Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
GPT 5.1 Codex Max· openaiHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Derive Euler's equations for rigid body rotation in the body frame. Explain the tennis…

  1. User

    Derive Euler's equations for rigid body rotation in the body frame. Explain the tennis racket theorem: rotation around intermediate axis is unstable while first and third are stable.

  2. Assistant

    Deriving and analyzing Euler's equations

    The user derives Euler's equations for rigid body rotation in the body frame with principal axes, presenting the torque-free form and component equations. They connect these to the intermediate axis theorem (tennis racket theorem), showing stability for rotation about the largest and smallest inertia axes and instability about the intermediate axis via linearized perturbations and energy considerations. For a rigid body the balance of angular momentum in an inertial frame is [ \frac{\mathrm d\mathbf{L}}{\mathrm dt}\bigg|{\text{space}}=\boldsymbol{\tau}, ] with (\mathbf{L}=\int \mathbf{r}\times \mathbf{v},\mathrm dm) and (\boldsymbol{\tau}=\int \mathbf{r}\times\mathrm d\mathbf{F}) the resultant torque. It is convenient to describe the motion with respect to a frame fixed in the body, because in that frame the inertia tensor is constant. The time derivative of a vector (\mathbf{a}) as seen from the body frame and from space are related by [ \frac{\mathrm d\mathbf{a}}{\mathrm dt}\bigg|{\text{space}}=\frac{\mathrm d\mathbf{a}}{\mathrm dt}\bigg|{\text{body}}+\boldsymbol{\omega}\times\mathbf{a}, ] where (\boldsymbol{\omega}) is the angular velocity of the body frame. Using this on (\mathbf{L}) gives [ \frac{\mathrm d\mathbf{L}}{\mathrm dt}\bigg|{\text{body}}+\boldsymbol{\omega}\times\mathbf{L}=\boldsymbol{\tau}. ]

    Choosing the body axes along the principal axes of inertia, the inertia tensor is diagonal, (\mathbf{L}=(I_1\omega_1,I_2\omega_2,I_3\omega_3)). In components the above vector equation becomes the Euler equations [ \begin{aligned} I_1 \dot\omega_1 + (I_3-I_2),\omega_2\omega_3 &= \tau_1,\ I_2 \dot\omega_2 + (I_1-I_3),\omega_3\omega_1 &= \tau_2,\ I_3 \dot\omega_3 + (I_2-I_1),\omega_1\omega_2 &= \tau_3, \end{aligned} ] where the dot denotes derivative with respect to time measured in the body frame. In the torque–free case (\boldsymbol{\tau}=0) these equations describe the free rotation of a rigid body.

    A rigid body has three principal moments (I_1,I_2,I_3) which we assume distinct and ordered, say (I_1<I_2<I_3). A steady rotation about any principal axis, (\boldsymbol{\omega}=\Omega,\mathbf{e}_i), is an equilibrium solution of the torque–free Euler equations. Its stability is determined by linearizing around that equilibrium. For example, about (\mathbf{e}_1) one finds for small perturbations (\delta\omega_2,\delta\omega_3) [ \ddot{\delta\omega}_2=\frac{(I_3-I_1)(I_1-I_2)}{I_2 I_3},\Omega^2,\delta\omega_2, ] and similarly for (\delta\omega_3). With (I_1<I_2<I_3) the coefficient is negative, so the perturbations oscillate and the rotation is stable. An analogous calculation about (\mathbf{e}_3) also gives oscillatory perturbations. In contrast, linearizing about the intermediate axis (\mathbf{e}_2) yields [ \ddot{\delta\omega}_1=\frac{(I_2-I_3)(I_1-I_2)}{I_1 I_3},\Omega^2,\delta\omega_1, ] which has a positive coefficient, so small deviations grow exponentially. This is the content of the “tennis racket theorem”: for a torque–free body with distinct principal moments the rotations about the axes with the largest and smallest moments are stable, but rotation about the intermediate–moment axis is dynamically unstable. It underlies the familiar flipping of a tossed racket about its middle axis.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.