Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
GLMGLM-5 / Pony Alpha· unknownHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Build a review response playbook: prioritization, tone ladders, and escalation rules.

  1. User

    Build a review response playbook: prioritization, tone ladders, and escalation rules.

  2. GLM Assistant

    The user wants a "Review Response Playbook." This is a specific operational document for managing online reviews (Google, Yelp, Trustpilot, etc.). It needs to cover three main components:

    1. Prioritization: Which reviews to answer first.
    2. Tone Ladders: How to adjust the voice based on sentiment.
    3. Escalation Rules: When and how to hand off issues to higher-ups or other departments.

    Structure of the Output: I need to create a structured, easy-to-read document that looks like an actual internal playbook.

    • Introduction: Brief purpose statement.
    • Section 1: Prioritization Matrix (The Triage): Define criteria (Sentiment + Influence).
    • Section 2: Tone Ladders: Define the brand voice across different scenarios.
    • Section 3: Escalation Rules: The "Stop, Drop, and Roll" for PR disasters or complex issues.
    • Section 4: The Checklist/SOP: A quick summary for the team.

    Drafting Content - Section by Section:

    • 1. Prioritization:

      • Concept: Not all reviews are equal. A 1-star from an elite yelper is dangerous. A 5-star from a regular is good but less urgent than a crisis.
      • Tier 1 (Critical): 1-2 stars, keywords like "lawsuit," "sick," "illegal," or influencers.
      • Tier 2 (Moderate): 3 stars, complaints about price/wait times.
      • Tier 3 (Positive): 4-5 stars.
      • Actionable Advice: Response time goals (e.g., 1 hour for Tier 1).
    • 2. Tone Ladders:

      • Concept: You can't sound robotic. You need to match or modulate the energy.
      • Scenario A: The Raving Fan (5 stars). Tone: Enthusiastic, grateful, personal. "So glad you loved the [Product]!"
      • Scenario B: The Constructive Critic (3-4 stars). Tone: Appreciative, validating, professional. "Thanks for the feedback on [X], we are working on it."
      • Scenario C: The Angry Customer (1-2 stars). Tone: Empathetic, de-escalating, offline focus. "We are sorry to hear this. Please contact us at..."
      • Scenario D: The Troll/Fake Review. Tone: Factual, brief, disengaged.
    • 3. Escalation Rules:

      • Concept: When does support need to talk to legal? Or marketing?
      • Triggers: Threats of legal action, health/safety claims (food poisoning, injury), hate speech, verified influencers/media.
      • Process: Who to contact? (Legal, PR, GM). Do not respond until cleared.
    • 4. Templates (Bonus):

      • Give concrete examples to make it usable immediately.

    Refining the "Tone Ladder" concept: It's not just "be nice." It's about a gradient.

    • Level 1 (High Energy): "We are over the moon!"
    • Level 2 (Warm & Professional): "Thank you for sharing your experience."
    • Level 3 (Clinical & Contrite): "We take this seriously."

    Refining the "Escalation": Need to define who owns the problem. Is it the Social Media Manager? No, usually Customer Support or the Store Manager.

    Self-Correction during drafting:

    • Initial thought: Just list priorities.
    • Correction: Use a matrix approach (Impact vs. Urgency).
    • Initial thought: Give generic advice.
    • Correction: Use "If this, then that" logic.

    Formatting: Use bolding, bullet points, and clear headers to make it "skimmable" for a team lead.

    Final Polish: Add a "Golden Rules" section to wrap it up (e.g., "Take it offline," "Don't copy-paste").

    Let's build the response based on this structure. This playbook is designed to help Customer Experience (CX) or Social Media teams manage online reputation efficiently. It covers how to sort incoming reviews, how to adjust your voice based on sentiment, and when to call in the cavalry.


    The Review Response Playbook

    Phase 1: Prioritization Matrix (Triage)

    You cannot respond to everything at once. Use the Impact vs. Urgency framework to determine the order of operations.

    Tier 1: Critical (Respond within 1–2 Hours)

    • Criteria: 1-Star reviews, mentions of legal action, safety hazards (e.g., "I found glass in my food"), or viral potential (influencer account).
    • Action: Immediate response. Do not use templates. Alert management.

    Tier 2: High (Respond within 4–6 Hours)

    • Criteria: 2-Star reviews, detailed constructive criticism, complaints about pricing/value, or service specific failures (e.g., "Wait time was 2 hours").
    • Action: Personalized response addressing the specific issue.

    Tier 3: Moderate (Respond within 24 Hours)

    • Criteria: 3-Star reviews (mixed sentiment), mentions of competitors, or general questions about hours/location.
    • Action: Helpful, clarifying response.

    Tier 4: Low (Respond within 48–72 Hours)

    • Criteria: 4–5 Star reviews, simple "Great service!" comments, or image-only reviews.
    • Action: Warm, appreciative "thank you." (Batch these for efficiency).

    Phase 2: The Tone Ladder

    Your brand voice should not be a flat line; it must flex to match the emotional state of the customer. This is the "Tone Ladder."

    Rung 1: The Raving Fan (5 Stars)

    • Customer Emotion: Joy, excitement, loyalty.
    • Your Tone: Energetic, personal, high-spirit.
    • Objective: Reinforce behavior and encourage word-of-mouth.
    • Example:
      • Bad: "Thank you for your review." (Too dry)
      • Good: "This made our day, Sarah! We are thrilled you loved the truffle fries. Can’t wait to see you back for Taco Tuesday!"

    Rung 2: The Constructive Critic (3–4 Stars)

    • Customer Emotion: Indifference, mixed feelings, specific disappointment.
    • Your Tone: Professional, grateful, validating, attentive.
    • Objective: Show you are listening and committed to improvement.
    • Example:
      • Bad: "Sorry we were slow."
      • Good: "Thanks for the honest feedback, Mike. We’re glad you enjoyed the entrée, but we’re sorry the wait time didn't match the standard. We’re working with the kitchen team on timing this week."

    Rung 3: The Detractor / Angry Customer (1–2 Stars)

    • Customer Emotion: Anger, frustration, feeling cheated.
    • Your Tone: Empathetic, apologetic (if warranted), de-escalating, "human."
    • Objective: Move the conversation offline. Do not argue publicly.
    • Example:
      • Bad: "You are wrong, we never said that."
      • Good: "We are very sorry to hear this experience didn't meet your expectations, John. This isn't the standard we set for ourselves. Please reach out to us directly at [Email] so our manager can make this right."

    Rung 4: The Troll / Abusive (1 Star)

    • Customer Emotion: Irrational, offensive, potentially fake.
    • Your Tone: Clinical, neutral, brief.
    • Objective: Fact-checking (for the public audience) and disengagement.
    • Rule: Never get defensive. If it violates platform guidelines, flag/hide it rather than responding.

    Phase 3: Escalation Rules (The "Red Flags")

    Frontline agents should not handle these situations alone. Create a "Break Glass" protocol.

    When to Escalate to a Manager/Senior Support:

    1. Legal Threats: Any mention of "suing," "lawyer," or "illegal activity."
    2. Health & Safety: Mentions of food poisoning, injury, allergic reactions, or hygiene issues (e.g., "hair in food").
    3. Discrimination/Harassment: Accusations of racism, sexism, or inappropriate behavior by staff.
    4. VIPs/High Value: Customers identified in the CRM as "Whale" accounts or "At-Risk Churn."
    5. Media/Viral Risk: If the reviewer has >10k followers or is a verified journalist.

    The Escalation Protocol (SOP)

    1. Pause: Do not respond publicly immediately.
    2. Log: Screenshot the review.
    3. Tag: Assign to the appropriate lead (Legal, GM, or PR) in your CRM/Slack.
    4. Draft: Have the lead approve the draft response before posting.
    5. Monitor: Check back every 30 minutes after posting to catch follow-up comments.

    Phase 4: Quick-Start Templates

    The "Mistake" Acknowledgement:

    "Hi [Name], thank you for bringing this to our attention. We messed up here, and we own that. We’ve sent you a DM to get this sorted out immediately."

    The "Confusion" Clarification:

    "Hi [Name], we’re sorry for the confusion! It looks like there was a mix-up regarding our [Policy/Product]. We’d love to explain this better and find a solution for you. Please email us at [Email]."

    The "Take it Offline" (The Pivot):

    "We are very sorry to hear about this experience. We take these matters seriously and would like to investigate further. Please reach out to our dedicated support team at [Phone/Email] so we can resolve this privately."

    The "Happy Review" (The Upsell):

    "So glad you enjoyed the [Product]! Did you know we just launched a new flavor? We think it would be perfect for you. Thanks for being a loyal customer!"

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.