Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
GPT 5.1 Codex Max· openaiHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Compare directory structures using the rsync algorithm with rolling hash. If files…

  1. User

    Compare directory structures using the rsync algorithm with rolling hash. If files differ, identify which blocks changed using Adler-32 rolling checksum so you only copy changed chunks, not whole files.

  2. Assistant

    Explaining simplified rsync-style block comparison

    The approach scans two directories, and for each file in both, divides files into fixed-size blocks computing Adler-32 checksums to detect differing blocks by index. This simplified method identifies changed chunks without full rolling checksum matching but illustrates how to copy only changed blocks efficiently. What rsync does to avoid shipping whole files is:

    • Walk the tree at the receiver, for each file break it into fixed‑size blocks (e.g. 4 KiB, 16 KiB …).
    • For each block compute a “weak” rolling checksum and a “strong” checksum to guard against collisions.
    • Send that signature list to the sender.
    • The sender scans its version of the file with a sliding window the same size as the block, maintaining the rolling checksum as it advances one byte at a time. When the weak checksum matches one in the receiver’s list, the sender verifies with the strong checksum. Matching regions are left in place, non‑matching regions are sent.

    You can use Adler‑32 as the rolling checksum. For a window of length (L) the Adler state is (s_1=\sum b_i), (s_2=\sum_{i=1\ldots L} s_1^{(i)}). When you advance the window by one byte you don’t have to recompute from scratch:

    MOD = 65521
    
    def adler32_state(buf):
        s1 = 0
        s2 = 0
        for b in buf:
            s1 = (s1 + b) % MOD
            s2 = (s2 + s1) % MOD
        return s1, s2  # combined value is (s2 << 16) | s1
    
    def roll_adler32(s1, s2, old_byte, new_byte, window_len):
        s1 = (s1 - old_byte + new_byte) % MOD
        s2 = (s2 - window_len*old_byte + s1) % MOD
        return s1, s2
    

    Putting it together in a simple directory comparer:

    import os, zlib, hashlib
    
    BLOCK = 4096
    
    def build_signature(path):
        sigs = []
        with open(path, 'rb') as f:
            idx = 0
            while True:
                block = f.read(BLOCK)
                if not block:
                    break
                weak_s1, weak_s2 = adler32_state(block)
                strong = hashlib.md5(block).digest()
                sigs.append((idx, (weak_s1, weak_s2), strong))
                idx += 1
        return sigs
    
    def find_changed_blocks(src_path, dst_sigs):
        # map weak checksum to list of (index,strong)
        weak_map = {}
        for idx, (s1,s2), strong in dst_sigs:
            weak_map.setdefault((s1,s2), []).append((idx,strong))
    
        changed = []
        with open(src_path, 'rb') as f:
            window = f.read(BLOCK)
            if not window:
                return []
            pos = 0
            s1, s2 = adler32_state(window)
            while True:
                candidates = weak_map.get((s1,s2), [])
                matched = False
                for idx,strong in candidates:
                    if hashlib.md5(window).digest() == strong:
                        # block matches receiver’s block idx, skip ahead
                        matched = True
                        pos += BLOCK
                        f.seek(pos)
                        window = f.read(BLOCK)
                        if not window:
                            return changed
                        s1, s2 = adler32_state(window)
                        break
                if matched:
                    continue
                # no match: current byte will need to be sent
                changed.append(pos)
                # slide window by one byte
                old = window[0]
                nxt = f.read(1)
                if not nxt:
                    return changed
                window = window[1:] + nxt
                s1, s2 = roll_adler32(s1, s2, old, nxt[0], BLOCK)
    
        return changed
    

    You can drive this over two directory trees with os.walk: for each relative path that exists in both trees, build the signature of the destination file, then call find_changed_blocks on the source file. The list of offsets you get back tells you which chunks differ and need to be transferred; matching blocks can be referenced by index and reused on the receiver side. Files that are new or missing on either side can simply be copied or deleted.

    This is the essence of rsync’s delta transfer: a rolling Adler‑32 lets you resynchronise even if bytes have been inserted or removed, and you only copy the changed chunks instead of whole files.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.