Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
GLMGLM-5 / Pony Alpha· unknownHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Build a reproducible thesis template: writing, code, data, and build.

  1. User

    Build a reproducible thesis template: writing, code, data, and build.

  2. GLM Assistant

    The user wants a "reproducible thesis template" that covers four main aspects:

    1. Writing: The actual text of the thesis (likely LaTeX or Markdown).
    2. Code: The scripts used for analysis/visualization.
    3. Data: The raw and processed data.
    4. Build: The system that knits everything together into a final PDF/document.

    The goal is to create a template structure and configuration that ensures anyone (or the user themselves, years later) can run a single command and regenerate the entire thesis exactly as it was.

    Core Technologies:

    • Writing: LaTeX is the standard for thesis work due to its typographic quality and citation management. Markdown (via Pandoc) is a modern alternative, but LaTeX offers more robust control for complex academic documents (like the University of Oxford/Harvard thesis templates). I should stick to LaTeX for the main document but maybe mention Quarto/Pandoc as an alternative. Actually, a Makefile or Snakemake or Python script can handle the build.
    • Code: Python (Jupyter/Scripts) or R. A template should probably be language-agnostic but provide examples. Let's use Python as a safe default but structure it so it's easy to swap.
    • Data: Needs a clear folder structure. Raw vs. Processed.
    • Build: This is the crucial part.
      • Old school: A Makefile. Very standard, very robust.
      • New school: Docker/Singularity. This ensures the environment (libraries, OS) is reproducible, not just the code. This is essential for "true" reproducibility.
      • Python specific: pyproject.toml / requirements.txt.
    • Version Control: Git is non-negotiable.

    Proposed Structure:

    1. Root Directory:

      • thesis.tex (Main file)
      • Makefile (The build engine)
      • README.md (Instructions)
      • .gitignore
      • Dockerfile (For environment reproducibility)
    2. Subdirectories:

      • src/ or chapters/: The LaTeX files for content.
      • code/: Python/R scripts.
      • data/:
        • raw/: Immutable original data.
        • processed/: Output from scripts.
      • output/ or figures/: Generated plots.
      • bib/: Bibliography.

    Detailed Implementation Steps:

    • The "Build" System (Makefile):

      • Needs to run the code (e.g., python code/analysis.py).
      • The code reads data/raw, outputs data/processed and figures/.
      • Then the Makefile runs latexmk to compile the PDF, including the generated figures.
      • This creates a dependency chain: Raw Data -> Code -> Figures/Proc Data -> LaTeX -> PDF.
    • The Environment (Docker):

      • A Dockerfile is necessary to lock down TexLive version and Python packages. Without this, "reproducible" is a lie 3 years later.
    • The LaTeX Template:

      • Keep it simple but standard. report or book class. Include standard packages (inputenc, biblatex, graphicx).
    • The Code Template:

      • A simple Python script that demonstrates reading CSV, doing a math operation, and saving a plot.

    Drafting the Content:

    • Intro: Explain the philosophy (Data -> Code -> Figure -> Text -> PDF).
    • File Tree: Visual representation.
    • Step 1: Directory Structure: Create folders.
    • Step 2: The Environment (Docker): Provide a Dockerfile. This is the "hardcore" part but necessary for the prompt.
    • Step 3: The Build Script (Makefile): The logic.
    • Step 4: The Code (Python): An example analysis.
    • Step 5: The Writing (LaTeX): The skeleton.
    • Step 6: Instructions: How to run it.

    Refinement:

    • Is Docker too complex for a starter template? Maybe. But "reproducible" implies it works 5 years from now. Docker is the answer. I will provide the Docker route as the primary solution but mention that it works locally without Docker if the user has the dependencies installed.
    • LaTeX vs. Quarto: Quarto is gaining ground. However, traditional PhDs often require strict LaTeX formatting provided by universities. I will stick to LaTeX because it's the "lingua franca" of academic theses, but I'll make the Makefile flexible enough to theoretically swap for Pandoc if desired.
    • Crucial detail: Git LFS. Data files are often big. I should mention .gitignore for data or Git LFS.

    Let's assemble the response. I'll provide a complete, copy-pasteable project structure.

    • Project Name: my-thesis

    • Files:

      1. Makefile
      2. Dockerfile
      3. requirements.txt
      4. thesis.tex
      5. code/analysis.py
      6. data/raw/data.csv (dummy)
      7. bib/references.bib
    • Makefile logic:

      • Target all: runs code, then builds pdf.
      • Target code: runs python.
      • Target pdf: runs latexmk.
      • Target clean: removes auxiliary files.

    This looks solid. It covers all four requested aspects.

    One final check on LaTeX: Use \inputminted or similar for code inclusion? Or just standard \lstlisting? Standard is safer. I will ensure the LaTeX document actually includes the generated figure to prove the pipeline works.

    Let's write it out. To build a truly reproducible thesis, you need an architecture that treats code, data, and text as interconnected components. If the data changes, the figures update; if the code changes, the output updates.

    Here is a complete, executable file structure and configuration for a Reproducible Thesis Template.

    This solution uses:

    1. LaTeX for typesetting (the gold standard for academia).
    2. Python for analysis and visualization.
    3. Make to orchestrate the build (the "glue" that forces code to run before PDF compilation).
    4. Docker (Optional but recommended) to ensure the environment (Python libraries, LaTeX distribution) is identical 5 years from now.

    1. The Directory Structure

    Create a folder named thesis_template and arrange it like this:

    thesis_template/
    ├── Makefile               # The build system orchestrator
    ├── Dockerfile             # Environment specification (OS + Libs)
    ├── requirements.txt       # Python dependencies
    ├── output/                # Generated content (Gitignored)
    │   ├── figures/
    │   └── tables/
    ├── data/
    │   ├── raw/               # Immutable original data
    │   └── processed/         # Cleaned data generated by scripts
    ├── code/
    │   ├── config.py          # Shared settings (paths, colors)
    │   ├── 01_process.py      # Script to clean data
    │   └── 02_analyze.py      # Script to generate figures
    ├── chapters/
    │   ├── introduction.tex
    │   └── results.tex        # Inputs the generated figures
    ├── bib/
    │   └── references.bib
    └── main.tex               # The root LaTeX file
    

    2. The Environment (Dockerfile & requirements.txt)

    This ensures your thesis compiles exactly the same way on your supervisor's machine as it does on yours.

    Dockerfile

    # Use a lightweight TeX distribution + Python image
    FROM python:3.11-slim
    
    # Install LaTeX and Make
    RUN apt-get update && apt-get install -y \
        texlive-latex-recommended \
        texlive-latex-extra \
        texlive-fonts-recommended \
        latexmk \
        make \
        && rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/*
    
    # Set working directory
    WORKDIR /thesis
    
    # Install Python dependencies
    COPY requirements.txt .
    RUN pip install --no-cache-dir -r requirements.txt
    

    requirements.txt

    pandas
    matplotlib
    numpy
    seaborn
    

    3. The Build System (Makefile)

    This is the engine of reproducibility. Instead of compiling LaTeX directly, you run make. It ensures your Python scripts run before the PDF is built.

    Makefile

    .PHONY: all clean figures data thesis
    
    # Default target: Build everything
    all: thesis
    
    # 1. Process Data (Code -> Data)
    data: code/01_process.py
    	python code/01_process.py
    
    # 2. Generate Figures (Data + Code -> Figures)
    # Depends on 'data' step being finished
    figures: data code/02_analyze.py
    	python code/02_analyze.py
    
    # 3. Build Thesis (Figures + LaTeX -> PDF)
    # Depends on 'figures' step being finished
    thesis: figures
    	latexmk -pdf -interaction=nonstopmode main.tex
    
    # Cleanup auxiliary files
    clean:
    	latexmk -c
    	rm -rf output/figures/*.pdf
    	rm -rf output/tables/*.tex
    
    # Nuclear option: clean everything
    scrub: clean
    	rm -f main.pdf
    

    4. The Code Layer (code/)

    We separate configuration from logic to keep things clean.

    code/config.py

    import os
    
    # Define paths relative to project root
    # This makes the script runnable from any directory
    ROOT = os.path.dirname(os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__)))
    PATHS = {
        'raw_data': os.path.join(ROOT, 'data', 'raw'),
        'proc_data': os.path.join(ROOT, 'data', 'processed'),
        'output': os.path.join(ROOT, 'output'),
        'figures': os.path.join(ROOT, 'output', 'figures')
    }
    
    # Ensure output directories exist
    for p in PATHS.values():
        os.makedirs(p, exist_ok=True)
    

    code/01_process.py

    import pandas as pd
    import config
    
    # 1. Load raw data (Dummy data for demonstration)
    print("Processing data...")
    raw = pd.DataFrame({
        'x': range(1, 11),
        'y': [i**2 + (i*0.5) for i in range(1, 11)]
    })
    
    # 2. Save processed data
    raw.to_csv(f"{config.PATHS['proc_data']}/clean_data.csv", index=False)
    print("Data processed.")
    

    code/02_analyze.py

    import pandas as pd
    import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
    import config
    
    print("Generating figures...")
    
    # 1. Load processed data
    df = pd.read_csv(f"{config.PATHS['proc_data']}/clean_data.csv")
    
    # 2. Plot
    fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(4, 3))
    ax.plot(df['x'], df['y'], marker='o', linestyle='-', color='navy')
    ax.set_xlabel('Independent Variable')
    ax.set_ylabel('Dependent Variable')
    ax.set_title('Reproducible Plot')
    ax.grid(True, alpha=0.3)
    
    # 3. Save to output/figures
    plt.tight_layout()
    plt.savefig(f"{config.PATHS['figures']}/result_plot.pdf")
    print("Figures saved.")
    

    5. The Writing Layer (main.tex & chapters/)

    In LaTeX, we point to the output files generated by Python. We use \input{} to keep the main file clean.

    main.tex

    \documentclass[12pt]{report}
    \usepackage{graphicx}
    \usepackage{lipsum} % For dummy text
    \usepackage[backend=biber, style=authoryear]{biblatex}
    \addbibresource{bib/references.bib}
    
    % Define paths for graphics (so we don't have to type 'output/figures/' every time)
    \graphicspath{{output/figures/}}
    
    \title{A Reproducible Thesis Template}
    \author{Graduate Student}
    
    \begin{document}
    \maketitle
    
    \input{chapters/introduction}
    \input{chapters/results}
    
    \printbibliography
    \end{document}
    

    chapters/results.tex

    \chapter{Results}
    
    Here is a plot generated automatically by the Python script.
    Note that if the data in \texttt{data/raw} changes, this figure updates
    automatically when you run \texttt{make}.
    
    \begin{figure}[h]
        \centering
        % We reference the file generated by code/02_analyze.py
        \includegraphics[width=0.8\textwidth]{result_plot.pdf}
        \caption{The relationship between X and Y.}
        \label{fig:results}
    \end{figure}
    
    As seen in Figure \ref{fig:results}, the trend is quadratic.
    

    6. How to Run It

    You have two options: using Docker (fully reproducible) or running locally (easier setup).

    Option A: The "Hardened" Way (Docker)

    This guarantees the build works in 2030.

    1. Build the container:
      docker build -t my-thesis .
      
    2. Run the build:
      # Mount current directory to /thesis and run make
      docker run -v $(pwd):/thesis my-thesis make
      

    Option B: The Local Way

    Requires you to have pdflatex and python installed locally.

    1. Install Python libs:
      pip install -r requirements.txt
      
    2. Build the thesis:
      make
      

    Summary of Workflow

    1. You write your analysis logic in code/.
    2. You write your text in chapters/.
    3. You run make.
      • make detects dependencies.
      • It runs Python scripts.
      • Python saves figures to output/.
      • make runs LaTeX.
      • LaTeX grabs the fresh figures from output/.
      • A PDF is born.

    If you change a number in your raw data, simply run make again, and the PDF will update with the new graph automatically.