Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
GPT 5.1 Codex Max· openaiHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Compute the convex hull using the monotone chain algorithm. Sort points by X-coordinate…

  1. User

    Compute the convex hull using the monotone chain algorithm. Sort points by X-coordinate then build the upper hull and lower hull separately in O(n) time after sorting.

  2. Assistant

    Explaining convex hull with monotone chain

    The monotone chain algorithm computes the convex hull by first sorting points by x (and y to break ties), then building the lower and upper hulls separately in O(n) time using a cross product check to maintain a left turn orientation. Finally, it concatenates the hulls (excluding duplicates) to form the full convex hull with overall O(n log n) complexity due to sorting. Below is a concise outline of Andrew’s monotone chain algorithm for computing the convex hull:

    1. Sort the points by (x) (then by (y) if (x)-coordinates tie).
      Let the sorted list be (P[0 \dots n-1]).

    2. Build the lower hull:

      • Initialize an empty list lower.
      • For each point (p) in (P):
        • While lower has at least two points and the last turn formed by the last two points in lower and (p) is not counterclockwise (i.e., the cross product is (\le 0) for the usual “strictly convex” version), pop the last point from lower.
        • Push (p) onto lower.
    3. Build the upper hull (similar procedure but iterate points in reverse order):

      • Initialize an empty list upper.
      • For each point (p) in (P) from right to left:
        • While upper has at least two points and the last turn formed by the last two points in upper and (p) is not counterclockwise (cross product (\le 0)), pop the last point from upper.
        • Push (p) onto upper.
    4. Concatenate lower and upper (omitting each list’s last point to avoid duplication) to get the full hull.

    This runs in (O(n \log n)) for the sort, plus (O(n)) for constructing the hulls.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.