Expanding: ⟨(ΔA)2⟩+iλ⟨[ΔA^,ΔB^]⟩+λ2⟨(ΔB)2⟩≥0\langle(\Delta A)^2\rangle + i\lambda\langle[\Delta\hat{A}, \Delta\hat{B}]\rangle + \lambda^2\langle(\Delta B)^2\rangle \geq 0

    Key observation: For Hermitian operators, the commutator is anti-Hermitian: [A^,B^]†=−[A^,B^][\hat{A}, \hat{B}]^\dagger = -[\hat{A}, \hat{B}]

    Therefore ⟨[A^,B^]⟩=iC\langle[\hat{A}, \hat{B}]\rangle = iC where C is real.

    Polynomial inequality: Writing ⟨[ΔA^,ΔB^]⟩=iC\langle[\Delta\hat{A}, \Delta\hat{B}]\rangle = iC: (ΔA)2−λC+λ2(ΔB)2≥0(\Delta A)^2 - \lambda C + \lambda^2(\Delta B)^2 \geq 0

    Discriminant condition: For this to hold ∀λ: C2−4(ΔA)2(ΔB)2≤0C^2 - 4(\Delta A)^2(\Delta B)^2 \leq 0

    ΔA⋅ΔB≥12∣⟨[A^,B^]⟩∣\boxed{\Delta A \cdot \Delta B \geq \frac{1}{2}|\langle[\hat{A}, \hat{B}]\rangle|}


    3. Position-Momentum Commutator

    In position representation: x^∣ψ⟩=xψ(x)\hat{x}|\psi\rangle = x\psi(x) and p^=−iℏddx\hat{p} = -i\hbar\frac{d}{dx}

    Direct calculation: [x^,p^]ψ=x^p^ψ−p^x^ψ[\hat{x}, \hat{p}]\psi = \hat{x}\hat{p}\psi - \hat{p}\hat{x}\psi

    =x^(−iℏdψdx)−(−iℏ)ddx(xψ)= \hat{x}\left(-i\hbar\frac{d\psi}{dx}\right) - (-i\hbar)\frac{d}{dx}(x\psi)

    =−iℏxdψdx+iℏ(ψ+xdψdx)= -i\hbar x\frac{d\psi}{dx} + i\hbar\left(\psi + x\frac{d\psi}{dx}\right)

    =iℏψ= i\hbar\psi

    Canonical Commutation Relation: [x^,p^]=iℏ\boxed{[\hat{x}, \hat{p}] = i\hbar}


    4. Derivation of Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

    Apply Robertson relation with A^=x^\hat{A} = \hat{x} and B^=p^\hat{B} = \hat{p}:

    Δx⋅Δp≥12∣⟨[x^,p^]⟩∣\Delta x \cdot \Delta p \geq \frac{1}{2}|\langle[\hat{x}, \hat{p}]\rangle|

    Δx⋅Δp≥12∣iℏ∣=ℏ2\Delta x \cdot \Delta p \geq \frac{1}{2}|i\hbar| = \frac{\hbar}{2}

    Δx⋅Δp≥ℏ2\boxed{\Delta x \cdot \Delta p \geq \frac{\hbar}{2}}

    Equality holds for Gaussian (minimum uncertainty) states.


    5. Physical Interpretation: Why Non-Commutativity Implies Measurement Limits

    A. Eigenvalue Problem Analysis

    If [x^,p^]=0[\hat{x}, \hat{p}] = 0 (hypothetically), then:

    • Simultaneous eigenstates would exist
    • Both would be arbitrarily sharply peaked
    • ✗ Violates de Broglie relations and wave-particle duality

    B. Measurement Sequence Argument

    First measurement of x: ∣ψ0⟩→∣ψ1⟩ (eigenstate of x^, Δx=0)|\psi_0\rangle \to |\psi_1\rangle \text{ (eigenstate of } \hat{x}\text{, } \Delta x = 0)

    Subsequent measurement of p: Δp≥ℏ2Δx→∞ as Δx→0\Delta p \geq \frac{\hbar}{2\Delta x} \to \infty \text{ as } \Delta x \to 0

    The very act of localizing position spreads momentum—a consequence of non-commutativity.

    C. Wavefunction Picture

    The minimum uncertainty state is a Gaussian: ψ(x)=(2aπ)1/4e−ax2+ip0x/ℏ\psi(x) = \left(\frac{2a}{\pi}\right)^{1/4}e^{-ax^2 + ip_0x/\hbar}

    with Δx=12a\Delta x = \frac{1}{2\sqrt{a}} and Δp=ℏa\Delta p = \hbar\sqrt{a}, giving Δx⋅Δp=ℏ2\Delta x \cdot \Delta p = \frac{\hbar}{2}


    6. Key Physical Consequences

    PropertyImplication
    [x^,p^]≠0[\hat{x}, \hat{p}] \neq 0Cannot have simultaneous sharply-defined values
    Δx→0\Delta x \to 0Must have Δp→∞\Delta p \to \infty (wave spreads)
    Fundamental limitIndependent of apparatus quality—quantum origin
    ℏ\hbar fundamental scaleMakes quantum vs. classical distinction manifest

    The uncertainty principle is not a statement about measurement apparatus limitations, but rather reflects the fundamental structure of quantum mechanics encoded in the commutation relations.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.