Develop a resilient distributed scheduler for GPUs and TPUs across regions: placement…
- User
Develop a resilient distributed scheduler for GPUs and TPUs across regions: placement heuristics, failure domains, utilization reporting, and fairness controls.
- Assistant
We are asked to develop a resilient distributed scheduler for GPUs and TPUs across regions: placement heuristics, failure domains, utilization reporting, and fairness controls.
We need to produce an answer that outlines such a scheduler. The question is broad and seems like a design question for a distributed system that schedules GPU/TPU resources across multiple regions, with considerations for resilience, placement heuristics, failure domains, utilization reporting, and fairness controls.
We need to produce a comprehensive design. The answer should include:
-
Overall architecture: components like central scheduler or distributed? Probably a central scheduler that has global view, but with resilience and failure domains, maybe a hierarchical approach? Or a federated approach? We need to discuss design choices.
-
Placement heuristics: how to decide where to place a job? Consider factors like data locality, network latency, resource availability, cost, etc. Possibly use a scoring system.
-
Failure domains: how to handle failures? We need to consider regions as failure domains, but also within a region, maybe zones/racks. We need to schedule jobs with replication or checkpointing? Or ensure that jobs can survive failures. Possibly using concepts like placement sets, anti-affinity, etc.
-
Utilization reporting: monitor resource usage and provide reports. Need to consider both real-time utilization and historical trends. Possibly expose metrics.
-
Fairness controls: ensure fair sharing among multiple users/tenants. Possibly use quotas, priorities, preemption, etc.
We need to be detailed but not excessively so. Provide a clear structure.
Let's think about the constraints: GPUs and TPUs are specialized accelerators. They are not as abundant as CPUs. The scheduler must handle jobs that require one or more accelerators. The jobs may have specific requirements (e.g., type of GPU, amount of memory, interconnect requirements like NVLink). Also, TPUs may have different generations. The scheduler must be aware of hardware heterogeneity.
Resilience: The system should continue to operate even if some components fail. Possibly use a replicated state store (like etcd) for the scheduler state. Scheduler itself can be made highly available. The jobs themselves may need to be resilient: checkpointing, restartable.
Failure domains: We consider regions as top-level failure domains (e.g., different geographic locations, separate power grids, network connections). Within a region, there may be availability zones (or clusters) that have independent failure modes (e.g., power, cooling). So we have a hierarchy: region -> zone -> cluster -> rack -> node. The scheduler should be aware of these to spread replicas for fault tolerance, or to place jobs that require high availability across zones.
Placement heuristics: Could include:
- Spreading for fault tolerance: if job has multiple tasks (e.g., data parallel), place them across zones to survive zone failure.
- Packing for performance: co-locate tasks that communicate heavily on the same node or within same rack/zone to reduce network latency.
- Data locality: if data is stored in a particular region (e.g., Cloud Storage bucket with regional endpoint), place jobs in that region to minimize data transfer.
- Resource constraints: match accelerator type, memory, interconnect.
- Cost: maybe choose cheaper regions if allowed.
- Quota: respect user quotas per region.
Implementation: The scheduler might be a global central component that receives job submissions and makes placement decisions. Alternatively, a two-level scheduler: a global scheduler that assigns jobs to regions, and regional schedulers that handle local placement. This can reduce the complexity and scale. The global scheduler could be a logical component that uses a distributed algorithm (like distributed consensus) to assign work, but easier to think of a central scheduler with replicated state and failover.
We'll describe a design with a central scheduler (or a cluster of scheduler replicas) that maintains a global view of available resources across regions (by heartbeat from regional agents). The scheduler uses a priority queue of pending jobs and a set of policies (fairness, priorities). For each job, it tries to find a feasible placement based on constraints and heuristics. It uses a bin-packing / knapsack approach maybe.
We need to incorporate failure domain constraints: jobs may have a "failure domain" requirement (e.g., "spread across at least 2 zones" or "no two replicas in same zone"). The scheduler must ensure that placement respects these. For jobs that are not fault-tolerant (single task), we might still want to place them in a zone with reliability.
Resilience of scheduler: we can have multiple scheduler instances with leader election, using a consensus protocol to store job queue and state. This way, if leader fails, a new one takes over. The regional agents can report to any scheduler.
Failure domains: Also we need to handle node failures, zone outages. The scheduler should detect failures (heartbeats) and resubmit or restart jobs elsewhere. Possibly integrate with checkpointing: if a job fails, it can be resumed from last checkpoint. The scheduler should have the ability to migrate jobs if needed.
Utilization reporting: expose metrics like per-region, per-zone GPU utilization, pending jobs, queue length, fairness metrics. Possibly integrate with monitoring systems (Prometheus). Also provide historical reports for billing and capacity planning.
Fairness controls: Implement a fair-share scheduler. For example, use a token bucket or hierarchical fair share. Each user/team has a weight or quota. The scheduler allocates resources based on demand and fairness over time. Could use a "dominant resource fairness" (DRF) for multiple resource types (CPU, GPU, memory). Or simpler: per-user quotas per region. Also support preemption: if a high-priority job arrives, lower priority jobs may be preempted (if preemptible). But need to ensure that preemption is not too disruptive. Could use gang scheduling to avoid deadlock.
We also need to consider specifics: GPUs and TPUs may have different reservation models. Some may require exclusive access. Could support time-slicing? Typically GPUs are allocated exclusively. So scheduler must allocate whole devices.
Also need to consider multi-node jobs: e.g., a job requiring multiple GPUs across nodes for distributed training (e.g., using NCCL). The scheduler must ensure that the nodes are placed appropriately (same zone for low latency, possibly same rack for NVLink). So placement heuristics must consider inter-node communication requirements.
Thus, we should define a job model: job = set of tasks (or a set of resource requests). A task may request a number of GPUs, TPUs, CPUs, memory, possibly specific topology (e.g., 2 GPUs on same node with NVLink). The scheduler must assign tasks to nodes satisfying constraints.
We can break down the answer:
-
Introduction: Problem statement, goals.
-
System Architecture:
- Central scheduler cluster (HA) with leader election, state in replicated log.
- Regional agents: each region runs an agent that monitors local resources and reports to central. They may also handle local scheduling decisions under guidance from central.
- Job submission: via API, with resource requirements and constraints.
- Scheduler components: admission control, policy engine, placement engine, resource tracker, failure detector, checkpoint manager (optional), metrics collector.
-
Resource Model and Job Description:
- Node resources: number of GPUs, TPUs, CPU, memory, GPU type, interconnect.
- Regions, zones, nodes.
- Job: tasks with resource requests, placement constraints (e.g., "spread across zones", "same zone", "region affinity", "node affinity", "anti-affinity").
- Possibly job priorities and preemption hints.
-
Placement Heuristics:
- Objective: maximize utilization, meet deadlines, minimize data transfer cost, etc.
- Steps:
a. Filter regions/zones based on constraints (e.g., required GPU type, region affinity).
b. Score each candidate placement using a cost function. Cost components:
- Network cost: if tasks need to communicate, factor in latency/bandwidth between nodes.
- Data locality penalty if data not in same region.
- Resource fragmentation: try to pack to avoid fragmentation.
- Utilization balance: avoid overloading a region. c. Use bin-packing for multi-node jobs: for each candidate region, try to place tasks on nodes that satisfy topology (e.g., all tasks in same zone for all-reduce). For cross-zone jobs, compute cost of cross-zone network.
- May also consider cost (if regions have different prices).
-
Failure Domain Handling:
- The scheduler maintains failure domain hierarchy. Each node belongs to zone and region.
- Jobs can specify replication factor and failure domain constraints (e.g., "at most one task per zone").
- When placing, the scheduler ensures that tasks are distributed across failure domains accordingly.
- Upon failure detection (heartbeat timeout), the scheduler marks nodes as dead and reschedules affected tasks. For non-preemptible jobs, it may wait for node recovery if job is not resilient, or checkpoint/restart if checkpointing is available.
- The scheduler can also proactively schedule tasks to avoid placing all critical replicas in the same zone (i.e., spread).
- Possibly implement a "replica set" concept for fault tolerance.
-
Fairness Controls:
- Fair-share algorithm: maintain each tenant's "used share" over a time window (e.g., last hour). Scheduler prefers tenants with lower usage relative to their weight.
- Quotas: per-user or per-group hard limits on total resources across all regions, or per region.
- Priority classes: jobs can have priority; high priority preempts low priority if needed, but with safeguards (e.g., minimum runtime before preemption, preemptible flag).
- Gang scheduling: if a job has multiple tasks that must start together, the scheduler reserves resources for all tasks to avoid deadlock while waiting.
- Fairness metric: track "normalized share" = resources used / weight. Scheduler picks job with smallest share that fits.
-
Utilization Reporting:
- Metrics collection: each regional agent reports resource utilization (GPUs used, memory, etc.) to central, which aggregates.
- Real-time dashboard: show per-region, per-zone usage, pending jobs, queue lengths, fairness indices (e.g., Jain's fairness index).
- Historical data: store in time-series DB for capacity planning, billing.
- Alerts: trigger if utilization too high or too low, or if fairness degrades.
- Expose APIs for users to see their usage.
-
Resilience of Scheduler:
- Use Raft/Paxos for leader election and state replication.
- State: job queue, assignments, resource inventory.
- Periodic snapshots and WAL for recovery.
- Regional agents have local state and can continue operating if disconnected from central? Possibly they can buffer jobs? But central is needed for global allocation. Could have a fallback mode where regional scheduler acts independently using local resources (but no global fairness). Better to have central HA.
-
Implementation considerations:
- Technology: e.g., Go for scheduler, etcd for storage, gRPC for communication.
- Scalability: number of regions (maybe 10s), zones (100s), nodes (1000s). Scheduler must handle thousands of jobs. Placement algorithm must be efficient. Possibly use hierarchical filtering to prune search space.
- Optimizations: use incremental updates, caching.
-
Example workflow: submit job -> scheduler checks resources, applies heuristics, places tasks, sends assignments to regional agents. Agents launch tasks. Heartbeats monitor nodes, failures cause rescheduling.
-
Conclusion: summarize.
We need to write in a clear, organized manner. Possibly include diagrams? But text only. So we can describe.
Let's start drafting.
We should address each required part:
- Placement heuristics: detailed.
- Failure domains: how they are defined and used.
- Utilization reporting: what metrics, how collected, how reported.
- Fairness controls: mechanisms.
Also "resilient distributed scheduler": so we must emphasize resilience: HA, fault tolerance, recovery.
I'll produce a comprehensive answer.
Potential pitfalls: be careful not to assume a particular cloud provider's terminology; but we can use generic terms: region, zone, cluster, node. Also we might mention that GPUs/TPUs are accelerators.
We should define failure domains: zones, racks, maybe even individual device failures. But main failure domain is region and zone. Also consider that within a node, GPU can fail individually? Typically GPUs are considered as resources; if a GPU fails, node may still be partially usable. Scheduler should be able to handle partial node failures (e.g., mark some GPUs as down). So we need fine-grained resource tracking per accelerator.
We can also talk about topology: NVLink, PCIe, network interconnects. For distributed training, we might need to place tasks on nodes that are connected via high-bandwidth network (e.g., within same zone or on the same switch). So placement heuristics can consider network topology.
Let's outline the answer:
-
Problem Overview
- Need to schedule GPU/TPU workloads across multiple regions, with resilience, fairness, and efficient utilization.
-
High-level Architecture
- Central Scheduler Cluster (CSC): multiple instances, leader election, state replication (using Raft). Provides global scheduling decisions.
- Regional Scheduler Agents (RSA): per region, report inventory, receive assignments, launch tasks, monitor health.
- Job Submission Service: API endpoint, authenticates, receives jobs.
- State Store: etcd cluster for persistent state.
- Monitoring & Metrics: Prometheus, Grafana.
-
Resource Model
- Hierarchical failure domains: Region -> Zone -> Rack -> Node -> Accelerator (GPU/TPU).
- Node attributes: number of accelerators, types (e.g., NVIDIA A100, TPU v4), memory, interconnect (NVLink, InfiniBand), CPU, RAM.
- Accelerator-level granularity: each accelerator can be individually healthy/unhealthy.
-
Job Model
- Job: consists of one or more tasks.
- Task: request for specific accelerators (count, type), CPU, memory, and optionally topology constraints (e.g., "accelerators must be on same node" or "accelerators must be on different nodes within same zone").
- Constraints:
- regionAffinity: must be in specific region(s).
- zoneSpread: maximum number of tasks per zone.
- antiAffinity: tasks with certain labels cannot co-locate.
- dataLocality: reference to dataset (which may be in a region).
- Policies: priority, preemptible, gangAllOrNothing.
-
Placement Heuristics
- Overview: The placement engine takes a job and attempts to find a feasible assignment of tasks to nodes that satisfies all constraints and optimizes a cost function.
- Process:
a. Filter candidate regions: based on regionAffinity, required accelerator type availability, and data locality (prefer region where data resides).
b. For each candidate region, examine zones. Apply zoneSpread constraints to determine distribution.
c. Within zones, consider node selection. Scoring for each node:
- Resource match: does node have enough free accelerators, CPU, memory?
- Topology: does node support required interconnect? (e.g., NVLink between GPUs on same node)
- Load: avoid overburdened nodes; use current utilization metrics (e.g., GPU usage, network I/O).
- Fragmentation: penalize nodes that cause fragmentation (e.g., leaving odd numbers of GPUs).
- Network cost: If tasks need to communicate across nodes, factor in estimated bandwidth/latency (based on zone topology: same zone = high bandwidth, cross-zone = lower, cross-region = high latency).
- Cost: if regions have different costs, incorporate.
- Failure domain: ensure that tasks are placed across zones as required. d. Use a bin-packing algorithm: for multi-task jobs, try to place tasks in a way that minimizes total cost. Could be NP-hard; use heuristics like best-fit decreasing.
- Placement strategies:
- Packing: for batch jobs that are not latency-sensitive, pack tasks onto as few nodes/zones to improve efficiency.
- Spreading: for fault-tolerant jobs, spread tasks across multiple zones/regions.
- Locality-aware: prioritize same region as data.
- Topology-aware: for multi-node jobs that use collective communication, try to place all nodes within the same zone or even same rack to maximize bandwidth.
-
Failure Domain Management
- The scheduler maintains a view of the failure domain hierarchy. Each node is tagged with its zone and region.
- For each job, the scheduler records which domains its tasks occupy. This is used for rescheduling.
- Detection of failures:
- Node heartbeats: RSA reports node status every few seconds. If heartbeat missing, node marked suspect.
- Accelerator-level health: drivers can report GPU failures; RSA flags individual accelerators as down.
- Zone/region outage: if all nodes in a zone stop heartbeating, mark zone down.
- Reaction to failures:
- For jobs that are not checkpointed and are not preemptible, the scheduler may attempt to restart them on healthy nodes if the failure is transient (node recovery). If the job is checkpointed, the scheduler can resume from last checkpoint.
- For jobs that have replication (e.g., parameter server replicas), if a replica fails, the scheduler can launch a replacement in a different failure domain to maintain replication factor.
- The scheduler also proactively avoids placing all tasks of a critical job in a single zone (unless forced by constraints).
- Resilience of the scheduler itself:
- Use Raft consensus among scheduler instances. Leader handles requests, followers replicate state. If leader fails, new leader elected.
- State is persisted in Write-Ahead Log (WAL) and snapshots. Regional agents buffer job assignments if disconnected.
- Scheduler can survive network partitions: remain read-only for safety? Or use quorum.
- Regional agents can continue to run existing jobs if they lose contact with central, but cannot start new jobs.
-
Fairness Controls
- Fair-share accounting:
- Each tenant (user/team/project) is assigned a "share" weight.
- Scheduler tracks each tenant's resource usage over a sliding time window (e.g., last 1 hour). Weighted usage = sum over resources (GPU-hours * weight factor).
- The normalized share = weighted usage / total cluster capacity (or total weight-adjusted capacity).
- Scheduler tries to equalize normalized share across tenants (like max-min fairness).
- Quotas:
- Hard quotas per tenant: cannot exceed X GPUs total or per region. Enforced at admission.
- Soft quotas: used for fair-share calculations.
- Priority and Preemption:
- Jobs have priority class (high, medium, low). Higher priority preempts lower if needed.
- Preemption is done only if the lower priority job is marked preemptible (or has a low priority that allows preemption). Non-preemptible jobs get reserved resources.
- Preempted jobs are checkpointed if possible and requeued.
- Gang Scheduling:
- For jobs that require multiple tasks to start simultaneously (e.g., distributed training with synchronous barrier), the scheduler reserves all required resources before launching any task. This prevents deadlock where some tasks wait indefinitely.
- Fairness Metrics: Expose metrics like Jain's fairness index, per-tenant usage graphs, and allow admins to adjust weights.
- Fair-share accounting:
-
Utilization Reporting
- Real-time metrics:
- Per-region, per-zone, per-node accelerator utilization (active vs idle).
- Queue lengths: number of pending jobs per priority/tenant.
- Resource fragmentation: e.g., number of partially free nodes.
- Job throughput, average wait time.
- Collection:
- RSA exports metrics in Prometheus format.
- Central aggregator collects and stores in TSDB (e.g., Cortex, InfluxDB).
- Dashboards: Grafana dashboards showing cluster utilization, fairness, heat maps.
- Historical reporting:
- Daily/weekly reports for capacity planning and billing.
- Retention of metrics.
- Alerts: Admin alerts if utilization spikes, fairness drops below threshold, or failures exceed limit.
- Real-time metrics:
-
Example Workflow
- User submits job with requirements: 8x A100 GPUs, region=any, zoneSpread=2 (max 4 per zone), data in us-central1.
- Scheduler selects region us-central1 due to data locality. Within that region, looks for zones with enough free GPUs. Suppose two zones have 4 each. Assigns 4 tasks to nodes in zone A, 4 tasks to zone B. Ensures nodes have NVLink topology for intra-node communication. Sends assignments to RSAs in each zone. RSAs launch tasks. Heartbeats monitor.
- If zone A fails, the 4 tasks on that zone are marked failed. Scheduler reschedules those 4 tasks in zone B or another zone, respecting constraints and quotas.
-
Conclusion
- Summarize design benefits: global optimization, resilience, fairness, observability.
Now we need to produce final answer as ChatGPT. We'll write in a structured format, maybe using headings. Since it's text, we can use markdown-like formatting: bold for headings, bullet points. But the final answer should be plain text? The instruction says "Develop a resilient distributed scheduler for GPUs and TPUs across regions: placement heuristics, failure domains, utilization reporting, and fairness controls." It's a design question. So we provide a thorough answer.
We'll produce a detailed response.
Let's begin.
But we must ensure we cover all aspects. Possibly also talk about integration with Kubernetes? Could be an extension of Kubernetes scheduler? But the question says "distributed scheduler", so we can design a custom system or describe as an extension. But to keep it generic, we can design a standalone scheduler. But mention that it can be implemented as a custom scheduler for Kubernetes using the scheduler framework. That might be a practical angle. But the problem is open.
We could say: "The design can be implemented as a custom Kubernetes scheduler (e.g., using the scheduler plugin mechanism) if the infrastructure is Kubernetes, or as a standalone system." But we can keep it generic.
Given that GPUs/TPUs are often managed in Kubernetes clusters, maybe we assume Kubernetes. But we can abstract.
Let's not commit to Kubernetes, but mention that it's compatible.
We'll produce final answer with clear sections.
Potential extra: we could talk about handling heterogeneous accelerators: GPUs vs TPUs, scheduling them together? Usually they are separate. The scheduler should know type and assign accordingly.
Also talk about scheduling for both training (long-running) and inference (maybe short). For inference, we might need autoscaling. Not necessary.
Resiliency: include checkpoint integration: if a job can checkpoint (e.g., using Kubernetes checkpointing or custom), the scheduler can trigger checkpoint on preemption or failure.
Now produce final answer.
Make it comprehensive but not too lengthy (maybe 1000-1500 words). We'll aim for around 1200.
We'll use headings:
1. Problem Statement and Goals
2. System Architecture
3. Resource and Job Model
4. Placement Heuristics
5. Failure Domains and Resilience
6. Fairness Controls
7. Utilization Reporting
8. Example Scenario
9. Conclusion
We can elaborate each.
Let's draft. Resilient Distributed Scheduler for GPUs and TPUs Across Regions
1. Problem Statement and Goals
We need to design a scheduler that can manage GPU and TPU resources distributed across multiple geographical regions. The scheduler must:
- Place jobs efficiently considering data locality, network topology, and hardware heterogeneity.
- Be resilient to failures at node, zone, region, and scheduler component levels.
- Provide fine-grained utilization reporting for monitoring and capacity planning.
- Enforce fairness among multiple users/tenants while respecting priorities and quotas.
2. System Architecture
The scheduler follows a centralized‑logical, physically distributed architecture to balance global optimization with fault tolerance.
-
Central Scheduler Cluster (CSC)
A set of identical scheduler instances that run the scheduling algorithm. One instance is the leader (elected via Raft); others are hot standbys. All state (job queue, assignments, resource inventory) is replicated in a strongly consistent log (e.g., etcd). The leader receives job submissions, runs placement, and dispatches assignments. -
Regional Scheduler Agents (RSA)
Deployed in each region. They maintain a real‑time view of local nodes (heartbeats, accelerator health), report inventory to the CSC, and execute task launches/kill/restart commands from the CSC. RSAs also perform local health checks and handle minor failures (e.g., restart a crashed container). -
Job Submission Service
A stateless API layer that receives job definitions, authenticates, validates constraints, and forwards jobs to the CSC leader. -
State Store
A replicated key‑value store (Raft‑based) that persists all scheduler state. Snapshots and WAL enable fast recovery. -
Monitoring Stack
RSAs expose metrics in Prometheus format; a central aggregator scrapes them and stores in a time‑series database (TSDB). Grafana dashboards provide real‑time and historical views.
The design ensures that if the CSC leader fails, a new leader is elected within seconds and resumes scheduling. RSAs buffer jobs if they lose connectivity and resynchronize when the cluster recovers.
3. Resource and Job Model
Failure Domain Hierarchy
Region → Zone → Rack → Node → Accelerator (GPU/TPU)- Each node belongs to exactly one rack and one zone.
- Each zone belongs to one region.
- Accelerators are individually trackable for health and allocation.
Resource Description
A Node advertises:
- Number and type of accelerators (e.g., 8× NVIDIA A100, 4× TPU v4).
- Accelerator memory, interconnect (NVLink, InfiniBand), CPU cores, RAM.
- Rack and zone identifiers.
Job Description
A Job is a collection of Tasks. A Task requests:
- Number of accelerators (and optionally specific types).
- CPU and memory.
- Topology constraints:
co-locate(accelerators on the same node),
spread(accelerators on distinct nodes),
interconnect(e.g., require NVLink between GPUs on same node or high‑bandwidth network between nodes). - Failure domain constraints: e.g.,
maxPerZone: 2(no more than two tasks of the job in any zone),zoneAffinity: ["zone‑1"],regionAffinity: ["us‑west"]. - Data locality: reference to a dataset (e.g., Cloud Storage bucket) with a preferred region.
- Policies: priority class (high/medium/low),
preemptibleflag,gang(all‑or‑nothing start), checkpointing capability.
4. Placement Heuristics
The placement engine runs every time a job is admitted or the resource state changes.
Step 1: Filter regions
- Apply
regionAffinityanddataLocality. Prefer regions where the required data resides. - Discard regions lacking sufficient free accelerators of the requested type.
Step 2: Within each candidate region, evaluate zones
- Respect
zoneSpread(e.g., if a job asks for 8 tasks andmaxPerZone=4, it needs at least 2 zones). - Compute a zone fit score based on:
- Number of free accelerators.
- Current utilization (to balance load).
- Network topology: for multi‑zone jobs, estimate inter‑zone bandwidth/latency (high‑speed links within a region are usually good, but cross‑region is penalized).
- Failure domain constraints.
Step 3: Node selection
For each task (or group of tasks that must co‑locate), score candidate nodes with a cost function:cost = w1·(1 - resourceFit) + w2·loadImbalance + w3·fragmentationPenalty + w4·networkCost + w5·topologyMismatch + w6·failureDomainRisk- resourceFit: how perfectly the node’s free accelerators match the request (e.g., a node with exactly the needed count gets 1, otherwise less).
- loadImbalance: deviation of node utilization from regional average (avoid hot nodes).
- fragmentationPenalty: if placing leaves an odd number of free accelerators that could lead to future waste.
- networkCost: for tasks that need to communicate (e.g., via NCCL), estimate bandwidth based on node/rack/zone placement. Same‑node = 0, same‑rack low cost, cross‑rack higher, cross‑zone even higher.
- topologyMismatch: fails if the node lacks required interconnect (e.g., tasks needing NVLink but the node’s GPUs are not linked).
- failureDomainRisk: if the placement would concentrate too many tasks of the same job in a domain that already hosts other critical jobs, increase cost to promote spreading.
Step 4: Bin‑Packing for Multi‑Task Jobs
- The placement is a constrained bin‑packing problem. We use a best‑fit decreasing heuristic: sort tasks by size (number of accelerators) descending, then assign each to the node/zones that minimize the incremental total cost.
- For gang‑scheduled jobs, we tentatively reserve resources for all tasks before committing; if any placement fails, we backtrack and try a different region/zone combination.
Step 5: Commit
Once a feasible assignment is found, the CSC sends placement instructions to the corresponding RSAs. The assignment is recorded in the state store and the resources are marked as allocated.Optimization Goals:
- Maximize overall cluster utilization.
- Minimize cross‑zone/region network traffic for data‑parallel jobs.
- Honor data locality to reduce egress costs.
- Provide fairness (see §6).
5. Failure Domains and Resilience
Failure Domain Awareness
- Scheduler tracks the health of each failure domain (node, rack, zone, region).
- Jobs can declare replication and spreading requirements.
- The scheduler therefore avoids placing all tasks of a job in a single zone unless forced.
Failure Detection
- RSAs send heartbeats every few seconds. Missing heartbeats mark the node suspect. After a timeout, the node is down.
- Accelerator‑level health is reported via driver APIs (e.g., NVIDIA‑SMI); faulty accelerators are marked unavailable.
Reaction to Failures
- Node/Accelerator Failure: Tasks running on the failed resource are marked as lost.
- If the job is checkpoints (e.g., using Kubernetes Volume Snapshots or custom checkpointing), the CSC instructs an RSA to restart the task from the latest checkpoint on a healthy node (potentially in a different zone).
- If the job is not checkpointable but is preemptible, it is requeued.
- If the job is non‑preemptible and cannot be resumed, it remains failed; the scheduler may alert the owner.
- Zone/Region Outage: All nodes in the affected zone are marked down. The scheduler attempts to reschedule tasks of any impacted jobs to other zones/regions, respecting constraints and quotas. If the job had a
zoneSpreadthat required the failed zone, the constraint may be relaxed pragmatically (e.g., reduce number of zones) or the job is paused. - Proactive Spreading: When placing a new job, the scheduler considers the failure domain risk of a node. If a zone already hosts many critical jobs, the cost for placing additional tasks there increases, encouraging distribution.
Scheduler Resilience
- CSC uses Raft for leader election and state replication. Followers can serve read‑only queries (e.g., job status) even if they are not the leader.
- State is persisted in a WAL and periodic snapshots. On restart, a scheduler instance loads the latest snapshot and replays logs.
- RSAs are stateless w.r.t. global decisions; they only hold local state (running tasks, node health) and can reconnect to a new CSC leader.
- If the entire CSC cluster is lost, the system can be resurrected from the persisted store; however, new submissions remain blocked until a new leader is elected.
6. Fairness Controls
Fairness is enforced at admission and during placement via a combination of share‑based scheduling and quotas.
Share Accounting
- Each tenant (user/team/project) has a weight (default 1.0).
- The scheduler computes, over a sliding window (e.g., last hour), the weighted usage of each tenant:
usage = Σ (accelerator‑hours used in window) × (weight of tenant) - The normalized share =
usage / (total cluster capacity × weight). - The scheduler aims to equalize normalized shares (max‑min fairness). Tenants with lower normalized share get higher priority in the placement queue.
Quotas
- Hard quotas: absolute caps on total accelerators a tenant can allocate, either globally or per region. These are checked at job submission; if a job would exceed the quota, it is rejected or held until resources free up.
- Soft quotas: used in fair‑share calculation to penalize tenants that exceed their nominal share.
Priority and Preemption
- Jobs belong to a priority class (configurable: e.g.,
production,batch,preemptible). - Higher‑priority jobs can preempt lower‑priority ones, but only if the lower‑priority job is marked
preemptibleor has already exceeded its fair share. - Preemption triggers a graceful termination: the scheduler asks the RSA to checkpoint (if possible) and requeue the job. Resources are then allocated to the higher‑priority job.
Gang Scheduling
- Jobs that declare
gang: truerequire all tasks to start simultaneously. The scheduler reserves the required resources for the entire job before launching any task. This prevents partial allocation that would deadlock the job.
Fairness Metrics
Exposed metrics:
- Jain’s Fairness Index based on normalized shares.
- Per‑tenant usage vs. quota.
- Average wait time per tenant.
Admins can adjust weights and quotas dynamically via API.
7. Utilization Reporting
The system collects a rich set of metrics for both operational awareness and capacity planning.
Real‑Time Metrics (exposed by RSAs)
- Accelerator utilization: active vs idle state, memory usage, temperature.
- Node metrics: CPU, memory, network I/O.
- Job metrics: running tasks, pending tasks, resource consumption per job.
- Queue metrics: number of pending jobs per priority/tenant, average wait time.
- Failure metrics: number of nodes/accelerators down per zone/region.
Aggregation & Storage
- A central metrics aggregator scrapes all RSA endpoints, enriches with job/tenant metadata, and writes to a TSDB (e.g., Cortex, Prometheus remote write, InfluxDB).
- Retain raw data for 30 days, down‑sample for longer history.
Dashboards & Alerts
- Grafana dashboards show:
- Global heat map of GPU/TPU utilization by region/zone.
- Fairness index over time.
- Top tenants by usage.
- Job throughput, average completion time.
- Fragmentation metrics (e.g., number of nodes with < 50% accelerator utilization).
- Alerts (via Alertmanager) trigger on:
- Sustained low utilization (< 20% cluster‑wide) – indicates over‑provisioning.
- Fairness index dropping below threshold.
- Sudden increase in failed nodes/accelerators.
- Quota violations.
Historical Reporting
- Daily/weekly reports generated automatically:
- Total accelerator‑hours consumed by tenant.
- Cost allocation (if regions have different prices).
- Capacity trends to guide future purchases.
8. Example Workflow
- Submission: Alice submits a training job requiring 8× A100 GPUs,
gang: true,zoneSpread: maxPerZone=4, and dataset residing inus-central1. She is a tenant with weight 1.0 and quota 16 GPUs. - Admission: Scheduler checks quota: Alice currently uses 4 GPUs, so the job fits. It estimates normalized share and decides the job is eligible.
- Placement:
- Filter regions: only
us-central1has the dataset and sufficient A100 capacity (10 GPUs free across two zones). - Zone evaluation: Zone A (6 free), Zone B (4 free). To satisfy
maxPerZone=4, we need to place 4 tasks in Zone A and 4 tasks in Zone B (or 3+5 but exceeds max). - Node selection: Within each zone, find nodes with at least 4 free A100s and NVLink support. Zone A has a node with 6 GPUs; assign 4 tasks to it (leaving 2 free). Zone B has two nodes with 4 GPUs each; assign 2 tasks to each.
- Cost calculation favors this packing because it keeps tasks in the same zone (low network cost) and respects the spread constraint.
- Filter regions: only
- Dispatch: CSC sends assignments to RSAs in
us-central1(Zone A and Zone B). RSAs launch the tasks on the selected nodes. - Failure: Zone A loses power (all nodes down). RSAs report outage. CSC marks all 4 tasks in Zone A as failed.
- Since the job is checkpointable (Alice used a checkpoint every hour), the scheduler restarts those 4 tasks in Zone B (using the remaining 2 GPUs on the partially used node and freeing up 2 more from the other node after preempting a lower‑priority preemptible job).
- The job resumes from the last checkpoint, experiencing a short interruption.
- Reporting: Utilization dashboards show a dip in Zone A, a spike in Zone B, and an overall fair‑share index that briefly dropped but recovered as Alice’s usage dropped and then increased within her quota.
9. Conclusion
The presented design offers a resilient, globally aware scheduler for GPUs and TPUs. It combines:
- Placement heuristics that balance locality, topology, load, and failure domain risk.
- Failure domain handling that spreads tasks, detects outages, and reschedules using checkpointing.
- Fairness controls that implement weighted fair‑share, quotas, preemption, and gang scheduling.
- Utilization reporting with real‑time metrics, dashboards, alerts, and historical analytics.
The architecture is scalable (hierarchical regions, consistent central state) and highly available (Raft‑based leader election). It can be implemented as a standalone system or as a custom scheduler within a container orchestrator like Kubernetes (using the scheduler framework). This approach optimally utilizes scarce accelerator resources while guaranteeing resilience and fairness across regions.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.