Draft a set of interrogatories for a personal injury case
- User
Draft a set of interrogatories for a personal injury case
Assistant
The user wants a set of interrogatories for a personal injury case. I need to provide a template or a comprehensive list of questions that a plaintiff's attorney would send to a defendant (or vice versa, though usually, the focus is on proving liability and damages, so a Plaintiff interrogating a Defendant is the most common starting point).
Key Elements of Personal Injury Interrogatories:
- General Information: Names, addresses, insurance info.
- Liability/Facts: How the incident happened, traffic laws (if auto), safety protocols (if slip and fall).
- Defenses: What is the defendant denying? Comparative negligence?
- Damages: Medical bills, lost wages, future treatment.
- Witnesses/Evidence: Who saw it? Are there photos/videos?
- Expert Witnesses: Who will testify?
Structure of the Response:
- Disclaimer: Must clarify that this is not legal advice and jurisdiction matters.
- Introduction/Preamble: Standard legal language about answering under oath.
- Categorized Questions:
- General Background: Identification.
- The Incident (Liability): Specific questions about the accident.
- Defenses: Negligence claims.
- Injuries and Treatment (if asking the Plaintiff, or asking the Defendant about their perception of Plaintiff's injuries).
- Lost Wages/Employment.
- Witnesses and Evidence.
- Expert Witnesses.
- Instructions: How to answer (objections, producing documents).
Drafting the Content (Iterative refinement):
- General: "State your full name, address..." standard.
- Insurance: "Do you have insurance?" "What are the policy limits?" (Crucial for settlement).
- The Accident: "Describe the accident in detail." "Where were you coming from/going to?" "Were you on the clock?" (Vicarious liability).
- Medicals (if Plaintiff is asking Defendant): Usually, the Defendant doesn't know the Plaintiff's medical condition, but the Plaintiff asks the Defendant about their injuries. If the user is the Plaintiff asking the Defendant, I should ask about the Defendant's physical condition at the time of the accident (drunk, tired, etc.).
- Self-Correction: Usually, the prompt implies the user needs a set, so providing a "Plaintiff to Defendant" set is the safest bet for a general template.
- Damages: If asking Plaintiff, it's "List all medical providers." If asking Defendant, it's "Do you contend Plaintiff was not injured?"
- Decision: I will draft this primarily as Plaintiff to Defendant, as that is the most common request. I will add a note about Defendant to Plaintiff sets.
Refining the Questions (Legalese check):
- Instead of "Did you see the accident?", use "Identify all persons who witnessed the incident."
- Instead of "Are you hurt?", use "Describe in detail all injuries sustained..."
- Include definitions (e.g., "Identify" means name, address, phone).
Adding Value:
- Mention "Requests for Production" usually go hand-in-hand.
- Mention the importance of "Rule 33" (Federal) or state equivalents.
Drafting the specific questions:
- Intro: Definitions.
- General: Name, address, DOB, employment.
- Insurance: Carrier, policy limits, adjuster info.
- The Incident: Time, place, weather, conditions. Specific acts of negligence.
- Statements: Did you talk to anyone? 911 calls?
- Evidence: Photos, videos, black box data (cars), surveillance (slip and fall).
- Witnesses: List them.
- Defendant's Physical State: Sick? Tired? On meds?
- Defenses: Comparative negligence? Pre-existing conditions?
- Experts: Who are you hiring to testify?
Final Polish: Ensure the tone is professional. Add a "Certificate of Service" placeholder. Add a strong disclaimer.
(Self-Correction during drafting): The user didn't specify the type of PI case (Car accident vs. Slip and Fall). I should draft generic enough to apply to both, but perhaps lean towards auto with a few specific "conditions of the property" questions, or note where to swap terms (e.g., "vehicle" vs. "premises"). I will stick to a mostly Auto-focused template as it's the most common, but keep the language adaptable (e.g., "the incident").
Let's structure the output clearly with headers.
Review against Safety Guidelines: No harmful content. This is legal drafting assistance, standard for LLMs. No specific legal advice is given (just templates).
Plan:
- Disclaimer.
- General Instructions/Definitions.
- Set 1: General Background & Insurance.
- Set 2: The Incident & Liability.
- Set 3: Witnesses & Evidence.
- Set 4: Defenses.
- Set 5: Experts.
- Closing/Certificate of Service.
- Contextual advice (Federal vs. State, limits on numbers).
Let's write it.
Drafting Question 12 (Liability): "State the factual basis for your contention that the Plaintiff was contributorily negligent..." (Standard boilerplate). Drafting Question 15 (Medical - asking Defendant): "Do you contend that the injuries... were caused by a prior incident?" (Standard defense strategy probe).
Double check: Did the user ask for Plaintiff to Defendant or Defendant to Plaintiff? "Draft a set of interrogatories..." implies the user is likely the one doing the suing (Plaintiff) or a paralegal needing a starting point. I will explicitly state this is Plaintiff to Defendant but note it can be adapted.
(Self-Correction): I should make sure to define "You" and "Incident" in the definitions section to make the template robust.
Okay, ready to generate. Disclaimer: I am an AI, not an attorney. The following is a standard template for educational purposes only. Laws regarding civil procedure (such as the number of questions allowed or specific wording requirements) vary significantly by jurisdiction (e.g., Federal Rules vs. California vs. New York). You must consult with a qualified attorney to tailor these to your specific case and local rules.
Below is a comprehensive set of Interrogatories (Propounded by Plaintiff to Defendant) designed for a typical personal injury scenario (such as an auto accident or slip and fall).
IN THE COURT OF [JURISDICTION/COUNTY]
**[PLAINTIFF NAME]
, *Plaintiff,* v. **[DEFENDANT NAME], Defendant.CASE NO: [NUMBER] CIVIL ACTION
PLAINTIFF’S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT
TO: [Defendant’s Name/Defense Counsel] PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Plaintiff, by and through undersigned counsel, requests that you answer the following Interrogatories in writing, under oath, and pursuant to the applicable Rules of Civil Procedure, within the time provided by the rules.
INSTRUCTIONS AND DEFINITIONS
- "You" or "You" refers to the Defendant answering these Interrogatories, and any agents, employees, attorneys, or insurers acting on your behalf.
- "Incident" refers to the event or occurrence alleged in the Complaint regarding the personal injury of the Plaintiff on [Date of Incident].
- "Document" includes any writing, recording, photograph, video, digital file, or data compilation.
INTERROGATORIES
General Background
1. State your full name, current residential address, and date of birth.
2. At the time of the Incident, state: a. Your home address; b. Your telephone number(s); c. Your employer’s name and address.
3. Have you ever been convicted of a crime? If so, for each conviction, state the nature of the offense, the date, and the court/jurisdiction where convicted.
Insurance and Indemnity
4. Identify every policy of liability insurance that might provide coverage for the Incident, including: a. The name of the insurance company; b. The policy number; c. The policy limits (per person and per accident/occurrence); d. The name of the insured party.
The Incident (Liability)
5. State in your own words the facts regarding how the Incident occurred, including the location, date, and time.
6. Describe in detail your actions and movements immediately before, during, and after the Incident.
7. Did you consume any alcohol, medication, or non-prescription drugs within 24 hours prior to the Incident? If so, please identify the substance, the amount consumed, and the time of consumption.
8. Were there any mechanical defects in the vehicle/equipment you were operating at the time of the Incident? If so, describe the defect and when you first became aware of it.
9. Did you possess a valid driver’s license (or relevant certification) at the time of the Incident? If not, explain why.
Statements and Witnesses
10. List the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of all persons who witnessed the Incident or were present immediately before or after the Incident.
11. List the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of all persons who have knowledge of any facts relevant to this lawsuit.
12. Have you given any written or recorded statement regarding the Incident to anyone (e.g., police, insurance adjuster)? If so, state to whom it was given, the date, and identify the person/organization currently in possession of the recording or transcript.
Injuries and Medical Treatment (Regarding Defendant)
13. Did you sustain any injuries in the Incident? If so, describe the nature and extent of your injuries and identify all healthcare providers who treated you.
Defenses
14. State the factual basis for every defense you intend to assert in response to the Complaint. (e.g., "The Plaintiff suddenly stopped in front of me.")
15. Do you contend that the Plaintiff was negligent in any manner contributing to the Incident? If so, state all facts upon which you base this contention.
Damages
16. Do you dispute any of the injuries or medical treatments claimed by the Plaintiff? If so, identify each specific injury or treatment you dispute and the factual basis for your dispute.
17. List all medical providers, hospitals, or clinics where you claim the Plaintiff received treatment that was unnecessary or unrelated to the Incident.
Expert Witnesses
18. Have you retained or consulted with any expert witnesses whom you may call to testify at trial? If so, for each expert, state: a. Their name and address; b. Their field of expertise; c. The subject matter on which they will testify; d. The substance of the facts and opinions to which they are expected to testify.
Surveillance and Evidence
19. Have you, your attorney, your insurance carrier, or any private investigator conducted surveillance of the Plaintiff? If so, identify the investigator and produce the resulting films, photographs, or videos.
20. List all photographs, videos, diagrams, or physical evidence relating to the Incident or the injuries sustained.
VERIFICATION
STATE OF [STATE]** COUNTY OF [COUNTY]**
I, [Name of Defendant], being duly sworn, depose and say: I am the Defendant in the above-captioned action. I have read the foregoing Interrogatories and the answers given are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief.
Signature
Subscribed and sworn to (or affirmed) before me on this ___ day of ____, 20, by ___________________.
Notary Public My Commission Expires: ______________
Strategic Notes for the User
- The "Cap": Most jurisdictions (like Federal Rule 33) limit you to 25 interrogatories (including subparts) unless the court permits more or the other party agrees. The draft above contains roughly 20 questions, leaving you room to ask specific questions unique to your case.
- Definitions: The definition of "Incident" is critical. It prevents the defendant from answering vaguely or narrowing the scope to avoid answering questions.
- Subparts: Be careful with subparts (a, b, c). In many courts, a question with three subparts counts as three separate interrogatories.
- Timing: Usually, you must serve these on the other party, and they have 30 days (depending on the jurisdiction) to answer and verify them.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.